WBAUnofficial
Do you still care about Brexit? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Do you still care about Brexit? (/showthread.php?tid=17289)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: Do you still care about Brexit? - Bortolazzi's Barnet - 05-06-2021

I remember Paddy Ashodwn on TV saying that leavers should not be like the Japanese soldier found in the jungle in 1974 still fighting WWII.

Yet we've had 5 years of it from some remainers.

Even now, they keep on.


RE: Do you still care about Brexit? - baggy1 - 05-06-2021

(05-06-2021, 11:12 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 10:54 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: It seems to me that the only people still wound up by Brexit are ardent Remainers who will never find anything else in their life to be so enthralled about.

Edited for you

Strangely it really is the opposite, it is a fuck up and will get worse over time but the drip drip of it won't be noticed and covid is masking the main problems. To paraphrase, "you won, get over it"

(05-06-2021, 10:43 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Here we go. So easy to dismantle these additional remain lies.

1. Easiest trade deal ih history. Firstly, this was after the referendum on Summer 2017 so how could it have influenced the referendum? Fox actually said that whilet the deal SHOULD be the easiest in history, the reality may well be different: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2017/jul/20/liam-fox-uk-eu-trade-deal-after-brexit-easiest-human-history

2. Control our borders? Well, we could only refuse entry to EU nationals if they posed an imminent risk to public health, public security or public morals, in accordance with Art 27 of Dir 2004/38. Note that Art 27(2) stipulates that a criminal record is not such a reason. Also note the restrictions on expulsion in Art 28, as well. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A32004L0038

Not really control, that, is it mate?

3. As for 'forms', again, this was post-referendum so had no effect on the result. I also don't think it was a lie, more a naively optimitsic prediction that should never have been made

4. The border in the Irish Sea was again post-referendum and is there at the insistence of the EU. I shiuld also remind you that Barnier said openly that the issue of Ireland should be leveraged and exploited

5. No freedom of movement - I have no idea what this is supposed to refer to

Be great to see you condemn the remain lies though instead of whataboutery.

Now,

So basically you are saying that there was no actual plan just a vague idea of leaving the EU which can't be shown to be a lie because there was no detail before the referendum. You forget that once we realised all the issues post referendum and there was an opportunity to articulate that to the electorate for their informed decision the Brexiteers moved heaven and hell to make sure that didn't happen.

No whataboutery there "mate"


RE: Do you still care about Brexit? - Borin' Baggie - 05-06-2021

No, I'm pissed off that remaining in the single market (even on a temporary basis, as per "Flexcit") was never made an option by the government and that we left Erasmus and EASA for some dumb reason despite membership of both being completely independent of the EU.


RE: Do you still care about Brexit? - Bortolazzi's Barnet - 05-06-2021

(05-06-2021, 11:36 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 11:12 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 10:54 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: It seems to me that the only people still wound up by Brexit are ardent Remainers who will never find anything else in their life to be so enthralled about.

Edited for you

Strangely it really is the opposite, it is a fuck up and will get worse over time but the drip drip of it won't be noticed and covid is masking the main problems. To paraphrase, "you won, get over it"

(05-06-2021, 10:43 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Here we go. So easy to dismantle these additional remain lies.

1. Easiest trade deal ih history. Firstly, this was after the referendum on Summer 2017 so how could it have influenced the referendum? Fox actually said that whilet the deal SHOULD be the easiest in history, the reality may well be different: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2017/jul/20/liam-fox-uk-eu-trade-deal-after-brexit-easiest-human-history

2. Control our borders? Well, we could only refuse entry to EU nationals if they posed an imminent risk to public health, public security or public morals, in accordance with Art 27 of Dir 2004/38. Note that Art 27(2) stipulates that a criminal record is not such a reason. Also note the restrictions on expulsion in Art 28, as well. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A32004L0038

Not really control, that, is it mate?

