RE: VI criticism - Sliced - 01-04-2022
(01-04-2022, 08:38 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Do we really need another thread slagging off Val?
I can't recall any manager getting this amount of stick before. I understand performances and results aren't what folks expect, but we're hardly having a disastrous season, and the amount of criticism is borderline silly.
It's exactly the same as when Big Dave would not win a match as convincingly as we should.
Bizarrely Bilic's team were shite for half a year in the championship and he never received the level of vitriol that either Big Dave or Val received. I guess some are swayed by a media friendly persona
RE: VI criticism - MassDebater - 01-04-2022
(01-04-2022, 12:06 AM)Squid Wrote: The same people who lauded the passion of Bilic, howled about Allardyce sitting down like he didn't care are now claiming that Val is some angry out of control man.
Doesn't sit well with me this.
Hmm a brand new poster comes on saying this and you use the term the same people?
I loved Slav's kick every ball attitude, hated BFS, but not for his lack of appearing to be bothered, although that never helped. Have zero issues with how Six has acted on the touchline, even with the silliness against Cardiff, just have a problem with his seeming inability to change things about when games aren't going our way.
Totally don't get the calls to give him 3 transfer windows either, but he'll get them due to his contract.
(01-04-2022, 09:17 AM)Sliced Wrote: (01-04-2022, 08:38 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Do we really need another thread slagging off Val?
I can't recall any manager getting this amount of stick before. I understand performances and results aren't what folks expect, but we're hardly having a disastrous season, and the amount of criticism is borderline silly.
It's exactly the same as when Big Dave would not win a match as convincingly as we should.
Bizarrely Bilic's team were shite for half a year in the championship and he never received the level of vitriol that either Big Dave or Val received. I guess some are swayed by a media friendly persona
I never got the stuff aimed at Dave, other than he appeared to have lost control towards the end, Bilic I criticised, I was one of the few asking questions about Livermore after the pandemic and got shot down on here (it's now the trendy thing to be doing), but mostly lauded due to giving me an enjoyable most of a season with entertaining football that yielded enough results to get us promoted.
Six simply hasn't given us enough to deserve plaudits and the free ride that some are calling for. That's what I don't get.
RE: VI criticism - boingingjim - 01-04-2022
Patrick Vieira at Palace stormed up to the ref post their game and got right in his face (was then yellow carded). VI was way less than that response.
The referee was shocking all game, out of control and incompetent. I for one don't blame VI's reaction, it's shocking in this day and age with all the money in the game that this is the quality of refs you have to deal with in the 2nd tier of one of the world's biggest leagues.
RE: VI criticism - Sliced - 01-04-2022
(01-04-2022, 09:21 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (01-04-2022, 12:06 AM)Squid Wrote: The same people who lauded the passion of Bilic, howled about Allardyce sitting down like he didn't care are now claiming that Val is some angry out of control man.
Doesn't sit well with me this.
Hmm a brand new poster comes on saying this and you use the term the same people?
I loved Slav's kick every ball attitude, hated BFS, but not for his lack of appearing to be bothered, although that never helped. Have zero issues with how Six has acted on the touchline, even with the silliness against Cardiff, just have a problem with his seeming inability to change things about when games aren't going our way.
Totally don't get the calls to give him 3 transfer windows either, but he'll get them due to his contract.
(01-04-2022, 09:17 AM)Sliced Wrote: (01-04-2022, 08:38 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Do we really need another thread slagging off Val?
I can't recall any manager getting this amount of stick before. I understand performances and results aren't what folks expect, but we're hardly having a disastrous season, and the amount of criticism is borderline silly.
It's exactly the same as when Big Dave would not win a match as convincingly as we should.
Bizarrely Bilic's team were shite for half a year in the championship and he never received the level of vitriol that either Big Dave or Val received. I guess some are swayed by a media friendly persona
I never got the stuff aimed at Dave, other than he appeared to have lost control towards the end, Bilic I criticised, I was one of the few asking questions about Livermore after the pandemic and got shot down on here (it's now the trendy thing to be doing), but mostly lauded due to giving me an enjoyable most of a season with entertaining football that yielded enough results to get us promoted.
Six simply hasn't given us enough to deserve plaudits and the free ride that some are calling for. That's what I don't get.
Find me someone who thinks he deserves a free ride? Some were criticising him after the first game!
He needs to be doing better as of the past few weeks, but some were going way over the top with criticism when things were going very well. Very much in the same way that happened with Dave.
RE: VI criticism - Squid - 01-04-2022
(01-04-2022, 09:35 AM)Sliced Wrote: (01-04-2022, 09:21 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (01-04-2022, 12:06 AM)Squid Wrote: The same people who lauded the passion of Bilic, howled about Allardyce sitting down like he didn't care are now claiming that Val is some angry out of control man.
Doesn't sit well with me this.
Hmm a brand new poster comes on saying this and you use the term the same people?
I loved Slav's kick every ball attitude, hated BFS, but not for his lack of appearing to be bothered, although that never helped. Have zero issues with how Six has acted on the touchline, even with the silliness against Cardiff, just have a problem with his seeming inability to change things about when games aren't going our way.
