RE: Snobbery - Sotv - 08-16-2021
(08-15-2021, 01:26 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-15-2021, 12:20 PM)Sotv Wrote: (08-15-2021, 10:14 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Questions…
Do many working class people in the Midlands and North have a degree?
Why does gaining a higher education mean their views are no longer as valid about the area they may still live in and have grown up in? It seems a rather weak argument to say all graduates leave their community, town or city as soon as they gain their degree. It’s also at odds with members of this government declaring many degrees are not worth taking because they don’t offer well paid jobs at the end of the course (not sure you measure education simply on the binary argument does it make me well off but that’s the current mindset sadly).
Do those on the leave side not throw insults around? I must have missed the polite discourse between the two sides.
Are those without degrees / higher education qualifications not influenced by others outside of their peer group? I only ask as the argument seems to be those who are educated are influenced by a small group of elites. It’s not made clear if this accusation can be equally laid at the door of those on the other side of the argument?
How has the leave side of the argument attempted to bring nearly half the population with them, with regards to Brexit or wider issues that divide the country? Have they been the better people, more magnanimous? Does the line ‘you lost get over it’ ring a bell?
Has the government tried to bring people together or looked to divide and blame groups of people whenever they feel any political heat?
Is the centre right author simply perpetuating the divide within society by only seemingly criticising one side of the argument?
When austerity was decimating public services (still is) for the poorest and most vulnerable were the posters portraying themselves as caring about the working class, campaigning against them? Or were they campaigning for, endorsing them or staying silent over them at best?
Put up or shut up
![[Image: qgaJjkiTGexznNLPDuBQ_The%20Independent.png]](https://storify.com/services/proxy/2/MURQSr9YnD1DAiPQtBmIcQ/https/media.fyre.co/qgaJjkiTGexznNLPDuBQ_The%20Independent.png)
you've clearly read the original article with one eye. Your attempts at misdirection and lies about what the author has written are so obvious its pitiful.
As i say, this has really touched a nerve for some
(08-15-2021, 11:15 AM)Ossian Wrote: There's a conundrum where the so-called 'Red wall' is concerned - one the centrists in both of the main parties should be considering. Are the reasons for abandoning Labour the same as those for embracing the Tories? My guess it's bit more complicated than that, and some of it may be indicative of nothing more than the Hobson's Choice effect of our enduring two-party system.
I don't know about anybody else on here, but it's 20 years since I last voted with any enthusiasm in a GE.
You raise a very good point about red wall voters.
I don't think the reasons for abandoning Labour are the same as why they voted for the Tories. I can imagine a lot of those who switched were going to the ballot box holding their noses but decided they could no longer vote for a party where may supporters have engaged in the kind of insulting discourse we have seen on social media for instance.
It's telling that the author makes the point that unless the Tories deliver on their levelling up agenda, then their majority will disappear or at least be greatly reduced.
If the tories fail to deliver and working class voters continue to see Labour as a party of metropolitan elites, this creates a dangerous vacuum ripe for exploitation.
Chuck in a few incidents that have the potential to stoke racial tensions or at least exploit them in some of the ex mill towns for example and we could be heading for a very nasty situation indeed.
Try answering the questions instead of trying to make this personal.
“And that brings me to the last and greatest group of male culprits. Most of these single mothers have had the common sense to detect that the modern British male is useless.
“If he is blue collar, he is likely to be drunk, criminal, aimless, feckless and hopeless, and perhaps claiming to suffer from low self-esteem brought on by unemployment.
“If he is white collar, he is likely to be little better.” Arf, it’s not nice when people play you at your own game is it?
There is no point in bothering, you’re so closed minded that any answer I give will be wrong in your eyes.
I’ll just stick to calling out your crap when you spout it, don’t like it you know where the ignore button is
RE: Snobbery - Protheroe - 08-17-2021
(08-15-2021, 10:14 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Do those on the leave side not throw insults around?
Could you enlighten me as to the nature of those 'insults'?
What exactly were they?
I can recall the various insults hurled at Leave voters:
- Thick
- Racist
- Narrow Minded
- Parochial
- Uncaring
- Old
- Betraying our young people
All of these insults fit perfectly into the narrative the author suggests (thought there's also plenty I don't agree with). Paul Embery's book is much better tbh.
