WBAUnofficial
Jimmy Savile - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Jimmy Savile (/showthread.php?tid=22723)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: Jimmy Savile - MassDebater - 11-10-2021

(11-09-2021, 07:26 PM)Duffers Wrote: Love that the report goes on about an “eerie transformation” when it’s literally nothing more than Coogan in a blonde wig.

Was about to post exactly the same thing!


RE: Jimmy Savile - UCEbaggie - 11-10-2021

(11-09-2021, 09:01 PM)Black Lake Victoria Wrote:
(11-09-2021, 06:49 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: This should be a good watch. A story that has to be told. How a creep like him was allowed such a high profile for so long is mind-boggling.
As a kid watching him it was clear he was a wrong un.

Why would anybody want to watch this and why are the BBC making it

This is a strange one. Can’t help but think you’re just using this as an opportunity to bash the BBC. Throughout the history of television and movies films and programmes have been made that dramatise real life events. Think about all those war films made in the late ‘40s early ‘50s. I don’t believe the studios were criticised for making them so soon after the end of war  at a time when people’s memories and traumas were still fresh. 

I watched a fantastic drama on ITV last year about a double murder in South Wales. Keith Allen was in it. Again, some of the people affected will still be with us but I didn’t see ITV being criticised for making it. I think it’s right that the BBC confronts it’s own failures on this. Remember, after the ITV expose on Saville it was the BBCs own Panorama that had investigated and broadcast the details of the Newsnight investigation being killed by senior management. 

The BBC has been rightly criticised and held to account for its awful failings in the Saville affair - including an independent enquiry. If this drama tells the story in a way that is respectful to the victims and maybe helps some people who have faced their own challenges with abusers then I reckon that’s a good thing.


RE: Jimmy Savile - MassDebater - 11-10-2021

(11-09-2021, 09:01 PM)Black Lake Victoria Wrote:
(11-09-2021, 06:49 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: This should be a good watch. A story that has to be told. How a creep like him was allowed such a high profile for so long is mind-boggling.
As a kid watching him it was clear he was a wrong un.

Why would anybody want to watch this and why are the BBC making it

Probably for similar reasons why there are numerous docu-shows about serial killers, Hitler, Pol Pot, The Wests, Shipman etc... a grim story seems to make for 'better' TV than something about someone lovely and clean cut I guess? people are fascinated by Evil people far more than they are good ones.


RE: Jimmy Savile - Squid - 11-10-2021

I think there's a difference between a documentary and a dramatisation though. The former seems more valid and necessary then the latter.

Besides this, it's all very well saying that the Saville drama will "raise awareness", on Monday night the documentary 'Rape: Who's on trial?' showed exactly how difficult it is to attain a conviction for rape.


RE: Jimmy Savile - Tom Joad - 11-10-2021

I find there is something very sensationalist about these true life drama-docs. Cynically, I think they are made for entertainment but dressed up to be informative and 'raise awareness '. As such, they should just drop the pretence and come out and say so.
As an aside. I have 2 stories about Saville ( who was truly the most bizarre "entertainer", inasmuch as no one ever liked his stuff). One, a nurse I knew in Hampshire 35 years ago who had seen him at her workplace. She commented while he was on telly, in a throwaway comment,  "He's a right creep and there's a lot of very unpleasant rumours about him".
Two. A mate sold cars at a prestige dealership in Yorkshire and Saville had been hired to boost publicity. He said he had absolutely no idea what his appeal was but he'd never seen anyone command such attention with his charisma.
Both of these comments were made long before it all came out.


RE: Jimmy Savile - Fido - 11-10-2021

(11-10-2021, 11:25 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I find there is something very sensationalist about these true life drama-docs. Cynically, I think they are made for entertainment but dressed up to be informative and 'raise awareness '. As such, they should just drop the pretence and come out and say so.
As an aside. I have 2 stories about Saville ( who was truly the most bizarre "entertainer", inasmuch as no one ever liked his stuff). One, a nurse I knew in Hampshire 35 years ago who had seen him at her workplace. She commented while he was on telly, in a throwaway comment,  "He's a right creep and there's a lot of very unpleasant rumours about him".
Two. A mate sold cars at a prestige dealership in Yorkshire and Saville had been hired to boost publicity. He said he had absolutely no idea what his appeal was but he'd never seen anyone command such attention with his charisma.
Both of these comments were made long before it all came out.

