WBAUnofficial
Scouting and Transfer Department - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Scouting and Transfer Department (/showthread.php?tid=13056)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: Scouting and Transfer Department - Sliced - 10-05-2020

(10-05-2020, 03:41 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: Dowling the pumpkin head. He did have Sheff United's trousers down for Burke to be fair.

Brilliant, well we can take a bit of consolation in that while we're being pumped week in week out

In all seriousness what happens after today if another Prem club willing to spend money need a striker? Who is currently the best option for a striker in the Championship? Probably Karlan Grant, or Troy Deeney; now for inflated prices, so we look further down the league.

Burke leaving is good, but I'll find it hard to take consolation in that when we're 3-0 down against Burnley and having to rely on Lukas Jutkiewicz off the bench.


RE: Scouting and Transfer Department - Hopalong - 10-05-2020

(10-05-2020, 03:03 PM)Sliced Wrote: Did a cracking job last year. We unearthed gems such as Pereira, Diangana, Ajayi; to a lesser extent Krovinovic the took us up to the Prem. 

This year did they just think the job was done? Have the scouting department done anything at all?! On the transfer front have they been in bed!? WTF is going on?

1) The top priority was to first secure the players we had last season. Pereira was already done, so that leaves Diangana, Robinson and Krovinovic. We managed to get Diangana tied down which was undoubtedly the success of the window, Sheff Utd would've taken a packet of crisps in exchange for Robinson, but for Krovinovic we had to settle for another loan, so that's 2 out of 3.

2) Beyond that we needed other incomings to give ourselves a chance of staying up. We've signed a 36 year old defender on a free identified by Bilic, a loan deal for Gallagher which was basically Bilic's doing and a player that everyone knew about and Kipre which was an opportunist purchase because he was going on the cheap and Wigan offered him out. It seems like we have no intention of having him near the first 11. Have I missed anyone or is that literally it? Oh yeah, resigning Bond and Button, again because he was cheap.

3) Offloading deadwood. We haven't even managed to do that have we!? Grosicki may be going but undoubtedly contributes more than most of those in the same position that are staying. Are Zohore and Austin still here? 

What the hell are we playing at? We can harp on and on about whether we aren't spending enough or whatever, but putting that aside, what the fuck have the scouting team done. There's a whole world of footballers out there and so much to be found overseas. Why have we basically identified and brought in absolutely no one outside of the old, the opportunistically cheap and the obvious; AND we haven't got rid of those we need to.

This has been an absolute failure.

Is it 16th October (have I been in a coma for the last 11 days?)  ?  Huh


RE: Scouting and Transfer Department - Birdman1811 - 10-05-2020

We have a max squad size, if we could have moved players in we may have done more. Sadly that was never going to happen.

We didn't expect to sign Diangana either, and that hurt our budget, but I imagine the meltdown if we turned that chance down.

People don't realise how little money we have.


RE: Scouting and Transfer Department - SW4Baggie - 10-05-2020

(10-05-2020, 03:33 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(10-05-2020, 03:31 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-05-2020, 03:03 PM)Sliced Wrote: Did a cracking job last year. We unearthed gems such as Pereira, Diangana, Ajayi; to a lesser extent Krovinovic the took us up to the Prem. 

This year did they just think the job was done? Have the scouting department done anything at all?! On the transfer front have they been in bed!? WTF is going on?

1) The top priority was to first secure the players we had last season. Pereira was already done, so that leaves Diangana, Robinson and Krovinovic. We managed to get Diangana tied down which was undoubtedly the success of the window, Sheff Utd would've taken a packet of crisps in exchange for Robinson, but for Krovinovic we had to settle for another loan, so that's 2 out of 3.

