WBAUnofficial
Wagner......no.....no....no - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Wagner......no.....no....no (/showthread.php?tid=18335)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Wagner......no.....no....no - keef - 06-08-2021

(06-08-2021, 08:09 PM)wba13 Wrote: Never understand some of our Albion fans, not even arrived and your righting him off.
If and when he does arrive he gets my full backing as he should all off you wether it works or not they will deserve our backing. It could backfire  but remember it’s a man sitting in an office in China who didn’t want our first choice Wilder, the same as a couple of years ago when he didn’t want Smith. Bilic came in and did ok for 12 months. Let’s get behind whoever comes in instead of bickering.
the big question is can he handle the pressure from this bored.
after all thats all that matters Big Grin


RE: Wagner......no.....no....no - Cunninghamismagic - 06-08-2021

(06-08-2021, 07:53 PM)Stratfordbaggie Wrote: Even if we ignore the stats of being one of the worst teams in Bundesliga history when Wagner took Schalke to a winless run that went to 16 games or more......I watched many of those games and the team, the organisation, the tactics and decision making was very poor. Wagner looked clueless, he led Huddersfield to relegation.......albeit he went before they dropped.

This is all about saving money, I really hope I am wrong but feel this is a poor decision if it transpires......

Didn't Wilder have a similar record this season with Sheff Utd?


RE: Wagner......no.....no....no - Dumbo - 06-08-2021

(06-08-2021, 09:54 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(06-08-2021, 07:53 PM)Stratfordbaggie Wrote: Even if we ignore the stats of being one of the worst teams in Bundesliga history when Wagner took Schalke to a winless run that went to 16 games or more......I watched many of those games and the team, the organisation, the tactics and decision making was very poor. Wagner looked clueless, he led Huddersfield to relegation.......albeit he went before they dropped.

This is all about saving money, I really hope I am wrong but feel this is a poor decision if it transpires......

Didn't Wilder have a similar record this season with Sheff Utd?

So that’s a good reason to appoint him, is it? Because he had a similar season to Wilder?

What about the fact that Wilder has had a good season every other year he’s managed, meanwhile, Wagner took Schalke on the worst ever winless run in the clubs history.


RE: Wagner......no.....no....no - MassDebater - 06-08-2021

Jesus, he didn't win a single game during the Play Offs that got Hudds up either. they drew them all and won 2 on penalties... I'm trying to find positives, but the more you look, the more he seems barely average.

Feck, Hudds finished 4th in that season, with a NEGATIVE goal difference! They only scored 56 in 46 games, but conceded 58... How do you even do that in the Chump? (Wigan finished 23rd that season and still had a better defence than Hudds did!)... That doesn't bode particularly well with how leaky and mistake riddled our defence can be.


RE: Wagner......no.....no....no - Dumbo - 06-08-2021

(06-08-2021, 11:11 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Jesus, he didn't win a single game during the Play Offs that got Hudds up either. they drew them all and won 2 on penalties... I'm trying to find positives, but the more you look, the more he seems barely average.

Feck, Hudds finished 4th in that season, with a NEGATIVE goal difference! They only scored 56 in 46 games, but conceded 58... How do you even do that in the Chump? (Wigan finished 23rd that season and still had a better defence than Hudds did!)... That doesn't bode particularly well with how leaky and mistake riddled our defence can be.

Correct. You make your own luck but that is one jammy promotion. 

Tbf, he did well keeping them up the season after but when the momentum and buzz wore off, they were awful the season after and relegated as one of the poorest teams of the past 10 years in the PL.

He then took Schalke on the clubs worst ever winless run before being sacked before they were eventually relegated. 

An utterly depressing appointment.


RE: Wagner......no.....no....no - SW4Baggie - 06-08-2021

(06-08-2021, 11:14 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(06-08-2021, 11:11 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Jesus, he didn't win a single game during the Play Offs that got Hudds up either. they drew them all and won 2 on penalties... I'm trying to find positives, but the more you look, the more he seems barely average.

Feck, Hudds finished 4th in that season, with a NEGATIVE goal difference! They only scored 56 in 46 games, but conceded 58... How do you even do that in the Chump? (Wigan finished 23rd that season and still had a better defence than Hudds did!)... That doesn't bode particularly well with how leaky and mistake riddled our defence can be.

Correct. You make your own luck but that is one jammy promotion. 

Tbf, he did well keeping them up the season after but when the momentum and buzz wore off, they were awful the season after and relegated as one of the poorest teams of the past 10 years in the PL.

He then took Schalke on the clubs worst ever winless run before being sacked before they were eventually relegated. 

An utterly depressing appointment.

You do not fluke promotion based on 46 games, and the fact Wigan had a better defence but managed to to get relegated whilst Hudds got promoted suggested that Hudds got the balance a little better.

Prior to that run they’d been pushing for the champs league and still finished mid tabke… a completely muddled January window, boardroom interference and massive overhauls behind the scenes managed to fuck us everything possible at Schalke.


