RE: The Pink Vote - Protheroe - 04-01-2022
(04-01-2022, 10:17 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (04-01-2022, 07:25 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-01-2022, 07:11 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Keir quoted what the law says what a woman is and said we need a grown up discussion on the subject.
If you want a grown up discussion on the subject then your starting point would not be that a woman can have a cock, whatever the law says.
Why are some people on the right so obsessed with what people have beneath their underwear?
I'm not. I'm concerned about the impact of a tiny number of trans-extremists on the position of women in society, not least in sport. At least World Cycling has blocked the ridiculous spectacle of that fella racing at the weekend.
RE: The Pink Vote - Squid - 04-01-2022
(04-01-2022, 10:17 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (04-01-2022, 07:25 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-01-2022, 07:11 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Keir quoted what the law says what a woman is and said we need a grown up discussion on the subject.
If you want a grown up discussion on the subject then your starting point would not be that a woman can have a cock, whatever the law says.
Why are some people on the right so obsessed with what people have beneath their underwear?
It's concerning.
And good to see the so called defenders of individual liberty once again laying down the law on what people can and cannot be.
Not people on the right. Women. Women of all political opinions. Because what Starmer has said is not sufficient if he is still going to press for Gender Self-ID.
It is not sufficient when his MPs have abused Rosie Duffield or called women wanting single sex facilities as "Dinosaurs hoarding rights" without any criticism or censure from Starmer.
I knew as soon as I posted that link that some would refuse to read it. It's about a woman who was raped in hospital by another patient. The hospital denied a rape had taken place, because it said there were no male inpatients on the ward. It took the victim a year to get the hospital to admit that actually there was a male on the ward.
Meanwhile, British Cycling were about to permit Emily Bridges (who had raced with the men's team only this year) to race in the women's cycling events. It took the other competitors threatening to boycott for them to change their minds.
You supposedly "progressive" men can sneer all you want about being "obsessed with what people have beneath their underwear". I am telling you that women will not accept being treated as a second class subset of our own sex and allowing our facilities to be lost.
If the Labour Party wants to win the next election, the leader cannot be saying that its wrong to say only women have a cervix and throwing an MP to the wolves in doing so.
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-58698406
The prison service has tried not caring what people had beneath their underwear. Women were raped as a result of that.
RE: The Pink Vote - baggy1 - 04-01-2022
(04-01-2022, 10:53 AM)Squid Wrote: (04-01-2022, 10:17 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (04-01-2022, 07:25 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-01-2022, 07:11 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Keir quoted what the law says what a woman is and said we need a grown up discussion on the subject.
If you want a grown up discussion on the subject then your starting point would not be that a woman can have a cock, whatever the law says.
Why are some people on the right so obsessed with what people have beneath their underwear?
It's concerning.
And good to see the so called defenders of individual liberty once again laying down the law on what people can and cannot be.
Not people on the right. Women. Women of all political opinions. Because what Starmer has said is not sufficient if he is still going to press for Gender Self-ID.
It is not sufficient when his MPs have abused Rosie Duffield or called women wanting single sex facilities as "Dinosaurs hoarding rights" without any criticism or censure from Starmer.
I knew as soon as I posted that link that some would refuse to read it. It's about a woman who was raped in hospital by another patient. The hospital denied a rape had taken place, because it said there were no male inpatients on the ward. It took the victim a year to get the hospital to admit that actually there was a male on the ward.
Meanwhile, British Cycling were about to permit Emily Bridges (who had raced with the men's team only this year) to race in the women's cycling events. It took the other competitors threatening to boycott for them to change their minds.
You supposedly "progressive" men can sneer all you want about being "obsessed with what people have beneath their underwear". I am telling you that women will not accept being treated as a second class subset of our own sex and allowing our facilities to be lost.
If the Labour Party wants to win the next election, the leader cannot be saying that its wrong to say only women have a cervix and throwing an MP to the wolves in doing so.