Totally don't get the calls to give him 3 transfer windows either, but he'll get them due to his contract.
(01-04-2022, 09:17 AM)Sliced Wrote: (01-04-2022, 08:38 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Do we really need another thread slagging off Val?
I can't recall any manager getting this amount of stick before. I understand performances and results aren't what folks expect, but we're hardly having a disastrous season, and the amount of criticism is borderline silly.
It's exactly the same as when Big Dave would not win a match as convincingly as we should.
Bizarrely Bilic's team were shite for half a year in the championship and he never received the level of vitriol that either Big Dave or Val received. I guess some are swayed by a media friendly persona
I never got the stuff aimed at Dave, other than he appeared to have lost control towards the end, Bilic I criticised, I was one of the few asking questions about Livermore after the pandemic and got shot down on here (it's now the trendy thing to be doing), but mostly lauded due to giving me an enjoyable most of a season with entertaining football that yielded enough results to get us promoted.
Six simply hasn't given us enough to deserve plaudits and the free ride that some are calling for. That's what I don't get.
Find me someone who thinks he deserves a free ride? Some were criticising him after the first game!
He needs to be doing better as of the past few weeks, but some were going way over the top with criticism when things were going very well. Very much in the same way that happened with Dave.
Hmm. Interesting that. Why could this be?
RE: VI criticism - Derek Hardballs - 01-04-2022
(01-04-2022, 10:58 AM)Squid Wrote: (01-04-2022, 09:35 AM)Sliced Wrote: (01-04-2022, 09:21 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (01-04-2022, 12:06 AM)Squid Wrote: The same people who lauded the passion of Bilic, howled about Allardyce sitting down like he didn't care are now claiming that Val is some angry out of control man.
Doesn't sit well with me this.
Hmm a brand new poster comes on saying this and you use the term the same people?
I loved Slav's kick every ball attitude, hated BFS, but not for his lack of appearing to be bothered, although that never helped. Have zero issues with how Six has acted on the touchline, even with the silliness against Cardiff, just have a problem with his seeming inability to change things about when games aren't going our way.
Totally don't get the calls to give him 3 transfer windows either, but he'll get them due to his contract.
(01-04-2022, 09:17 AM)Sliced Wrote: (01-04-2022, 08:38 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Do we really need another thread slagging off Val?
I can't recall any manager getting this amount of stick before. I understand performances and results aren't what folks expect, but we're hardly having a disastrous season, and the amount of criticism is borderline silly.
It's exactly the same as when Big Dave would not win a match as convincingly as we should.
Bizarrely Bilic's team were shite for half a year in the championship and he never received the level of vitriol that either Big Dave or Val received. I guess some are swayed by a media friendly persona
I never got the stuff aimed at Dave, other than he appeared to have lost control towards the end, Bilic I criticised, I was one of the few asking questions about Livermore after the pandemic and got shot down on here (it's now the trendy thing to be doing), but mostly lauded due to giving me an enjoyable most of a season with entertaining football that yielded enough results to get us promoted.
Six simply hasn't given us enough to deserve plaudits and the free ride that some are calling for. That's what I don't get.
Find me someone who thinks he deserves a free ride? Some were criticising him after the first game!
He needs to be doing better as of the past few weeks, but some were going way over the top with criticism when things were going very well. Very much in the same way that happened with Dave.
Hmm. Interesting that. Why could this be?
Really? Come on now, this is silly. Pulis was criticised relentlessly and stupidly for keeping us up and finishing very comfortably in midtable in the Prem for two seasons. Big Sam was relentlessly criticised for not keeping up a squad that is now apparently not good enough to even get out the Championship! Some are looking for things that aren’t there or if they are, are very much in the minority.
Results against resources should always be the things to judge a manager by and if Val gets us up he will have succeeded, if he doesn’t imo with our squad he will have failed.
RE: VI criticism - baggie93 - 01-04-2022
(01-04-2022, 09:21 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (01-04-2022, 12:06 AM)Squid Wrote: The same people who lauded the passion of Bilic, howled about Allardyce sitting down like he didn't care are now claiming that Val is some angry out of control man.
Doesn't sit well with me this.
Hmm a brand new poster comes on saying this and you use the term the same people?
I loved Slav's kick every ball attitude, hated BFS, but not for his lack of appearing to be bothered, although that never helped. Have zero issues with how Six has acted on the touchline, even with the silliness against Cardiff, just have a problem with his seeming inability to change things about when games aren't going our way.
Totally don't get the calls to give him 3 transfer windows either, but he'll get them due to his contract.
(01-04-2022, 09:17 AM)Sliced Wrote: (01-04-2022, 08:38 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Do we really need another thread slagging off Val?
I can't recall any manager getting this amount of stick before. I understand performances and results aren't what folks expect, but we're hardly having a disastrous season, and the amount of criticism is borderline silly.
It's exactly the same as when Big Dave would not win a match as convincingly as we should.