2) Beyond that we needed other incomings to give ourselves a chance of staying up. We've signed a 36 year old defender on a free identified by Bilic, a loan deal for Gallagher which was basically Bilic's doing and a player that everyone knew about and Kipre which was an opportunist purchase because he was going on the cheap and Wigan offered him out. It seems like we have no intention of having him near the first 11. Have I missed anyone or is that literally it? Oh yeah, resigning Bond and Button, again because he was cheap.

3) Offloading deadwood. We haven't even managed to do that have we!? Grosicki may be going but undoubtedly contributes more than most of those in the same position that are staying. Are Zohore and Austin still here? 

What the hell are we playing at? We can harp on and on about whether we aren't spending enough or whatever, but putting that aside, what the fuck have the scouting team done. There's a whole world of footballers out there and so much to be found overseas. Why have we basically identified and brought in absolutely no one outside of the old, the opportunistically cheap and the obvious; AND we haven't got rid of those we need to.

This has been an absolute failure.

Sadly this is bang on.

Anyone with Twitter and TransferMarkt could put together a list of 50 potential signings from Eastern Europe, South America and level 2 leagues like Portugal,controlling shareholder and director Holland and Belgium if they had a day at a laptop. We then have scouting softwares and huge analytics engines which can refine and isolate pretty much any player for any position from anywhere in the world - Brentford and Watford literally scout EVERY division in the world. 

The fact we have known for 15 months that we will need a striker, a central midfielder and to replace our fullbacks regardless of the division we find ourselves in this year it is negligence beyond belief that we haven’t filled any of those positions yet.

Dowling played a blinder last summer with Slav, tying down some youth contracts and with the incomings and outgoings, but this summer his job was to maximise the budget to give Slav the best tools to stay up, and we just haven’t done that. We’ve made a handful of intelligent signings, but arguably were no stronger - if at all - than we were last year.

Is this serious?

Yup...
there are literally tonnes of analysts posting content on a daily basis about players in various leagues, and usually analysed to a very high standard... so much so that most are picked up by recruitment teams / sports data companies on the back of it... Soucek and Coufral were regularly mentioned by these bloggers,  as have been several Croatian players who've moved to bigger things this summer. 

People seem to think scouting is some dark art... it's not... Monchi, possibly the best scout and DoF in the world basically has a team of people watching football games from all round the world every hour of every day for 3-4 months, they highlight players and then overtime build a database. Brentford use AI modelling to assess every player in every league, and then select those who over-perform relative to their teams' positions and then watch them individually.

Getting deals over the line is bloody difficult, but the first part of the jigsaw.... finding players outside of "he played alright against us last year" is the easy part!


RE: Scouting and Transfer Department - Birdman1811 - 10-05-2020

We had a world leading scouting set up until Ashworth left and McDonut deleted it all amd cancelled the subscription in favour of his excel spreadsheet.

Not sure we've gone back to something similar yet. Sadly the investment is significant to do so.


RE: Scouting and Transfer Department - Birdman1811 - 10-05-2020

I had a job interview for the company who made that software and Brentford btw, fascinating stuff

Didn't get it sadly.


RE: Scouting and Transfer Department - billybassett - 10-05-2020

(10-05-2020, 04:16 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-05-2020, 03:33 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(10-05-2020, 03:31 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-05-2020, 03:03 PM)Sliced Wrote: Did a cracking job last year. We unearthed gems such as Pereira, Diangana, Ajayi; to a lesser extent Krovinovic the took us up to the Prem. 

This year did they just think the job was done? Have the scouting department done anything at all?! On the transfer front have they been in bed!? WTF is going on?

1) The top priority was to first secure the players we had last season. Pereira was already done, so that leaves Diangana, Robinson and Krovinovic. We managed to get Diangana tied down which was undoubtedly the success of the window, Sheff Utd would've taken a packet of crisps in exchange for Robinson, but for Krovinovic we had to settle for another loan, so that's 2 out of 3.

