WBAUnofficial
Button? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Button? (/showthread.php?tid=23450)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Button? - MrFizz - 01-09-2022

Had a good game i thought. Three excellent saves, kicking was good. Got a bit over-enthusiastic at times with the sweeper-keeper stuff, but its only his second game in this system so he should get more used to that if he plays more.


RE: Button? - Wotty - 01-09-2022

I wondered when this thread would appear.

I must admit I was grateful I wasn’t eating or drinking anything when I read someone describe his first half as ‘faultless’

His first two clearances would have had SJ marked down as a ‘4’ instantly. His first one was wild into the crowd and the other one was panicked due to lack of communication.

He hesitated coming off his line which meant he had to make one of a number of decent saves he made. One of his ‘sweeper’ clearances was entirely down to Barts or Kipre fouling their centre forward otherwise he wasn’t getting there.

Second half was a touch calamitous.

He’s actually better than that yesterday, his kicking was just terrible.

Surely that puts to bed the decision as to whether we try and hold onto SJ or not.

I appreciate it’s an unpopular observation, I get that, but SJ would have been absolutely slaughtered for a fraction of what Button did yesterday


RE: Button? - chasetownbaggie - 01-09-2022

Disappointed he got beat at the near post for their equaliser though.

The Brighton fans don't like him, do they?


RE: Button? - Peachy - 01-09-2022

I think in Button and Palmer we have enough this season to cope with losing SJ. SJ is going to move. He doesn't want to stay and wants a big payday. The issue is we cannot afford to let him move for nothing so we need to make a deal this month. Now SJ might well not want that as it jeopardises a big signing on fee this summer but we should call his bluff. The club is the most important issue and we need money to strengthen.

Tell SJ unless he moves now we will drop him (thus harming his England place). We did it with Pereira, with Val stating he only wants players committed to the club, and I honestly don't see how SJs current stance is any different. It's obvious he's looking for the best deal for himself and not interested in the club making any money. We need to be ruthless imo.


RE: Button? - chasetownbaggie - 01-09-2022

(01-09-2022, 12:17 PM)Loanee Wrote: No idea why we aren’t playing Palmer is games like yesterday.

Proved he is more than good enough for league 1 last season, Young & part of the future, whilst Button is simply a stop gap

I did think that too.


RE: Button? - EastMidsBaggie - 01-09-2022

Wotty Wrote:I wondered when this thread would appear.

I must admit I was grateful I wasn’t eating or drinking anything when I read someone describe his first half as ‘faultless’

His first two clearances would have had SJ marked down as a ‘4’ instantly. His first one was wild into the crowd and the other one was panicked due to lack of communication.

He hesitated coming off his line which meant he had to make one of a number of decent saves he made. One of his ‘sweeper’ clearances was entirely down to Barts or Kipre fouling their centre forward otherwise he wasn’t getting there.

Second half was a touch calamitous.

He’s actually better than that yesterday, his kicking was just terrible.

Surely that puts to bed the decision as to whether we try and hold onto SJ or not.

I appreciate it’s an unpopular observation, I get that, but SJ would have been absolutely slaughtered for a fraction of what Button did yesterday

Didn't thinks he was quite that bad but not particularly good either.
Not sure why we think if we sell Sam (one of the best in the division) we think we wouldn't have to replace and 'could get by' with a less that average keeper at this top half level ?


RE: Button? - wba13 - 01-09-2022

Button looked to me what he is a decent 2nd choice keeper, kicking woeful, made some decent saves but also beaten easily at the near post for 1st goal.
Not for me a championship first choice, if Sam goes we need a replacement.
Nothing against Button and I am happy for him to be a suspension or injury replacement for two or three matches, but our first choice not for me.


RE: Button? - HLS - 01-09-2022

For me, the difference between Johnstone and Button is the same as Mitrovic to Grant. It'd be swapping best in the league for an alright one. We need our best players and Johnstone is probably the best, especially given how he's adapted to the sweeper role.


RE: Button? - oldun - 01-09-2022

(01-09-2022, 01:46 PM)wba13 Wrote: Button looked to me what he is a decent 2nd choice keeper, kicking woeful, made some decent saves but also beaten easily at the near post for 1st goal.
Not for me a championship first choice, if Sam goes we need a replacement.
Nothing against Button and I am happy for him to be a suspension or injury replacement for two or three matches, but our first choice not for me.

Perhaps we could persuade West Ham to give us a few mill and Fabianski?i   not a great fan of SJ I'm afraid, disappointed he doesn't  think enough of our club to sign a contract as Bellingham  did,  money is all I suppose


RE: Button? - baggiebloke - 01-09-2022

(01-09-2022, 02:09 PM)HLS Wrote: For me, the difference between Johnstone and Button is the same as Mitrovic to Grant. It'd be swapping best in the league for an alright one. We need our best players and Johnstone is probably the best, especially given how he's adapted to the sweeper role.

^

In fairness to Benjamin, yesterday was a cameo and he did alright.