RE: Wagner......no.....no....no - Dumbo - 06-08-2021

(06-08-2021, 11:19 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(06-08-2021, 11:14 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(06-08-2021, 11:11 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Jesus, he didn't win a single game during the Play Offs that got Hudds up either. they drew them all and won 2 on penalties... I'm trying to find positives, but the more you look, the more he seems barely average.

Feck, Hudds finished 4th in that season, with a NEGATIVE goal difference! They only scored 56 in 46 games, but conceded 58... How do you even do that in the Chump? (Wigan finished 23rd that season and still had a better defence than Hudds did!)... That doesn't bode particularly well with how leaky and mistake riddled our defence can be.

Correct. You make your own luck but that is one jammy promotion. 

Tbf, he did well keeping them up the season after but when the momentum and buzz wore off, they were awful the season after and relegated as one of the poorest teams of the past 10 years in the PL.

He then took Schalke on the clubs worst ever winless run before being sacked before they were eventually relegated. 

An utterly depressing appointment.

You do not fluke promotion based on 46 games, and the fact Wigan had a better defence but managed to to get relegated whilst Hudds got promoted suggested that Hudds got the balance a little better.

Prior to that run they’d been pushing for the champs league and still finished mid tabke… a completely muddled January window, boardroom interference and massive overhauls behind the scenes managed to fuck us everything possible at Schalke.

You’re right. You can’t fluke promotion based on 46 games but they certainly got lucky. Scoring the amount of goals that would normally equate to a lower mid table position finish, not scoring in 3 play off games but still winning them at least tells you about the style of play the took on under him.

There may have been other factors at play during his time at Schalke, but he’s still responsible for their worst winless run in history. A good manager can put aside off field antics and get his team focused on the field.

Absolutely nothing about his last 3 years in management should even lead us to consider interviewing him, let alone giving him the job.


RE: Wagner......no.....no....no - MassDebater - 06-08-2021

(06-08-2021, 11:19 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(06-08-2021, 11:14 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(06-08-2021, 11:11 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Jesus, he didn't win a single game during the Play Offs that got Hudds up either. they drew them all and won 2 on penalties... I'm trying to find positives, but the more you look, the more he seems barely average.

Feck, Hudds finished 4th in that season, with a NEGATIVE goal difference! They only scored 56 in 46 games, but conceded 58... How do you even do that in the Chump? (Wigan finished 23rd that season and still had a better defence than Hudds did!)... That doesn't bode particularly well with how leaky and mistake riddled our defence can be.

Correct. You make your own luck but that is one jammy promotion. 

Tbf, he did well keeping them up the season after but when the momentum and buzz wore off, they were awful the season after and relegated as one of the poorest teams of the past 10 years in the PL.

He then took Schalke on the clubs worst ever winless run before being sacked before they were eventually relegated. 

An utterly depressing appointment.

You do not fluke promotion based on 46 games, and the fact Wigan had a better defence but managed to to get relegated whilst Hudds got promoted suggested that Hudds got the balance a little better.

Prior to that run they’d been pushing for the champs league and still finished mid tabke… a completely muddled January window, boardroom interference and massive overhauls behind the scenes managed to fuck us everything possible at Schalke.

Some on here still claim Slav fluked getting us up... I'd hazard a guess that no other team has scored so few and conceded so many and got promotion as Hudds did. I might be wrong...OK Seals did concede more than 58, they let in 61, but they scored 81...palace in 2013 conceded 62, but scored 73...Blackpool in 2009 conceded 59, but scored 74...I got bored at that point, in short I can't find another club that got promotion with a negative GD, so as far as flukey promotions go Wagner's has to be the front runner?

Still, here's hoping that he has a blinder with us, and that we ride with the Valkyries, rather than dropping with the pigeons.


RE: Wagner......no.....no....no - Rustynail - 06-09-2021

This has to be a wind up ... someone tell me it's another of FF's jokes ... please

If it is true then there are going to be some toys leaving the prams in the boardroom I would have thought, what is the point of the directors carrying out interviews, recommending the appointment to watch the owner ignore them and make his own choice.


RE: Wagner......no.....no....no - baggie_ray - 06-09-2021

Rustynail Wrote:This has to be a wind up ... someone tell me it's another of FF's jokes ... please

If it is true then there are going to be some toys leaving the prams in the boardroom I would have thought, what is the point of the directors carrying out interviews, recommending the appointment to watch the owner ignore them and make his own choice.

The manager will be the most important position in the club so it shouldn't surprise people that Lai would have the final say on who is appointed.

The point of the directors will be to do the due diligence and present Lai with the options, both good and bad points, with a recommendation as to who they think is the best candidate, and how strongly they feel about that recommendation.

The puzzling part is where Lai would go against that recommendation in view of the fact that, as many believe, he knows fuck all as to what a football club manager is all about.

Perhaps he just thought that Wilder wouldn't be a good fit but couldn't base that on anything but a gut feeling. People have been known to think likewise...  Wink

The directors will do as most employees do, I feel, and that is to grumble then get on with it.