WBAUnofficial
We must be realistic - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: We must be realistic (/showthread.php?tid=23336)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: We must be realistic - Ted Maul - 01-02-2022

Start of the season anyone who knows anything would have said we'd got the 3rd or 4th best squad in the division.

Results have been poor the past couple of months, a decent striker and I'd say we'd be out performing where many would have expected us to be.

I'd challenge any manager to get a team without a striker scoring freely and competing at the top of their league. Maybe we should give Pep a call.


RE: We must be realistic - Hopalong - 01-02-2022

(01-02-2022, 04:42 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: We simply aren’t good enough to go up with this squad. I hate to say it but another season of rebuilding and improving this squad is essential if we are going to get up and not totally embarrass ourselves. 

Automatic promotion looks beyond us (unless Dike is even better than we hope) and I am confident that we will make the play offs but if we do get up by that route then it will really show what a poor standard the Championship is this year.

(01-02-2022, 04:42 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: We simply aren’t good enough to go up with this squad. I hate to say it but another season of rebuilding and improving this squad is essential if we are going to get up and not totally embarrass ourselves. 

Automatic promotion looks beyond us (unless Dike is even better than we hope) and I am confident that we will make the play offs but if we do get up by that route then it will really show what a poor standard the Championship is this year.

Depends on signings and their impact. Snods gone and hopefully Zohire next. 

Get Okay back and another offensive player and who knows.


RE: We must be realistic - wbamitch - 01-02-2022

The players the manager has signed look shit in his system aswell as many of the original players who look as bad as ever. I refuse to accept that he is getting the best out of them. We’ve gone from scoring at ease and blowing some teams away in the first 10 games to looking like mid table at best plodders the following 10. A sign of things to come? We were told we would get stronger as time goes on as the players learn his tactics, in reality the opposite is happening. How long and how much money do we let this guy spend before we admit he isn’t right for us. Whether you like him or not, point blank refusing to change things mid game no matter what is happening in front of his eyes is just barmy.


RE: We must be realistic - MassDebater - 01-02-2022

So, we throw in the towel now and give Six free reign to do whatever he wants (a bit like he's been doing for several months), because yep, that makes a load of sense. Just imagine how feeble we'll be next season if we don't go up? Imagine if say Newcastle come down... That leaves in effect one automatic place.

This is the worst this division has ever been, we look crap, we play crap, we are crap. Yet I can't help thinking a different manager (Wilder? heck Slav or Moore) would have us actually being far more competitive than we have been for months. The thing is, we are only going to get worse if we don't go up, why do people choose to ignore that?

Like many I just cannot work out how we are trying to 'play' these days, it's baffling. I don't like Six's hard press, but give us that again FFS, give us something that makes sense.


RE: We must be realistic - Dumbo - 01-02-2022

Playing with 3 CD’s against 1 striker ??‍♂️

Take one off and put an extra man in the middle of the park.

Livermore sitting and 2 box to box midfielders so they can get forwards & be close to Robinson.

Playing at home!


RE: We must be realistic - Pragmatist - 01-02-2022

(01-02-2022, 06:03 PM)wbamitch Wrote: The players the manager has signed look shit in his system aswell as many of the original players who look as bad as ever. I refuse to accept that he is getting the best out of them. We’ve gone from scoring at ease and blowing some teams away in the first 10 games to looking like mid table at best plodders the following 10. A sign of things to come? We were told we would get stronger as time goes on as the players learn his tactics, in reality the opposite is happening. How long and how much money do we let this guy spend before we admit he isn’t right for us. Whether you like him or not, point blank refusing to change things mid game no matter what is happening in front of his eyes is just barmy.

Some of these players are not up to it and need replacing.  They aren’t capable of adapting.  But replacing them doesn’t happen overnight.   The fan base seems to be split between (a) allowing time for that that process to happen - and still probably teaching the play-offs, or (b) starting all over again with yet another new manager who would need time to build his own squad and possibly missing out on this year’s play-offs and spending even more money on future windows to have a chance of getting up next year.

