WBAUnofficial
Looks like 20 points needed - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Looks like 20 points needed (/showthread.php?tid=24678)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Looks like 20 points needed - Kit Kat Chunky - 03-19-2022

(03-19-2022, 09:27 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(03-19-2022, 08:11 PM)Artist Wrote: Even if we have a storming end to the season (without making the play offs), I'd just put it down to the players only performing when the pressure is off again. Time for a new manager in the summer.

Time for a major refresh of the squad

Exactly. The players are shit, so lets sack another manager..............


RE: Looks like 20 points needed - TartanRug - 03-19-2022

(03-19-2022, 09:27 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(03-19-2022, 08:11 PM)Artist Wrote: Even if we have a storming end to the season (without making the play offs), I'd just put it down to the players only performing when the pressure is off again. Time for a new manager in the summer.

Time for a major refresh of the squad

It certainly is but the problem is whether we can get rid of a lot of the dross that still have years of contract left


RE: Looks like 20 points needed - WorcsWBA - 03-19-2022

It's just been a catalogue of errors by the Board since the Bilic promotion season. Huge sums wasted on players that didn't really warrant it, letting Pereira go for about half of what he was worth and then they presided over, and learned nothing from, the Allardyce disaster which saw us get much worse when he first arrived and ended up with us winning just 4 of the 25 games for which he was at the helm.

Having failed to persuade Allardyce to stay (they shouldn't have tried - I never got the impression his heart was in it at any point), they made a brave and unusual (for us) decision to go for a project. However, the project should have been based on the vision of, and under the control of, a Director of Football. Instead, at best, we had just an adviser and maybe not even that.

Having set the project under way, the Board's job was to provide Ismael with the tools to enable him to get off to a flying start, given that the plan was still to get promoted. They miserably failed, merely bringing in a small group of uninspiring loans and free transfers, some of which smacked of desperation rather than inspiration. 

A flying start was nonetheless obtained, but it was derailed when it became apparent that a majority of the fans weren't up for a project, at least not that particular one, and weren't willing to tolerate a poor run of form where they didn't feel that Ismael's style of play was entertaining enough to compensate for a blip. The Board did what it should have done in the summer and made a key signing in January. It was so unlucky that Dike got injured on his home debut, because I believe we'd still be well in the hunt if he'd stayed fit, with Ismael still here.

However, a bit of player power was added to the fan unrest to push things towards the cliff and the Board, with Dike now injured, lost its nerve and sacked Ismael just 7 months into his 4 year contract when we were in 5th place at the time.

Then it became Groundhog Day with a virtual repeat of what happened with Allardyce. The Board panicked and brought in another vastly experienced manager who nevertheless had some baggage and, once again, things got worse and, despite a minor recovery, we've now slipped down the table to the point where a miracle is now required for us just to make the play-offs.

All the while during the above, the Board failed to spot that the actual problem is the players - poor signings, cheap options and rewarding older players who've been part of the problem rather than part of the solution with lengthy new contracts, meaning that we're now pretty much stuck with them all for at least one more season.

So what to do about Bruce? He was brought in to at least get us into the play-offs and, if he fails to do that, if you also bear in mind the effects of his punishing experience at Newcastle in the end, I think he should leave at the end of the season.

In the meantime, regardless of what happens, we should be leaving no stone unturned to identify and appoint a visionary, talented and well-connected Director of Football ready for the close season and then allow him to come up with another project that will introduce a style of play that fans are more likely to accept, and then bring in first the manager and then enough players before the season starts to give the next project a chance to get off to an excellent start.

No more short-termism and no more failing to join the dots, otherwise we could be in this division, or worse, for years to come.


RE: Looks like 20 points needed - Sliced - 03-19-2022

(03-19-2022, 10:01 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: It's just been a catalogue of errors by the Board since the Bilic promotion season. Huge sums wasted on players that didn't really warrant it, letting Pereira go for about half of what he was worth and then they presided over, and learned nothing from, the Allardyce disaster which saw us get much worse when he first arrived and ended up with us winning just 4 of the 25 games for which he was at the helm.

Having failed to persuade Allardyce to stay (they shouldn't have tried - I never got the impression his heart was in it at any point), they made a brave and unusual (for us) decision to go for a project. However, the project should have been based on the vision of, and under the control of, a Director of Football. Instead, at best, we had just an adviser and maybe not even that.

