RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - MassDebater - 10-21-2021
(10-21-2021, 07:47 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: (10-21-2021, 07:42 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (10-21-2021, 07:41 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: (10-21-2021, 07:28 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (10-21-2021, 07:09 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Derek Statham
Cyrille Regis
Bryan Robson
Remi Moses
John Trewick
Carlton Palmer
David Burrows (maybe)
Were all playing regularly as teenagers. Times have changed, it seems.
Except at the top clubs, where they trust in their youth a lot more, and you'd have to say there must be more pressure turning our for Chelsea, Man U, Citeh or Liverpool than for us?
if they don't get a chance then nobody will ever know. For me, now is the time to try at least one, and possibly two of them. Heck it can't get any worse than we've been dishing up lately, and maybe some of the young ones will have the legs to play the high press again?
The top clubs tend to have the best youngsters (often poached from other teams) and also have world class players around them to bail them out should they make a mistake. We don't have that luxury.
There is that flaw to the argument.
Then again, Blues gave Bellingham a chance and he didn't do too badly...
Jude Bellingham is exceptional. As were the likes of Bale, Walcott and Shaw at Southampton. They weren't just thrown in, they deserved their place.
Yes, but at some point he would still no doubt have been seen as a risk. Someone made the choice to give him a go, same with the others. I thought Six had sung the praises of some of our youth when he arrived? (i may be misremembering that though)
RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - SausEggBaton - 10-21-2021
I do question why we let Edwards go. A good option for Val Ball in this league. Makes you wonder whether Val even had a look at him before he left. Cracking on FIFA 2020 anyway.
RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - Korenavirus - 10-21-2021
(10-21-2021, 06:31 PM)Squid Wrote: People have no patience with young players though. It's the classic thing to say when the first team aren't doing well "Bring on the kids", but when the kids make a mistake, everyone's howling and calling the club small-time.
I know it's claimed we have a good academy, and in fairness, we do produce players who go on to have a decent career in football.
However, the fact is, there's not a single player you've listed that I wish we'd kept and I think blaming the club for their careers stagnating is also harsh. Yes, Field had potential, but he's always injured. Leko just isn't as good as we thought he'd be and the other two seemed to be more into the football lifestyle than actually being footballers.
I see Morgan Rogers is at Bournemouth on loan, not sure how much game time he's had there, but we sold him to pay for Bilic and considering Bilic did get us promoted, that was money well spent.
We don't have a fanbase willing to look to the long term, because (for various reasons) we don't have a club that's looking to the long term either. It's either promotion by any means necessary, or survival by any means necessary. Fans have no patience per se. 3rd in the table and spent nowt and still not satisfied.
Ffs, what the fuck do people want.
RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - Birdman1811 - 10-21-2021
And there is the issue.
We are too scared to play them in case it's a costly mistake. So we simply won't ever develop players for the first team at the rate we need to to use that as a competitive edge..... Vicious circle.
RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - Squid - 10-21-2021
(10-21-2021, 08:00 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: I do question why we let Edwards go. A good option for Val Ball in this league. Makes you wonder whether Val even had a look at him before he left. Cracking on FIFA anyway.
Because we have three other players in his position and then there was widely cited accounts of him having a party at Christmas and subsequently catching Covid.
There are plenty of things to criticise the club over*, but not playing players who are not and will never be good enough surely isn't on the list.
*I'm less critical than many, but lest I be called a happy clapper, here are my list of things the club can be rightly criticised for, dating from 2017 onward:
Complete failure to conduct any sucession planning for Pulis.
Giving Pulis a new contract.
Buying Oli Burke and loaning Gap Year Greg instead of a decent midfielder and striker
Appointing Pardew
Not sacking Pardew until it was too late
Appointing Terrano
Allowing Dowling to fall out with the academy staff so badly
I will make allowances for the Darren Moore and replacement of, because that was a messy situation all around
Buying Zohore
Not raising any alarm bells when the team limped to promotion
The absolute mess of the summer of 2020 when we had an unfit mess of a team
Paying £15m for Grant
Taking too long to sack Bilic.
Trying to sell Pereira in January
Wasting time chasing Wilder when it was clear we wouldn't appint him.
I'm sure there are plenty more.
RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - Peachy - 10-21-2021
(10-21-2021, 05:45 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I said I'd go for a more detailed post on this earlier. So here it is.
We have a fantastic academy, as said, I know coaches in the pro game, they all talk with sometimes awe regarding our academy set up, it's considered one of the best out there, in fact, that's why Villa have basically stolen and copied it. And we've had multiple talented players through who many considered should have achieved far more than they have or are so far. Of course sometimes player attitude is an issue, Saido for example. However we've always been very poor at developing them from academy to first team. Some examples.
Field. Pulis highly rated him, like really, really rated him, felt he was one of the best players he'd seen come from an academy, and exactly the type of player he wanted to develop. But he would always favour an average, experienced journeyman over him, because of the fear of a fact, young players make mistakes, they do. Pulis didn't allow for mistakes, so it was hard for him to give Field the game time he needed. It was actually a source of conflict between Megson and Pulis in that relegation season, Megson couldn't see why Field wasn't playing, hence he started as soon as Megson took over. We then got relegated, and in what will always be a mystery, Moore preferred Barry over him, no one anywhere near the club understood this at all. He should have been paired with Livermore or Brunt and allowed to develop at that level. Instead he stagnated, having already stagnated a bit too much under Pulis, and had his confidence sundered by Pardew. Injuries hit, and maybe they would have done anyway, but that ruined him under Bilic and Allardyce, and sensibly we moved him on, best for all parties, but he was very close to being a first teamer here. In another universe, Megson stayed on instead of Pardew coming in, we stayed up, Field is now a regular starter for the team.
