WBAUnofficial
Making peace... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Making peace... (/showthread.php?tid=12659)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


RE: Making peace... - Spandaubaggie - 09-18-2020

(09-17-2020, 11:26 PM)rickbaggie Wrote:
(09-17-2020, 10:47 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(09-17-2020, 10:35 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: We may well go down. But I really can't see it being like Derby, Villa or Sunderland.
Some of the negativity is way OTT in my humble opinion.

Massively. OTT and premature. We lost to a team with European football and there's 3 weeks of the transfer window left

as it stands...this is possibly the weakest premier league squad we have ever had. currently not one of the strikers is premiership quality.

The Leicester game was deeply worrying. It was the equivalent of a Prem side playing a lower league team that puts on a gutsy show for a while until the goal goes in.
Despite two silly penalties, it was a comprehensive 3-0 as much as ours v Harrogate.
However, I think there's hope as our team is unlikely to be that weak again, we've seen Ivanovic and Gallagher arrive this week, there's few as good as Leicester, we do have several weaker teams, and were also trying a new system.. 
Yet, the striking department is a huge concern, as Rich says.
In summary, the squad is weaker than in a long while, being almost utterly rebuilt since 2018, but it is more akin to the 2008 Mowbray team in terms of quality and probability of survival- not as industrial as the Megson sides.
We have to hope the new faces hit the ground running and we have to get a striker in who can give us a fighting chance. Chances are still 40/60 to my mind.


RE: Making peace... - clem4england - 09-18-2020

If the squad stays the same I feel the same as the OP. With a quality striker and midfielder things will improve but the other key is how the existing group do:

Diangana and Pereira must adapt quickly to be as effective as last season.
Ivanovic needs to be the Ivanovic of old or close to it.
Ajayi needs to step up to this level. So does O’Shea.
Gibbs must stay fit.

Gallagher is a class act. We must replicate that with the striker and next midfielder.


RE: Making peace... - Johnnykayeengland - 09-18-2020

(09-18-2020, 06:38 AM)clem4england Wrote: If the squad stays the same I feel the same as the OP. With a quality striker and midfielder things will improve but the other key is how the existing group do:

Diangana and Pereira must adapt quickly to be as effective as last season.
Ivanovic needs to be the Ivanovic of old or close to it.
Ajayi needs to step up to this level. So does O’Shea.
Gibbs must stay fit.

Gallagher is a class act. We must replicate that with the striker and next midfielder.
As you know, Clem, I don't like agreeing with you (!), But you and the excellent op appear sadly about right.
We need the above to step up and hope we get that striker in. Just like half the PL.


RE: Making peace... - cornishbaggie - 09-18-2020

Begley Wrote:
ericlegrisly Wrote:
SW4Baggie Wrote:Realise it’s easy days for doom and gloom, but I have to say I’ve accepted relegation will happen this season, and it won’t be a pleasant one either... I really can see us pushing Derby / Sunderland levels of disappointment this year.

Whilst I think it’s going to hurt, the fact we’ve effectively saved ourselves from serious financial problems, boosted our bank balance for the foreseeable future and strengthened our position during a time when self sustaining clubs will be hit incredibly hard is the biggest positive of this promotion.

For all our sakes I hope Slav and the lads pull off something special, but let’s be realistic, we probably have the lowest wage bill in the division, probably have the weakest squad, with the most gaps and the least amount of money to spend. On paper we’re a decent Championship side that needs a striker. 

The next 12 months will be bloody difficult for football teams all over the country, and I fear many more fans will lose their club like Macc Town and Bury have, so I find it really hard to get worked up about the PL...

Really good post.  It will be astonishing if we reach 17th given that we do have the weakest squad, no forwards and no money.  I agree that we do have hope for the longer term given our fiscal prudence, but I do fear a genuinely horrible season coming in terms of results.  Be rubbish if we do a Derby / Sunderland, but it is, sadly possible. Maybe there's 3 worse teams, but I can't see it just now.

