WBAUnofficial
Our recruitment - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Our recruitment (/showthread.php?tid=23079)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Our recruitment - Lillwall's left foot - 12-14-2021

(12-13-2021, 10:24 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote: At least £40m commitment on Grant & Diangana with wages, maybe more

One looks disastrous, the other significantly overpaid. All hindsight but both £5m players, not at the level we thought

Resale value negligible & effectively significant proportion of our premiership monies squandered

Yep, and don't forget the £4-8 million paid for the sad sack playing U-23 football (when fit), and the £4m? and wages that went on Austin.  

We currently have a forward line that cost upwards of £40 million but must have a current market value of £15-20 million tops! 

I do agree however, that when fishing in our own pool we find decent players and get good value.  It's when we try and play Premier League big bollocks that it falls down. 

We simply can't compete in terms of finance or location, so when we flash the cash it's inevitable that the big deals fall flat. Let's face it, most of our A list targets over the last few years have just ended up at West Ham (at one point I think they disbanded their recruitment team and just waited for our targets to become known). Even if we were able to match wages (unlikely) the pull of London will always trump the social scene offered around the Brom.

It will be interesting to see if Vals analytical approach, allied to the knowledge we have shown in finding the likes of Townsend, Kipre, Semi and Furlong (said very hesitantly) can produce a list of young (under 30 ?) hungry number 9s from which to.choose.


RE: Our recruitment - Baggeridgebaggy - 12-14-2021

Burke situation obviously mitigated with Sheff U effectively paying us with Robinson to take an expensive problem off our hands (we did give them around £3m in cash as well)

Turned a disaster into a much more neutral situation for the club

Diangana is shaping up to be very easily the worst transfer in the clubs history given cost against return on the pitch /resale

Overpaid significantly for Grant but at least there’s a contribution


RE: Our recruitment - Lillwall's left foot - 12-14-2021

(12-14-2021, 08:23 AM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote: Burke situation obviously mitigated with Sheff U effectively paying us with Robinson to take an expensive problem off our hands (we did give them around £3m in cash as well)

Turned a disaster into a much more neutral situation for the club

Diangana is shaping up to be very easily the worst transfer in the clubs history given cost against return on the pitch /resale

Overpaid significantly for Grant but at least there’s a contribution

Grant could turn out to be a decent long term investment as part of a more balanced attack.  Only 24 (seens older) and guarantees 10 goals a season with potential for more if he can start snaffling some half chances.  

Grant as a footballer has never been a problem, the problem is that for some bizarre reason Slav seems to think he could be converted into a PL number 9!! And we paid a premium for that.

Hudds fans knew he wasn't And told us so, as did we within a few games of seeing him.   £15 million should buy you a half decent leader of the line....instead we got ANOTHER left sided attacker.  If Zahore is Dowlings legacy then I'm afraid our lack of a decent number 9 belongs to Slav.


RE: Our recruitment - Bob Fossil - 12-14-2021

If we get someone in in Jan and they average a goal every 2.4 games, I would suggest we would consider that good business, especially if it gets us promoted.

That is exactly where Grant is at present, however, some see him as a massive failure. Yes the price tag was too high but, in terms of value to the team, he is massive this season and has every chance of being the 20+ striker we all crave.

Every team's recruitment is a bit hit and miss, but, I would say, respective of our budget, we are above average.


RE: Our recruitment - Tom Joad - 12-14-2021

When talking of worst buys in club history, don't forget the one we didn't even own, Gap Year Greg. Reported as £106,000 a week, or £5.5M! With Grady, I believe the deal is hugely incremental and we may not have paid anything like the reported fee. Grant may well pay for himself if he keeps going at this rate and we go up (and find him a proper no 9 to play off.)


RE: Our recruitment - Squid - 12-14-2021

(12-14-2021, 07:47 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: When talking of worst buys in club history, don't forget the one we didn't even own, Gap Year Greg. Reported as £106,000 a week, or £5.5M! With Grady, I believe the deal is hugely incremental and we may not have paid anything like the reported fee. Grant may well pay for himself if he keeps going at this rate and we go up (and find him a proper no 9 to play off.)

I'd also consider Austin a decent buy. Won several matches with his goals and got us promoted so job done.


RE: Our recruitment - Peachy - 12-14-2021

(12-14-2021, 07:47 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: When talking of worst buys in club history, don't forget the one we didn't even own, Gap Year Greg. Reported as £106,000 a week, or £5.5M!  With Grady, I believe the deal is hugely incremental and we may not have paid anything like the reported fee. Grant may well pay for himself if he keeps going at this rate and we go up (and find him a proper no 9 to play off.)

I've heard from a couple of people that Grady was £8m phased. The remaining £10m is based on premier league appearances and england call ups etc.

So with that in mind i'd be very surprised if we end up paying more than £8m on him.......  Big Grin


RE: Our recruitment - coxy134 - 12-14-2021

It seems its the big money signings that have failed? Perhaps why the owners are reluctant to put any money in.
I do think there seems to be a shortage of decent forwards at the moment.


RE: Our recruitment - Baggeridgebaggy - 12-14-2021

Grant, despite his goals this season for me cannot be seen as anything other than a pretty poor signing given what amounts to a very significant financial commitment for the club over a 6 year period

Signed as the main man in the Premier League, but in terms of his general play has at times struggled to make an decent impression in the Championship

He’s a good finisher, but poor technically, can’t head a ball or go past a defender. Not quick or tricky, but does well in getting the ball out of his feet to get shots in at goal. His goal return is decent, but his contributions beyond that in many games has been really limited

We’ve had dozens & dozens of much better players over the years that have cost a fraction of what he cost

Unfortunately sad truth Is that If we get promoted players like him (and many others) would need to be sidelined or sold even for us to contemplate competing in the Premier League


RE: Our recruitment - Sliced - 12-15-2021

(12-14-2021, 07:47 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: When talking of worst buys in club history, don't forget the one we didn't even own, Gap Year Greg. Reported as £106,000 a week, or £5.5M!  With Grady, I believe the deal is hugely incremental and we may not have paid anything like the reported fee. Grant may well pay for himself if he keeps going at this rate and we go up (and find him a proper no 9 to play off.)

We paid 60% of Greg's wages, amounting to just over 60K per week....which was still a monumental waste of money