Having set the project under way, the Board's job was to provide Ismael with the tools to enable him to get off to a flying start, given that the plan was still to get promoted. They miserably failed, merely bringing in a small group of uninspiring loans and free transfers, some of which smacked of desperation rather than inspiration. 

A flying start was nonetheless obtained, but it was derailed when it became apparent that a majority of the fans weren't up for a project, at least not that particular one, and weren't willing to tolerate a poor run of form where they didn't feel that Ismael's style of play was entertaining enough to compensate for a blip. The Board did what it should have done in the summer and made a key signing in January. It was so unlucky that Dike got injured on his home debut, because I believe we'd still be well in the hunt if he'd stayed fit, with Ismael still here.

However, a bit of player power was added to the fan unrest to push things towards the cliff and the Board, with Dike now injured, lost its nerve and sacked Ismael just 7 months into his 4 year contract when we were in 5th place at the time.

Then it became Groundhog Day with a virtual repeat of what happened with Allardyce. The Board panicked and brought in another vastly experienced manager who nevertheless had some baggage and, once again, things got worse and, despite a minor recovery, we've now slipped down the table to the point where a miracle is now required for us just to make the play-offs.

All the while during the above, the Board failed to spot that the actual problem is the players - poor signings, cheap options and rewarding older players who've been part of the problem rather than part of the solution with lengthy new contracts, meaning that we're now pretty much stuck with them all for at least one more season.

So what to do about Bruce? He was brought in to at least get us into the play-offs and, if he fails to do that, if you also bear in mind the effects of his punishing experience at Newcastle in the end, I think he should leave at the end of the season.

In the meantime, regardless of what happens, we should be leaving no stone unturned to identify and appoint a visionary, talented and well-connected Director of Football ready for the close season and then allow him to come up with another project that will introduce a style of play that fans are more likely to accept, and then bring in first the manager and then enough players before the season starts to give the next project a chance to get off to an excellent start.

No more short-termism and no more failing to join the dots, otherwise we could be in this division, or worse, for years to come.

Just a brilliant post. Perfect summary really


RE: Looks like 20 points needed - Squid - 03-19-2022

(03-19-2022, 10:13 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(03-19-2022, 10:01 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: It's just been a catalogue of errors by the Board since the Bilic promotion season. Huge sums wasted on players that didn't really warrant it, letting Pereira go for about half of what he was worth and then they presided over, and learned nothing from, the Allardyce disaster which saw us get much worse when he first arrived and ended up with us winning just 4 of the 25 games for which he was at the helm.

Having failed to persuade Allardyce to stay (they shouldn't have tried - I never got the impression his heart was in it at any point), they made a brave and unusual (for us) decision to go for a project. However, the project should have been based on the vision of, and under the control of, a Director of Football. Instead, at best, we had just an adviser and maybe not even that.

Having set the project under way, the Board's job was to provide Ismael with the tools to enable him to get off to a flying start, given that the plan was still to get promoted. They miserably failed, merely bringing in a small group of uninspiring loans and free transfers, some of which smacked of desperation rather than inspiration. 

A flying start was nonetheless obtained, but it was derailed when it became apparent that a majority of the fans weren't up for a project, at least not that particular one, and weren't willing to tolerate a poor run of form where they didn't feel that Ismael's style of play was entertaining enough to compensate for a blip. The Board did what it should have done in the summer and made a key signing in January. It was so unlucky that Dike got injured on his home debut, because I believe we'd still be well in the hunt if he'd stayed fit, with Ismael still here.

However, a bit of player power was added to the fan unrest to push things towards the cliff and the Board, with Dike now injured, lost its nerve and sacked Ismael just 7 months into his 4 year contract when we were in 5th place at the time.

Then it became Groundhog Day with a virtual repeat of what happened with Allardyce. The Board panicked and brought in another vastly experienced manager who nevertheless had some baggage and, once again, things got worse and, despite a minor recovery, we've now slipped down the table to the point where a miracle is now required for us just to make the play-offs.

All the while during the above, the Board failed to spot that the actual problem is the players - poor signings, cheap options and rewarding older players who've been part of the problem rather than part of the solution with lengthy new contracts, meaning that we're now pretty much stuck with them all for at least one more season.

So what to do about Bruce? He was brought in to at least get us into the play-offs and, if he fails to do that, if you also bear in mind the effects of his punishing experience at Newcastle in the end, I think he should leave at the end of the season.

In the meantime, regardless of what happens, we should be leaving no stone unturned to identify and appoint a visionary, talented and well-connected Director of Football ready for the close season and then allow him to come up with another project that will introduce a style of play that fans are more likely to accept, and then bring in first the manager and then enough players before the season starts to give the next project a chance to get off to an excellent start.