Leko. Another Pulis really rated. However again, that fear of mistakes in important games. We all tease Cuzer for his 'Form of his Life' comment, but there is some truth to it. Leko SHOULD have played a lot more often, he was more than comfortable in training with the first team, he needed to play at their level to develop into one of them. Instead he stagnated and fell away.
Harper. A strange one, because he's an awkward player, more of an athlete than a footballer in many ways. but very versatile and a lot of raw talent, if it can be moulded. Shan was a big fan of his, as was Moore. However struggled to make an impact as much as he'd have liked. He went off the boil a bit too attitude wise, however I think he's the type of player Val would have been able to mould into something worth having. He was strong, athletic, quick and when motivated, covered a lot of ground. Capable of playing midfield, attacking midfield and had spent a lot of time as a striker in youth football, would have been decent squad cover this season in my opinion. Not the fault of previous managers this one, he possibly hurt his own chances, but feel we've let him go a little too easily considering what's left here.
Edwards. People forget that he actually won us games under Shan and Bilic. Should have had a loan while we were in the prem, since he was never going to get game time in that league, and rumours of parties over Covid sort of did for him here really. Though he would have suited Val I feel, again, prefers the Left, already have Grant, Grady and Robinson for that. Considering his desired wage, possibly rightly let go.
Here's the thing, if at 21-22, a player isn't getting first team football, near to the level you want them to end up playing, they rarely seem to get there unless they get a second chance in their late 20's. Ferguson and O'Shea have got there, because they got that game time when needed (O'Shea is a late developer, some players are.) But they got game time, and trusted to play at a level we needed them to early in their post academy careers, that allows them to continue developing, until 23 players cannot be allowed to stagnate, you limit their potential career by doing so, it's why long term injuries at that age are so concerning. Every season should be a development on the last, and long term loans must be to clubs with decent coaching set ups and equipment. Also preferably a similar style to the club ethos (If we fucking had one.)
If we want the likes of Tulloch, Cleary etc to become first teamers here, they need to get chances, they need to be trusted, as subs to change a game, or to hold on, or even start and see how they react. U23's football is awful, it's not good for developing players, but League 1 and league 2 clubs rarely have the training conditions we want our players to be in, and also, we have no control over how they'll be asked to play. The removal of the 30 day loan for youth players was a killer for this imo, that was a great way to get some first team experience, but not risk stalling the development of a player.
So that's where, with our limited resources, and lack of sellable assets, we need to start improving, now. Val has a record of moving youth players into the first team, well now he might want to start the process here in earnest.
My thoughts anyway.
Great post Birdy. I know I must bore people with me constantly banging on about the youth team but I watch a lot of their games and we have some cracking prospects. We really do.
We are in the championship with a smallish squad and pre season Val said the squad will be topped up with youngsters yet so far it hasn't happened. Tulloch will 100% get his chance this season if he can stay fit. I'd also be getting Cleary on the bench even at 17. He is much leaner than pre season and looks really fired up and most importantly he's scoring goals regularly. I'm not saying he should start but having a kid who has no fear and wanting to prove himself on the bench has to be a better option than having 2 or 3 average pro's on the bench who all play a similar position. We have other players who with the right players alongside them wouldn't let anybody down.
A lack of saleable assets is another very good point. If we give one of these players a platform and he grasps the opportunity all of a sudden you have another asset. That will only happen though by easing them in to games.
Like I said before looking at that bench last night no one can tell me we wouldn't have been better off having a young striker on the bench instead of one of Kipre or Bryan who neither of which were needed.
RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - Gzbaggy - 10-22-2021
Well written piece but you really hit the nail on the head when you say "we have a fantastic academy" but we "always favour an average, experienced journeyman over him, because of the fear of a fact, young players make mistakes"
Bearing that in mind it seems pointless to have an academy as players will not be given a chance
Would you advise any teenager to go to the Albion? I hate to say this but the answer is probably no
RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - Birdman1811 - 10-22-2021
They'll get a fantastic education. I'd advise them to jump ship at 18 though. Though Villa aren't better, Birmingham seem to be the best in the area for giving chances.
RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - MassDebater - 10-22-2021
(10-22-2021, 09:51 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: They'll get a fantastic education. I'd advise them to jump ship at 18 though. Though Villa aren't better, Birmingham seem to be the best in the area for giving chances.
I suppose that's the rub, the lower clubs who are on shoestrings have to give them more of a chance...
We really should be giving some of them a go by now. Slav at least did, and tbf would have earned the club £11m off Ferguson had he not got a dodgy body. He also played Edwards and Harper a fair bit.
RE: Youth, and our struggles with it. - Gzbaggy - 10-22-2021
how many youngsters have Southampton, Norwich and Leicester given chances to in the past decade?
|