WBAUnofficial
Over thinking our simple problem - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Over thinking our simple problem (/showthread.php?tid=22932)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Over thinking our simple problem - Derek Hardballs - 11-27-2021

(11-27-2021, 12:40 PM)Cuzer Wrote: I’m still very much pro Val and can’t help thinking the toxic feeling in the stadium is mainly aimed at Ken and Lai, and our pathetic recruitment of bang average players such as Reach, Moloumby, Hugill and letting good players leave the club on a free or for a pittance, see Pereira

Val’s criticism is his inability to even try something different, we are so easy to set up against as every opposition coaching staff knows it will be 3-4-3 with a high line

We don’t have a midfielder who breaks into the box, so it’s completely rigid, everybody we play goes 3 at the back so our front 3 are always man marked

Yes we work the ball wide but often have nobody to very few in the box and we have no aerial presence either

For me even for a 10 minute period of a game Val should drop Grady behind Robbo and Grant and those pair play a front two, straight away the centre halves have to change their set up, straight away Mowatt could run past Grady and break into the box, we do none of this, the only time we’ve ever changed shape is when we’ve had a sending off, zero flexibility and too predictable

Cuzer

Cuzer, steady yourself… I completely agree with your points in bold. The refusal to tweak the system in games makes us one dimensional. Not giving or having a system that allows our midfield and forwards to break forward or sit deeper is head scratchingly stubborn at best at worst it may show a lack of tactical nouse. 

My questions are..

What does Val do during games to make the opposition change their tactics from those they set out with? 
What is the point of the manager being at games if the same tactics are rigidly stuck to game after game? 
What do we do to alter our tactics to stop the opposition? 

Our only tactical changes currently are invariably like for like subs.


RE: Over thinking our simple problem - Tom Joad - 11-27-2021

Agree with all of these posts. I do think we need unity, not apathy.


RE: Over thinking our simple problem - Hopalong - 11-27-2021

(11-27-2021, 12:10 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Fortunately for me I missed last night’s game as I went to see James and The Happy Mondays at the NIA. 
I had the pleasure of being joined by another poster on this board through a mutual friend, and both of us were relatively downbeat with what’s going on. 
I’ve just watched the highlights and simply the problem was failing to convert at least one very good chance. 
We had about 4 of them and whilst Hugill’s miss will be focused on(incidentally it was relatively poor, but not unusually so) the simple fact we’ve not scored in three games, and have only scored 8 in 10, after the hiding we gave Cardiff shows the problem is a relatively decent striker. 
We can go on about the football style, but we are and continue to create enough decent chances to win games. 
Promisingly we are tight at the back but failure to get a quality striker, at least on loan, will be the simple difference in our season. 
It seems to me it has to be an upgraded target man rather than a poacher. That’s the only sticking point.
A half decent forward and the views of virtually all on here changes dramatically. 
The calmer fans will have noted this.

If we can see it,  then surely so can the powers that be.  Newcastle will surely break the bank for goals otherwise they're relegated so Gayle must be available, however there's a question mark over his fitness/injury record.  Knowing us we will gamble on a Carroll!  

Pretty sure we'll be trying to get Dike or maybe even Diagne as he's not featuring for Gala.  I'd also like to see us sign Yokuslu on loan with a view to a perm.   

The other position we badly need to strengthen is RWB.  Furlong has been appalling since Val Singelton'd him out after the Swansea debacle.  TGH is not the answer.


RE: Over thinking our simple problem - Swagbaggie - 11-27-2021

(11-27-2021, 03:00 PM)Hopalong Wrote: If we can see it,  then surely so can the powers that be.  Newcastle will surely break the bank for goals otherwise they're relegated so Gayle must be available, however there's a question mark over his fitness/injury record.  Knowing us we will gamble on a Carroll!  

Pretty sure we'll be trying to get Dike or maybe even Diagne as he's not featuring for Gala.  I'd also like to see us sign Yokuslu on loan with a view to a perm.   

The other position we badly need to strengthen is RWB.  Furlong has been appalling since Val Singelton'd him out after the Swansea debacle.  TGH is not the answer.

See what you did there.
Get a Blue Peter badge


RE: Over thinking our simple problem - Hopalong - 11-27-2021

(11-27-2021, 02:23 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Agree with all of these posts. I do think we need unity, not apathy.

Totally agree TJ - the games coming up are winnable as they all are potentially but I'm reasonably confident we can close the gap on the top 2 by the new year, with Bournemouth and Fulham still to come at home and them playing each other twice. Long, long way to go.


RE: Over thinking our simple problem - Birdman1811 - 11-27-2021

Agree with both Cuzer and Derek, at the same time.

Fuck...


RE: Over thinking our simple problem - Brandywell - 11-27-2021

Be interesting to see how tight at the back we are should Sam Johnstone leave in January


RE: Over thinking our simple problem - Hopalong - 11-27-2021

(11-27-2021, 03:33 PM)Brandywell Wrote: Be interesting to see how tight at the back we are should Sam Johnstone leave in January


Stick or twist -  keep Sam and hope we go up or try and generate an auction, get what we can and get a striker and RWB.


RE: Over thinking our simple problem - Cuzer - 11-27-2021

(11-27-2021, 03:25 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Agree with both Cuzer and Derek, at the same time.

Fuck...

You after a ban Birrdman or what? Big Grin 

Cuzer


RE: Over thinking our simple problem - Pragmatist - 11-27-2021

Most of the comments are spot on and refreshing.

Val may well be getting criticised for not having a plan B, but we are creating a huge number of chances per game. It’s only the conversion rate that’s the problem. We’d be top 2 with a decent striker in the side. Mitrovic would have just as many for us as he has scored for Fulham.

Get that bit right in January and we’ll be fine. Not sure where we will get one from, but we must get at least one!