![]() |
|
Gone With The Wind - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Gone With The Wind (/showthread.php?tid=10681) |
RE: Gone With The Wind - TETLEY74 - 06-10-2020 (06-10-2020, 08:32 AM)The liquidator Wrote: The re writing of history is concerning it's going one way ....if they want to get all slavery statues that's fine by me but they they want anyone who was a abuser to their workforce and tyrants but I hope some dont go crying to mommy when nelson Mandela is torn down by some as he neclaced his own people by putting tyres around their neck and set them alight burning them alive .its a dangerous path we are going down. Removing statues(by legal means) of slave traders etc is one thing but trying to air brush or change history is a extremely worrying trend and the danger is we will go to far the other way and all the good work and progress that has been hard won over decades may well be lost and could ultimately put race relations back many many years. RE: Gone With The Wind - steviedm - 06-10-2020 This is a worrying development, in my opinion. While I broadly welcome the events of the last few weeks and have no problem with the removal of statues that glorify those who profited from the slave trade, we need to be careful about how far this is pushed. The statue issue is very different to film/TV representations - statues by their nature are erected for the purpose of idolatry: the subject usually stands literally higher than the onlooker and the artwork exists because there is a widely held belief its subject should be admired and venerated. The removal of statues that effectively celebrate those involved in the slave trade is therefore welcome - but they should not be wiped from history; statues such as Colston's have a future in museums with proper interpretation detailing the history of slavery and the way in which it enriched individuals and nations such as our own. I teach film at A level and one of the options on the Film History paper is The Birth of a Nation, DW Griffiths's groundbreaking 1915 film, which introduced many of the techniques now standard in filmmaking. The film is racist to its core, surpassing Gone With The Wind, but its shocking representations help add context to discussions of race and provide an insight into the way America saw race just over a hundred years ago. Rather than be banned, it should be shown with contextual notes and used as an educational tool to help people frame contemporary debates. I also teach media and for about 15 years now have shown students excerpts from lots of 1970s TV shows such as Love Thy Neighbour, Curry and Chips, Till Death Us Do Part etc. They are shocked at the racist content and then I show them clips of Matt Lucas playing characters in Come Fly With Me. In one, he is blacked up as a Jamaican coffee shop worker called Precious Little. She is depicted as lazy and overly religious - ridiculous stereotyping for a show broadcast on BBC1 within the last decade. I found it offensive at the time and I find it offensive now, but I don't think it should be removed from streaming services as if it never happened. I am against historical revisionism in any form - the removal of smoking from Tom and Jerry cartoons, the apparent deletion of Gary Glitter from Glam Rock history (BBC4 once ran a documentary on the history of Glam Rock and did not even mention his name). It is dangerous and sets worrying precedents for the future. I always teach students that pretty much everything is about context so some orientation/contextual materials to accompany content with questionable representations by modern standards is important to frame them correctly - removing them is a step too far. RE: Gone With The Wind - Ted Maul - 06-10-2020 (06-10-2020, 09:02 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:(06-10-2020, 08:32 AM)The liquidator Wrote: The re writing of history is concerning it's going one way ....if they want to get all slavery statues that's fine by me but they they want anyone who was a abuser to their workforce and tyrants but I hope some dont go crying to mommy when nelson Mandela is torn down by some as he neclaced his own people by putting tyres around their neck and set them alight burning them alive .its a dangerous path we are going down. He's a shite professor. I mean, I'm glad we still have all those statues of Adolf Hitler knocking about otherwise we'd not have a fucking clue who he was. RE: Gone With The Wind - Spandaubaggie - 06-10-2020 (06-10-2020, 09:12 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:Difference is we all know about Hitler as he is possibly the most demonic person in history. However, had you heard of Coulston before the weekend? I hadn't. He was also a philanthropist, who did a lot of good also, so context is needed to these debates. Did some think they were doing the Africans a favour taking them to our 'more superior' culture? I don't know, but it opens a debate.