WBAUnofficial
Handball - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Handball (/showthread.php?tid=12869)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


RE: Handball - steviedm - 09-26-2020

I'm led to believe the goal should have stood under the current rules. I agree the rules are shite and unclear, but I'm not really buying into the view that it wasn't disallowed just because Chelsea scored it. I'm told the rule has changed so that if there is accidental handball which doesn't lead directly to a goal then it will be allowed to stand. He hand balled it, HRK messed up his clearance, the ball came back in and was tapped in by Abraham from Johnstone's save. Therefore, the goal stood - it would have been chalked off had it been scored last season or the player who hand balled it immediately whacked it in the net. Having said that, let's see how consistently this rule is applied across the season and whether 'bigger' clubs get more benefit of the doubt.

I'm sure we're also going to fall foul of the defensive handball rule before long, giving away a penalty when a player would have to chop an arm off to avoid it hitting him. This appears to me to be so stupid that managers should tell forwards to shoot very hard at defenders' arms instead of the goal.


RE: Handball - MassDebater - 09-26-2020

(09-26-2020, 07:14 PM)steviedm Wrote: I'm led to believe the goal should have stood under the current rules. I agree the rules are shite and unclear, but I'm not really buying into the view that it wasn't disallowed just because Chelsea scored it. I'm told the rule has changed so that if there is accidental handball which doesn't lead directly to a goal then it will be allowed to stand. He hand balled it, HRK messed up his clearance, the ball came back in and was tapped in by Abraham from Johnstone's save. Therefore, the goal stood - it would have been chalked off had it been scored last season or the player who hand balled it immediately whacked it in the net. Having said that, let's see how consistently this rule is applied across the season and whether 'bigger' clubs get more benefit of the doubt.

I'm sure we're also going to fall foul of the defensive handball rule before long, giving away a penalty when a player would have to chop an arm off to avoid it hitting him. This appears to me to be so stupid that managers should tell forwards to shoot very hard at defenders' arms instead of the goal.

Had he not handballed it then the ball would most likely have gone out of play!


RE: Handball - boingingbaggie - 09-26-2020

I can’t buy it doesn’t directly lead to a goal though
If the ball doesn’t hit his arm it’s going out for a goal kick. 10 seconds later it’s in our net. It’s an abysmal decision


RE: Handball - MrFizz - 09-26-2020

The rule is deliberately obscure. Using words like 'several'. It means they can weigh up who it is, what situation, decide if a fuss will be made (by Klopp, Frank, Pep, Mourinho etc) and then make the decision that will cause less fuss and bother


RE: Handball - rsbaggy2 - 09-26-2020

New interpretation of rule penned by Klopp, Solskjaer, Fat Frank, Mourinho et al.


RE: Handball - Ampadu's Left Boot - 09-26-2020

(09-26-2020, 07:28 PM)MrFizz Wrote: The rule is deliberately obscure. Using words like 'several'. It means they can weigh up who it is, what situation, decide if a fuss will be made (by Klopp, Frank, Pep, Mourinho etc) and then make the decision that will cause less fuss and bother

Exactly, it's vague enough that it leaves these kind of decisions open to interpretation, which is just going to create a lot of problems. There will be plenty of times this season where the same/similar incidents lead to VAR ruling goals out, I'm of no doubt about that.


RE: Handball - Begley - 09-26-2020

(09-26-2020, 06:57 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(09-26-2020, 06:53 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Does anyone actually know the rule now?  

If you are Chelsea, Man Utd or Liverpool then it goes in your favour. Them's the rules.

That's just BS  and typical of the moaning about refs and blame of everyone else other than self-reflection. Last week Lindelof had a ridiculous handball awarded against him. Yes, Lindelof plays for Man U. The pen was taken and DeGea saved it and VAR let Palace take it again and let them change the penalty taker too. So it is clearly not one rule for some teams and not others. It is not the ref either, it is the new handball rules which most football people agree are stupid. Maybe if HRK had of cleared the ball you wouldn't feel so hard done by.

BTW, great result today, tough to take after a 3-0 lead but it is a point gained and a good one at that.


RE: Handball - Ampadu's Left Boot - 09-26-2020

(09-26-2020, 07:20 PM)boingingbaggie Wrote: I can’t buy it doesn’t directly lead to a goal though
If the ball doesn’t hit his arm it’s going out for a goal kick. 10 seconds later it’s in our net. It’s an abysmal decision

Worse, it was 3-4 seconds! As you say, abysmal decision.


RE: Handball - MassDebater - 09-26-2020

(09-26-2020, 07:50 PM)Ampadu's Left Boot Wrote:
(09-26-2020, 07:20 PM)boingingbaggie Wrote: I can’t buy it doesn’t directly lead to a goal though
If the ball doesn’t hit his arm it’s going out for a goal kick. 10 seconds later it’s in our net. It’s an abysmal decision

Worse, it was 3-4 seconds! As you say, abysmal decision.

TBF to my old memory I was trying to recount it in my mind's eye, and erred on the side of caution.


RE: Handball - Duffers - 09-27-2020

Sounds like there’s been a dodgy penalty in the Spurs - Newcastle game.

Not watching but on the BBC updates they are incredulous it’s been given.