WBAUnofficial
Six's style and scoring goals.... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Six's style and scoring goals.... (/showthread.php?tid=23261)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Six's style and scoring goals.... - MassDebater - 12-28-2021

(12-28-2021, 02:05 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: Nonsense statistics though. If from creating a dozen good changes a game and only scoring an average of 1.2 then that is down to one thing only - poor conversion. Were Barnsley and those other clubs also creating (and missing) 10 or more gilt-edged chances per game? What about their XG in comparison?

Knock yourself in finding that if you like. Personally I don't buy into XG meaning an awful lot, as at the end of the day it is purely goals scored and conceded that sort the points out. But if XG gets you more points, then maybe have a word with Rooney and ask if we can have some points back from yesterday.

We create no more than about 3 maybe 4 actual real chances per game, sometimes less, but our shots stat will be high. Some on here would try and suggest that we are peppering the opposition goal constantly, but we are not. Most opposition keepers are probably making around the same amount of *meaningful* saves per game as SJ is...


RE: Six's style and scoring goals.... - Sliced - 12-28-2021

(12-28-2021, 02:11 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(12-28-2021, 02:05 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: Nonsense statistics though.  If from creating a dozen good changes a game and only scoring an average of 1.2 then that is down to one thing only - poor conversion.  Were Barnsley and those other clubs also creating (and missing) 10 or more gilt-edged chances per game?  What about their XG in comparison?

Knock yourself in finding that if you like. Personally I don't buy into XG meaning an awful lot, as at the end of the day it is purely goals scored and conceded that sort the points out. But if XG gets you more points, then maybe have a word with Rooney and ask if we can have some points back from yesterday.

We create no more than about 3 maybe 4 actual real chances per game, sometimes less, but our shots stat will be high. Some on here would try and suggest that we are peppering the opposition goal constantly, but we are not. Most opposition keepers are probably making around the same amount of *meaningful* saves per game as SJ is...

Well we've had the highest number of shots in the league (including having 100 more shots than the team with the third highest shots in the league) and have the second highest XG. We've also had the second highest number of shots on target.

Defensively we've had the fewest goals conceded, the lowest XG against, the fewest shots against us and the fewest shots on target against us

But none of these mean anything compared to "number of meaningful saves". That's the real quiz, even though there's zero data for that, and it basically would be encapsulated in XG anyway.

We're not finishing the easy chances we're getting even though we spend most of our time camped in the oppositions half.

There's another stat. Most time spent in the attacking third in the championship and joint least amount of time spent in our defensive third.


RE: Six's style and scoring goals.... - HugeHons - 12-28-2021

We create lots of chances, it’s the poor quality of finishing that’s costing us,not his ‘style’.

(12-28-2021, 01:57 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(12-28-2021, 01:43 PM)MassDebater Wrote: I said this was one of the areas of most concern that I had when he was appointed:

Barnsley: 1.2 goals per game
Us right now: 1.2 goals per game

LASK: 2 goals per game
VFL Wolfsburg: 1 goal per game
VFL Wolfsburg II: 2.1 goals per game
FC Nurnberg: 1 goal per game
VFL Wolfsburg II (first stint): 2.3 goals per game
Hannover 96: 1.9 goals per game

Overall: 1.7 goals per game.


So he's actually doing exactly what he did goals wise with Barnsley.

Conceding wise us and Barnsley are both at pretty much 1 goal per game. So he has been successful in emulating Barnsley, almost goal for goal so far.

The only difference is that Barnsley had Dike...So he's achieved pretty much exactly the same with, no Dike. So either having Dike means we'll score loads more, or maybe Six's tactics just are not suited to actually scoring goals?

(Bilic managed 1.6 goals scored with 1 conceded - 47+% win ratio)
(Dave managed 1.8 goals scored with 1.3 conceded - 50% win ratio)
Six so far 45.8% win ratio

I've rounded all figures down(which is extra harsh on Dave as his should really be 1.9 scored).

So in short, Six's way rarely equals a team that scores goals.

Good statting MD. 

Being fair though we have missed an awful lot of chances - I don't have the stats but they are substantial.  We have also hammered a few sides.

Val used the words lack of mentality, desire and ruthlessness last night -  'lion mentality'.  He also interestingly said players have to prepare properly for games and take individual responsibility - have some of them had a little bit too much turkey and sherry over xmas?

168 shots in the last 10 games. 38 on target. 5 goals


RE: Six's style and scoring goals.... - Hopalong - 12-28-2021

(12-28-2021, 02:02 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(12-28-2021, 01:57 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Agreed about team selection.

Personally think Livermore is better suited to playing as the Ball Playing Centre back of the three now. Reach will do his best wherever, but is just a cover option. TGH should have played more the last couple of games, considering he can cover Furlong, Townsend and Livermore, all out of form, he should be playing.

All managers suffer it though, a liking to go back to players they trust even when it seems daft, and it's hit Val hard since there is very, very little support for him from fans. Some undeserved and is misplaced anger that should be directed at the club, some criticisms are perfectly fair.

I think his biggest problem is himself. He just comes across as being teflon coated and it's all to do with others... Although it was refreshing to hear him slag the players finally. Shame he didn't add, but they are playing to my instructions... he just doesn't seem to have much likability and so when things go bad it's easy to seem to be attacking him.

