WBAUnofficial
Poor referring or something.. - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Poor referring or something.. (/showthread.php?tid=14073)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Poor referring or something.. - Baggie_Nick - 12-07-2020

(12-07-2020, 09:23 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(12-07-2020, 09:19 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: We had all this in 2002-03 under Megson. A similar feel this season. As a squad not enough quality to compete in the Prem. Constant bizarre decisions by officials going against us.
As I recall the club and ir Megson wrote to the Premier League highlighting the numerous decisions that had gone against us. We ended the season dressed as referees at the end of season party at Blackburn. Giant yellow and red cards dished out to all.

Yeah, but back then the refs correct decisions weren't being told to be reviewed by some faceless wonders...Also, whilst decisions always go against the smaller clubs, we just were totally unprepared for a Premiership season back then too. This time, we were much better prepared and would likely have another 3 - 6 points on the board if it weren't for these 'reviews', ordered from upon high.

Really? Do you think?


RE: Poor referring or something.. - CA Baggie - 12-07-2020

(12-07-2020, 10:40 AM)Baggie_Nick Wrote:
(12-07-2020, 09:23 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(12-07-2020, 09:19 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: We had all this in 2002-03 under Megson. A similar feel this season. As a squad not enough quality to compete in the Prem. Constant bizarre decisions by officials going against us.
As I recall the club and ir Megson wrote to the Premier League highlighting the numerous decisions that had gone against us. We ended the season dressed as referees at the end of season party at Blackburn. Giant yellow and red cards dished out to all.

Yeah, but back then the refs correct decisions weren't being told to be reviewed by some faceless wonders...Also, whilst decisions always go against the smaller clubs, we just were totally unprepared for a Premiership season back then too. This time, we were much better prepared and would likely have another 3 - 6 points on the board if it weren't for these 'reviews', ordered from upon high.

Really? Do you think?

As a club yes, the playing side leaves us a bit short on quality.

The lack of transparency makes me wonder too.  The pictures being looked at should be on the screen, the conversation and reasoning for the VAR should be played to the crowd, look at the way cricket and rugby do it.  Even tennis shows the ball in\out on the screen on a player appeal.

I'm sure the thought process for the incidents against ManU went something like:

Pen to West Brom - VAR start the check for a reason it shouldn't be allowed.

Pen to ManU - Looking for why it should be allowed.  How has the referee on the pitch missed the foul on Gallagher and then upon review we're supposed to believe that VAR didn't wind back to the start of the attack and see it either!

They should come to the same outcome as there's only one right answer, but that thought process is determining what they look at and how. Clear and obvious is deliberately vague and allows leeway. If the ref has seen it and acted on it that should be the end of the matter unless one of the teams wants to appeal it, off the ball incidents should be flagged to the ref for him to review on the screen.

Don't really have a problem with the offside rulings, some sympathy for them actually.  You're either on or off, its a bit like the ball is either over the line or not, yeah it takes a minute or two but is at least consistent.

We found out on day 1 of the PL in 2002 that you do get an even hand with decisions but having video evidence to correct this that isn't being used properly is, in my opinion, more than just poor officiating.


RE: Poor referring or something.. - sickParrot - 12-07-2020

(12-07-2020, 11:21 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: The lack of transparency makes me wonder too. The pictures being looked at should be on the screen, the conversation and reasoning for the VAR should be played to the crowd, look at the way cricket and rugby do it. Even tennis shows the ball in\out on the screen on a player appeal.

I think having the refs and 4th official mic'd up is the only way out of this mess that they have created.


RE: Poor referring or something.. - Borin' Baggie - 12-07-2020

(12-07-2020, 09:23 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(12-07-2020, 09:19 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: We had all this in 2002-03 under Megson. A similar feel this season. As a squad not enough quality to compete in the Prem. Constant bizarre decisions by officials going against us.
As I recall the club and ir Megson wrote to the Premier League highlighting the numerous decisions that had gone against us. We ended the season dressed as referees at the end of season party at Blackburn. Giant yellow and red cards dished out to all.

Yeah, but back then the refs correct decisions weren't being told to be reviewed by some faceless wonders...Also, whilst decisions always go against the smaller clubs, we just were totally unprepared for a Premiership season back then too. This time, we were much better prepared and would likely have another 3 - 6 points on the board if it weren't for these 'reviews', ordered from upon high.

2 points from Chelsea as their second goal should not have stood

At least 1 from United, probably 3 as we should have had a pen and they shouldn't have

Maybe 1 from Everton, potentially 3 as their equaliser came from a penalty where Furlong was fouled

Maybe 1 yesterday, potentially 3 as Pereira was given a very harsh red card while we were on top and Ivanovic getting taken out by Guita wasn't a foul for some bizarre reason.

5-7 points, rising to 11 by my maths. That is a lot of points.