3. As for 'forms', again, this was post-referendum so had no effect on the result. I also don't think it was a lie, more a naively optimitsic prediction that should never have been made

4. The border in the Irish Sea was again post-referendum and is there at the insistence of the EU. I shiuld also remind you that Barnier said openly that the issue of Ireland should be leveraged and exploited

5. No freedom of movement - I have no idea what this is supposed to refer to

Be great to see you condemn the remain lies though instead of whataboutery.

Now,

So basically you are saying that there was no actual plan just a vague idea of leaving the EU which can't be shown to be a lie because there was no detail before the referendum. You forget that once we realised all the issues post referendum and there was an opportunity to articulate that to the electorate for their informed decision the Brexiteers moved heaven and hell to make sure that didn't happen.

No whataboutery there "mate"

I have no idea how you can infer from anything that I said that there was no 'plan'.

If there was a plan and it turned out not to transpire, that doesn't make it a lie, does it? I imagine we planned to stay up this year. We haven't. Does that mean theplan to stay up was therefore a lie?

Call it naive, over-optimistic, whatever. But not a lie, no.

Abd there was whataboutery. A poster mentioned 'project fear' in relation to the deleterous consequences which are accruing as a result of us leaving. I pointed-out that this is not project fear, which was a term used for the demonstrable lies from remain, not every prediction they made.

Another poster then said "What about the leave lies?" (in effect). Sounds like whataboutery to me.

(05-06-2021, 11:42 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, I'm pissed off that remaining in the single market (even on a temporary basis, as per "Flexcit") was never made an option by the government and that we left Erasmus and EASA for some dumb reason despite membership of both being completely independent of the EU.

How do you know that the EU was prepared for us to remain a part of them, though?

Staying in the Single Market was also not compatible with the result. It was made clear that we would leave as you can see here from leave leaders and the PM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aUI5A1Gd5D0 and the PM here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zNnh-KhiLm0

You can also see from the poster below that Stronger In accepted leaving the Single Market as the leave position - and lied that leaving it would mean no access (we have access and even if we left with no deal we'd still have had access to SM member states, what would differ is the terms - as Stronger In's own James McGrory says at 5mins 16 in this clip https://youtube.com/watch?v=UHzmCH).

Don't bother citing the remain favourites of Paterson (he was dishonestly edited), Farage (he spoke in 2009 and was dishonestly edited) and Hanan (he was speaking in 2015 and by 2016 was on the Board of Vote Leave, which advocated leaving the SM). The first 2 here are debunked in that last video clip: https://youtube.com/watch?v=UHzmCH.


RE: Do you still care about Brexit? - baggy1 - 05-06-2021

Our mistake, it must be a raging success then.


RE: Do you still care about Brexit? - Borin' Baggie - 05-06-2021

(05-06-2021, 10:43 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Here we go. So easy to dismantle these additional remain lies.

1. Easiest trade deal ih history. Firstly, this was after the referendum on Summer 2017 so how could it have influenced the referendum? Fox actually said that whilet the deal SHOULD be the easiest in history, the reality may well be different: https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2017/jul/20/liam-fox-uk-eu-trade-deal-after-brexit-easiest-human-history

2. Control our borders? Well, we could only refuse entry to EU nationals if they posed an imminent risk to public health, public security or public morals, in accordance with Art 27 of Dir 2004/38. Note that Art 27(2) stipulates that a criminal record is not such a reason. Also note the restrictions on expulsion in Art 28, as well. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A32004L0038

Not really control, that, is it mate?

3. As for 'forms', again, this was post-referendum so had no effect on the result. I also don't think it was a lie, more a naively optimitsic prediction that should never have been made

4. The border in the Irish Sea was again post-referendum and is there at the insistence of the EU. I shiuld also remind you that Barnier said openly that the issue of Ireland should be leveraged and exploited

5. No freedom of movement - I have no idea what this is supposed to refer to

Be great to see you condemn the remain lies though instead of whataboutery.

Now,

Point two, this only applies for a 3 month period. After the fact it's within the domain of the member state as per self sufficiency or exemptions for things like students or specialist healthcare. Further restrictions on entry are given through the UK never being part of Schengen. The only member state under UK law that we could not apply these restrictions to is Ireland.