Fulham, Hammers, Leeds, Burnley, Sheffield Utd, Villa and Leeds will give a good run at it. I think Fulham are nailed on for relegation. Hammers are in complete disarray, have a shyte defense and a manager that sets up his team to defend. They are going to struggle. Only 3 teams scored fewer goals than Blades last season and two of those are now in the Championship. They stayed up because GK  imo. Henderson is gone and they haven't improved. I fancy them for the drop. Leeds and Villa may buy their way from the drop but Burnley look weak every year and then pull it out of the bag, at some stage that will not happen. WBA absolutely need a goal scorer and if one arrives then I wouldn't write off survival. Without a goal scorer then I think relegation will happen. A very expensive loan signing is required. 100k / 150k a week will cost about 5m in wages and another 5m in loan fee but imo worth the risk. Tammy Abraham looks potentially available

Not to us he's not, unless the prem suddenly change the loan rules for lil ole us.


RE: Making peace... - chasetownbaggie - 09-18-2020

Whilst I agree with the OP, I think SW4 should have waited until the end of the transfer window to post it. Things might look a lot different by then.


RE: Making peace... - Beachboysbaggie - 09-18-2020

We’ve stayed up, thrived even, with Rondon/Ideye and Rondon/HRK as our strike force. I liked Rondon but surely it’s not out of the question we get someone in of similar quality.


RE: Making peace... - Begley - 09-18-2020

(09-18-2020, 01:35 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(09-18-2020, 12:27 AM)Begley Wrote:
(09-17-2020, 11:32 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote:
(09-17-2020, 10:15 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Realise it’s easy days for doom and gloom, but I have to say I’ve accepted relegation will happen this season, and it won’t be a pleasant one either... I really can see us pushing Derby / Sunderland levels of disappointment this year.

Whilst I think it’s going to hurt, the fact we’ve effectively saved ourselves from serious financial problems, boosted our bank balance for the foreseeable future and strengthened our position during a time when self sustaining clubs will be hit incredibly hard is the biggest positive of this promotion.

For all our sakes I hope Slav and the lads pull off something special, but let’s be realistic, we probably have the lowest wage bill in the division, probably have the weakest squad, with the most gaps and the least amount of money to spend. On paper we’re a decent Championship side that needs a striker. 

The next 12 months will be bloody difficult for football teams all over the country, and I fear many more fans will lose their club like Macc Town and Bury have, so I find it really hard to get worked up about the PL...

Really good post.  It will be astonishing if we reach 17th given that we do have the weakest squad, no forwards and no money.  I agree that we do have hope for the longer term given our fiscal prudence, but I do fear a genuinely horrible season coming in terms of results.  Be rubbish if we do a Derby / Sunderland, but it is, sadly possible. Maybe there's 3 worse teams, but I can't see it just now.

Fulham, Hammers, Leeds, Burnley, Sheffield Utd, Villa and Leeds will give a good run at it. I think Fulham are nailed on for relegation. Hammers are in complete disarray, have a shyte defense and a manager that sets up his team to defend. They are going to struggle. Only 3 teams scored fewer goals than Blades last season and two of those are now in the Championship. They stayed up because GK  imo. Henderson is gone and they haven't improved. I fancy them for the drop. Leeds and Villa may buy their way from the drop but Burnley look weak every year and then pull it out of the bag, at some stage that will not happen. WBA absolutely need a goal scorer and if one arrives then I wouldn't write off survival. Without a goal scorer then I think relegation will happen. A very expensive loan signing is required. 100k / 150k a week will cost about 5m in wages and another 5m in loan fee but imo worth the risk. Tammy Abraham looks potentially available

Spunking your way out will never work. Not even your lot are stupid enough to commit £150K a week on player. It's suicide. Not sure what you are paying Tom Sealish, but if you think he has been given a £40M contract, from a club that is at real risk of relegation then either you or your owners must be on drugs.