2) Beyond that we needed other incomings to give ourselves a chance of staying up. We've signed a 36 year old defender on a free identified by Bilic, a loan deal for Gallagher which was basically Bilic's doing and a player that everyone knew about and Kipre which was an opportunist purchase because he was going on the cheap and Wigan offered him out. It seems like we have no intention of having him near the first 11. Have I missed anyone or is that literally it? Oh yeah, resigning Bond and Button, again because he was cheap.

3) Offloading deadwood. We haven't even managed to do that have we!? Grosicki may be going but undoubtedly contributes more than most of those in the same position that are staying. Are Zohore and Austin still here? 

What the hell are we playing at? We can harp on and on about whether we aren't spending enough or whatever, but putting that aside, what the fuck have the scouting team done. There's a whole world of footballers out there and so much to be found overseas. Why have we basically identified and brought in absolutely no one outside of the old, the opportunistically cheap and the obvious; AND we haven't got rid of those we need to.

This has been an absolute failure.

Sadly this is bang on.

Anyone with Twitter and TransferMarkt could put together a list of 50 potential signings from Eastern Europe, South America and level 2 leagues like Portugal,controlling shareholder and director Holland and Belgium if they had a day at a laptop. We then have scouting softwares and huge analytics engines which can refine and isolate pretty much any player for any position from anywhere in the world - Brentford and Watford literally scout EVERY division in the world. 

The fact we have known for 15 months that we will need a striker, a central midfielder and to replace our fullbacks regardless of the division we find ourselves in this year it is negligence beyond belief that we haven’t filled any of those positions yet.

Dowling played a blinder last summer with Slav, tying down some youth contracts and with the incomings and outgoings, but this summer his job was to maximise the budget to give Slav the best tools to stay up, and we just haven’t done that. We’ve made a handful of intelligent signings, but arguably were no stronger - if at all - than we were last year.

Is this serious?

Yup...
there are literally tonnes of analysts posting content on a daily basis about players in various leagues, and usually analysed to a very high standard... so much so that most are picked up by recruitment teams / sports data companies on the back of it... Soucek and Coufral were regularly mentioned by these bloggers,  as have been several Croatian players who've moved to bigger things this summer. 

People seem to think scouting is some dark art... it's not... Monchi, possibly the best scout and DoF in the world basically has a team of people watching football games from all round the world every hour of every day for 3-4 months, they highlight players and then overtime build a database. Brentford use AI modelling to assess every player in every league, and then select those who over-perform relative to their teams' positions and then watch them individually.

Getting deals over the line is bloody difficult, but the first part of the jigsaw.... finding players outside of "he played alright against us last year" is the easy part!

So you know for sure we don't use any similar software given it is so easy


RE: Scouting and Transfer Department - Hopalong - 10-05-2020

We can have a squad of 25 plus grads 

Roughly two players for each position - current 1st choice in bold? 

By this simple analysis, by my reckoning we are 3 first choice players short - a right back,  right winger/midfielder (could Gallagher fill this role?) and a striker plus another striker and these are the FOUR critical signings we need to make to stand any chance of staying up.  * Livermore getting a massive benefit of the doubt here.

If you need any further advice Luke just drop me a message.  Cheers.   Wink


1. Johnstone
1a  Button 

2.  Vacant 
2a  Furlong (O'Shea) 

3.  Gibbs
3a Townsend

4.  Livermore
4a  Field 

5.  Ivanovic
     Hegazi

6.  Ajayi
     Bartley 

7.  Vacant
7a  Phillips

8.  Krovinovic
8a  Gallagher

9,   Vacant 
9a  Vacant  (Robinson) 
    
10.  Pereira
10a  Vacant

11.  Diangana
11a  Robinson 


Squad 

Bond
Robson-Kanu
Kipre
O'Shea  (loan?) 
Harper (loan)
Sawyers


RE: Scouting and Transfer Department - Super_Slav - 10-05-2020

(10-05-2020, 04:20 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: We had a world leading scouting set up  until Ashworth left and McDonut deleted it all amd cancelled the subscription in favour of his excel spreadsheet.