I can only really recall insulting Remainers as anti-democratic metropolitan star spangled flag shaggers, but that's more of an observation.
RE: Snobbery - Derek Hardballs - 08-17-2021
(08-16-2021, 08:31 PM)Sotv Wrote: (08-15-2021, 01:26 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-15-2021, 12:20 PM)Sotv Wrote: (08-15-2021, 10:14 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Questions…
Do many working class people in the Midlands and North have a degree?
Why does gaining a higher education mean their views are no longer as valid about the area they may still live in and have grown up in? It seems a rather weak argument to say all graduates leave their community, town or city as soon as they gain their degree. It’s also at odds with members of this government declaring many degrees are not worth taking because they don’t offer well paid jobs at the end of the course (not sure you measure education simply on the binary argument does it make me well off but that’s the current mindset sadly).
Do those on the leave side not throw insults around? I must have missed the polite discourse between the two sides.
Are those without degrees / higher education qualifications not influenced by others outside of their peer group? I only ask as the argument seems to be those who are educated are influenced by a small group of elites. It’s not made clear if this accusation can be equally laid at the door of those on the other side of the argument?
How has the leave side of the argument attempted to bring nearly half the population with them, with regards to Brexit or wider issues that divide the country? Have they been the better people, more magnanimous? Does the line ‘you lost get over it’ ring a bell?
Has the government tried to bring people together or looked to divide and blame groups of people whenever they feel any political heat?
Is the centre right author simply perpetuating the divide within society by only seemingly criticising one side of the argument?
When austerity was decimating public services (still is) for the poorest and most vulnerable were the posters portraying themselves as caring about the working class, campaigning against them? Or were they campaigning for, endorsing them or staying silent over them at best?
Put up or shut up
![[Image: qgaJjkiTGexznNLPDuBQ_The%20Independent.png]](https://storify.com/services/proxy/2/MURQSr9YnD1DAiPQtBmIcQ/https/media.fyre.co/qgaJjkiTGexznNLPDuBQ_The%20Independent.png)
you've clearly read the original article with one eye. Your attempts at misdirection and lies about what the author has written are so obvious its pitiful.
As i say, this has really touched a nerve for some
(08-15-2021, 11:15 AM)Ossian Wrote: There's a conundrum where the so-called 'Red wall' is concerned - one the centrists in both of the main parties should be considering. Are the reasons for abandoning Labour the same as those for embracing the Tories? My guess it's bit more complicated than that, and some of it may be indicative of nothing more than the Hobson's Choice effect of our enduring two-party system.
I don't know about anybody else on here, but it's 20 years since I last voted with any enthusiasm in a GE.
You raise a very good point about red wall voters.
I don't think the reasons for abandoning Labour are the same as why they voted for the Tories. I can imagine a lot of those who switched were going to the ballot box holding their noses but decided they could no longer vote for a party where may supporters have engaged in the kind of insulting discourse we have seen on social media for instance.
It's telling that the author makes the point that unless the Tories deliver on their levelling up agenda, then their majority will disappear or at least be greatly reduced.
If the tories fail to deliver and working class voters continue to see Labour as a party of metropolitan elites, this creates a dangerous vacuum ripe for exploitation.
Chuck in a few incidents that have the potential to stoke racial tensions or at least exploit them in some of the ex mill towns for example and we could be heading for a very nasty situation indeed.
Try answering the questions instead of trying to make this personal.
“And that brings me to the last and greatest group of male culprits. Most of these single mothers have had the common sense to detect that the modern British male is useless.
“If he is blue collar, he is likely to be drunk, criminal, aimless, feckless and hopeless, and perhaps claiming to suffer from low self-esteem brought on by unemployment.
“If he is white collar, he is likely to be little better.” Arf, it’s not nice when people play you at your own game is it?
There is no point in bothering, you’re so closed minded that any answer I give will be wrong in your eyes.