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-58698406
The prison service has tried not caring what people had beneath their underwear. Women were raped as a result of that.
You do realise who the party is that make the current rules for the prison service up is don't you?
RE: The Pink Vote - Borin' Baggie - 04-01-2022
(04-01-2022, 10:53 AM)Squid Wrote: (04-01-2022, 10:17 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (04-01-2022, 07:25 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-01-2022, 07:11 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Keir quoted what the law says what a woman is and said we need a grown up discussion on the subject.
If you want a grown up discussion on the subject then your starting point would not be that a woman can have a cock, whatever the law says.
Why are some people on the right so obsessed with what people have beneath their underwear?
It's concerning.
And good to see the so called defenders of individual liberty once again laying down the law on what people can and cannot be.
Not people on the right. Women. Women of all political opinions. Because what Starmer has said is not sufficient if he is still going to press for Gender Self-ID.
It is not sufficient when his MPs have abused Rosie Duffield or called women wanting single sex facilities as "Dinosaurs hoarding rights" without any criticism or censure from Starmer.
I knew as soon as I posted that link that some would refuse to read it. It's about a woman who was raped in hospital by another patient. The hospital denied a rape had taken place, because it said there were no male inpatients on the ward. It took the victim a year to get the hospital to admit that actually there was a male on the ward.
Meanwhile, British Cycling were about to permit Emily Bridges (who had raced with the men's team only this year) to race in the women's cycling events. It took the other competitors threatening to boycott for them to change their minds.
You supposedly "progressive" men can sneer all you want about being "obsessed with what people have beneath their underwear". I am telling you that women will not accept being treated as a second class subset of our own sex and allowing our facilities to be lost.
If the Labour Party wants to win the next election, the leader cannot be saying that its wrong to say only women have a cervix and throwing an MP to the wolves in doing so.
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-58698406
The prison service has tried not caring what people had beneath their underwear. Women were raped as a result of that.
Self-ID is about access to legal services, not access to spaces. Access to spaces based on self identification of gender already exists and has done forever. The whole argument over self-ID wouldn't even exist if gaining access to gender identification certificates wasn't so ludicrous that it takes 7 years to go from referral to first appointment and my mate who has been living as a man, has a beard due to hormone therapy, had a double mastectomy and uses male spaces still isn't legally classed as a woman because he is stuck in an underfunded queue. Not to mention that he's had to fund his treatment privately because the NHS is such a mess.
Emily Bridges was blocked from competing because of international competition rules, not a boycott, based around fair competition for participants which suggests the rules are fine. The prison service not having suitable facilities for third spaces separate to men and women's wings outside of a single prison is because of inadequate facilities and underfunding meaning risk mitigation is hamstrung by available access to resources.
And none of this is the fault of Labour or Kier Starmer, and it wholly irrelevant to what the "definition of a woman is". All this culture war bollocks does is act as a convenient distraction for the Tories to not actually do anything meaningful to solve the problems.
Any loophole on allowing this torture to be applied to transgender people opens it up to be applied to any and all LGBT people. Wonder how many butch lesbians or effeminate gay people will be swept up by this as a means of applying those loopholes to help "straighten them up"?
Typical lack of foresight from the government to keep them pushing the culture wars in the hope of distracting from the issues their incompetence is causing, if not for ITV calling them out yesterday then it wouldn't even be a bloody loophole either.
RE: The Pink Vote - Derek Hardballs - 04-01-2022
(04-01-2022, 10:53 AM)Squid Wrote: (04-01-2022, 10:17 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (04-01-2022, 07:25 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-01-2022, 07:11 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Keir quoted what the law says what a woman is and said we need a grown up discussion on the subject.
If you want a grown up discussion on the subject then your starting point would not be that a woman can have a cock, whatever the law says.
Why are some people on the right so obsessed with what people have beneath their underwear?
It's concerning.
And good to see the so called defenders of individual liberty once again laying down the law on what people can and cannot be.
