![]() |
|
A New Deal For The Young - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: A New Deal For The Young (/showthread.php?tid=13334) |
RE: A New Deal For The Young - The liquidator - 10-22-2020 Derek hates anyone from brexit to the sacking of pulis. RE: A New Deal For The Young - Derek Hardballs - 10-22-2020 (10-22-2020, 02:25 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(10-22-2020, 02:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It’s hardly news the Boomer generation has shafted every generation after them. It’s an economic, social and cultural war that they will eventually lose. They will however lose it in relative comfort. You campaigned for a populist government you didn’t improve the situation you actively made it a lot worse. RE: A New Deal For The Young - FenlandBoing - 10-22-2020 Another change in the periods the article discusses is in the general populace being obsessed in their rights rather than personal responsibility. The over reliance on the state that many have to support them and/or then blaming the govt for their own failings as individuals is a sizeable chunk. How many times do we have to see interviews on every news channel with single mothers with 3-5 children pleading poverty (and many living in real poverty) and yet the piece never once asks where is the father or female partner for that matter? Be responsible for your own life choices, you've created the life you have. If you want more go earn it! Or maybe do what successful people in USA do - they go to college, get a professional job or similar, then they marry then they get a house and then they have kids and guess what - they seldom end up in poverty. Weird that! RE: A New Deal For The Young - Derek Hardballs - 10-22-2020 (10-22-2020, 03:02 PM)FenlandBoing Wrote: Another change in the periods the article discusses is in the general populace being obsessed in their rights rather than personal responsibility. The over reliance on the state that many have to support them and/or then blaming the govt for their own failings as individuals is a sizeable chunk. How many times do we have to see interviews on every news channel with single mothers with 3-5 children pleading poverty (and many living in real poverty) and yet the piece never once asks where is the father or female partner for that matter? Be responsible for your own life choices, you've created the life you have. If you want more go earn it! Or maybe do what successful people in USA do - they go to college, get a professional job or similar, then they marry then they get a house and then they have kids and guess what - they seldom end up in poverty. Weird that! Yeah because the US is a great yardstick to judge political, cultural and economic democracy by! If that is the standard we should aspire to then we are fecked! I’m just off out to buy myself a semi-automatic rifle, and matching Trump T-shirt and baseball cap combo. RE: A New Deal For The Young - Protheroe - 10-22-2020 (10-22-2020, 02:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You campaigned for a populist government you didn’t improve the situation you actively made it a lot worse. I have never campaigned for anything but the #LeastWorst outcome. As you know. (10-22-2020, 03:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Yeah because the US is a great yardstick to judge political, cultural and economic democracy by! If that is the standard we should aspire to then we are fecked! I’m just off out to buy myself a semi-automatic rifle, and matching Trump T-shirt and baseball cap combo. You're illustrating yet again why it's pointless debating with you. Are you so one-eyed in real life? RE: A New Deal For The Young - baggy1 - 10-22-2020 (10-22-2020, 03:02 PM)FenlandBoing Wrote: Another change in the periods the article discusses is in the general populace being obsessed in their rights rather than personal responsibility. The over reliance on the state that many have to support them and/or then blaming the govt for their own failings as individuals is a sizeable chunk. How many times do we have to see interviews on every news channel with single mothers with 3-5 children pleading poverty (and many living in real poverty) and yet the piece never once asks where is the father or female partner for that matter? Be responsible for your own life choices, you've created the life you have. If you want more go earn it! Or maybe do what successful people in USA do - they go to college, get a professional job or similar, then they marry then they get a house and then they have kids and guess what - they seldom end up in poverty. Weird that! Strangely that is the same approach in any part of the world - I'm not certain why the USofA was called out specifically there. However life choices are easy in hindsight - I had the opportunity to get a free uni place which I wasted and then latterly, when I had some money, got professional qualifications. Some kids know everything at 18 and have kids - some of them do well and others fall into a trap of ever decreasing circles and bad choices. Your view is 'well tough shit, that's their own fault', when really as a society we should be helping them to help themselves. RE: A New Deal For The Young - Derek Hardballs - 10-22-2020 (10-22-2020, 03:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(10-22-2020, 02:54 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You campaigned for a populist government you didn’t improve the situation you actively made it a lot worse. So the stereotypes that Fenland set out are a well rounded wholistic argument? The idea we should be looking to the US as a roadmap of where to get to as a civilised, responsible and fair society is erm nonsense imo. Popularism is already here it’s just appealing to those who are the most engaged which is the older generations which in turn has turned off younger generations. RE: A New Deal For The Young - Tom Joad - 10-22-2020 baggy1 Wrote:Fenland has a good point though. While not particularly against the OP in it's sympathy for the yoot, I have to point out that I left school at 15 and have worked every year since, mostly self employed. I also have been told my pension age is 66 or 67 (I don't remember