No more short-termism and no more failing to join the dots, otherwise we could be in this division, or worse, for years to come.

Just a brilliant post. Perfect summary really

I would agree. The major thing I learned is that style is critical here. I am a Winning At All Costs type, but I'm in the minority. Covid hasn't helped, but even when we were winning, the attendances were starting to slide and I say that as someone who liked Ismael.

We cannot be short term, but it doesn't mean being entirely Jam Tomorrow either. Make sensible choices for today, make sensible decisions for the future. Too often we've done neither.

We've also had some awful luck along the way.


RE: Looks like 20 points needed - wba13 - 03-19-2022

As good a post worcs puts across, I’m sticking with Bruce as I’m sick and tired of constant change. I think he deserves the chance no matter what happens this season. He deserves the chance to change the mindset of our crap bunch of wasters and bring in some players that he wants and we need. Remember we went long term with Ismael and a lot of players that worked out well didn’t it. I must admit I would like DOF but we also know it’s not on the agenda at present. So for me as the last couple of weeks have shown we have found some fight, let’s hope that fight gives them confidence.


RE: Looks like 20 points needed - Big Daddy Cool - 03-19-2022

I don't understand how anyone who paid good money to watch us this season would have wanted Val to stay. I've never seen such a terrible atmosphere inside The Hawthorns and it was a result of the mindnumbing atrocious football he was serving up. Fans will put up with it if it's getting results but near the end we were one of the worst form sides in the league, we were hardly scoring goals and he was falling out with a different player every week. Add to that our lack of discipline and the type of signings he made. His refusal to make changes and choosing to ignore what was happening in front of him just because our xG stat was decent was simply baffling management. Four more years of that....really?

I've seen more positives the last few games under Bruce than I saw in months under Val. And I actually think Bruce will make signings to improve us if given chance.


RE: Looks like 20 points needed - Hopalong - 03-20-2022

(03-19-2022, 10:01 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: It's just been a catalogue of errors by the Board since the Bilic promotion season. Huge sums wasted on players that didn't really warrant it, letting Pereira go for about half of what he was worth and then they presided over, and learned nothing from, the Allardyce disaster which saw us get much worse when he first arrived and ended up with us winning just 4 of the 25 games for which he was at the helm.

Having failed to persuade Allardyce to stay (they shouldn't have tried - I never got the impression his heart was in it at any point), they made a brave and unusual (for us) decision to go for a project. However, the project should have been based on the vision of, and under the control of, a Director of Football. Instead, at best, we had just an adviser and maybe not even that.

Having set the project under way, the Board's job was to provide Ismael with the tools to enable him to get off to a flying start, given that the plan was still to get promoted. They miserably failed, merely bringing in a small group of uninspiring loans and free transfers, some of which smacked of desperation rather than inspiration. 

A flying start was nonetheless obtained, but it was derailed when it became apparent that a majority of the fans weren't up for a project, at least not that particular one, and weren't willing to tolerate a poor run of form where they didn't feel that Ismael's style of play was entertaining enough to compensate for a blip. The Board did what it should have done in the summer and made a key signing in January. It was so unlucky that Dike got injured on his home debut, because I believe we'd still be well in the hunt if he'd stayed fit, with Ismael still here.

However, a bit of player power was added to the fan unrest to push things towards the cliff and the Board, with Dike now injured, lost its nerve and sacked Ismael just 7 months into his 4 year contract when we were in 5th place at the time.

Then it became Groundhog Day with a virtual repeat of what happened with Allardyce. The Board panicked and brought in another vastly experienced manager who nevertheless had some baggage and, once again, things got worse and, despite a minor recovery, we've now slipped down the table to the point where a miracle is now required for us just to make the play-offs.

All the while during the above, the Board failed to spot that the actual problem is the players - poor signings, cheap options and rewarding older players who've been part of the problem rather than part of the solution with lengthy new contracts, meaning that we're now pretty much stuck with them all for at least one more season.

So what to do about Bruce? He was brought in to at least get us into the play-offs and, if he fails to do that, if you also bear in mind the effects of his punishing experience at Newcastle in the end, I think he should leave at the end of the season.

In the meantime, regardless of what happens, we should be leaving no stone unturned to identify and appoint a visionary, talented and well-connected Director of Football ready for the close season and then allow him to come up with another project that will introduce a style of play that fans are more likely to accept, and then bring in first the manager and then enough players before the season starts to give the next project a chance to get off to an excellent start.