Everybody is blaming the manager and his tactics without realising that the issue is that it takes at least a couple transfer windows to get the right blend of players for ANY manager’s tactics.  Val inherited a dog’s breakfast of a squad and needs time.  Yes he could be more flexible and yes he needs to select his starting 11 better (apart from Mulumby for Livermore I’d have started the same 11 today). 

People just need to be patient and back the manager.  We needed a striker in the summer and for whatever reason we didn’t get one. We are paying a price for that but it isn’t Val’s fault that for half a season our 3 strikers couldn’t score in a brothel.


RE: We must be realistic - Cunninghamismagic - 01-02-2022

(01-02-2022, 04:42 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: We simply aren’t good enough to go up with this manager

Edited for you


RE: We must be realistic - wbamitch - 01-02-2022

(01-02-2022, 06:19 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(01-02-2022, 06:03 PM)wbamitch Wrote: The players the manager has signed look shit in his system aswell as many of the original players who look as bad as ever. I refuse to accept that he is getting the best out of them. We’ve gone from scoring at ease and blowing some teams away in the first 10 games to looking like mid table at best plodders the following 10. A sign of things to come? We were told we would get stronger as time goes on as the players learn his tactics, in reality the opposite is happening. How long and how much money do we let this guy spend before we admit he isn’t right for us. Whether you like him or not, point blank refusing to change things mid game no matter what is happening in front of his eyes is just barmy.

Some of these players are not up to it and need replacing.  They aren’t capable of adapting.  But replacing them doesn’t happen overnight.   The fan base seems to be split between (a) allowing time for that that process to happen - and still probably teaching the play-offs, or (b) starting all over again with yet another new manager who would need time to build his own squad and possibly missing out on this year’s play-offs and spending even more money on future windows to have a chance of getting up next year.

Everybody is blaming the manager and his tactics without realising that the issue is that it takes at least a couple transfer windows to get the right blend of players for ANY manager’s tactics.  Val inherited a dog’s breakfast of a squad and needs time.  Yes he could be more flexible and yes he needs to select his starting 11 better (apart from Mulumby for Livermore I’d have started the same 11 today). 

People just need to be patient and back the manager.  We needed a striker in the summer and for whatever reason we didn’t get one. We are paying a price for that but it isn’t Val’s fault that for half a season our 3 strikers couldn’t score in a brothel.

Wilder and Cooper seem to be doing alright with the players they have inherited. Bilic done a good job of finding a way that suited our players and added to it with signings. It’s not impossible, everyone knows realistically we need to go up this season. If the players are incapable of adapting why hasn’t our manager realised that and changed? It’s not ideal to keep changing managers but he isn’t giving me much hope that things will get better after a few transfer windows. I think what’s more likely is we will have a squad full of Adam Reaches and Hugils


RE: We must be realistic - MassDebater - 01-02-2022

(01-02-2022, 06:29 PM)wbamitch Wrote: Wilder and Cooper seem to be doing alright with the players they have inherited. Bilic done a good job of finding a way that suited our players and added to it with signings. It’s not impossible, everyone knows realistically we need to go up this season. If the players are incapable of adapting why hasn’t our manager realised that and changed? It’s not ideal to keep changing managers but he isn’t giving me much hope that things will get better after a few transfer windows. I think what’s more likely is we will have a squad full of Adam Reaches and Hugils

I think you make many good points, but fuck me is it hard to read and accept that you are probably spot on. How long before some on here are saying our squad realistically was only ever 4th/5th best... it's gone from 1/2 to 2/3 and now I'm seeing 3/4 best... Moore arguably did better with less than Six is.


RE: We must be realistic - wbamitch - 01-02-2022

Also, how is the side going to look drastically different in 2 windows time? Grant, Robinson & Grady are on long term contracts, is anyone going to sign these guys off us? He rewarded Furlong, Bartley and Matt Phillips with new contracts soon after arriving. Those hoping for wholesale changes are going to be a bit disappointed I think