WBAUnofficial
Birmingham Post on tfransfers - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Birmingham Post on tfransfers (/showthread.php?tid=14481)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Birmingham Post on tfransfers - Psalm23 - 12-23-2020

I wouldn't be too worried about the Andy Carroll links, Sam might be a pragmatist with his style of football, but I'm guessing he's inteligent enough, & seen enough of him at West Ham, not to get bitten twice.
If these idiots in the press are gonna be linking every player Sam's ever managed, it's gonna be a long window, & pampers will be in very short supply.


RE: Birmingham Post on tfransfers - Lillwall's left foot - 12-23-2020

As we move to the end of the window the question will not be "are they good enough/fit enough?" to "might they offer more than the players we have?"

You would hope that between them they have a good list of potential targets. But if they are good enough to impact the PL why are they coming to relegation certainties in January?


RE: Birmingham Post on tfransfers - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 12-23-2020

(12-23-2020, 10:18 AM)Psalm23 Wrote: I wouldn't be too worried about the Andy Carroll links, Sam might be a pragmatist with his style of football, but I'm guessing he's inteligent enough, & seen enough of him at West Ham, not to get bitten twice.
If these idiots in the press are gonna be linking every player Sam's ever managed, it's gonna be a long window, & pampers will be in very short supply.

As you say, Psalm, the press will link anybody ever associated with Lardarse. Good God, I think he managed Shamrock Rovers and Notts County in the distant past.


RE: Birmingham Post on tfransfers - MassDebater - 12-23-2020

(12-23-2020, 10:02 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-23-2020, 08:48 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(12-23-2020, 08:43 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Issa Diop on loan plus Andy Carroll on a short term deal wouldn’t be the worst business given our limited finances

Carroll has played a whopping 38 league games in the last 3 seasons...34 in the two seasons before that. And scored 10 goals in those 72 games... Which sounds meh at best, then you look closer and he hasn't scored a league goal in the last 3 seasons, 0 in 38 games... in effect no goals in a whole season. Sounds like we're back to going after non scoring strikers again!

So we could expect/hope for maybe 10 games out of him. and 0 to 1 goal, just what we need

I agree it's not ideal MD, but with the pandemic making overseas acquisitions difficult, and us having little or no money to spend, who else is there? We need a physical presence up top, who wont cost a fee, won't tie us to an expensive long term wage cost, and can add something we don't currently have? 

Ideally we'd be looking abroad for a loan to perm if we survive, but I doubt it's the easiest deal to do under current restrictions. 

Sam knows Carroll and got goals out of him... he also has a track record of getting bursts of goals if you can get consistent games out of him. 

Again, far from my first choice, but much with Sam, we have to take gambles... We're probably on a 3 at the moment, if we roll the dice, we could roll a 6, or we could roll a 1.

Why get Carroll to do the Carroll job when we've already got Charlie Austin? Austin is great at the puffing out of his arse and not scoring whilst occasionally running about a bit job, which is probably a bit more running than we'd get from Carroll. Would rather go for Deeney, and I really don't want Deeney.

As with when Slav was here, we need a midfield boss, a Yacob / Mulumbu / McInnes type and I honestly believe the rest will click into place with that one key player there. Defence gets more protection, midfield gets more balls (literal and figurative) and hopefully the flair get more freedom and the striker gets more service.

I don't think Grant is as shit as he is being made out to be, he's not getting quality service is all, and I think Pereira and Grady would shine again with someone actually doing the graft behind them. Who knows, maybe Field can step up and do it, but I have my doubts.

For me, that's what we've been lacking for months and also lacked last season when things got tough. Could be an age thing, in that most of our good players are young, and there is no clever old head leading them about. Brunt a few years ago would probably have worked wonders. Livermore just doesn't have it in him.


RE: Birmingham Post on tfransfers - Kit Kat Chunky - 12-23-2020

Livermore is the next Jamie O'Hara.