My wife's family lived (well, still live) in Crowthorne where Broadmoor is situated and where Savile had a private room. He was often at the Broadmoor School fetes (for kids that lived outside the walls, I have to add!) and because of those same rumours young girls were warned to keep their distance. My missus and her sister never knew of anything that had actually happened to anyone they knew but the stories passed around so they were on their guard.


RE: Jimmy Savile - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 11-10-2021

(11-10-2021, 11:34 AM)Fido Wrote:
(11-10-2021, 11:25 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I find there is something very sensationalist about these true life drama-docs. Cynically, I think they are made for entertainment but dressed up to be informative and 'raise awareness '. As such, they should just drop the pretence and come out and say so.
As an aside. I have 2 stories about Saville ( who was truly the most bizarre "entertainer", inasmuch as no one ever liked his stuff). One, a nurse I knew in Hampshire 35 years ago who had seen him at her workplace. She commented while he was on telly, in a throwaway comment,  "He's a right creep and there's a lot of very unpleasant rumours about him".
Two. A mate sold cars at a prestige dealership in Yorkshire and Saville had been hired to boost publicity. He said he had absolutely no idea what his appeal was but he'd never seen anyone command such attention with his charisma.
Both of these comments were made long before it all came out.

My wife's family lived (well, still live) in Crowthorne where Broadmoor is situated and where Savile had a private room. He was often at the Broadmoor School fetes (for kids that lived outside the walls, I have to add!) and because of those same rumours young girls were warned to keep their distance. My missus and her sister never knew of anything that had actually happened to anyone they knew but the stories passed around so they were on their guard.
I think, the more you look back on it, the rumours about him etc, makes it even more awful that he kept getting away with it.
When his crimes came to light, I saw an interview with Bob Langley, a reporter on `Midlands Today`in the 70s / 80s. He was sent to report on one of Savilles sponsored walks for charity, which was passing through Nuneaton or wherever. After doing an interview, he and the camera man had to wait for a car to pick them up. Saville talked with them, and, made a remark about always ensuring his walks  went past schools, `might get a cuddle off a nice schoolgirl`etc, Langley, at the time, thought it must be a bad joke, but now realised that Saville was basically a monster, and wished he had spoken to someone about it.


RE: Jimmy Savile - Spandaubaggie - 11-10-2021

My Savile story is I worked on a newspaper in Norfolk in the mid 90s. Anyhow a bloke from the region got paralysed on a bouncy castle and was in Stoke Mandeville for months. The lad I shared a house with, a fellow news reporter, had to go and visit the bloke. Savile was there that day and had photos taken for the paper and was interviewed by my colleague .
My house mate said: "That Jimmy Savile ain't right at all. He's proper strange and who knows what he's up to."


RE: Jimmy Savile - Duffers - 11-10-2021

(11-09-2021, 11:07 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(11-09-2021, 09:24 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-09-2021, 09:01 PM)Black Lake Victoria Wrote:
(11-09-2021, 06:49 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: This should be a good watch. A story that has to be told. How a creep like him was allowed such a high profile for so long is mind-boggling.
As a kid watching him it was clear he was a wrong un.

Why would anybody want to watch this and why are the BBC making it

Is it because he was really good at presenting pop videos?
He wasn’t even good at that Duffers. Unfortunately he was there at the time of memorable music in the 60s, 70s and 80s and his appearances now mean artists have lost any royalties of the BBC showing them again. 
He used to do some retro hits show on Radio 2 in the 80s and I recall thinking he’s just plain weird and was bewildered at why he was famous- he was odd and irritating.

That’s not really true though. TOTP2 is still going strong, they’ve just edited the presenters out and kept the performances.


RE: Jimmy Savile - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 11-10-2021

(11-10-2021, 11:49 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: My Savile story is I worked on a newspaper in Norfolk in the mid 90s. Anyhow a bloke from the region got paralysed on a bouncy castle and was in Stoke Mandeville for months. The lad I shared a house with, a fellow news reporter, had to go and visit the bloke. Savile was there that day and had photos taken for the paper and was interviewed by my colleague .
My house mate said: "That Jimmy Savile ain't right at all. He's proper strange and who knows what he's up to."
Trouble was though, Spandau, he was famous, a major star for the BBC, a blind eye was turned, if your housemate had reported his concerns, nothing would be done. I recall a lady, who was assaulted by Saville when she was a teenager in the 60s, being on the news when this all was exposed. She threatened to go to the police at the time, he laughed at her, `you`ll get the cheapest solicitor, I`ll get the top barrister in England`.