Bizarrely Bilic's team were shite for half a year in the championship and he never received the level of vitriol that either Big Dave or Val received. I guess some are swayed by a media friendly persona
I never got the stuff aimed at Dave, other than he appeared to have lost control towards the end, Bilic I criticised, I was one of the few asking questions about Livermore after the pandemic and got shot down on here (it's now the trendy thing to be doing), but mostly lauded due to giving me an enjoyable most of a season with entertaining football that yielded enough results to get us promoted.
Six simply hasn't given us enough to deserve plaudits and the free ride that some are calling for. That's what I don't get. I like to think I started the Livermore trend ! ;-)
Moaned the day we signed him. Never rated him.
RE: VI criticism - TETLEY74 - 01-04-2022
Well i'm not happy with performances who would be, but i'll reserve judgement on him until he has the majority of his own and type of players he needs for his philosophy. Lets not forget he basically having to utilise a squad that its core has let down and underperformed for the majority of their time under 4 plus managers.
RE: VI criticism - Dumbo - 01-04-2022
(01-04-2022, 10:58 AM)Squid Wrote: (01-04-2022, 09:35 AM)Sliced Wrote: (01-04-2022, 09:21 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (01-04-2022, 12:06 AM)Squid Wrote: The same people who lauded the passion of Bilic, howled about Allardyce sitting down like he didn't care are now claiming that Val is some angry out of control man.
Doesn't sit well with me this.
Hmm a brand new poster comes on saying this and you use the term the same people?
I loved Slav's kick every ball attitude, hated BFS, but not for his lack of appearing to be bothered, although that never helped. Have zero issues with how Six has acted on the touchline, even with the silliness against Cardiff, just have a problem with his seeming inability to change things about when games aren't going our way.
Totally don't get the calls to give him 3 transfer windows either, but he'll get them due to his contract.
(01-04-2022, 09:17 AM)Sliced Wrote: (01-04-2022, 08:38 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Do we really need another thread slagging off Val?
I can't recall any manager getting this amount of stick before. I understand performances and results aren't what folks expect, but we're hardly having a disastrous season, and the amount of criticism is borderline silly.
It's exactly the same as when Big Dave would not win a match as convincingly as we should.
Bizarrely Bilic's team were shite for half a year in the championship and he never received the level of vitriol that either Big Dave or Val received. I guess some are swayed by a media friendly persona
I never got the stuff aimed at Dave, other than he appeared to have lost control towards the end, Bilic I criticised, I was one of the few asking questions about Livermore after the pandemic and got shot down on here (it's now the trendy thing to be doing), but mostly lauded due to giving me an enjoyable most of a season with entertaining football that yielded enough results to get us promoted.
Six simply hasn't given us enough to deserve plaudits and the free ride that some are calling for. That's what I don't get.
Find me someone who thinks he deserves a free ride? Some were criticising him after the first game!
He needs to be doing better as of the past few weeks, but some were going way over the top with criticism when things were going very well. Very much in the same way that happened with Dave.
Hmm. Interesting that. Why could this be?
Not the first time you’ve leant towards this. And you need to be careful.
Fat Sam and Pulis were bemoaned just as much as Dave and Val. Let’s no rewrite history. Some of the online abuse aimed at Sam far outweighs anything I’ve seen aimed at Val.
RE: VI criticism - Psalm23 - 01-04-2022
(01-04-2022, 09:35 AM)Sliced Wrote: (01-04-2022, 09:21 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (01-04-2022, 12:06 AM)Squid Wrote: The same people who lauded the passion of Bilic, howled about Allardyce sitting down like he didn't care are now claiming that Val is some angry out of control man.
Doesn't sit well with me this.
Hmm a brand new poster comes on saying this and you use the term the same people?
I loved Slav's kick every ball attitude, hated BFS, but not for his lack of appearing to be bothered, although that never helped. Have zero issues with how Six has acted on the touchline, even with the silliness against Cardiff, just have a problem with his seeming inability to change things about when games aren't going our way.
Totally don't get the calls to give him 3 transfer windows either, but he'll get them due to his contract.
(01-04-2022, 09:17 AM)Sliced Wrote: (01-04-2022, 08:38 AM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Do we really need another thread slagging off Val?
I can't recall any manager getting this amount of stick before. I understand performances and results aren't what folks expect, but we're hardly having a disastrous season, and the amount of criticism is borderline silly.
It's exactly the same as when Big Dave would not win a match as convincingly as we should.
Bizarrely Bilic's team were shite for half a year in the championship and he never received the level of vitriol that either Big Dave or Val received. I guess some are swayed by a media friendly persona
I never got the stuff aimed at Dave, other than he appeared to have lost control towards the end, Bilic I criticised, I was one of the few asking questions about Livermore after the pandemic and got shot down on here (it's now the trendy thing to be doing), but mostly lauded due to giving me an enjoyable most of a season with entertaining football that yielded enough results to get us promoted.
Six simply hasn't given us enough to deserve plaudits and the free ride that some are calling for. That's what I don't get.
Find me someone who thinks he deserves a free ride? Some were criticising him after the first game!
He needs to be doing better as of the past few weeks, but some were going way over the top with criticism when things were going very well. Very much in the same way that happened with Dave.
+1
Literally no one has come even come close to suggesting he should be given a free ride, & very very few, if any have suggested he should be showered in plaudits.
|