WBAUnofficial
VAR - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: VAR (/showthread.php?tid=12897)

Pages: 1 2 3


RE: VAR - MrFizz - 09-27-2020

(09-27-2020, 04:12 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 04:02 PM)MrFizz Wrote: Awful. Get rid of it ASAP. Keep goal line tech but nothing else (make sure its switched on at Seal Park though). Let refs and assistants referee again.

Perhaps allow managers 1 challenge per game for penalty area incidents to be looked at by the match referee on a pitchside monitor.

Trouble is though mate, SKY, BTSport etc probably love it, controversial decisions can be replayed over & over, pundits, ( and increasingly, ex refs ), analyse it to death, more ` lets look at it from another angle`,` lets see the incident again`etc.

They do you're right. 

Another thing is that IMO refs have become lazy, assistants even more so, knowing that VAR will pick up on things. Get back to reffing you lazy shits


RE: VAR - Everything Zin - 09-27-2020

It’s very frustrating. Linesmen told to keep their flag down if in doubt with VAR to check later but VAR only checks if there’s a goal or penalty claim. Yesterday there was one occasion where a Chelsea player looked offside, lino keeps the flag down, Chelsea win a corner. If the corner leads to a goal, it stands.
Utterly ridiculous.


RE: VAR - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 09-27-2020

(09-27-2020, 04:22 PM)MrFizz Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 04:12 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 04:02 PM)MrFizz Wrote: Awful. Get rid of it ASAP. Keep goal line tech but nothing else (make sure its switched on at Seal Park though). Let refs and assistants referee again.

Perhaps allow managers 1 challenge per game for penalty area incidents to be looked at by the match referee on a pitchside monitor.

Trouble is though mate, SKY, BTSport etc probably love it, controversial decisions can be replayed over & over, pundits, ( and increasingly, ex refs ), analyse it to death, more ` lets look at it from another angle`,` lets see the incident again`etc.

They do you're right. 

Another thing is that IMO refs have become lazy, assistants even more so, knowing that VAR will pick up on things. Get back to reffing you lazy shits
Don`t know if you would agree, but is it similar to Rugby? A few years back Rugby refs referred almost any slightly contentious issue to the TV replay bloke, so they couldn`t get blamed for any controversial decision.


RE: VAR - yeoman lai - 09-27-2020

Brought in purely as a toy to appease the armchair fan.. Real football supporters know is bollox.


RE: VAR - Cuzer - 09-27-2020

Sure I heard on MOTD last night they can't even discuss removing it before UEFA next meet up which is in March, so it's clearly here to stay

As has been said above it's absolute bollocks, Roy summed it up perfectly even Potato Head said we've lost the plot and the decision worked in his favour.

Handball is so simple, deliberate or not deliberate, so easy, neither Ward or Dier were even 1% deliberate and both penalties, absolutely farcical. In training strikers will be practising hitting the defenders arms rather than crossing

Game's bloody gone!

Cuzer


RE: VAR - Shabby Russian - 09-27-2020

Think VAR is drastically changing the game and not in a good way.

The handball situation is entirely because of VAR. Every time the ball strikes a defender's hand/arm in the penalty box it will be picked up by the video referee and then a decision has to be made. To ensure consistency refs will want a definite rule as to what is and isn't handball - so now we have the situation where anytime the ball hits a defender's hand/arm when it is away from the body it will be a penalty - a rule change entirely made to facilitate VAR.

The number of penalties being given at the top level is due to VAR as well, teams are starting to cotton on that it is easier to play for penalties than to try and score. Leicester have made a flyer scoring 12 goals but 5 of these have been penalties. I don't think that's coincidence.

Very soon forwards will be aiming to hit defender's hands rather than at the goals, we already have forwards cutting in front of defenders initiating contact, tumbling to the floor and getting the inevitable penalty.

This may be my personal oddity, but i have always felt that a penalty goal of a lower value than other goals. Seems i will have to get used to seeing more of them.


RE: VAR - Bristolbion - 09-27-2020

VAR should only be used for 2 reasons
1. If the ref isn’t sure about something and wants clarification
2. If the VAR operator spots serious foul play that the ref has missed
.... which is roughly how it works in rugby.
So if the ref is a cunt (step forward Messrs Dean and Scott), it’s just tough and we have to live with his myopic decisions. But at least we can celebrate when the ball hits the net and a 3pm kick off can finish before midnight


RE: VAR - MassDebater - 09-27-2020

I'm for the 2 challenges per team, 1 per half, unused gets lost.

Slav could've used one for the foul in the lead up to one of Chelsea's goals for example.

Other than that the refs word stands, rightly or wrongly. Keep goal line tech, just install 4 in each seal park goal.


RE: VAR - wba13 - 10-03-2020

When are they going to get this VAR right, a horrible tackle by Dallas of Leeds That fucking clown Dean gives him a yellow And whoever was the var ref stood by his Mate it was a cowards tackle.


RE: VAR - Cunninghamismagic - 10-03-2020

(10-03-2020, 06:25 PM)wba13 Wrote: When are they going to get this VAR right, a horrible tackle by Dallas of Leeds That fucking clown Dean gives him a yellow And  whoever was the var ref stood by his Mate it was a cowards tackle.

Blatant red card that. Shocking challenge from the Leeds player