I’ll just stick to calling out your crap when you spout it, don’t like it you know where the ignore button is 
You posted a thread presumably to get people to engage with it? I obliged knowing full well you just wanted to have pop at me and that any response would illicit a ‘hit a nerve’ type response. If this makes you feel like you’ve won the argument because I politely answered the opinions raised in the article then I am pleased you got the reaction you wanted.
I appreciate that answering the questions I put in response to the article and subsequent posts isn’t something you wish to engage with, and hope you engage more meaningfully in the future.
I do have to say at this point that I do not take the opinions of those who accuse others of snobbery / not taking the problems of working class areas seriously, whilst they have supported ideologically driven austerity measures be that through the ballot box or actively campaigning for those who undertook cuts to frontline services in those areas.
RE: Snobbery - Sotv - 08-17-2021
(08-17-2021, 11:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-16-2021, 08:31 PM)Sotv Wrote: (08-15-2021, 01:26 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-15-2021, 12:20 PM)Sotv Wrote: (08-15-2021, 10:14 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Questions…
Do many working class people in the Midlands and North have a degree?
Why does gaining a higher education mean their views are no longer as valid about the area they may still live in and have grown up in? It seems a rather weak argument to say all graduates leave their community, town or city as soon as they gain their degree. It’s also at odds with members of this government declaring many degrees are not worth taking because they don’t offer well paid jobs at the end of the course (not sure you measure education simply on the binary argument does it make me well off but that’s the current mindset sadly).
Do those on the leave side not throw insults around? I must have missed the polite discourse between the two sides.
Are those without degrees / higher education qualifications not influenced by others outside of their peer group? I only ask as the argument seems to be those who are educated are influenced by a small group of elites. It’s not made clear if this accusation can be equally laid at the door of those on the other side of the argument?
How has the leave side of the argument attempted to bring nearly half the population with them, with regards to Brexit or wider issues that divide the country? Have they been the better people, more magnanimous? Does the line ‘you lost get over it’ ring a bell?
Has the government tried to bring people together or looked to divide and blame groups of people whenever they feel any political heat?
Is the centre right author simply perpetuating the divide within society by only seemingly criticising one side of the argument?
When austerity was decimating public services (still is) for the poorest and most vulnerable were the posters portraying themselves as caring about the working class, campaigning against them? Or were they campaigning for, endorsing them or staying silent over them at best?
Put up or shut up
![[Image: qgaJjkiTGexznNLPDuBQ_The%20Independent.png]](https://storify.com/services/proxy/2/MURQSr9YnD1DAiPQtBmIcQ/https/media.fyre.co/qgaJjkiTGexznNLPDuBQ_The%20Independent.png)
you've clearly read the original article with one eye. Your attempts at misdirection and lies about what the author has written are so obvious its pitiful.
As i say, this has really touched a nerve for some
(08-15-2021, 11:15 AM)Ossian Wrote: There's a conundrum where the so-called 'Red wall' is concerned - one the centrists in both of the main parties should be considering. Are the reasons for abandoning Labour the same as those for embracing the Tories? My guess it's bit more complicated than that, and some of it may be indicative of nothing more than the Hobson's Choice effect of our enduring two-party system.
I don't know about anybody else on here, but it's 20 years since I last voted with any enthusiasm in a GE.
You raise a very good point about red wall voters.
I don't think the reasons for abandoning Labour are the same as why they voted for the Tories. I can imagine a lot of those who switched were going to the ballot box holding their noses but decided they could no longer vote for a party where may supporters have engaged in the kind of insulting discourse we have seen on social media for instance.
It's telling that the author makes the point that unless the Tories deliver on their levelling up agenda, then their majority will disappear or at least be greatly reduced.
If the tories fail to deliver and working class voters continue to see Labour as a party of metropolitan elites, this creates a dangerous vacuum ripe for exploitation.
Chuck in a few incidents that have the potential to stoke racial tensions or at least exploit them in some of the ex mill towns for example and we could be heading for a very nasty situation indeed.
Try answering the questions instead of trying to make this personal.
“And that brings me to the last and greatest group of male culprits. Most of these single mothers have had the common sense to detect that the modern British male is useless.
“If he is blue collar, he is likely to be drunk, criminal, aimless, feckless and hopeless, and perhaps claiming to suffer from low self-esteem brought on by unemployment.
