WBAUnofficial
Football styles- your thoughts - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Football styles- your thoughts (/showthread.php?tid=18709)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Football styles- your thoughts - col lard - 06-18-2021

The whole concept of tippy-tappy is presumably that if you have possession the opponents won't score (unless Sawyers is playing) and that passing round opponents a) tires the opponents and b) is statistically less risky that trying to beat a player.
Unfortunately it gives defences more time to get into position and, what with improved defensive athleticism and technique, much harder to get into the penalty area and shoot.
As a spectacle, this rolling the ball to a defender, passing it across the back line, out to a wide man,back to the full-back,across the back line, repeat on the other flank, forward pass to a guy who is double-marked, back to centre-back, repeat ad nauseum, is just terrible. No wide men can beat a player because fullbacks are not lumbering cart-horses like they used to be, and crosses are invariably cut out by the first defender or sail right over a packed penalty area.
It's Ok Man City doing this because they can afford the best there is, but lesser outfits have to attack with pace, beat players in midfield and on the flanks, cross the ball and SHOOT, FFS. Everyone wants to score the perfect goal all the time.


RE: Football styles- your thoughts - Birdman1811 - 06-18-2021

Winning. I like to win.

However ultimately I think for teams like us, it's about being fit, energetic and direct.


RE: Football styles- your thoughts - Lurker#3 - 06-18-2021

I like my teams to be fit, determined and graft firstly. I can ever excuse lack of bottle and fitness.

In terms of attacking/in possession preferences. I love to see player run hard, and leave their 'positions'. Especially from deep areas. So a high energy, direct approach to exploit 3rd and 4th runners is what I like to see.


RE: Football styles- your thoughts - Black Lake Victoria - 06-18-2021

Mixer football works with players suited for it (many don't like this but it's true).
Charles Hughes castigated in recent years knew what he was on about


RE: Football styles- your thoughts - DJPunkRoc - 06-18-2021

(06-18-2021, 01:15 PM)col lard Wrote: The whole concept of tippy-tappy is presumably that if you have possession the opponents won't score (unless Sawyers is playing) and that passing round opponents a) tires the opponents and b) is statistically less risky that trying to beat a player.
Unfortunately it gives defences more time to get into position and, what with improved defensive athleticism and technique, much harder to get into the penalty area and shoot.
As a spectacle, this rolling the ball to a defender, passing it across the back line, out to a wide man,back to the full-back,across the back line, repeat on the other flank, forward pass to a guy who is double-marked, back to centre-back, repeat ad nauseum, is just terrible. No wide men can beat a player because fullbacks are not lumbering cart-horses like they used to be, and crosses are invariably cut out by the first defender or sail right over a packed penalty area.
It's Ok Man City doing this because they can afford the best there is, but lesser outfits have to attack with pace, beat players in midfield and on the flanks, cross the ball and SHOOT, FFS. Everyone wants to score the perfect goal all the time.

I was starting to have a similar moan as this about England vs Croatia but, with patience, the ball inevitably ended towards the final 3rd.  What didn't happen enough was a change of pace or multiple runs at the same time to create space on we'd got to the final 3rd.  But is was 80 degrees to be fair.


RE: Football styles- your thoughts - wba13 - 06-18-2021

(06-18-2021, 01:41 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I like my teams to be fit, determined and graft firstly. I can ever excuse lack of bottle and fitness.

In terms of attacking/in possession preferences. I love to see player run hard, and leave their 'positions'. Especially from deep areas. So a high energy, direct approach to exploit 3rd and 4th runners is what I like to see.

I like a winning style, under Pulis it was two defensive hoping for a set piece or long ball. Under Moore and to a degree Bilic it was to much tippy tappy. Let’s hope when we do get a new man in he can get us playing a winning style.


RE: Football styles- your thoughts - Ted Maul - 06-18-2021

Direct football is definitely making a comeback in recent seasons. Whether it be Bayern who play lots of short, sharp vertical passes or teams like Young Boys (who's manager has just gone to Leverkusen) who have just won the league playing a really direct 4-4-2. Hassenhutl with varying degrees of success has played in this manner at Southampton, and Brendan Rodgers has had another good season with Leicester with a mid-block and incisive counter attacks.

