WBAUnofficial
Our penalty on Saturday - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Our penalty on Saturday (/showthread.php?tid=13829)

Pages: 1 2


RE: Our penalty on Saturday - Cuzer - 11-23-2020

Correct CIM

The Brighton one you can clealry see he gets a touch on the ball, however ours, no matter how many times you watch it there is no evidence he's got anything on the ball and certainly not before he catches Gallgher

Interestingly I saw something on the twatter that Keys & Gray on Bein sports had some audio coverage of the ref going to the monitor and saying to those in the VAR hut "You want me to change my decision" or words to that effect

This price was the VAR guy who didn't send off Pickford v Van Dyke in the Liverpool game so he wanted zero controversy, as soon as he went to the monitor there is no way he can see Fernandes has won the ball, he made his mind up, or it was made up for him before he even seen the VAR replay, absolute joke

Cuzer


RE: Our penalty on Saturday - Shabby Russian - 11-23-2020

(11-23-2020, 09:54 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(11-23-2020, 09:45 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: For me it was a 50/50 decision, if we hadn't got the decision in the first place i wouldn't have been that annoyed.

But once given i don't see that the ref's decision was so 'wrong' that it should be overturned.

The problem is that many, if not the majority of decisions a referee has to make will be subjective , Adding the clear and obvious clause into the var process just adds another level of subjectivity - what is clear and obvious to one person may not to another.

Not a 50/50 for me. I've watched it over and over. He barely touches the ball but clearly takes out Gallagher

Their pen a 50/50. Neither Leicester or Arsenal got ones for similar incidents yesterday

I'm in the same camp as Paul Scholes on this, i really am not convinced it was a penalty, not saying it wasn't one either. From the angle the ref had it seemed nailed on, bit from the view goal side i wasn't as convinced. But i would reiterate once the decision was made, there wasn't enough to suggest a clear and obvious error had been made.

Their penalty should 100% have not been given because there was a clear foul on Gallagher in the immediate build up to the penalty incident.


RE: Our penalty on Saturday - foreveralbion - 11-23-2020

Someone at said they had seen the keys and gray bit discussing the audio. 

If this is true and can be proven then I think we need to pursue this. 

VAR is surely meant to assist the ref and not tell him what decisions to make?

That opens It up to all sort of allegations of corruption.


RE: Our penalty on Saturday - billybassett - 11-23-2020

Is it just me but I've watched it 15 times and there's no way from either angle that I can tell the ball has moved when Fernandez supposedly touches it.

Compared to the Brighton Villa one it's a mile apart - that ball moves significantly. Does my head in when they say it's the same as the Albion one.

Why the hell are VAR asking the ref to go back and look at something that's clearly unseeable. In no other sport does the VAR box ask the ref to go back and have a look. If the decision is wrong they just tell him and they overrule it. I mean FFS they are supposed to be trained refs in Stockley park as well.

I just don't get this pitch side monitor bollocks full stop never had. VAR can rule whether a decision is completely wrong. Just tell him. For subjective decisions it's exactly that. A guy in Stockley park has a different view to the ref. The ref has made a decision on field. Get on with it.

Boils my blood this - and that fking Fernandez has form - diving all over the place - whining at the ref - retaking pens - hop skipping and jumping like Bambi on acid. Twat

https://twitter.com/i/status/1330260532876734466

You can physically see Gallagher's shin go back before Fernandez feathers the ball.

Fkin joke


RE: Our penalty on Saturday - Baggiejacko - 11-23-2020

Unseen highlights of our game and the penalty incident.

https://youtu.be/_9nDHupVqVw

Uncanny resemblances


RE: Our penalty on Saturday - MassDebater - 11-23-2020

I've watched it several times, and for me, it's a penalty all day long. Gallagher moves the ball between his legs, their player takes him out. Clear cut. The ref gave it instantly, that tells me all I need to know.


RE: Our penalty on Saturday - Olympic - 11-24-2020

Three days later and I'm still seething about this. This is VAR refs fault mainly for calling the ref over to review it. There was nothing clear and obvious about that incident. We all know our on field referees haven't got any conviction to stand by their decisions once VAR calls them over to look at the monitor. I am all for VAR, but if we haven't got competent people using it than it's a lot worse than not having it at all.