WBAUnofficial
For so many reasons VAR is not working - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: For so many reasons VAR is not working (/showthread.php?tid=13833)

Pages: 1 2


RE: For so many reasons VAR is not working - SW4Baggie - 11-23-2020

I’ve been a backer of VAR from the start, and still do back the concept, but how it’s currently manifesting itself is indefensible.

There is too much money at stake at the top level to accept the level of human error that exists, and there is enough technology available to minimise its impact.

The problem for me is the interpretation of “clear and obvious” error... an “offside” goal being wrongly judged onside due to an armpit is not clear and obvious. The referee giving our pen and missing theirs originally’ the weekend were not clear and obvious.

In reality there’s probably only 1 or 2 clear and obvious errors across all 10 games each weekend, but the fact we seem desperate to make use of the technology is counter productive to its effectiveness.

It’s the same reason I’m against giving captains the right to review. It will just cause more chaos and interrupt the flow of the game, and lead to players feeling they can question the ref’s authority. What we need is a far clearer interpretation of what constitutes clear and obvious.

Give the team in Stockley Park 1 replay, and all 3 members of the team must agree the decision needs review, and only then should the referee on the field be informed.


RE: For so many reasons VAR is not working - Peachy - 11-23-2020

(11-23-2020, 11:42 AM)steviedm Wrote: I have been loud and vocal about my hatred of VAR from the moment it was introduced - unlike others on here, I may add, who have staunchly defended it when it's been discussed previously.

My view has always been that the excitement of football is about the instant celebration of a goal, penalty award or save etc. The ball goes in, you have a quick look at the ref to see if he's pointing to the centre circle, glance at the lino to see his flag isn't up and then go mental. VAR has taken all of that away. If it's aim is to remove subjectivity, it's had the opposite effect so it's lose, lose all round.

Our penalty on Saturday is a good example of why the system is an utter failure. Like others, I'm not 100% convinced it was one but giving it was fair enough in the circumstances and certainly not a clear and obvious error. I'd be disappointed if we gave one away like that, but wouldn't complain too much. To overturn it is 100% a subjective decision forced on the referee by someone else being subjective after looking at some inconclusive replays. How does this help?

VAR is a blight on football and will ruin the game. Referees make mistakes but make decisions they believe to be right at the time. This is how it's always been. It doesn't even itself over the season, but that's OK. That's football. That's the game we love. It's clinical, cynical and removes every ounce of joy I get out of the game.

I was desperate for us to get promoted and, as soon as we did, I cancelled Sky Sports and BT Sport as I knew that entering the world of VAR would wind me up to the extent I'd become someone I don't want to be. I therefore I didn't watch the footage of our game until Sunday, calmly and rationally.  I was following the game on Saturday, but watching it would have sent me apoplectic.

Great Post. 

I said right from the start all football needed was goal line technology. After all that is the most important function of any game. The injustice if you'd actually scored and it wasn't seen. 

Everything else was fine. Marginal penalty decisions and offsides were fine by me.they are always going to happen. We are getting the wrong decisions now even with VAR so I see absolutely no reason to keep it. The handball situation now is an absolute farce. What was ever wrong by a deliberate handball? Now some guy in stocky Park slows down the footage to a millisecond and deems it a penalty when in reality that ball was hit at 90 miles an hour from 2 feet away!!! 

The games gone Tom...... 

Bar one incident (which ironically and oh so typically kept Villa up) Hawkeye has been great. No grey areas. Nothing open to interpretation.

Go back to how it was because I really am fast falling out of love with the beautiful game.....


RE: For so many reasons VAR is not working - Hopalong - 11-23-2020

(11-23-2020, 10:37 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Because as with all technology, it is only as good as the humans operating and overseeing it, and the FA and PGMOL are inherently biased and corrupt.

You do wonder whether had VAR been around 4 years ago whether Leicester would have won the league.


RE: For so many reasons VAR is not working - TETLEY74 - 11-23-2020

(11-23-2020, 02:20 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(11-23-2020, 10:37 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Because as with all technology, it is only as good as the humans operating and overseeing it, and the FA and PGMOL are inherently biased and corrupt.

You do wonder whether had VAR been around 4 years ago whether Leicester would have won the league.

We all know the answer to tha not a cat in hells chance, var is here to make sure no one outside of the big 6 will ever challenge their monoply of winning trophies, the Asian markets etc pay to see these big clubs win things not the likes of Leicester or us, football is corrupt end of.


RE: For so many reasons VAR is not working - Remi_Moses - 11-23-2020

Absolutely nothing wrong with VAR at all, it's the corrupt operators that's the problem.


RE: For so many reasons VAR is not working - Everything Zin - 11-23-2020

It was supposed to remove subjectivity - it hasn’t. One of my major gripes is who decides what to review - eg on Saturday, was the pull back on Grant reviewed? Was the foul in the build up to their penalty? I’m sure the answer in both cases was no (despite what Slav was allegedly told). Would they have been reviewed if they had been in Utd’s favour? Hmmm.
Our penalty review was correct - it was clearly and obviously not in the Premier Leagues interest for a penalty to be given to us, so correctly overturned. We also Moab about the inconsistency of referees- well nobody could claim that Coote wasn’t consistent in giving Utd every possible advantage.


RE: For so many reasons VAR is not working - Dreamkiller - 11-23-2020

If there was a nice trade-off between losing that instantaneous feeling of joy at scoring a goal and never again feeling that you’d been robbed, I’d still on balance be against VAR because that instantaneous feeling is one of the most exhilarating, life affirming feelings known to the average football fan. Stoke have skilfully avoided being a victim of this system, so I don’t know how much that instantaneous feeling has actually been lost, but it looks terminal to me

Your match the other night, and far too many other matches involving just about every team, shows that the feeling you’ve been robbed hasn’t been remotely removed, and if anything has been made far worse in sheer frustration that it’s such a shit system being administered by the same one-eyed buffoons as before. 