Point three, it was a lie. There is no reality where leaving the customs union would ever in any conceivable possibility not lead to more red tape, any suggestion otherwise is a lie either through ignorance or malice. Neither is a valid excuse.

Point four, the issue over the Irish border was made clear well before the referendum. The sea border was implemented at the insistence of the EU due to the UK having no viable solution to a paradox that the UK itself had created as the only internal EU solution would require Ireland leaving the EU which is a non-starter.

Point five, relates to point two and the UK opting unilaterally not to apply allowable restrictions within the legislation coupled with extra freedoms from not being within Schengen.


RE: Do you still care about Brexit? - Shabby Russian - 05-06-2021

(05-06-2021, 11:12 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 10:54 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: It seems to me that the only people still wound up by Brexit are ardent Remainers who will never find anything else in their life to be so enthralled about.

Edited for you

I like the selective quoting. That I specifically wrote I wouldn't  campaign to re join the EU was missed. Presumably because it undermined the point you wanted to make.


RE: Do you still care about Brexit? - Borin' Baggie - 05-06-2021

(05-06-2021, 11:56 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 11:42 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, I'm pissed off that remaining in the single market (even on a temporary basis, as per "Flexcit") was never made an option by the government and that we left Erasmus and EASA for some dumb reason despite membership of both being completely independent of the EU.

How do you know that the EU was prepared for us to remain a part of them, though?

Staying in the Single Market was also not compatible with the result. It was made clear that we would leave as you can see here from leave leaders and the PM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aUI5A1Gd5D0 and the PM here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zNnh-KhiLm0

You can also see from the poster below that Stronger In accepted leaving the Single Market as the leave position - and lied that leaving it would mean no access (we have access and even if we left with no deal we'd still have had access to SM member states, what would differ is the terms - as Stronger In's own James McGrory says at 5mins 16 in this clip https://youtube.com/watch?v=UHzmCH).

Don't bother citing the remain favourites of Paterson (he was dishonestly edited), Farage (he spoke in 2009 and was dishonestly edited) and Hanan (he was speaking in 2015 and by 2016 was on the Board of Vote Leave, which advocated leaving the SM). The first 2 here are debunked in that last video clip: https://youtube.com/watch?v=UHzmCH.

First point, why the hell would the EU want us to leave the single market? It's so much easier for them as it is us. Second point, the EU would have an extremely limited scope to prevent us from remaining with it as we had to notify leaving the single market in a separate, unrelated process to Article 50.

And I don't care what the campaigners say, the referendum was a vote on membership of the EU and that's it. Single market membership, extent of treaty participation, joint cooperation agreements etc weren't under scrutiny and weren't on the ballot. This doesn't apply to single market membership in any way, and I don't care about what anybody in any campaign says or said. The same applies to every other referendum. The AV referendum was about implementing AV not a choice between maternity services/bulletproof vests as the no campaign said nor a proportional system as the yes campaign said. The same can be extrapolated to the last Scottish independence referendum where the reality of the yes campaign's economic development has crumbled with the collapse of oil and the no campaign said that it was the only way Scotland would remain an EU member and Devo max would be implemented with the former not being true and the latter the Tories blocked in 2016. Do you want to my carry on? I've got more, the North East parliament referendum, the London mayoralty referendum, the Scottish parliament referendum in the 1970s. Hell, Cameron said he'd activate Article 50 immediately and then fucked off whistling. The fundamental core of referenda in this country is the only thing up for debate is written on the ballot, we are not Switzerland.

The fact is that membership of the single market is an entirely and solely independent issue and not pursuing it as an avenue to meet the promises of the referendum in relation to free trade or as a temporary transitional arrangement to allow the private sector to adapt was a dumb idea. As is leaving EASA, Erasmus and Europol.


RE: Do you still care about Brexit? - Bortolazzi's Barnet - 05-06-2021

(05-06-2021, 12:36 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 11:56 AM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote:
(05-06-2021, 11:42 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, I'm pissed off that remaining in the single market (even on a temporary basis, as per "Flexcit") was never made an option by the government and that we left Erasmus and EASA for some dumb reason despite membership of both being completely independent of the EU.

