WBAUnofficial
3 transfer windows required. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: 3 transfer windows required. (/showthread.php?tid=23036)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: 3 transfer windows required. - Lillwall's left foot - 12-08-2021

(12-08-2021, 10:42 AM)Sliced Wrote: It’s taken us one to go from Pereira on a perm to Hugill on loan and the numbers bulked up with a couple of Brighton loanees and Adam Reach on a free.

Imagine how shit we could be after three transfer windows

Huggy Bear has been a complete disaster, but wages wise was a straight swap for Hal who was obs ready to focus on Tumeric sales.   Didn't expect goals but thought he would bring something to the team, as I imagine did our recruitment dept.

Clarke IMO has been a very good loan signing calm and assured.  Molomby a punt who could still come good and Reach was undoubtedly from the existing west brom list of potential squad fillers offered to Val to cover LWB and ARM vs Cov.  Add Mowatt and it wasn't a terrible window, just yet again lacking in addressing the two positions that need more quality in CF and CM.

We can't be sure if Hugil was identified by Val or was just one of a number of strikers that had been lined up for him at the time.  We DO know that any future acquisitions will have been heavily influenced by Val.  This is where it gets interesting.   I'd certainly be happy to have a few more additions in the mould of Mowatt but it's the striker that is most anticipated and should give us an idea of where those next three windows could take us.


RE: 3 transfer windows required. - Borin' Baggie - 12-08-2021

(12-08-2021, 10:57 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-08-2021, 10:48 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Do we trust the people in charge of recruitment and those in charge of the pursestrings to act in the best interests of the long term health of the club though?
We have what money we have, we can't just print more so everything has to be done within the budget. That doesn't mean it can't be done, however.
The best signing of the summer was free (Mowatt), the best signing in recent times (Pereira) was a fantastic loan to buy deal.
The "pursestrings" are what they are, it's the recruitment that is key and the two examples above prove we can get it right, so I'm buoyed by these comments. He clearly knows where the deficiencies are and is keen to address them, whilst admitting that, until then, he has to work with what he's got.

I'm not on about spending lots of money, I'm pointing out that the people who ultimately have the power to make the decisions are people who I do not trust to make decisions to benefit the long term health of the club. I'm under no illusions that money is tight but I doubt we will combine our frugality with the necessary shrewdness.


RE: 3 transfer windows required. - Lillwall's left foot - 12-08-2021

(12-08-2021, 11:10 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(12-08-2021, 10:57 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-08-2021, 10:48 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Do we trust the people in charge of recruitment and those in charge of the pursestrings to act in the best interests of the long term health of the club though?
We have what money we have, we can't just print more so everything has to be done within the budget. That doesn't mean it can't be done, however.
The best signing of the summer was free (Mowatt), the best signing in recent times (Pereira) was a fantastic loan to buy deal.
The "pursestrings" are what they are, it's the recruitment that is key and the two examples above prove we can get it right, so I'm buoyed by these comments. He clearly knows where the deficiencies are and is keen to address them, whilst admitting that, until then, he has to work with what he's got.

I'm not on about spending lots of money, I'm pointing out that the people who ultimately have the power to make the decisions are people who I do not trust to make decisions to benefit the long term health of the club. I'm under no illusions that money is tight but I doubt we will combine our frugality with the necessary shrewdness.

Think this is one of the reasons Val has been confident to talk about three windows.  It does to me feel like the owners are going shit or bust on him.  Not in regards to throwing money at his player wish list, but in trusting in his methods on recruitment and playing style.


RE: 3 transfer windows required. - Bob Fossil - 12-08-2021

(12-08-2021, 10:59 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Worryingly he's sticking to his "A" plan.
Adopting a Walsall type recruitment policy is not exactly what I dreamt of. 
The secretive 60 minute substitution system is a stroke of genius though Big Grin
I think he's saying he's deviated from his "A" plan because he doesn't have the players, but he clearly believes that this "A" plan is the right way forward in the long term.

Being fickle, I've been for him and against him this season, but this has actually given me some hope that what we are seeing is not the finished article and that he clearly believes that business can be done in January.


RE: 3 transfer windows required. - wba13 - 12-08-2021

From day one of the Ismael era we new he needed time to get the players he wanted to play the system he plays. I for one and a lot of us have jumped on his back because of the way he plays, but he has shown at times this system can be excellent and we have won and drew matches with good displays without having some of the correct players to play the Val way. Kipre is a prime example of this he’s a decent defender and a very good distributor of the ball and has played well in the last few games as his confidence rises. If we do go up this season Val will have done it without having some of the correct players which he knows he needs. Here’s hoping for a decent January window.


RE: 3 transfer windows required. - Lillwall's left foot - 12-08-2021

I know these are fuggin ridiculous comparisons but other managers basing their game on a high press philosophy, in Klipperty and Murder Ball Bielsa, also needed a few windows to build their teams before succeeding. The problem is that we have to rebuild using buttons as currency.


RE: 3 transfer windows required. - cornishbaggie - 12-08-2021

Makes me wonder what our recruitment policy will be like if miracles of miracles, we go up and more importantly, what type of player Val will be capable of attracting.


RE: 3 transfer windows required. - Lillwall's left foot - 12-08-2021

(12-08-2021, 11:51 AM)cornishbaggie Wrote: Makes me wonder what our recruitment policy will be like if miracles of miracles, we go up and more importantly, what type of player Val will be capable of attracting.

I won't be expecting a long stay. But that is not really a direct comment on Val more of where we are as a club.


RE: 3 transfer windows required. - Sliced - 12-08-2021

(12-08-2021, 11:02 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote:
(12-08-2021, 10:42 AM)Sliced Wrote: It’s taken us one to go from Pereira on a perm to Hugill on loan and the numbers bulked up with a couple of Brighton loanees and Adam Reach on a free.

Imagine how shit we could be after three transfer windows

Huggy Bear has been a complete disaster, but wages wise was a straight swap for Hal who was obs ready to focus on Tumeric sales.   Didn't expect goals but thought he would bring something to the team, as I imagine did our recruitment dept.

Clarke IMO has been a very good loan signing calm and assured.  Molomby a punt who could still come good and Reach was undoubtedly from the existing west brom list of potential squad fillers offered to Val to cover LWB and ARM vs Cov.  Add Mowatt and it wasn't a terrible window, just yet again lacking in addressing the two positions that need more quality in CF and CM.

We can't be sure if Hugil was identified by Val or was just one of a number of strikers that had been lined up for him at the time.  We DO know that any future acquisitions will have been heavily influenced by Val.  This is where it gets interesting.   I'd certainly be happy to have a few more additions in the mould of Mowatt but it's the striker that is most anticipated and should give us an idea of where those next three windows could take us.

I admire your optimism. Maybe I'm focusing on the negatives and the fact that we seem reluctant to spend anything and sell our best players for peanuts rather than the fact that Clarke and Mowatt have been successful signings so far.

I'm also being a bit harsh on Reach. He's actually been pretty good, he's just not an improvement on our first 11.


RE: 3 transfer windows required. - Cheshire East Baggie - 12-08-2021

(12-08-2021, 10:36 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: I'm sure the current squad will be delighted to hear this and it will improve morale no end

I didn't see much wrong in what he said. Plenty of talk about needing to keep all the players involved and happy. But we can still criticise Ismael because that's what we do.