WBAUnofficial
Ambition, what does it mean? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ambition, what does it mean? (/showthread.php?tid=25159)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Ambition, what does it mean? - Peachy - 05-05-2022

(05-05-2022, 11:39 AM)Hopalong Wrote:
(05-05-2022, 11:17 AM)richbaggie Wrote: We hear it all the time, from fans of every club at most levels. Where's the ambition?What does this actually mean though, putting yourself in the shoes of any owner or perspective owner? 

It means investing your money in an enterprise that will ultimately lead you to lose money in the vast majority of cases. Unless you are at the very top table and even then risk reward provides relative small returns and in many cases huge debt that are unlikely ever to be repaid.

So when we as fans demand ambition, what we are actually demanding is for someone to lose money for our entertainment. Which is why I never join in with the demands. If a club is lucky to have an owner to do this, putting own money in as a hobby because they've got it, then they are extremely lucky. However, for the most part, money just gets borrowed to finance the ambition. The debt grows, the club finds itself more and more disappearing down a nightmare rabbit hole of financial problems. I firmly believe fans are partly to blame for the mess that so many clubs are in.

I'm quite proud that as yet, we haven't disappeared down this rabbit hole but for how long will this be the case?  Fans demand he sells, anyone but Lai, get him out. But that personally scares me more than Lai staying. Where is the incentive for anyone to buy unless they are ridiculously wealthy and prepared to lose on their investment. We are more likely to end up with the Burnley model of "investor" and that would be a disaster.

What I do demand however is that the club is run well on and off the pitch. That's been missing for a long time now. Going back to Dan Ashworth going and not replacing him well. Pulis was a sticking plaster which bought more time but the dye was set before that.

I'd love us to continue to self finance as long as we were well run unless we found a stinking rich benefactor. It should be within our ability within our finances to do all these things well
1. Manage the academy well, producing golden nuggets every so often that produce 1st team players, loan fees for good prospects and strong sales down the line.
2. A strong and effective scouting network that identifies players that are needed. Not just ability wise but mentally strong and hungry players on the up.
3. Talented administrators that ensure that contracts are well set up whether that's for new players, youth or players coming in.
4. Quality coaching throughout the ages up to 1st team. Where every penny counts, you have to eek every bit of ability out of what you have. There are excellent examples of this elsewhere with Cooper at Forest being a good example.
5. Good communication between fans and club. Cut out the bullshit, be very honest at all times.
6. Do great work in the community to build trust and a feeling of belonging part of something.

This for me is key. Pretty much all the above has been missing for too long. This is where I want us to improve. Not throw money at it. Build a strong well run club from top to bottom. It's possible, with the right people. We aren't there with the right people now but this should be the RG and Lai focus and ambition.

Good post Rich you should forward it on to Gourlay, maybe you have already made the points to him in the meetings. 

Whilst Megson got us promoted,  for me the biggest lost opportunity - maybe in our history -  was him effectively ousting Paul Thompson for Peace.  

Thompson is the only WBA Director with any ambition that I can recall in all my time supporting Albion and it makes you wonder where we'd be today had he stayed or alternatively Megson had not (like Pulis ) been so pig-headed about Don's bloody one-man scouting system when PT wanted to introduce something far more extensive.

Great post Rich....


RE: Ambition, what does it mean? - TTM2 - 05-05-2022

This is why I don’t see the furore around Gourlay’s statement.

He acknowledged the fact this season has been a mess, some of the players are a disgrace and our financial position is going to be hampered for a while yet by the bad decisions made in recent history.

So to compete we need to be smart.


RE: Ambition, what does it mean? - Squid - 05-05-2022

This is a great post. I agree with every word.

As for Burnley, The Athletic have gone over their finances today. How that purchase was allowed, I do not know. I am not one of those who constantly criticises Lai, because I know which ever owner we are flogged to could be very much worse and that the current F+PPT regulation are toothless to prevent otherwise.

A lot of discontent is that football is increasingly a world of haves and have nots. So there's an increase in armchair fans, glory hunters, people following US sports instead or watching Non-League. Where lower PL/Championship clubs fit into to this is not entirely clear.


RE: Ambition, what does it mean? - Lightnin - 05-05-2022

Just on the last point and the community stuff, the Albion foundation and the work that they do really are at a top level and I’ve heard of several recent examples where the club has gone above any expectations with the people concerned. Some of the people that run the foundation, just as an example are staunch Wolves or Blues fans but recognise that we are excellent in this particular area and are very proud to work for it despite supporting a rival team.


RE: Ambition, what does it mean? - sickParrot - 05-05-2022

I used to think that one day big money in football would come crashing down and the well run clubs like us would finally be ahead of the big clubs struggling in debts and ffp rules.

I also used to believe that the tooth fairy put 50p under my pillow. Big Grin


RE: Ambition, what does it mean? - SW4Baggie - 05-05-2022

(05-05-2022, 12:44 PM)sickParrot Wrote: I used to think that one day big money in football would come crashing down and the well run clubs like us would finally be ahead of the big clubs struggling in debts and ffp rules.

I also used to believe that the tooth fairy put 50p under my pillow. Big Grin

Maybe this is a novel way of boosting our transfer budget?


RE: Ambition, what does it mean? - MassDebater - 05-05-2022

Ambition for me would be that we try and play decent, entertaining football, and the players give their all. to come away from the match having enjoyed it, win, lose ort draw. It'd be nice not to have a club who make it feel like we're lurching from one bad idea to the next, one that feels stable.

Like it did not so long ago sort of thing! As loads of others said, a club that feels like it's got a plan and is implementing it for the better.