which). Meaning I will, if I survive, have done 52 years at work by the time I retire. My wife also left school early, had also got about 10 years of taxes paid by the age most start work now and she had her pension age hiked from 60 to 67. I have seen many that chose the right career take early retirement with nice company boosted pensions but it doesn't apply to everyone.FenlandBoing Wrote:Another change in the periods the article discusses is in the general populace being obsessed in their rights rather than personal responsibility. The over reliance on the state that many have to support them and/or then blaming the govt for their own failings as individuals is a sizeable chunk. How many times do we have to see interviews on every news channel with single mothers with 3-5 children pleading poverty (and many living in real poverty) and yet the piece never once asks where is the father or female partner for that matter? Be responsible for your own life choices, you've created the life you have. If you want more go earn it! Or maybe do what successful people in USA do - they go to college, get a professional job or similar, then they marry then they get a house and then they have kids and guess what - they seldom end up in poverty. Weird that! RE: A New Deal For The Young - Derek Hardballs - 10-22-2020 (10-22-2020, 05:30 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:baggy1 Wrote:Fenland has a good point though. While not particularly against the OP in it's sympathy for the yoot, I have to point out that I left school at 15 and have worked every year since, mostly self employed. I also have been told my pension age is 66 or 67 (I don't remember which). Meaning I will, if I survive, have done 52 years at work by the time I retire. My wife also left school early, had also got about 10 years of taxes paid by the age most start work now and she had her pension age hiked from 60 to 67. I have seen many that chose the right career take early retirement with nice company boosted pensions but it doesn't apply to everyone.FenlandBoing Wrote:Another change in the periods the article discusses is in the general populace being obsessed in their rights rather than personal responsibility. The over reliance on the state that many have to support them and/or then blaming the govt for their own failings as individuals is a sizeable chunk. How many times do we have to see interviews on every news channel with single mothers with 3-5 children pleading poverty (and many living in real poverty) and yet the piece never once asks where is the father or female partner for that matter? Be responsible for your own life choices, you've created the life you have. If you want more go earn it! Or maybe do what successful people in USA do - they go to college, get a professional job or similar, then they marry then they get a house and then they have kids and guess what - they seldom end up in poverty. Weird that! I don’t think you can accommodate everyone’s circumstances into this conversation there will always be exceptions. Bringing the cliche of mothers with three to five kids into the debate is pretty meaningless. TV researchers go for stereotypes, they seek them out, they look for the most extreme cases as does print media. The idea that there are huge numbers of feckless young people or working age for that matter lounging about on benefits is a cliche that started in the 90s. 538,000 young people claim universal credit (Sept 2020) for example and nearly half of those are since Covid. Two thirds of benefits are state pension age (13m). Yes there are exceptions who take the piss and don’t take personal responsibility but it’s as lazy as my deliberate Trump supporter stereotype to lump people on benefit into wanting to be dependent on the state. A sizeable proportion are working but their wage and gig economy / zero hour contracts means they need the stability of the state to help them. You can blame certain business’s / business models just as much for dependency on the state as the individual. RE: A New Deal For The Young - Tom Joad - 10-22-2020 Derek Hardballs Wrote:Tom Joad Wrote:baggy1 Wrote:Fenland has a good point though. While not particularly against the OP in it's sympathy for the yoot, I have to point out that I left school at 15 and have worked every year since, mostly self employed. I also have been told my pension age is 66 or 67 (I don't remember which). Meaning I will, if I survive, have done 52 years at work by the time I retire. My wife also left school early, had also got about 10 years of taxes paid by the age most start work now and she had her pension age hiked from 60 to 67. I have seen many that chose the right career take early retirement with nice company boosted pensions but it doesn't apply to everyone.FenlandBoing Wrote:Another change in the periods the article discusses is in the general populace being obsessed in their rights rather than personal responsibility. The over reliance on the state that many have to support them and/or then blaming the govt for their own failings as individuals is a sizeable chunk. How many times do we have to see interviews on every news channel with single mothers with 3-5 children pleading poverty (and many living in real poverty) and yet the piece never once asks where is the father or female partner for that matter? Be responsible for your own life choices, you've created the life you have. If you want more go earn it! Or maybe do what successful people in USA do - they go to college, get a professional job or similar, then they marry then they get a house and then they have kids and guess what - they seldom end up in poverty. Weird that! I could have also added that I was driving to work the morning interest rates were hiked 2% to 15%. That was a bleak day. So when I hear people bemoaning houses used to be much cheaper, I ought to remind them interest rates weren't always 1 and 2%. I don't want to take sides in an old v young row but there are 2 sides. There are those now that, after gap years and uni, start work when they are closing in on 30 years old. There were those then that retired on almost full salary after 30 years at work. Many of us aren't either and have had their own hard times. |