It’s an absolute abomination.


RE: For so many reasons VAR is not working - Tom Joad - 11-23-2020

Dreamkiller Wrote:If there was a nice trade-off between losing that instantaneous feeling of joy at scoring a goal and never again feeling that you’d been robbed, I’d still on balance be against VAR because that instantaneous feeling is one of the most exhilarating, life affirming feelings known to the average football fan. Stoke have skilfully avoided being a victim of this system, so I don’t know how much that instantaneous feeling has actually been lost, but it looks terminal to me

Your match the other night, and far too many other matches involving just about every team, shows that the feeling you’ve been robbed hasn’t been remotely removed, and if anything has been made far worse in sheer frustration that it’s such a shit system being administered by the same one-eyed buffoons as before. 

It’s an absolute abomination.
Is right DK. Actually I noticed your reply on Saturday re the controversial decisions. (Brave of you!!!). My intended point wasn't to disagree with your opinion but to say, 1/ the Albion non pen, 2/ The foul just prior to the Man U pen,  3/The Furlong handball, 4/ The penalty save, 5/ The alleged penalty area encroachment for the retake. All were debateable decisions but in the space of 10 minutes,  all  5 went the way of Man Utd. VAR is clearly (possibly even unconsciously) biased against certain clubs. Oddly enough, The Dings have suffered more than most with VAR.


RE: For so many reasons VAR is not working - Dreamkiller - 11-23-2020

(11-23-2020, 07:42 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Dreamkiller Wrote:If there was a nice trade-off between losing that instantaneous feeling of joy at scoring a goal and never again feeling that you’d been robbed, I’d still on balance be against VAR because that instantaneous feeling is one of the most exhilarating, life affirming feelings known to the average football fan. Stoke have skilfully avoided being a victim of this system, so I don’t know how much that instantaneous feeling has actually been lost, but it looks terminal to me

Your match the other night, and far too many other matches involving just about every team, shows that the feeling you’ve been robbed hasn’t been remotely removed, and if anything has been made far worse in sheer frustration that it’s such a shit system being administered by the same one-eyed buffoons as before. 

It’s an absolute abomination.
Is right DK. Actually I noticed your reply on Saturday re the controversial decisions. (Brave of you!!!).  My intended point wasn't to disagree with your opinion but to say, 1/ the Albion non pen, 2/ The foul just prior to the Man U pen,  3/The Furlong handball, 4/ The penalty save, 5/ The alleged penalty area encroachment for the retake. All were debateable decisions but in the space of 10 minutes,  all  5 went the way of Man Utd.  VAR is clearly (possibly even unconsciously) biased against certain clubs. Oddly enough, The Dings have suffered more than most with VAR.

Haha, yeah, it was either brave or reckless of me, though to be honest if I’d seen how others had fared for voicing the same opinions, I think I’d have given the subject a miss.  Big Grin

I kind of revised my opinions later anyway, partly based on other incidents in the build up etc, so I’m not sure if you saw those posts. I did actually say something along the lines that had the incidents been reversed, ie, you just swapped the colour of the shirts for each incident, then it’s debatable whether the decisions would have gone the same way. 

As far as I’m concerned, the same biases are still there. If Twatkinson was in charge of the VAR for a Stoke match, and I had the good fortune to be in the ground to see it, I wouldn’t feel safe enough to celebrate a winning goal until I’d got home and checked the results.


RE: For so many reasons VAR is not working - Tom Joad - 11-23-2020

Dreamkiller Wrote:
Tom Joad Wrote:
Dreamkiller Wrote:If there was a nice trade-off between losing that instantaneous feeling of joy at scoring a goal and never again feeling that you’d been robbed, I’d still on balance be against VAR because that instantaneous feeling is one of the most exhilarating, life affirming feelings known to the average football fan. Stoke have skilfully avoided being a victim of this system, so I don’t know how much that instantaneous feeling has actually been lost, but it looks terminal to me

Your match the other night, and far too many other matches involving just about every team, shows that the feeling you’ve been robbed hasn’t been remotely removed, and if anything has been made far worse in sheer frustration that it’s such a shit system being administered by the same one-eyed buffoons as before. 

It’s an absolute abomination.
Is right DK. Actually I noticed your reply on Saturday re the controversial decisions. (Brave of you!!!).  My intended point wasn't to disagree with your opinion but to say, 1/ the Albion non pen, 2/ The foul just prior to the Man U pen,  3/The Furlong handball, 4/ The penalty save, 5/ The alleged penalty area encroachment for the retake. All were debateable decisions but in the space of 10 minutes,  all  5 went the way of Man Utd.  VAR is clearly (possibly even unconsciously) biased against certain clubs. Oddly enough, The Dings have suffered more than most with VAR.

Haha, yeah, it was either brave or reckless of me, though to be honest if I’d seen how others had fared for voicing the same opinions, I think I’d have given the subject a miss.  Big Grin

I kind of revised my opinions later anyway, partly based on other incidents in the build up etc, so I’m not sure if you saw those posts. I did actually say something along the lines that had the incidents been reversed, ie, you just swapped the colour of the shirts for each incident, then it’s debatable whether the decisions would have gone the same way. 

As far as I’m concerned, the same biases are still there. If Twatkinson was in charge of the VAR for a Stoke match, and I had the good fortune to be in the ground to see it, I wouldn’t feel safe enough to celebrate a winning goal until I’d got home and checked the results.
Arf!  I'm still convinced they'll deduct a goal a week on Tuesday if it became necessary...