![]() |
|
Following the science? - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Following the science? (/showthread.php?tid=10554) |
RE: Following the science? - strawman - 05-31-2020 (05-31-2020, 06:36 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: So those shielding can go out with a member of their family or a friend? Have we got a cure then? I only ask as the five provisos the government set are nowhere near ‘One’. What’s changed?Well Dekka, I have always said that I find all politicians incompetent wasters, but in the past when I have posted what I consider to be some balance against your incessant, tiresome, negative and sometimes well founded tirades against one party you have accused me of being Tory and you do once again. To be fair I have voted Tory and Labour because there is no box which says 'No thanks – none of the above'. So by the same token when you show such bigoted, unthinking bias it's only reasonable that we can conclude that you are one of Labour's greatest cheerleaders so I'm thinking of putting you forward as leader of Momentum. I'm sure you'll do a great job. The difference between us of course, is that I am prepared to criticise both sides and state they should all lose their jobs, you as head of the Labour excuse foundation would choke on criticising Labour. RE: Following the science? - Derek Hardballs - 05-31-2020 (05-31-2020, 06:59 PM)strawman Wrote:(05-31-2020, 06:36 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: So those shielding can go out with a member of their family or a friend? Have we got a cure then? I only ask as the five provisos the government set are nowhere near ‘One’. What’s changed?Well Dekka, I have always said that I find all politicians incompetent wasters, but in the past when I have posted what I consider to be some balance against your incessant, tiresome, negative and sometimes well founded tirades against one party you have accused me of being Tory and you do once again. To be fair I have voted Tory and Labour because there is no box which says 'No thanks – none of the above'. You’re going to have to find a thread where I have praised Labour. I have put a number of threads up criticising Momentum and Corbyn and likening the choice of Labour or Tory at the last election as buying a Villa or Wolves top and that was the polite version there were others. I have this year praised Rishi Sunak and Kier Starmer this year though... You say bigoted I’d say rational criticism.
RE: Following the science? - JOK - 06-01-2020 (05-31-2020, 07:37 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:I’d say fixated hatred.(05-31-2020, 06:59 PM)strawman Wrote:
RE: Following the science? - ChamonixBaggie - 06-01-2020 Its entirely reasonable to have a fixated hatred of the Conservative party IMO, not that I think Derek does. He has consistently criticised Labour, although not with the same regularity as the Tories. This is because the Tories are currently in govt so they are the ones who are open to the vast majority of the criticism. Also, saying all politicians are incompetent wasters who should all lose their jobs is a foolish and cowardly statement. Its just a way of trying to seem 'reasonable' and 'bipartisan' by not actually adopting a position or offering an opinion. "both sides" are very much not as bad as each other. RE: Following the science? - PeakBaggie - 06-01-2020 Frankly i am not sure how you can follow the science when so many in the scientific community Do not agree with each other. Perhaps guided by the science is thd only true way to describe the path we have taken. Lockdown was easy and succesful by fear, release was always going to split opinion and be by Political judgement poor or otherwise. RE: Following the science? - Shabby Russian - 06-01-2020 (06-01-2020, 10:14 AM)PeakBaggie Wrote: Frankly i am not sure how you can follow the science when so many in the scientific community Yes I agree with this. Govts of all political persuasion can adopt vague, meaningless phrases that can come back to bite them - following the science is one such. RE: Following the science? - baggy1 - 06-01-2020 Follow the science is just another of the 3 word slogans that the Tory party seem so keen on to appease the masses. In their defence there are a number of scientists on the SAGE committee apparently and from them there are a few that feel it is too early. The message from the govt is that there are more that are saying it is ok. My personal view is that it simply doesn't make sense based on their own rules set out in the 5 steps, but they just got bored and got pressure off the money men and are fudging it. They should make the new 3 word slogan, Cross Your Fingers RE: Following the science? - billybassett - 06-01-2020 The government is, in some respects damned if they do and damned if they don't. Every country was woefully under prepared and have made mistakes along the way. I'm sure people are following the science but the interpretation of the science is not straightforward. Like in any scientific discipline good science is basically the accretion of many years of refinement by multiple scientists always building on the last iteration. That's a good thing, but in a completely new case there's no way the science can always be right. The interpretation is what's key along with: agility of decision making and in covid's case the other factors around protection, testing, etc... The big question is whether the number of deaths could have been lower if alternative actions were taken. For me this is not about finger pointing but absolutely critical to the next hit - because that will be coming sooner than we think given that the planet is boiling in terms of heat, people, pollution. What gets my goat is that as an Island we have an advantage. Close the borders. We never did. Govt is culpable for that in my book. But to finish.... the science and those advisors will inevitably be the fall guy in the inquiry/review of what has happened. Politically astute to have them at every briefing - not just because they should be there, but because that will be Boris's get out of jail card. A bit like "Get Brexit Done" and "£350m for the NHS", "Following the Science" is just another phrase that can be parroted out to keep the populus under control and make it look like the govt has control RE: Following the science? - baggy1 - 06-01-2020 Agree with all of that BB - as for the close the borders piece, the "we followed the science" line has already been pulled out in questions. The logic was that the virus was already here so closing the borders wouldn't stop it getting here. My view was that, forget about we could see it coming and could have closed down really early, but when we did realise we didn't need to have additional cases from overseas as we were cultivating enough of our own anyway - closing the borders would have meant what we had was contained and lockdown would control it. RE: Following the science? - HomersBelly - 06-01-2020 We got the lockdown because the public wanted it at the time we got it. Nobody was calling for one in January were they? We are now getting a quicker lifting of restrictions because public opinion is starting to turn that way. That's the way I see it anyway. |