“If he is white collar, he is likely to be little better.” Arf, it’s not nice when people play you at your own game is it?
There is no point in bothering, you’re so closed minded that any answer I give will be wrong in your eyes.
I’ll just stick to calling out your crap when you spout it, don’t like it you know where the ignore button is 
You posted a thread presumably to get people to engage with it? I obliged knowing full well you just wanted to have pop at me and that any response would illicit a ‘hit a nerve’ type response. If this makes you feel like you’ve won the argument because I politely answered the opinions raised in the article then I am pleased you got the reaction you wanted.
I appreciate that answering the questions I put in response to the article and subsequent posts isn’t something you wish to engage with, and hope you engage more meaningfully in the future.
I do have to say at this point that I do not take the opinions of those who accuse others of snobbery / not taking the problems of working class areas seriously, whilst they have supported ideologically driven austerity measures be that through the ballot box or actively campaigning for those who undertook cuts to frontline services in those areas.
you answered nothing, as per usual. As i've said, any attempt at sensible debate with you is entirely pointless as your mind is already made up.
How did you know i was just wanting to have a pop at you? It's incredibly arrogant to think it was all about you, as i originally mentioned there are a few people on here it could apply to, not just yourself.
RE: Snobbery - Derek Hardballs - 08-17-2021
(08-17-2021, 12:24 PM)Sotv Wrote: (08-17-2021, 11:00 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-16-2021, 08:31 PM)Sotv Wrote: (08-15-2021, 01:26 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-15-2021, 12:20 PM)Sotv Wrote: you've clearly read the original article with one eye. Your attempts at misdirection and lies about what the author has written are so obvious its pitiful.
As i say, this has really touched a nerve for some
You raise a very good point about red wall voters.
I don't think the reasons for abandoning Labour are the same as why they voted for the Tories. I can imagine a lot of those who switched were going to the ballot box holding their noses but decided they could no longer vote for a party where may supporters have engaged in the kind of insulting discourse we have seen on social media for instance.
It's telling that the author makes the point that unless the Tories deliver on their levelling up agenda, then their majority will disappear or at least be greatly reduced.
If the tories fail to deliver and working class voters continue to see Labour as a party of metropolitan elites, this creates a dangerous vacuum ripe for exploitation.
Chuck in a few incidents that have the potential to stoke racial tensions or at least exploit them in some of the ex mill towns for example and we could be heading for a very nasty situation indeed.
Try answering the questions instead of trying to make this personal.
“And that brings me to the last and greatest group of male culprits. Most of these single mothers have had the common sense to detect that the modern British male is useless.
“If he is blue collar, he is likely to be drunk, criminal, aimless, feckless and hopeless, and perhaps claiming to suffer from low self-esteem brought on by unemployment.
“If he is white collar, he is likely to be little better.” Arf, it’s not nice when people play you at your own game is it?
There is no point in bothering, you’re so closed minded that any answer I give will be wrong in your eyes.
I’ll just stick to calling out your crap when you spout it, don’t like it you know where the ignore button is 
You posted a thread presumably to get people to engage with it? I obliged knowing full well you just wanted to have pop at me and that any response would illicit a ‘hit a nerve’ type response. If this makes you feel like you’ve won the argument because I politely answered the opinions raised in the article then I am pleased you got the reaction you wanted.
I appreciate that answering the questions I put in response to the article and subsequent posts isn’t something you wish to engage with, and hope you engage more meaningfully in the future.
I do have to say at this point that I do not take the opinions of those who accuse others of snobbery / not taking the problems of working class areas seriously, whilst they have supported ideologically driven austerity measures be that through the ballot box or actively campaigning for those who undertook cuts to frontline services in those areas.
you answered nothing, as per usual. As i've said, any attempt at sensible debate with you is entirely pointless as your mind is already made up.
How did you know i was just wanting to have a pop at you? It's incredibly arrogant to think it was all about you, as i originally mentioned there are a few people on here it could apply to, not just yourself.
This is absolutely fine, if you wish to try and get a reaction from a number of us, that is your prerogative.
|