WBAUnofficial
Ratings - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Ratings (/showthread.php?tid=24886)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Ratings - Baggeridgebaggy - 04-09-2022

I don’t think I’ve ever seen an Albion player pass backwards more than Molumby. How we’ve paid money for him I just don’t know. Sums up our recruitment, awful

Mowatt not much better - just hides and doesn’t look fit

That midfield 3 was never going to work, all too similar, none of them even face forward when they receive the ball


RE: Ratings - YoYoBaggie - 04-09-2022

(04-09-2022, 06:08 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: TGH struggled first half. Was exposed a few times but at least showed desire and passion.

Agreed ,but shouldn't  have been taken  out of midfield, I think SB dropped a bollock there .


RE: Ratings - Squid - 04-09-2022

I feel really out of step with everyone.

After I missed Bournemouth, I knew we'd be bad today. All I asked for was a better performance then the last time we played Stoke at home, which was utterly dire.

We looked even until Livermore's absolute brain fart. Then all the energy was sucked out of us, as we've seen so many times before. Bruce should have made changes at half time. Once we scored, we looked good for getting an equaliser. I can't fault Molumby or Carroll. Even Reach when he came on, put in some good crosses. TGH looked out of position, but he'll have learned a lot from today.

It seemed like one of those games where the opposition gets three shots on target and scores three times. It happens.

We haven't learned anything we didn't already know. Need a reset in the summer and to build a team with mental fortitude and organisation.


RE: Ratings - Cheshire East Baggie - 04-09-2022

(04-09-2022, 06:45 PM)Cuzer Wrote: SJ 3 Static for the 3rd, zero interest, first down the tunnel

TGH 3 Sjoke left back who is a good player had him on toast all day, plenty of effort and passion but struggled today, for those saying he’s not a wing back…that’s exactly where he plays

Townsend 2 Disgusting performance and one of the biggest parasites to down tools months ago

Clarke 3 Ropey afternoon after so impressive v Bournemouth

Bartley 2 Stinker, switched off for 2nd and poor throughout

Semi 4 Just about passable but uncomfortable on the ball at the best of times

Mowatt 2 Terrible, looked leggy from the off and game passed him by

Livermore 3 Tried. It just not very good, comical OG summed up the season

Molumby 5Plenty of effort and tried to break the lines at times, no confidence on the ball though, often went sideways when a forward pass was on

Grady 2 Ineffective until withdrawn but tactic completely wrong

Carrol 5* Actually gives a shit, put himself about, won his headers and caused problems, criminally under used 8n the first half

Subs

Robbo 3 Thought he was lazy today and I’ve defended him against others, tidy but no desire

Grant 3 Little impact

Reach 3 He’s dog shit but at least he tries, should be in ahead of Townsend on that alone

As for Bruce I’ve been banging on for weeks on here, Grady behind 2 strikers is our best set up, we did it 2nd half with Robbo there and at least we created a little
Why oh why are we playing that system at home against a side 15th? Such a negative, stand off start to the game when we should be flying out the blocks, that is down to the manager I’m afraid

Terrible, terrible afternoon

Cuzer
No Cuz, no. You are just wrong about this. Ajayi switched off for their second goal. Just like Bristol City's first, for which Bartley also got the blame. Can you not tell these two people apart?


RE: Ratings - Cuzer - 04-09-2022

I’ve not watched any replays back so you may be right, all the social media reports including the express and star video analysis post game said it was Bartleys fault

The lad was given a free run and header so whoever it was needs a rocket

Cuzer


RE: Ratings - Everything Zin - 04-09-2022

He was being marked by Ajayi who just stood and watched him. Bartley was the only defender to react but was never going to get near him. Totally down to Ajayi.


RE: Ratings - Sliced - 04-09-2022

Ajayi should have been marking him. Bartley saw Ajayi was out of position and continued as if everything was fine. Then when the ball was played through he made a half arsed attempt to get back.

Fundamentally Ajayi’s fault but as soon as Bartley saw the situation he should have reacted rather than continue to stroll forward as if everything was fine before ‘trying’ to fix the situation.


RE: Ratings - Tom Joad - 04-09-2022

Reach was decent. First time in an age we managed some decent crosses was after he came on. Jake was fine in a defensive mode, as soon as we expect him to create anything, we'll you know the rest. TGH was hit and miss, huge effort and energy but beaten a few times. Most of the others were worse than dire.


RE: Ratings - Cheshire East Baggie - 04-09-2022

I thought Molumby looked lively, especially later on when Livermore's legs had gone and Mowatt had just gone. He has potential for sure. Small crumb of comfort.


RE: Ratings - TartanRug - 04-09-2022

(04-09-2022, 06:23 PM)coxy134 Wrote: I actually thought Livermore played well certainly passed the ball well.

TGH is not a wing back.

Reach gave us lift in the time he was on.

Mowatt just hid behind opposition players rather than move into space.

Molumby played it back for to often when he could have gone forward.

Getting utterly sick of seeing yet another game pass Mowatt by. Such an important position and he gives us absolutely nothing bar the very occassional belter from the edge of the box. He absolutely does hide and looks like he's scared to death of getting the ball, I know we're not exactly blessed with options there but he plays every game no matter what.