RE: Israel - CaptainFantastico - 08-05-2024
https://x.com/abierkhatib/status/1820253312886694039?s=46
It’s good to see you spell out what sort of world you advocate Ponty. This is the kind of moral base you sit upon.
One day you’ll grow up enough to see these things beyond your own mindset that condemning one “side” doesn’t mean someone supports another. It’s little wonder you can only reach a conclusion about me based on logic that’s as far as your mind currently stretches.
As for believing that someone should form their views from what they have been “educated” to believe, it’s frightening really that someone like you is anywhere near our system. Thank fuck it’s only a status boost on a panel so you can wear a suit and feel important while others do the graft. Unsurprising, given the limitations of your debating framework.
RE: Israel - man in the corner shop - 08-05-2024
Not the Israel is a shining beacon shite argument again.
And also a belief that there is a need to take sides.
I oppose the genocide of Israel and Hamas. I don't take sides.
Pontys's arguments are infantile.
As with Proth, it is pointless trying to discuss Israel when there isn't a smidgeon of objectivity. Even Hawks called Proth out on this.
RE: Israel - Birdman1811 - 08-05-2024
(08-05-2024, 09:47 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: https://x.com/abierkhatib/status/1820253312886694039?s=46
It’s good to see you spell out what sort of world you advocate Ponty. This is the kind of moral base you sit upon.
One day you’ll grow up enough to see these things beyond your own mindset that condemning one “side” doesn’t mean someone supports another. It’s little wonder you can only reach a conclusion about me based on logic that’s as far as your mind currently stretches.
As for believing that someone should form their views from what they have been “educated” to believe, it’s frightening really that someone like you is anywhere near our system. Thank fuck it’s only a status boost on a panel so you can wear a suit and feel important while others do the graft. Unsurprising, given the limitations of your debating framework.
Old gaming friend of mine was in Israeli army, has similar stories, he's said to me a d our group online to never think Israel is some innocent victim, they want Palestine gone as much as Palestine want them gone.
Why I say, it's simplistic, but both sides are cunts, doing cuntish things to eachother.
RE: Israel - CaptainFantastico - 08-05-2024
Your last sentence about sums it up
RE: Israel - Pontificator - 08-06-2024
(08-05-2024, 09:47 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: https://x.com/abierkhatib/status/1820253312886694039?s=46
It’s good to see you spell out what sort of world you advocate Ponty. This is the kind of moral base you sit upon.
One day you’ll grow up enough to see these things beyond your own mindset that condemning one “side” doesn’t mean someone supports another. It’s little wonder you can only reach a conclusion about me based on logic that’s as far as your mind currently stretches.
As for believing that someone should form their views from what they have been “educated” to believe, it’s frightening really that someone like you is anywhere near our system. Thank fuck it’s only a status boost on a panel so you can wear a suit and feel important while others do the graft. Unsurprising, given the limitations of your debating framework.
I stand by what I said and I award you three gold medals, for arrogance, pomposity and baloney.
RE: Israel - CaptainFantastico - 08-06-2024
I award you the giant nonce trophy. Jog on ya weapon.
RE: Israel - Shabby Russian - 08-06-2024
(08-05-2024, 08:20 AM)Pontificator Wrote: (08-03-2024, 10:45 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Your original point was about why people are pointing out Israel are genocidal maniacs and why they aren’t condemning Hamas. I was explaining to you that that’s because no one is defending Hamas on here but people are defending Israel.
Your post above has (conveniently) moved on to something else.
So lets get back to it. Israel is the only democracy in the entire region, surrounded by rogue states like Iran and by despots & terrorist groups. They were attacked on 7th October with the sole intentions of destroying jews and provoking Israel to defend the existence of their state.
If you do not know which side to support there is something seriously wrong with your education, illustrated by the above post. If Israel is attacked by Iran I've no doubt you will blame the Jews for existing and defending themselves
https://x.com/JakeWSimons/status/1820242642208260390
Israel is not surrounded by Iran, geographically it is some distance away.
Neighbouring countries include two ravaged by internal conflict, Syria and Lebanon, and two Arab countries not noted for their recent belligerence to Israel, Jordan and Egypt.
Israel has a right to exist and I would fundamentally disagree with anyone who disputed that. It's entry as a sovereign country was not without issues, clumsily executed and leaving people with a genuine reason for grievance. But a Jewish homeland was a necessity following the holocaust.
But defending Israel whatever it does is not being a true friend. There can be no defending the atrocities in Gaza no matter how heinous the provocation, it goes way beyond what can be called reasonable defence. And there can be no defending the many and continued breached of international law on the West Bank.