@Hopalong, pretty sure we missed loads of chances under Bilic and Dave too, but when you're scoring 33%+ less goals those misses become something to cling on to.

Maybe some of the players expected the game to be off like so many others were? No excuse it's their one job, and I think a lot of blame has to be given to them as well.



(12-28-2021, 02:02 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(12-28-2021, 01:57 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Agreed about team selection.

Personally think Livermore is better suited to playing as the Ball Playing Centre back of the three now. Reach will do his best wherever, but is just a cover option. TGH should have played more the last couple of games, considering he can cover Furlong, Townsend and Livermore, all out of form, he should be playing.

All managers suffer it though, a liking to go back to players they trust even when it seems daft, and it's hit Val hard since there is very, very little support for him from fans. Some undeserved and is misplaced anger that should be directed at the club, some criticisms are perfectly fair.

I think his biggest problem is himself. He just comes across as being teflon coated and it's all to do with others... Although it was refreshing to hear him slag the players finally. Shame he didn't add, but they are playing to my instructions... he just doesn't seem to have much likability and so when things go bad it's easy to seem to be attacking him.

@Hopalong, pretty sure we missed loads of chances under Bilic and Dave too, but when you're scoring 33%+ less goals those misses become something to cling on to.

Maybe some of the players expected the game to be off like so many others were? No excuse it's their one job, and I think a lot of blame has to be given to them as well.

I don't think we created as many chances under Bilic and Dave MD. 

I thought I'd read a story last week with Robinson and Livermore praising Val to the hilt?  

https://footballleagueworld.co.uk/jake-livermore-details-two-things-valerien-ismael-has-given-his-west-brom-players/

Re. preparation, yes maybe they did think the game would be off and as the Preston game was off maybe they thought they could get away with it playing bottom of the league, Val certainly inferred that.  The reality is without thr 21 points reduction, Derby would be 15th, 8 points off the playoffs, so not as easy a game as maybe the players thought which again was the inference from Val in terms of mentality and lack of desire from the 1st minute.


RE: Six's style and scoring goals.... - Brentbaggie - 12-28-2021

(12-28-2021, 05:00 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(12-28-2021, 02:02 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(12-28-2021, 01:57 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Agreed about team selection.

Personally think Livermore is better suited to playing as the Ball Playing Centre back of the three now. Reach will do his best wherever, but is just a cover option. TGH should have played more the last couple of games, considering he can cover Furlong, Townsend and Livermore, all out of form, he should be playing.

All managers suffer it though, a liking to go back to players they trust even when it seems daft, and it's hit Val hard since there is very, very little support for him from fans. Some undeserved and is misplaced anger that should be directed at the club, some criticisms are perfectly fair.

I think his biggest problem is himself. He just comes across as being teflon coated and it's all to do with others... Although it was refreshing to hear him slag the players finally. Shame he didn't add, but they are playing to my instructions... he just doesn't seem to have much likability and so when things go bad it's easy to seem to be attacking him.

@Hopalong, pretty sure we missed loads of chances under Bilic and Dave too, but when you're scoring 33%+ less goals those misses become something to cling on to.

Maybe some of the players expected the game to be off like so many others were? No excuse it's their one job, and I think a lot of blame has to be given to them as well.

I don't think we created as many chances under Bilic and Dave MD. 

I thought I'd read a story last week with Robinson and Livermore praising Val to the hilt?  

Re. preparation, yes maybe they did think the game would be off and as the Preston game was off maybe they thought they could get away with it playing bottom of the league, Val certainly inferred that.  The reality is without thr 21 points reduction, Derby would be 15th, 8 points off the playoffs, so not as easy a game as maybe the players thought which again was the inference from Val in terms of mentality and lack of desire from the 1st minute.

Yes, but they would have been 19th yesterday.  The 15th position would only be because we gifted them three points.  They threw themselves in front of everything and all credit to their defending but we should still have won the game.  A large number the shots "on target" in many of the above stats I would suggest are powder-puff or straight at the keeper, they didn't demand much saving and that's where the problem lies.  Our players often panic or snatch at shots, they're just not finishers.


RE: Six's style and scoring goals.... - Borin' Baggie - 12-28-2021

Barnsley underperformed their xG by 0.2 last season. We are underperforming our xG by 0.72.

Not really a direct comparison, is it?

Our xG is higher so far this season than it was under Slav in the Championship (1.85) and Moore (1.34, JayRod and Gayle were absolute freaks). The last season we had a comparable xG to this season was under Di Matteo (1.93), where we scored 89 goals. We are creating chances, we're just so bad at finishing them.


RE: Six's style and scoring goals.... - Squid - 12-28-2021

(12-28-2021, 05:28 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Barnsley underperformed their xG by 0.2 last season. We are underperforming our xG by 0.72.

Not really a direct comparison, is it?

Our xG is higher so far this season than it was under Slav in the Championship (1.85) and Moore (1.34, JayRod and Gayle were absolute freaks). The last season we had a comparable xG to this season was under Di Matteo (1.93), where we scored 89 goals. We are creating chances, we're just so bad at finishing them.

And still, people moaned and said they didn't enjoy that season. 

Forget who posted the stat about most time in the opposition half and least time in our defensive half, that echoes exactly what I see down the Hawthorns and proves exactly why the comparisons to Pulis are laughable.