WBAUnofficial
Another Yoof Departure - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Another Yoof Departure (/showthread.php?tid=23483)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Another Yoof Departure - Lillwall's left foot - 01-11-2022

(01-11-2022, 10:22 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Exemplifies that there is little point in investing in yoof till rules are tightened up to or made so that the signing club needs to pay an appropriate amount of money.

Get the odd Dara/TGH through and keep totting up the cash for the guys not quite making it (Leko, Harper, Field) and it's worthwhile.    Its fugging annoying but the more kids that end up at top clubs the more desirable our academy is to attend.


RE: Another Yoof Departure - baggie_ray - 01-11-2022

(01-11-2022, 11:07 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(01-11-2022, 10:24 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(01-11-2022, 10:18 PM)Dumbo Wrote: I can’t pretend to be angry over someone I never knew existed until I opened this thread.

I'd never heard of him either. Perhaps some of our erm, yoof-minded posters can elaborate.

Great lad. Lovely family. Definitely going to captain England.

He already has. 

Probably.


RE: Another Yoof Departure - Hopalong - 01-12-2022

Happens every day.

Couldn't give  a  f***.  The mercenary will never play for the aresholes. 

No loss.


RE: Another Yoof Departure - Duffers - 01-12-2022

(01-12-2022, 12:51 AM)Hopalong Wrote: Happens every day.

Couldn't give  a  f***.  The mercenary will never play for the aresholes. 

No loss.

Mercenary? Get a fucking grip.


RE: Another Yoof Departure - Pragmatist - 01-12-2022

(01-11-2022, 10:50 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote: According to what I have just read he is 17 next week I believe. Been playing for the U18's as a 16 year old. It says he had a game for the U23's as well.
I think we signed him about 18 months ago. He has played for England youth teams at U15's and U16's
I had heard he was very highly rated and was being sought by other Prem clubs.
No money mentioned and given that he is 17 very soon it would be peanuts anyway I suppose.

We can’t sign players on pro terms until their 17th birthday and the reality of the situation is that our top youngsters get poached when they go away to play in the England age group teams.  They get advised not to sign a pro contract for us which means the big clubs pick them up for peanuts in compensation. 

Until and unless we make a real song and dance about it with other “small” clubs with good Academies nothing is going to change.  Probably the easiest solution is to put in place a sliding scale of compensation based on what that player achieves by age 23, and with a minimum of £250k for a player who leaves before they’ve signed pro terms with us (provided that we prove we have offered them pro terms).  Poaching will always happen and we won’t ever stop that. It’s just the compensation side that urgently needs to be addressed.


RE: Another Yoof Departure - Peachy - 01-12-2022

(01-12-2022, 07:23 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(01-11-2022, 10:50 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote: According to what I have just read he is 17 next week I believe. Been playing for the U18's as a 16 year old. It says he had a game for the U23's as well.
I think we signed him about 18 months ago. He has played for England youth teams at U15's and U16's
I had heard he was very highly rated and was being sought by other Prem clubs.
No money mentioned and given that he is 17 very soon it would be peanuts anyway I suppose.

We can’t sign players on pro terms until their 17th birthday and the reality of the situation is that our top youngsters get poached when they go away to play in the England age group teams.  They get advised not to sign a pro contract for us which means the big clubs pick them up for peanuts in compensation. 

Until and unless we make a real song and dance about it with other “small” clubs with good Academies nothing is going to change.  Probably the easiest solution is to put in place a sliding scale of compensation based on what that player achieves by age 23, and with a minimum of £250k for a player who leaves before they’ve signed pro terms with us (provided that we prove we have offered them pro terms).  Poaching will always happen and we won’t ever stop that. It’s just the compensation side that urgently needs to be addressed.

Agree re the compo. Been saying the same for years. I've always said if a kid moves from an A cat academy to another A Cat academy then the flat compo should be £1m now.

Any top prem side has bilions to spunk but the current compo is pocket change to those sides and they can just stockpile these kids.

The kid is moving for money. Has to be as we are all yhe same standard academies so why else move? He'd also have a much better chance of first team football with us than he would at Arsenal. I'm sure his family have done well out of it so fair play to them.


RE: Another Yoof Departure - Man from delmonte - 01-12-2022

(01-11-2022, 10:22 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Exemplifies that there is little point in investing in yoof till rules are tightened up to or made so that the signing club needs to pay an appropriate amount of money.

Not really. We currently have the likes of O'Shea, TGH and Fellows as part of the main squad and the others like Taylor, Cleary, Ashworth and Griffiths to potentially break through to supplement this. For a self sufficient club like Albion bringing through youth players is going to have to play a huge part for us for to progress as a club as we can't compete in terms of transfer fees.

Ok so we may lose the odd player to Villa but this happens to every club at our level. Only the likes of City and Chelsea with their huge resources are able to hold on to all their youth players as they can chuck unlimited money at it. And of the players we have lost in recent years who has actually been any great success? Izzy Brown is an ok but hugely injury prone Championship player. The likes of Barry and Azaz have hardly been tearing it up in the lower divisions. We got a good fee for Morgan Rogers and Man City clearly decided early on we wasn't worth holding on to for the long term.

I just don't get the despair that some people seem to feel when we lose 16 year olds who in all probability may not have a career in the top two divisions. The England squads at youth levels are full of players who never make it at the top level.


RE: Another Yoof Departure - Peachy - 01-12-2022

(01-12-2022, 07:52 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(01-11-2022, 10:22 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Exemplifies that there is little point in investing in yoof till rules are tightened up to or made so that the signing club needs to pay an appropriate amount of money.

