WBAUnofficial
This 'ere outstanding loan - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: This 'ere outstanding loan (/showthread.php?tid=15136)

Pages: 1 2


RE: This 'ere outstanding loan - Fulham Fallout - 01-25-2021

(01-25-2021, 09:21 AM)halasbaggie Wrote:
(01-24-2021, 08:19 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Who is the ultimate parent of the football club?

Holdings is a limited company. There is absolutely no recourse to its shareholders.

The ultimate parent is WBA Group -  Lai [WBA holdings] are not sole owners, they have a 87.8% share .   Therefore the loan has to repaid by WBA Holdings to WBA Group .
There are two choices  - either pay a dividend to shareholders in WBA group   which will cost  Lai 12.2%  of  £4.7 million+  to minority shareholders  and clear the debt to WBA holdings or , as most minority shareholders wish , pay it back in total so the football club can use it in the transfer market.

Or the third choice, don’t pay it back as there is no date for the repayment to be made and therefore recovering the debt is not possible and that’s the most inevitable situation. Peace should have repaid that back before he sold up so it came out of his pocket as he was the one who took out the loan.


RE: This 'ere outstanding loan - Juan Quidonqui - 01-25-2021

(01-25-2021, 09:21 AM)halasbaggie Wrote:
(01-24-2021, 08:19 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Who is the ultimate parent of the football club?

Holdings is a limited company. There is absolutely no recourse to its shareholders.

The ultimate parent is WBA Group -  Lai [WBA holdings] are not sole owners, they have a 87.8% share .   Therefore the loan has to repaid by WBA Holdings to WBA Group .
There are two choices  - either pay a dividend to shareholders in WBA group   which will cost  Lai 12.2%  of  £4.7 million+  to minority shareholders  and clear the debt to WBA holdings or , as most minority shareholders wish , pay it back in total so the football club can use it in the transfer market.
Isn’t there a third option though? As there is presumably no repayment date for the loan and Lai is actively trying to sell (WBA Holdings), he can take the ‘do fuck all’ option until such time as he sells WBA Holdings - and then it becomes someone else’s problem. 
If I was in Lai’s size 4 shoes I know what option I’d be taking.


RE: This 'ere outstanding loan - Kit Kat Chunky - 01-25-2021

(01-25-2021, 09:21 AM)halasbaggie Wrote:
(01-24-2021, 08:19 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Who is the ultimate parent of the football club?

Holdings is a limited company. There is absolutely no recourse to its shareholders.

The ultimate parent is WBA Group -  Lai [WBA holdings] are not sole owners, they have a 87.8% share .   Therefore the loan has to repaid by WBA Holdings to WBA Group .
There are two choices  - either pay a dividend to shareholders in WBA group   which will cost  Lai 12.2%  of  £4.7 million+  to minority shareholders  and clear the debt to WBA holdings or , as most minority shareholders wish , pay it back in total so the football club can use it in the transfer market.

Do you understand the concept of Limited Liability? 

Holdings is a limited company. A proportion of the shares in Holdings were sold from one entity to another. A shareholders liability for any of the company's obligations is limited to the amount they have invested in share capital, no more.

A divivdend cannot be paid, because there is not enough distributable reserves within holdings to pay the dividend you suggest. 

You keep saying "will cost Lai". Lai has no responsibility for the obligations of Holdings whatsoever.

I'm not going any further with this with you. You don't understand the mechanics of Limited liability, and corporate ownership. Holdings owes a subsidiary some money. If it pays this loan, it simply transfers monies from one of it's companies to another. Lai or no other shareholders have any responsibility for the debt of a separate limited liability entity unless they have personally guaranteed the debt.


RE: This 'ere outstanding loan - halasbaggie - 01-25-2021

(01-25-2021, 09:52 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-25-2021, 09:21 AM)halasbaggie Wrote:
(01-24-2021, 08:19 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Who is the ultimate parent of the football club?

Holdings is a limited company. There is absolutely no recourse to its shareholders.

The ultimate parent is WBA Group -  Lai [WBA holdings] are not sole owners, they have a 87.8% share .   Therefore the loan has to repaid by WBA Holdings to WBA Group .
There are two choices  - either pay a dividend to shareholders in WBA group   which will cost  Lai 12.2%  of  £4.7 million+  to minority shareholders  and clear the debt to WBA holdings or , as most minority shareholders wish , pay it back in total so the football club can use it in the transfer market.