(06-10-2020, 09:02 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:(06-10-2020, 08:32 AM)The liquidator Wrote: The re writing of history is concerning it's going one way ....if they want to get all slavery statues that's fine by me but they they want anyone who was a abuser to their workforce and tyrants but I hope some dont go crying to mommy when nelson Mandela is torn down by some as he neclaced his own people by putting tyres around their neck and set them alight burning them alive .its a dangerous path we are going down. Pardon the pun, but it's not as black and white as you say. History is complex and has to be analysed and knee-jerk banning of fims, comedy, burning books and ripping down statues doesn't seem a clever long-term strategy. RE: Gone With The Wind - WWHO - 06-10-2020 (06-10-2020, 09:28 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:(06-10-2020, 09:12 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:Difference is we all know about Hitler as he is possibly the most demonic person in history. However, had you heard of Coulston before the weekend? I hadn't. He was also a philanthropist, who did a lot of good also, so context is needed to these debates. Did some think they were doing the Africans a favour taking them to our 'more superior' culture? I don't know, but it opens a debate.(06-10-2020, 09:02 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:(06-10-2020, 08:32 AM)The liquidator Wrote: The re writing of history is concerning it's going one way ....if they want to get all slavery statues that's fine by me but they they want anyone who was a abuser to their workforce and tyrants but I hope some dont go crying to mommy when nelson Mandela is torn down by some as he neclaced his own people by putting tyres around their neck and set them alight burning them alive .its a dangerous path we are going down. Surely, if you're going down that route, you could make the same point about Hitler?! RE: Gone With The Wind - Kit Kat Chunky - 06-10-2020 Just been listening to a radio show, when a commentator ripped into Keith Lemon for what he did to Craig David, calling it racist. Yes, he did "black up", but I don't consider it to be racist (many will). He portrayed the character. How is he supposed to visualise him in character without looking like him? I don't find him funny, anyway. RE: Gone With The Wind - Bartley_baggie - 06-10-2020 If you have a quick google of just about any famous industrialist from the 18th century you’ll find some connection with slave trade, try Boulton, Watt and Brindley and Galton,we can’t change History only hopefully learn from it! RE: Gone With The Wind - Kit Kat Chunky - 06-10-2020 The Song of the South film was ditched by Disney years ago. Three of their theme parks have a "Splash Mountain" ride though, that is based on the film, and plays music from it. RE: Gone With The Wind - Fido - 06-10-2020 (06-10-2020, 08:53 AM)Duffers Wrote:(06-10-2020, 08:24 AM)Protheroe Wrote: They will be burning books by the end of the weekend. Well I'm not racist because I have a black Kindle. (06-10-2020, 09:28 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:(06-10-2020, 09:12 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:Difference is we all know about Hitler as he is possibly the most demonic person in history. However, had you heard of Coulston before the weekend? I hadn't. He was also a philanthropist, who did a lot of good also, so context is needed to these debates. Did some think they were doing the Africans a favour taking them to our 'more superior' culture? I don't know, but it opens a debate.(06-10-2020, 09:02 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:(06-10-2020, 08:32 AM)The liquidator Wrote: The re writing of history is concerning it's going one way ....if they want to get all slavery statues that's fine by me but they they want anyone who was a abuser to their workforce and tyrants but I hope some dont go crying to mommy when nelson Mandela is torn down by some as he neclaced his own people by putting tyres around their neck and set them alight burning them alive .its a dangerous path we are going down. Jesus. One role that has to be criticised though is that of many arms of the Church that openly condoned slavery and benefited from it and whose stance would have been that they were being saved from their heathen lives. The money-makers used this to their advantage and could even claim they had God on their side, even though their sole ambition was profit. RE: Gone With The Wind - Ted Maul - 06-10-2020 (06-10-2020, 09:34 AM)WWHO Wrote:(06-10-2020, 09:28 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:(06-10-2020, 09:12 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:Difference is we all know about Hitler as he is possibly the most demonic person in history. However, had you heard of Coulston before the weekend? I hadn't. He was also a philanthropist, who did a lot of good also, so context is needed to these debates. Did some think they were doing the Africans a favour taking them to our 'more superior' culture? I don't know, but it opens a debate.(06-10-2020, 09:02 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:(06-10-2020, 08:32 AM)The liquidator Wrote: The re writing of history is concerning it's going one way ....if they want to get all slavery statues that's fine by me but they they want anyone who was a abuser to their workforce and tyrants but I hope some dont go crying to mommy when nelson Mandela is torn down by some as he neclaced his own people by putting tyres around their neck and set them alight burning them alive .its a dangerous path we are going down. I think the point is we're not taught it, so something has to change. If the Colston statue hadn't of come down over the weekend, Tower Hamlets wouldn't have removed the statue of Robert Milligan yesterday. Jimmy Savile did a lot of charity work ffs. |