Not people on the right. Women. Women of all political opinions. Because what Starmer has said is not sufficient if he is still going to press for Gender Self-ID.
It is not sufficient when his MPs have abused Rosie Duffield or called women wanting single sex facilities as "Dinosaurs hoarding rights" without any criticism or censure from Starmer.
I knew as soon as I posted that link that some would refuse to read it. It's about a woman who was raped in hospital by another patient. The hospital denied a rape had taken place, because it said there were no male inpatients on the ward. It took the victim a year to get the hospital to admit that actually there was a male on the ward.
Meanwhile, British Cycling were about to permit Emily Bridges (who had raced with the men's team only this year) to race in the women's cycling events. It took the other competitors threatening to boycott for them to change their minds.
You supposedly "progressive" men can sneer all you want about being "obsessed with what people have beneath their underwear". I am telling you that women will not accept being treated as a second class subset of our own sex and allowing our facilities to be lost.
If the Labour Party wants to win the next election, the leader cannot be saying that its wrong to say only women have a cervix and throwing an MP to the wolves in doing so.
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-58698406
The prison service has tried not caring what people had beneath their underwear. Women were raped as a result of that.
At what point do voters start blaming the government in power rather than the one who has been out of power over a decade? It’s getting silly now.
RE: The Pink Vote - Protheroe - 04-01-2022
(04-01-2022, 10:53 AM)Squid Wrote: (04-01-2022, 10:17 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (04-01-2022, 07:25 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-01-2022, 07:11 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Keir quoted what the law says what a woman is and said we need a grown up discussion on the subject.
If you want a grown up discussion on the subject then your starting point would not be that a woman can have a cock, whatever the law says.
Why are some people on the right so obsessed with what people have beneath their underwear?
It's concerning.
And good to see the so called defenders of individual liberty once again laying down the law on what people can and cannot be.
Not people on the right. Women. Women of all political opinions. Because what Starmer has said is not sufficient if he is still going to press for Gender Self-ID.
It is not sufficient when his MPs have abused Rosie Duffield or called women wanting single sex facilities as "Dinosaurs hoarding rights" without any criticism or censure from Starmer.
I knew as soon as I posted that link that some would refuse to read it. It's about a woman who was raped in hospital by another patient. The hospital denied a rape had taken place, because it said there were no male inpatients on the ward. It took the victim a year to get the hospital to admit that actually there was a male on the ward.
Meanwhile, British Cycling were about to permit Emily Bridges (who had raced with the men's team only this year) to race in the women's cycling events. It took the other competitors threatening to boycott for them to change their minds.
You supposedly "progressive" men can sneer all you want about being "obsessed with what people have beneath their underwear". I am telling you that women will not accept being treated as a second class subset of our own sex and allowing our facilities to be lost.
If the Labour Party wants to win the next election, the leader cannot be saying that its wrong to say only women have a cervix and throwing an MP to the wolves in doing so.
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-58698406
The prison service has tried not caring what people had beneath their underwear. Women were raped as a result of that.
Amen to all that.
RE: The Pink Vote - baggy1 - 04-01-2022
(04-01-2022, 12:40 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-01-2022, 10:53 AM)Squid Wrote: (04-01-2022, 10:17 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (04-01-2022, 07:25 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-01-2022, 07:11 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Keir quoted what the law says what a woman is and said we need a grown up discussion on the subject.
If you want a grown up discussion on the subject then your starting point would not be that a woman can have a cock, whatever the law says.
Why are some people on the right so obsessed with what people have beneath their underwear?
It's concerning.
And good to see the so called defenders of individual liberty once again laying down the law on what people can and cannot be.
Not people on the right. Women. Women of all political opinions. Because what Starmer has said is not sufficient if he is still going to press for Gender Self-ID.
It is not sufficient when his MPs have abused Rosie Duffield or called women wanting single sex facilities as "Dinosaurs hoarding rights" without any criticism or censure from Starmer.