Do you understand the concept of Limited Liability? 

Holdings is a limited company. A proportion of the shares in Holdings were sold from one entity to another. A shareholders liability for any of the company's obligations is limited to the amount they have invested in share capital, no more.

A divivdend cannot be paid, because there is not enough distributable reserves within holdings to pay the dividend you suggest. 

You keep saying "will cost Lai". Lai has no responsibility for the obligations of Holdings whatsoever.

I'm not going any further with this with you. You don't understand the mechanics of Limited liability, and corporate ownership. Holdings owes a subsidiary some money. If it pays this loan, it simply transfers monies from one of it's companies to another. Lai or no other shareholders have any responsibility for the debt of a separate limited liability entity unless they have personally guaranteed the debt.

WBA Holdings have no subsidiaries, the "only assets" they have is a share of WBA Group.


RE: This 'ere outstanding loan - Stourbridge Baggie - 01-25-2021

In reply to Kit Kat, Obviously the right answer. By the way I'm a minority shareholder and nobody asked me what I want. This is a red herring, in my view stirred up by individuals/groups with a not so hidden agenda. Take a bow Mr L.


RE: This 'ere outstanding loan - Kit Kat Chunky - 01-25-2021

(01-25-2021, 10:48 AM)halasbaggie Wrote:
(01-25-2021, 09:52 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-25-2021, 09:21 AM)halasbaggie Wrote:
(01-24-2021, 08:19 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Who is the ultimate parent of the football club?

Holdings is a limited company. There is absolutely no recourse to its shareholders.

The ultimate parent is WBA Group -  Lai [WBA holdings] are not sole owners, they have a 87.8% share .   Therefore the loan has to repaid by WBA Holdings to WBA Group .
There are two choices  - either pay a dividend to shareholders in WBA group   which will cost  Lai 12.2%  of  £4.7 million+  to minority shareholders  and clear the debt to WBA holdings or , as most minority shareholders wish , pay it back in total so the football club can use it in the transfer market.

Do you understand the concept of Limited Liability? 

Holdings is a limited company. A proportion of the shares in Holdings were sold from one entity to another. A shareholders liability for any of the company's obligations is limited to the amount they have invested in share capital, no more.

A divivdend cannot be paid, because there is not enough distributable reserves within holdings to pay the dividend you suggest. 

You keep saying "will cost Lai". Lai has no responsibility for the obligations of Holdings whatsoever.

I'm not going any further with this with you. You don't understand the mechanics of Limited liability, and corporate ownership. Holdings owes a subsidiary some money. If it pays this loan, it simply transfers monies from one of it's companies to another. Lai or no other shareholders have any responsibility for the debt of a separate limited liability entity unless they have personally guaranteed the debt.

WBA Holdings have no subsidiaries, the "only assets" they have is a share of WBA Group.

If you control more than 50% of the issued share capital it is by definition a subsidiary. If you own more than 75% you control the company because the minority shareholders cannot call an Extraordinary General Meeting without the consent of the majority shareholder, West Bromwich Albion Holdings Ltd.


RE: This 'ere outstanding loan - Kit Kat Chunky - 01-25-2021

(01-25-2021, 09:52 AM)Juan Quidonqui Wrote:
(01-25-2021, 09:21 AM)halasbaggie Wrote:
(01-24-2021, 08:19 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Who is the ultimate parent of the football club?

Holdings is a limited company. There is absolutely no recourse to its shareholders.

The ultimate parent is WBA Group -  Lai [WBA holdings] are not sole owners, they have a 87.8% share .   Therefore the loan has to repaid by WBA Holdings to WBA Group .
There are two choices  - either pay a dividend to shareholders in WBA group   which will cost  Lai 12.2%  of  £4.7 million+  to minority shareholders  and clear the debt to WBA holdings or , as most minority shareholders wish , pay it back in total so the football club can use it in the transfer market.
Isn’t there a third option though? As there is presumably no repayment date for the loan and Lai is actively trying to sell (WBA Holdings), he can take the ‘do fuck all’ option until such time as he sells WBA Holdings - and then it becomes someone else’s problem. 
If I was in Lai’s size 4 shoes I know what option I’d be taking.