Not sure we've gone back to something similar yet. Sadly the investment is significant to do so.

https://www.hfe.co.uk/blog/technical-analysis-football/


RE: Scouting and Transfer Department - SW4Baggie - 10-05-2020

(10-05-2020, 05:13 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(10-05-2020, 04:16 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-05-2020, 03:33 PM)billybassett Wrote:
(10-05-2020, 03:31 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-05-2020, 03:03 PM)Sliced Wrote: Did a cracking job last year. We unearthed gems such as Pereira, Diangana, Ajayi; to a lesser extent Krovinovic the took us up to the Prem. 

This year did they just think the job was done? Have the scouting department done anything at all?! On the transfer front have they been in bed!? WTF is going on?

1) The top priority was to first secure the players we had last season. Pereira was already done, so that leaves Diangana, Robinson and Krovinovic. We managed to get Diangana tied down which was undoubtedly the success of the window, Sheff Utd would've taken a packet of crisps in exchange for Robinson, but for Krovinovic we had to settle for another loan, so that's 2 out of 3.

2) Beyond that we needed other incomings to give ourselves a chance of staying up. We've signed a 36 year old defender on a free identified by Bilic, a loan deal for Gallagher which was basically Bilic's doing and a player that everyone knew about and Kipre which was an opportunist purchase because he was going on the cheap and Wigan offered him out. It seems like we have no intention of having him near the first 11. Have I missed anyone or is that literally it? Oh yeah, resigning Bond and Button, again because he was cheap.

3) Offloading deadwood. We haven't even managed to do that have we!? Grosicki may be going but undoubtedly contributes more than most of those in the same position that are staying. Are Zohore and Austin still here? 

What the hell are we playing at? We can harp on and on about whether we aren't spending enough or whatever, but putting that aside, what the fuck have the scouting team done. There's a whole world of footballers out there and so much to be found overseas. Why have we basically identified and brought in absolutely no one outside of the old, the opportunistically cheap and the obvious; AND we haven't got rid of those we need to.

This has been an absolute failure.

Sadly this is bang on.

Anyone with Twitter and TransferMarkt could put together a list of 50 potential signings from Eastern Europe, South America and level 2 leagues like Portugal,controlling shareholder and director Holland and Belgium if they had a day at a laptop. We then have scouting softwares and huge analytics engines which can refine and isolate pretty much any player for any position from anywhere in the world - Brentford and Watford literally scout EVERY division in the world. 

The fact we have known for 15 months that we will need a striker, a central midfielder and to replace our fullbacks regardless of the division we find ourselves in this year it is negligence beyond belief that we haven’t filled any of those positions yet.

Dowling played a blinder last summer with Slav, tying down some youth contracts and with the incomings and outgoings, but this summer his job was to maximise the budget to give Slav the best tools to stay up, and we just haven’t done that. We’ve made a handful of intelligent signings, but arguably were no stronger - if at all - than we were last year.

Is this serious?

Yup...
there are literally tonnes of analysts posting content on a daily basis about players in various leagues, and usually analysed to a very high standard... so much so that most are picked up by recruitment teams / sports data companies on the back of it... Soucek and Coufral were regularly mentioned by these bloggers,  as have been several Croatian players who've moved to bigger things this summer. 

People seem to think scouting is some dark art... it's not... Monchi, possibly the best scout and DoF in the world basically has a team of people watching football games from all round the world every hour of every day for 3-4 months, they highlight players and then overtime build a database. Brentford use AI modelling to assess every player in every league, and then select those who over-perform relative to their teams' positions and then watch them individually.

Getting deals over the line is bloody difficult, but the first part of the jigsaw.... finding players outside of "he played alright against us last year" is the easy part!

So you know for sure we don't use any similar software given it is so easy

Judging by the signings we’ve made in the last couple windows, I reckon we have the same person in charge of booting it up as Hawkeye...