A) I knew as soon as I posted that link that some would refuse to read it. B) It's about a woman who was raped in hospital by another patient. The hospital denied a rape had taken place, because it said there were no male inpatients on the ward. It took the victim a year to get the hospital to admit that actually there was a male on the ward.
Meanwhile, British Cycling were about to permit Emily Bridges (who had raced with the men's team only this year) to race in the women's cycling events. It took the other competitors threatening to boycott for them to change their minds.
You supposedly "progressive" men can sneer all you want about being "obsessed with what people have beneath their underwear". I am telling you that women will not accept being treated as a second class subset of our own sex and allowing our facilities to be lost.
If the Labour Party wants to win the next election, the leader cannot be saying that its wrong to say only women have a cervix and throwing an MP to the wolves in doing so.
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-politics-58698406
C) The prison service has tried not caring what people had beneath their underwear. Women were raped as a result of that.
Amen to all that.
Just to clarify some of the points raised by the resident gammons for today.
A) Nobody refused to read it, it's behind a paywall and I do refuse to pay to read anything from that Tory propaganda machine.
B) Presumably the hospital is following government guidelines on the treatment of patients in hospitals
C) Presumably the prison service is following government guidelines of the treatment of prisoners in prison
And somehow from all that indignation you don't appear to want to criticise those that actually put the laws and guidelines in place that allow these incidents. You seem to have a hard on (sorry for the pun in such a serious discussion) to criticise the bloke that has said this needs a serious discussion on the subject as is highlighted in BBs post. You appear to be responding in true Borislavs dogs style to anything the tory party say and have simplified it down to 'Some bloke called George had a shave and put a skirt on and is in the women's changing room' type argument.
And I repeat - the party in power allowing the hospital and prison incidents are not the one headed up by the chap being criticised for quoting the law and saying we need to have a proper conversation about this which going by your comments is very clearly correct.
And as an edit Squid old chap - the bit i've highlighted in italics: Are you getting confused over your own gender or is that just a bad cut and paste job? Busted
RE: The Pink Vote - backsidebaggie - 04-01-2022
Although I agree that the culture war aspect of all this is distracting from more prominent issues, I’d say firstly when it comes to Emily Bridges and trans women in women’s sport, there’s going to be a hell of a backlash from women and I don’t blame them.
And labelling people gammons when they’ve made points about gender… whether you agree with them or not Baggy1, it’s so immature. Women have a lot of concerns about this and name calling and labelling them gammons is really not the adult conversation you’re saying should happen.
But then again, why am I surprised any more, the labelling and name calling on here is staggering.
RE: The Pink Vote - baggy1 - 04-01-2022
(04-01-2022, 01:15 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Although I agree that the culture war aspect of all this is distracting from more prominent issues, I’d say firstly when it comes to Emily Bridges and trans women in women’s sport, there’s going to be a hell of a backlash from women and I don’t blame them.
And labelling people gammons when they’ve made points about gender… whether you agree with them or not Baggy1, it’s so immature. Women have a lot of concerns about this and name calling and labelling them gammons is really not the adult conversation you’re saying should happen.
But then again, why am I surprised any more, the labelling and name calling on here is staggering.
Read the reasoning behind the gammon quotes bb, don't just fall into the comfortable position of 'please everyone stop name calling'. Squid has even ballsed up a cut and paste line to tell him how to react.
RE: The Pink Vote - Shabby Russian - 04-01-2022
A reply to Squid.
You seem to be suggesting that the trans community it as a whole can be judged by a tiny minority who commit crime.
No one is suggesting that there aren't difficult areas with regard to trans issues and prison is one of those areas.But there has to be a balance both ways...it wouldn't be right to send someone who has lived as a trans woman for a long period of time, and has been accepted by the wider community as a woman, to a male prison.
And if I was you I wouldn't claim to speak for all women, Whilst I am sceptical of polling many show that a majority of women don't necessarily agree with your view.
|