It's not Lai's problem.

Holdings owes the money to a limited company that it controls.

If Lai sells the club, then the debt will remain, just as it did when Peace sold the club. Just because you buy the shares in a company, you do not become personally liable for its debts. The limited company is a separate legal entity to its owner.


RE: This 'ere outstanding loan - Juan Quidonqui - 01-25-2021

(01-25-2021, 01:56 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-25-2021, 09:52 AM)Juan Quidonqui Wrote:
(01-25-2021, 09:21 AM)halasbaggie Wrote:
(01-24-2021, 08:19 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Who is the ultimate parent of the football club?

Holdings is a limited company. There is absolutely no recourse to its shareholders.

The ultimate parent is WBA Group -  Lai [WBA holdings] are not sole owners, they have a 87.8% share .   Therefore the loan has to repaid by WBA Holdings to WBA Group .
There are two choices  - either pay a dividend to shareholders in WBA group   which will cost  Lai 12.2%  of  £4.7 million+  to minority shareholders  and clear the debt to WBA holdings or , as most minority shareholders wish , pay it back in total so the football club can use it in the transfer market.
Isn’t there a third option though? As there is presumably no repayment date for the loan and Lai is actively trying to sell (WBA Holdings), he can take the ‘do fuck all’ option until such time as he sells WBA Holdings - and then it becomes someone else’s problem. 
If I was in Lai’s size 4 shoes I know what option I’d be taking.

It's not Lai's problem.

Holdings owes the money to a limited company that it controls.

If Lai sells the club, then the debt will remain, just as it did when Peace sold the club. Just because you buy the shares in a company, you do not become personally liable for its debts. The limited company is a separate legal entity to its owner.

Cheers KKC. 
That was kind of what I meant (I think!). 
My point being why would Lai (or anyone else linked to him) put close on £5m into the entity of WBA Holdings, for that entity to simply move those funds over to WBA Group (to repay the loan) when there’s absolutely no obligation for him to do so. As/when he sells the club the loan will remain a liability of WBA Holdings and so whoever acquires WBA Holdings can decide what they do about it. 
I think we’re on the same page KKC - but you just put it much more eloquently than I do.


RE: This 'ere outstanding loan - Kit Kat Chunky - 01-25-2021

(01-25-2021, 02:54 PM)Juan Quidonqui Wrote:
(01-25-2021, 01:56 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-25-2021, 09:52 AM)Juan Quidonqui Wrote:
(01-25-2021, 09:21 AM)halasbaggie Wrote:
(01-24-2021, 08:19 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Who is the ultimate parent of the football club?

Holdings is a limited company. There is absolutely no recourse to its shareholders.

The ultimate parent is WBA Group -  Lai [WBA holdings] are not sole owners, they have a 87.8% share .   Therefore the loan has to repaid by WBA Holdings to WBA Group .
There are two choices  - either pay a dividend to shareholders in WBA group   which will cost  Lai 12.2%  of  £4.7 million+  to minority shareholders  and clear the debt to WBA holdings or , as most minority shareholders wish , pay it back in total so the football club can use it in the transfer market.
Isn’t there a third option though? As there is presumably no repayment date for the loan and Lai is actively trying to sell (WBA Holdings), he can take the ‘do fuck all’ option until such time as he sells WBA Holdings - and then it becomes someone else’s problem. 
If I was in Lai’s size 4 shoes I know what option I’d be taking.

It's not Lai's problem.

Holdings owes the money to a limited company that it controls.

If Lai sells the club, then the debt will remain, just as it did when Peace sold the club. Just because you buy the shares in a company, you do not become personally liable for its debts. The limited company is a separate legal entity to its owner.

Cheers KKC. 
That was kind of what I meant (I think!). 
My point being why would Lai (or anyone else linked to him) put close on £5m into the entity of WBA Holdings, for that entity to simply move those funds over to WBA Group (to repay the loan) when there’s absolutely no obligation for him to do so. As/when he sells the club the loan will remain a liability of WBA Holdings and so whoever acquires WBA Holdings can decide what they do about it. 
I think we’re on the same page KKC - but you just put it much more eloquently than I do.
I wouldn't call it eloquent! But yes, we are both making the same point  Smile