Not really. We currently have the likes of O'Shea, TGH and Fellows as part of the main squad and the others like Taylor, Cleary, Ashworth and Griffiths to potentially break through to supplement this. For a self sufficient club like Albion bringing through youth players is going to have to play a huge part for us for to progress as a club as we can't compete in terms of transfer fees.

Ok so we may lose the odd player to Villa but this happens to every club at our level. Only the likes of City and Chelsea with their huge resources are able to hold on to all their youth players as they can chuck unlimited money at it. And of the players we have lost in recent years who has actually been any great success? Izzy Brown is an ok but hugely injury prone Championship player. The likes of Barry and Azaz have hardly been tearing it up in the lower divisions. We got a good fee for Morgan Rogers and Man City clearly decided early on we wasn't worth holding on to for the long term.

I just don't get the despair that some people seem to feel when we lose 16 year olds who in all probability may not have a career in the top two divisions. The England squads at youth levels are full of players who never make it at the top level.

Good post. I'm the same although I was particularly pissed off with Iregbonum moving to Villa. I just felt that lot were taking the piss and he's already involved in their first team squads. 

For me its all about getting fair compensation. Thats the biggest issue. Its all weighted to the rich clubs getting to cherry pick the best kids and pay fuck all. 

A million pound fee would at least make those clubs weigh up whether they really need that kid and if they do the selling club have proper compo. The compo fee hasn't moved with the times. A £2m player 10 years ago is £10m in todays money yet the compo fee for poaching a 16 year old academy prospect hasnt changed. Thats wrong imo.


RE: Another Yoof Departure - Man from delmonte - 01-12-2022

(01-12-2022, 08:59 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(01-12-2022, 07:52 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(01-11-2022, 10:22 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Exemplifies that there is little point in investing in yoof till rules are tightened up to or made so that the signing club needs to pay an appropriate amount of money.

Not really. We currently have the likes of O'Shea, TGH and Fellows as part of the main squad and the others like Taylor, Cleary, Ashworth and Griffiths to potentially break through to supplement this. For a self sufficient club like Albion bringing through youth players is going to have to play a huge part for us for to progress as a club as we can't compete in terms of transfer fees.

Ok so we may lose the odd player to Villa but this happens to every club at our level. Only the likes of City and Chelsea with their huge resources are able to hold on to all their youth players as they can chuck unlimited money at it. And of the players we have lost in recent years who has actually been any great success? Izzy Brown is an ok but hugely injury prone Championship player. The likes of Barry and Azaz have hardly been tearing it up in the lower divisions. We got a good fee for Morgan Rogers and Man City clearly decided early on we wasn't worth holding on to for the long term.

I just don't get the despair that some people seem to feel when we lose 16 year olds who in all probability may not have a career in the top two divisions. The England squads at youth levels are full of players who never make it at the top level.

Good post. I'm the same although I was particularly pissed off with Iregbonum moving to Villa. I just felt that lot were taking the piss and he's already involved in their first team squads. 

For me its all about getting fair compensation. Thats the biggest issue. Its all weighted to the rich clubs getting to cherry pick the best kids and pay fuck all. 

A million pound fee would at least make those clubs weigh up whether they really need that kid and if they do the selling club have proper compo. The compo fee hasn't moved with the times. A £2m player 10 years ago is £10m in todays money yet the compo fee for poaching a 16 year old academy prospect hasnt changed. Thats wrong imo.

Fully agree with what you're saying there.


RE: Another Yoof Departure - MrFizz - 01-12-2022

(01-12-2022, 09:34 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(01-12-2022, 08:59 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(01-12-2022, 07:52 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(01-11-2022, 10:22 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Exemplifies that there is little point in investing in yoof till rules are tightened up to or made so that the signing club needs to pay an appropriate amount of money.

Not really. We currently have the likes of O'Shea, TGH and Fellows as part of the main squad and the others like Taylor, Cleary, Ashworth and Griffiths to potentially break through to supplement this. For a self sufficient club like Albion bringing through youth players is going to have to play a huge part for us for to progress as a club as we can't compete in terms of transfer fees.

Ok so we may lose the odd player to Villa but this happens to every club at our level. Only the likes of City and Chelsea with their huge resources are able to hold on to all their youth players as they can chuck unlimited money at it. And of the players we have lost in recent years who has actually been any great success? Izzy Brown is an ok but hugely injury prone Championship player. The likes of Barry and Azaz have hardly been tearing it up in the lower divisions. We got a good fee for Morgan Rogers and Man City clearly decided early on we wasn't worth holding on to for the long term.

I just don't get the despair that some people seem to feel when we lose 16 year olds who in all probability may not have a career in the top two divisions. The England squads at youth levels are full of players who never make it at the top level.

Good post. I'm the same although I was particularly pissed off with Iregbonum moving to Villa. I just felt that lot were taking the piss and he's already involved in their first team squads. 

For me its all about getting fair compensation. Thats the biggest issue. Its all weighted to the rich clubs getting to cherry pick the best kids and pay fuck all. 

A million pound fee would at least make those clubs weigh up whether they really need that kid and if they do the selling club have proper compo. The compo fee hasn't moved with the times. A £2m player 10 years ago is £10m in todays money yet the compo fee for poaching a 16 year old academy prospect hasnt changed. Thats wrong imo.

Fully agree with what you're saying there.

An yowm roit.