Potter has massively improved the Brighton side from what they were under Hughton, they're more effective in the press, they progress the ball up the pitch better, the only difference has been in the quality of finishing. I said three summers ago we should have taken a chance on Potter and the stats suggest his methods work, it's just a shame that most the chances fall to Neal Maupay. If Everton can't get Benitez they could do much worse than Potter.

It's been a while since we've had a true identifiable way of playing, one of the exciting things about Ismael is that he might bring that.


RE: Football styles- your thoughts - Fulham Fallout - 06-18-2021

I’d rather us lose and play a fast, passing, attacking game and utilise the wingers as opposed to defend deep and hope to nick a goal.

Attack, attack, attack attack attack.


RE: Football styles- your thoughts - SW4Baggie - 06-18-2021

(06-18-2021, 01:55 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Direct football is definitely making a comeback in recent seasons. Whether it be Bayern who play lots of short, sharp vertical passes or teams like Young Boys (who's manager has just gone to Leverkusen) who have just won the league playing a really direct 4-4-2. Hassenhutl with varying degrees of success has played in this manner at Southampton, and Brendan Rodgers has had another good season with Leicester with a mid-block and incisive counter attacks.

Potter has massively improved the Brighton side from what they were under Hughton, they're more effective in the press, they progress the ball up the pitch better, the only difference has been in the quality of finishing. I said three summers ago we should have taken a chance on Potter and the stats suggest his methods work, it's just a shame that most the chances fall to Neal Maupay. If Everton can't get Benitez they could do much worse than Potter.

It's been a while since we've had a true identifiable way of playing, one of the exciting things about Ismael is that he might bring that.

If I were Everton I’d have been going all out for Potter. Right now he’d jump at the chance to move there…. But if BHA find a striker more capable of finishing than Maupay, they’ll finish above Everton and Potter will be out of their reach.

When Liverpool appointed Benitez they were getting a young coach with a track record of success. If Everton want to be taken as seriously as their owner wants, they need to be finding the next Benitez, not giving him another payday post China.

Imo they were very lucky Real bought them out of Ancelotti’s incredibly expensive contract.


RE: Football styles- your thoughts - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 06-18-2021

(06-18-2021, 12:54 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: The Ismael thread has started a side debate about football styles, which is worthy of further investigation.

Personally I loved the Spain side of 2008-2012, and for me those names will stand out, but for me the best side ever, which was about attacking flair was Brazil 82- how the hell didn't they win that World Cup? It was an almost freak defeat v Italy, and I'm sure if they had won that World Cup they would unquestionably be seen as the superiors of the 70 side, which many hold as the best ever.

However, as a supporter rather than an impartial observer I do question the love of style over grinding out results. Megson is lauded for what he did and some of that football was tough to watch, but 1-0 was often enough, without going past the half way line, much of the time. 

On the other hand, Mowbray was like some bohemian poet about football, but ultimately it came up short, despite some memorable days.

I think Atkinson's side is eulogised too much for its attack, but we had a gritty defence too and didn't go hung-ho.

FWIW the pragmatic Hodgson is to me the guy who has given me the best of Albion, a tough side, who could adapt when needs be.

As for direct football, it was appalling what Pulis did. The worst football I've ever seen and I'd say a 1-0 defeat at Southampton in his last days was the most disgusting anti-football event I've witnessed.

So hoof-ball v tippy tippy- as ever, with most things in life, the answer lies in the middle. Give me Roy's 2011 team any day of it all.
Remember Brazil 82, great to watch but, ultimately, Italy had good, solid players, Cabrini,Conti, Tardelli etc, plus a very good striker, Rossi.
For all Brazils quality, Zico, Socrates, Eder etc, they had a rubbish striker, Serginho who was in the Anichebe class and was, apparently, picked on the say so of some official at their FA. They also had a dodgy keeper.
Personally, thought in 82 France played superb, but were cynically kicked out of it by West Germany.
As for style, a bloke I knew did kids coaching and had played at non-league, Halesowen Town sort of level, told me `there is no right or wrong way to win a game`.
Would think most coaches have to adapt their style to players their club has, or can afford or pick up at the right price.
I must admit though, I struggled to sit through some of the Pulis 0-0 draws.