WBAUnofficial
2nd hand car advice off diesel eds - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: 2nd hand car advice off diesel eds (/showthread.php?tid=23368)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: 2nd hand car advice off diesel eds - boingingjim - 01-04-2022

Not sure how big / old your family is but the B Class is substantial step up in practicality / space vs A Class.

Mercs are a class product now for sure.


RE: 2nd hand car advice off diesel eds - Midget In A Pinstripe Suit - 01-04-2022

Had my Audi A4 estate for about 6 months now, love it. It's a diesel as well but don't let that put you off, I think everything registered after April 2017 falls in the medium tax bracket so isn't as bad on the pocket as I'd expected. I went second hand and also don't do massive mileage, would recommend but as KK says most German cars are similar in terms of what you get for your money.


RE: 2nd hand car advice off diesel eds - Protheroe - 01-04-2022

I bought Mrs P a second hand XF-S 3.0 V6 last weekend, you can get a late model well specced 2.0 180ps diesel within your budget - I wouldn't write diesels off unless you really are just pootling to the shops and back.


RE: 2nd hand car advice off diesel eds - Cheshire East Baggie - 01-04-2022

(01-04-2022, 08:22 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: I've owned lots of cars over the years.
Bar far the most reliable is Honda. My current CRV I've had for 3 years and it has never missed a beat, nothing. Driven all around Europe. Piece of mind car.
Mercedes are a super drive, but always have niggly problems and build quality dropped compared with cars built before 2005 BMW like visiting the deals on a regular basis. 
Diesels need more maintenance then petrol. 
VW-Audi engines need regular parts replacement after 100k 
Peugeot - Renault - Citroen build quality = short life.
Of course everyone has different opinions on cars.

I've never understood why German cars are the only ones to be seen in. BMWs in particular are poorly engineered and have a bad reputation for both reliability and customer service. VW/Audi are solid but un-exciting. Mercs are horribly over-priced.

Our experience with lesser brands has been generally OK. Nissan Qashqai+2 diesel lasted 10 years without a hitch. Renault Megane (same Nissan diesel engine) has gone round the clock and is still on the drive at 10 years old. I did 85,000 miles in a few short years in a Fiat Brava back in the day - the only fault with that was when a passing lorry pulled a front wing off it. My daughter's Corsa D has been solid as a rock for years (that's German engineering for you!).

We've gone back to petrol. Our new Qashqai is the 1.3 engine (as shared with the Merc A class) - this model came out in 2018, you don't want the earlier 1.2 engine, it's garbage. 160bhp, EDC auto gearbox, 38-40 mpg locally and up towards 50 mpg on a long run. Very pleased with it.


RE: 2nd hand car advice off diesel eds - HawkingsHalfpint - 01-04-2022

Last (TFSI, petrol) and current car (TDI) were both A5s, which have both been great. Both give very impressive economy and aren’t expensive to run (tyres aside). Hold their value well too. Sadly I don’t think I can get away with the coupe model for much longer (kids getting too big!) so will have to change later in the year. So the recommendations on here will be useful!

German cars are nice but for me Jap cars drive better if you can live with more plasticky interiors.

Probably won’t be going diesel again though, can see these are gonna be increasingly hard to shift as time goes on.


RE: 2nd hand car advice off diesel eds - Solihull Throstle - 01-04-2022

Whether you go for Audi, Merc or BMW do ensure that you get one with working indicators....they appear to be an optional extra for all of these manufacturers.


RE: 2nd hand car advice off diesel eds - Wednesburybaggie - 01-04-2022

(01-04-2022, 07:58 AM)coxy134 Wrote: I wouldnt rule out a Hyundai, got some decent warranty on them and from what I can gather decent reliability.

Audi would be my choice or Honda.

Funny you should say that. I've a Tuscon auto, 1 year old, broke down boxing day. When the AA came out he was shocked, as he said the newer Hyundais are pretty much bullet proof. Still in garage now, not even been looked at as of today, due to holidays and over half the technicians off with covid. Hyundai have given me a free courtesy car until fixed mind.


RE: 2nd hand car advice off diesel eds - B36baggie - 01-04-2022

(01-04-2022, 11:45 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(01-04-2022, 08:22 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: I've owned lots of cars over the years.
Bar far the most reliable is Honda. My current CRV I've had for 3 years and it has never missed a beat, nothing. Driven all around Europe. Piece of mind car.
Mercedes are a super drive, but always have niggly problems and build quality dropped compared with cars built before 2005 BMW like visiting the deals on a regular basis. 
Diesels need more maintenance then petrol. 
VW-Audi engines need regular parts replacement after 100k 
Peugeot - Renault - Citroen build quality = short life.
Of course everyone has different opinions on cars.

I've never understood why German cars are the only ones to be seen in. BMWs in particular are poorly engineered and have a bad reputation for both reliability and customer service. VW/Audi are solid but un-exciting. Mercs are horribly over-priced.

Our experience with lesser brands has been generally OK. Nissan Qashqai+2 diesel lasted 10 years without a hitch. Renault Megane (same Nissan diesel engine) has gone round the clock and is still on the drive at 10 years old. I did 85,000 miles in a few short years in a Fiat Brava back in the day - the only fault with that was when a passing lorry pulled a front wing off it. My daughter's Corsa D has been solid as a rock for years (that's German engineering for you!).

We've gone back to petrol. Our new Qashqai is the 1.3 engine (as shared with the Merc A class) - this model came out in 2018, you don't want the earlier 1.2 engine, it's garbage. 160bhp, EDC auto gearbox, 38-40 mpg locally and up towards 50 mpg on a long run. Very pleased with it.

Agree with this, I have a 17plate Seat Ateca & am extremely pleased with it.


RE: 2nd hand car advice off diesel eds - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 01-04-2022

Have a Citroen C4, have also had Citroens before, never had a problem with any of them. Nice to drive.
Also, a bit left field but, Dacia are good cars, a new one costs the same as a second hand Ford etc. Went to Romania a couple of years back, the B&B we stayed in had a Duster that had 350,000miles on the clock, still ran fine.


RE: 2nd hand car advice off diesel eds - Offside - 01-04-2022

Until recently I have driven E class Mercs for the last 30 years. But with working from home I didn't bother getting a replacement at the end of the lease.   Mercs are great cars to drive but cost a fortune once things start going wrong.   You'll be lucky to get much change from a grand if you use a main dealer for a service and a few repairs.

In the meantime I've been driving a Kia.  They may be a bit plasticy inside,  but if you're not doing much mileage anyway why spend a fortune on  a lump of metal that sits on the drive?   Engineering wise they are solid. 

The beauty of a second hand Kia is that it will still carry the 7 year warranty on major parts.  Servicing is really cheap and they are moving big time into hybrids and all electric vehicles.  Staff get a new car every six thousand miles or six months and the car then goes on the forecourt for the second-hand market. 
   
Well worth a look. 

One other factor to consider is that second hand cars are in short supply at the moment because of the micro chip shortage delaying the build of new models.  Second hand prices are sky high.

Once the chip shortage is solved,  and new cars are in good supply again, the prices in the second hand market will go through the floor.  It might be worth waiting for that if you are not in a rush.