How do you know that the EU was prepared for us to remain a part of them, though?

Staying in the Single Market was also not compatible with the result. It was made clear that we would leave as you can see here from leave leaders and the PM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aUI5A1Gd5D0 and the PM here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zNnh-KhiLm0

You can also see from the poster below that Stronger In accepted leaving the Single Market as the leave position - and lied that leaving it would mean no access (we have access and even if we left with no deal we'd still have had access to SM member states, what would differ is the terms - as Stronger In's own James McGrory says at 5mins 16 in this clip https://youtube.com/watch?v=UHzmCH).

Don't bother citing the remain favourites of Paterson (he was dishonestly edited), Farage (he spoke in 2009 and was dishonestly edited) and Hanan (he was speaking in 2015 and by 2016 was on the Board of Vote Leave, which advocated leaving the SM). The first 2 here are debunked in that last video clip: https://youtube.com/watch?v=UHzmCH.

First point, why the hell would the EU want us to leave the single market? It's so much easier for them as it is us. Second point, the EU would have an extremely limited scope to prevent us from remaining with it as we had to notify leaving the single market in a separate, unrelated process to Article 50.

And I don't care what the campaigners say, the referendum was a vote on membership of the EU and that's it. Single market membership, extent of treaty participation, joint cooperation agreements etc weren't under scrutiny and weren't on the ballot. This doesn't apply to single market membership in any way, and I don't care about what anybody in any campaign says or said. The same applies to every other referendum. The AV referendum was about implementing AV not a choice between maternity services/bulletproof vests as the no campaign said nor a proportional system as the yes campaign said. The same can be extrapolated to the last Scottish independence referendum where the reality of the yes campaign's economic development has crumbled with the collapse of oil and the no campaign said that it was the only way Scotland would remain an EU member and Devo max would be implemented with the former not being true and the latter the Tories blocked in 2016. Do you want to my carry on? I've got more, the North East parliament referendum, the London mayoralty referendum, the Scottish parliament referendum in the 1970s. Hell, Cameron said he'd activate Article 50 immediately and then fucked off whistling. The fundamental core of referenda in this country is the only thing up for debate is written on the ballot, we are not Switzerland.

The fact is that membership of the single market is an entirely and solely independent issue and not pursuing it as an avenue to meet the promises of the referendum in relation to free trade or as a temporary transitional arrangement to allow the private sector to adapt was a dumb idea. As is leaving EASA, Erasmus and Europol.

I meant would allow us to stay in Ersamus. Don't know if the EU might have been open to us staying in the SM. Maybe Barnier's book published today will shed light.

So on your logic a vote to remain in the EU was not a vote to stay in the customs union, Euratom, etc, then. Only to stay a signatory to the Maastricht Treaty which gave rise to the EU.

That's crazy.

Whilst in strict legal terms the EU is the organisation formed by Maastricht it's really an umbrella term for a collection of Treaties and organisations. The Single Market has also been the centrepiece of what became the EC and EU since 1986. It would be an odd vote to leave that left that unaffected. And with This is the case even though I am aware that non-EU states are members of the SM. It's worth pointing-out that EFTA/EEA are seen as transitory stages towards EU membership, however.

Why is it only remainers who try to tell leavers that we didn't vote to leave the Single Market, never any leaver saying, "Hang on, I didn't vote for that"?


RE: Do you still care about Brexit? - baggy1 - 05-06-2021

(05-06-2021, 01:12 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Why is it only remainers who try to tell leavers that we didn't vote to leave the Single Market, never any leaver saying, "Hang on, I didn't vote for that"?

You mean all of the leave voters knew what they were voting for, fucking hell priceless. For a leaver to say that it would be an admission that they didn't know what they voted for and that's about as likely as us staying up this year.

Do you think the fishermen voted to be in their current position - I will guarantee they are currently saying "Hang on, I didn't vote for that".