No more short-termism and no more failing to join the dots, otherwise we could be in this division, or worse, for years to come.

Cheers Worcs, a great summary.

Problem is we have no real influence on strategy and we have no idea what the thoughts of our owners are in terms of longevity.

All I know is we all deeply love our club and we're hurting at the moment.  None of us individually have any control or influence on the future direction really.  We just seem to go from one crisis to another, difficult to know what the solution and way forward is. 

Having said that had we won today we wouldn't be having this discussion.  

Fine margins indeed.


RE: Looks like 20 points needed - Tom Joad - 03-20-2022

WorcsWBA Wrote:It's just been a catalogue of errors by the Board since the Bilic promotion season. Huge sums wasted on players that didn't really warrant it, letting Pereira go for about half of what he was worth and then they presided over, and learned nothing from, the Allardyce disaster which saw us get much worse when he first arrived and ended up with us winning just 4 of the 25 games for which he was at the helm.

Having failed to persuade Allardyce to stay (they shouldn't have tried - I never got the impression his heart was in it at any point), they made a brave and unusual (for us) decision to go for a project. However, the project should have been based on the vision of, and under the control of, a Director of Football. Instead, at best, we had just an adviser and maybe not even that.

Having set the project under way, the Board's job was to provide Ismael with the tools to enable him to get off to a flying start, given that the plan was still to get promoted. They miserably failed, merely bringing in a small group of uninspiring loans and free transfers, some of which smacked of desperation rather than inspiration. 

A flying start was nonetheless obtained, but it was derailed when it became apparent that a majority of the fans weren't up for a project, at least not that particular one, and weren't willing to tolerate a poor run of form where they didn't feel that Ismael's style of play was entertaining enough to compensate for a blip. The Board did what it should have done in the summer and made a key signing in January. It was so unlucky that Dike got injured on his home debut, because I believe we'd still be well in the hunt if he'd stayed fit, with Ismael still here.

However, a bit of player power was added to the fan unrest to push things towards the cliff and the Board, with Dike now injured, lost its nerve and sacked Ismael just 7 months into his 4 year contract when we were in 5th place at the time.

Then it became Groundhog Day with a virtual repeat of what happened with Allardyce. The Board panicked and brought in another vastly experienced manager who nevertheless had some baggage and, once again, things got worse and, despite a minor recovery, we've now slipped down the table to the point where a miracle is now required for us just to make the play-offs.

All the while during the above, the Board failed to spot that the actual problem is the players - poor signings, cheap options and rewarding older players who've been part of the problem rather than part of the solution with lengthy new contracts, meaning that we're now pretty much stuck with them all for at least one more season.

So what to do about Bruce? He was brought in to at least get us into the play-offs and, if he fails to do that, if you also bear in mind the effects of his punishing experience at Newcastle in the end, I think he should leave at the end of the season.

In the meantime, regardless of what happens, we should be leaving no stone unturned to identify and appoint a visionary, talented and well-connected Director of Football ready for the close season and then allow him to come up with another project that will introduce a style of play that fans are more likely to accept, and then bring in first the manager and then enough players before the season starts to give the next project a chance to get off to an excellent start.

No more short-termism and no more failing to join the dots, otherwise we could be in this division, or worse, for years to come.
Great post Worcs. I took the liberty of highlighting the bits that really resonate with me. You will have lit a bonfire here with many simply jumping on the fact that Val was given too long or they just don't like Bruce (or Allardyce or Slav). The fact is, since Pulis was given a free hit to run the club on his terms alone, we have had a tug of war between managers and DoFs and the owner's stooge, whoever that was at the time. In the meantime we have this bunch of players with little spirit and over inflated views of themselves with no lasting team morale, no captain that can galvanise them. Until there is proper leadership from the top down to the team we are doomed to repeat the same mistakes. It is such a situation that I don't think any of us really know for certain whether Bruce should stay or not.
You also missed out the Wilder non appointment farce! the problems at our club summed up in one move!


RE: Looks like 20 points needed - lesley - 03-20-2022

Some great posts here on page 2 of this thread.
Yes, Ismael had to go, but will getting rid of yet another manager (Steve Bruce) really make us into a promotion challenging team? I think I would like to see him given the chance to bring in some players ( difficult , I know with our reputation of spending) and then see what happens. Persistent changing of manager isn’t working!
And as WorcsWBA so eloquently posts, please oh please can we get a good Director of Football.