We would not court Abraham, nor would (or should) we commit to his wages. We look for better value. Long term high value contracts are risk for all but the top 6 established clubs, and neither of us are anywhere near that league.
I agree long term contracts with high wages are a risk that is why I suggested to 'LOAN' Abraham for a year. As I said, I think you need a goal scorer and without a goal scorer relegation looks likely. A year in the PL is worth 100m+. I would think paying 10m to have a genuine goal scorer for a year is worth it


RE: Making peace... - Tom Joad - 09-18-2020

aj21 Wrote:1 fucking game and it’s talk of Derby and Sunderland style season. Gallagher will make a difference and we’ll get a couple more. All I want us to do is have a go at teams, there are some very average teams - Fulham, Newcastle, Villa, Leeds, Palace, West Ham, Burnley, Sheff Utd, Southampton and Brighton should not be having you panicking

...is correct. 4 weeks till the transfer window shuts so we don't even know who has a weak or strong squad yet.  We don't know if one of the 12 possible relegation candidates will make  a Pardew style appointment. Keep yer pants dry, everyone.


RE: Making peace... - Duffers - 09-18-2020

You can only go on what you see.

As things stand right now you’d have to agree with SW4. However there is still time for things to change, and you would hope that there will be changes to the squad between now and the window closing.


RE: Making peace... - cornishbaggie - 09-18-2020

Begley Wrote:
Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
Begley Wrote:
ericlegrisly Wrote:
SW4Baggie Wrote:Realise it’s easy days for doom and gloom, but I have to say I’ve accepted relegation will happen this season, and it won’t be a pleasant one either... I really can see us pushing Derby / Sunderland levels of disappointment this year.

Whilst I think it’s going to hurt, the fact we’ve effectively saved ourselves from serious financial problems, boosted our bank balance for the foreseeable future and strengthened our position during a time when self sustaining clubs will be hit incredibly hard is the biggest positive of this promotion.

For all our sakes I hope Slav and the lads pull off something special, but let’s be realistic, we probably have the lowest wage bill in the division, probably have the weakest squad, with the most gaps and the least amount of money to spend. On paper we’re a decent Championship side that needs a striker. 

The next 12 months will be bloody difficult for football teams all over the country, and I fear many more fans will lose their club like Macc Town and Bury have, so I find it really hard to get worked up about the PL...

Really good post.  It will be astonishing if we reach 17th given that we do have the weakest squad, no forwards and no money.  I agree that we do have hope for the longer term given our fiscal prudence, but I do fear a genuinely horrible season coming in terms of results.  Be rubbish if we do a Derby / Sunderland, but it is, sadly possible. Maybe there's 3 worse teams, but I can't see it just now.

Fulham, Hammers, Leeds, Burnley, Sheffield Utd, Villa and Leeds will give a good run at it. I think Fulham are nailed on for relegation. Hammers are in complete disarray, have a shyte defense and a manager that sets up his team to defend. They are going to struggle. Only 3 teams scored fewer goals than Blades last season and two of those are now in the Championship. They stayed up because GK  imo. Henderson is gone and they haven't improved. I fancy them for the drop. Leeds and Villa may buy their way from the drop but Burnley look weak every year and then pull it out of the bag, at some stage that will not happen. WBA absolutely need a goal scorer and if one arrives then I wouldn't write off survival. Without a goal scorer then I think relegation will happen. A very expensive loan signing is required. 100k / 150k a week will cost about 5m in wages and another 5m in loan fee but imo worth the risk. Tammy Abraham looks potentially available

Spunking your way out will never work. Not even your lot are stupid enough to commit £150K a week on player. It's suicide. Not sure what you are paying Tom Sealish, but if you think he has been given a £40M contract, from a club that is at real risk of relegation then either you or your owners must be on drugs.

We would not court Abraham, nor would (or should) we commit to his wages. We look for better value. Long term high value contracts are risk for all but the top 6 established clubs, and neither of us are anywhere near that league.
I agree long term contracts with high wages are a risk that is why I suggested to 'LOAN' Abraham for a year. As I said, I think you need a goal scorer and without a goal scorer relegation looks likely. A year in the PL is worth 100m+. I would think paying 10m to have a genuine goal scorer for a year is worth it

It's irrelevant, we couldn't loan him if we wanted to.