RE: Ambition, what does it mean? - TartanRug - 05-05-2022

(05-05-2022, 11:17 AM)richbaggie Wrote: We hear it all the time, from fans of every club at most levels. Where's the ambition?What does this actually mean though, putting yourself in the shoes of any owner or perspective owner? 

It means investing your money in an enterprise that will ultimately lead you to lose money in the vast majority of cases. Unless you are at the very top table and even then risk reward provides relative small returns and in many cases huge debt that are unlikely ever to be repaid.

So when we as fans demand ambition, what we are actually demanding is for someone to lose money for our entertainment. Which is why I never join in with the demands. If a club is lucky to have an owner to do this, putting own money in as a hobby because they've got it, then they are extremely lucky. However, for the most part, money just gets borrowed to finance the ambition. The debt grows, the club finds itself more and more disappearing down a nightmare rabbit hole of financial problems. I firmly believe fans are partly to blame for the mess that so many clubs are in.

I'm quite proud that as yet, we haven't disappeared down this rabbit hole but for how long will this be the case?  Fans demand he sells, anyone but Lai, get him out. But that personally scares me more than Lai staying. Where is the incentive for anyone to buy unless they are ridiculously wealthy and prepared to lose on their investment. We are more likely to end up with the Burnley model of "investor" and that would be a disaster.

What I do demand however is that the club is run well on and off the pitch. That's been missing for a long time now. Going back to Dan Ashworth going and not replacing him well. Pulis was a sticking plaster which bought more time but the dye was set before that.

I'd love us to continue to self finance as long as we were well run unless we found a stinking rich benefactor. It should be within our ability within our finances to do all these things well
1. Manage the academy well, producing golden nuggets every so often that produce 1st team players, loan fees for good prospects and strong sales down the line.
2. A strong and effective scouting network that identifies players that are needed. Not just ability wise but mentally strong and hungry players on the up.
3. Talented administrators that ensure that contracts are well set up whether that's for new players, youth or players coming in.
4. Quality coaching throughout the ages up to 1st team. Where every penny counts, you have to eek every bit of ability out of what you have. There are excellent examples of this elsewhere with Cooper at Forest being a good example.
5. Good communication between fans and club. Cut out the bullshit, be very honest at all times.
6. Do great work in the community to build trust and a feeling of belonging part of something.

This for me is key. Pretty much all the above has been missing for too long. This is where I want us to improve. Not throw money at it. Build a strong well run club from top to bottom. It's possible, with the right people. We aren't there with the right people now but this should be the RG and Lai focus and ambition.

Great post Rich and highlights what I hate about the modern game, where you can be an underachieving club who are suddenly transformed just because someone incredibly rich has picked them to be their plaything.

The problem I have with Lai is not that he isn't willing to chuck millions of his own money on new players it's more that he's had such a hands off approach and has let the club drift so that we've failed in recent years on many of the points you mention. Jezza for all his faults was more hands on and had some football knowledge. I'm hoping that we've started to realise we can't carry on like this otherwise we'll never be anything better than a mid-table chump club, Gourlay has made some points similar to some of yours so it's up to him and the club to deliver on this.


RE: Ambition, what does it mean? - HawkingsHalfpint - 05-05-2022

I thought *a M B I T I O N* was just another one of football's paradoxical misnomers (or, put a more reminiscent way, 'non-sequiturs'). Along with 'projects', the underbelly, having a great academy, having players 'proud to wear the shirt' and a million and one other things we've all heard before, that scream of optimism without ever actually guaranteeing it. Or in some cases even coming close to representing it.

Yet when all is said and done, it's simply about staying in business; and its investors trying to make the most on their return. JRP did very well out of this. The current lot haven't. Football is a stupid game to follow really, because there are so few winners and quite a few losers, with most of the rest hovering somewhere inbetween. For quite a long while we've hovered pretty well. We're now hovering not so well, and will probably continue to do so until the right combination of factors comes along again that see this change.

During the best recent years, JRP did well to recognise that there was a ceiling to how much he could pump in to guarantee an attractive return on that; and that above a certain expectation the money required wouldn't guarantee the same proportional return. At the same time - around about the time Clarkeycat failed - he probably also realised the risk involved in losing key strategic personnel. And that a lot of our transfer nous, administrative setup endeavours and various other things we did well would become slowly but surly emulated, by those perhaps less risk-averse. To those with the most money, there is a natural sustainability to it all that will keep the money and the advantage flowing their way. To the rest, it's simply a merry-go-round. So I don't really blame him for wanting to get off, and sell it to a bunch who thought that they could do as good a job, when in such a lop-sided climate it's actually in practise far from guaranteed.

So I doubt anyone has no ambition, really. Including us. They may be extremely half-arsed, fanciful, naive, or even hair-brained in the way they go about it, but who wants to fail, really? Not really very many clubs. Just some do it better than others, but for most it will always be ephemeral unless they have bottomless pockets.

Good post though.


RE: Ambition, what does it mean? - Bob Fossil - 05-05-2022

(05-05-2022, 02:01 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Ambition for me would be that we try and play decent, entertaining football, and the players give their all. to come away from the match having enjoyed it, win, lose ort draw. It'd be nice not to have a club who make it feel like we're lurching from one bad idea to the next, one that feels stable.

Like it did not so long ago sort of thing! As loads of others said, a club that feels like it's got a plan and is implementing it for the better.

This was Forest just a few months ago, which shows that things can fall into place very quickly indeed, if all the pieces are in place.
This season is gone, we may as well look forward to next with a positive outlook.