You might think you are being a staunch friend to Israel in defending their actions no matter what. You are not. You are aiding those who wish to see Israel destroyed.
RE: Israel - man in the corner shop - 08-06-2024
Stop being sensible and reasonable Shabby. There are none so blind as those who refuse to see.
RE: Israel - Pontificator - 08-06-2024
(08-06-2024, 09:00 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (08-05-2024, 08:20 AM)Pontificator Wrote: (08-03-2024, 10:45 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Your original point was about why people are pointing out Israel are genocidal maniacs and why they aren’t condemning Hamas. I was explaining to you that that’s because no one is defending Hamas on here but people are defending Israel.
Your post above has (conveniently) moved on to something else.
So lets get back to it. Israel is the only democracy in the entire region, surrounded by rogue states like Iran and by despots & terrorist groups. They were attacked on 7th October with the sole intentions of destroying jews and provoking Israel to defend the existence of their state.
If you do not know which side to support there is something seriously wrong with your education, illustrated by the above post. If Israel is attacked by Iran I've no doubt you will blame the Jews for existing and defending themselves
https://x.com/JakeWSimons/status/1820242642208260390
Israel is not surrounded by Iran, geographically it is some distance away.
Neighbouring countries include two ravaged by internal conflict, Syria and Lebanon, and two Arab countries not noted for their recent belligerence to Israel, Jordan and Egypt.
Israel has a right to exist and I would fundamentally disagree with anyone who disputed that. It's entry as a sovereign country was not without issues, clumsily executed and leaving people with a genuine reason for grievance. But a Jewish homeland was a necessity following the holocaust.
But defending Israel whatever it does is not being a true friend. There can be no defending the atrocities in Gaza no matter how heinous the provocation, it goes way beyond what can be called reasonable defence. And there can be no defending the many and continued breached of international law on the West Bank.
You might think you are being a staunch friend to Israel in defending their actions no matter what. You are not. You are aiding those who wish to see Israel destroyed.
Israel is the only democracy in the entire region, surrounded by rogue states like Iran and by despots & terrorist groups. That is a factually correct statement. I ddn't say Israel is surrounded by Iran. Israel do not have carte blanche to do what they like and what is being done in the West Bank is wrong. I do not believe that Israel is intent on genocide in Gaza and is basically defending itself on the premise that we are not putting up with this shit again. I find that perfectly understandable and such I would defend their right to do what they think fit within the rules of combat. I think perhap the majority of Israelis support the war in Gaza
RE: Israel - Ted Maul - 08-06-2024
(08-06-2024, 11:53 AM)Pontificator Wrote: (08-06-2024, 09:00 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (08-05-2024, 08:20 AM)Pontificator Wrote: (08-03-2024, 10:45 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Your original point was about why people are pointing out Israel are genocidal maniacs and why they aren’t condemning Hamas. I was explaining to you that that’s because no one is defending Hamas on here but people are defending Israel.
Your post above has (conveniently) moved on to something else.
So lets get back to it. Israel is the only democracy in the entire region, surrounded by rogue states like Iran and by despots & terrorist groups. They were attacked on 7th October with the sole intentions of destroying jews and provoking Israel to defend the existence of their state.
If you do not know which side to support there is something seriously wrong with your education, illustrated by the above post. If Israel is attacked by Iran I've no doubt you will blame the Jews for existing and defending themselves
https://x.com/JakeWSimons/status/1820242642208260390
Israel is not surrounded by Iran, geographically it is some distance away.
Neighbouring countries include two ravaged by internal conflict, Syria and Lebanon, and two Arab countries not noted for their recent belligerence to Israel, Jordan and Egypt.
Israel has a right to exist and I would fundamentally disagree with anyone who disputed that. It's entry as a sovereign country was not without issues, clumsily executed and leaving people with a genuine reason for grievance. But a Jewish homeland was a necessity following the holocaust.
But defending Israel whatever it does is not being a true friend. There can be no defending the atrocities in Gaza no matter how heinous the provocation, it goes way beyond what can be called reasonable defence. And there can be no defending the many and continued breached of international law on the West Bank.
You might think you are being a staunch friend to Israel in defending their actions no matter what. You are not. You are aiding those who wish to see Israel destroyed.
Israel is the only democracy in the entire region, surrounded by rogue states like Iran and by despots & terrorist groups. That is a factually correct statement. I ddn't say Israel is surrounded by Iran. Israel do not have carte blanche to do what they like and what is being done in the West Bank is wrong. I do not believe that Israel is intent on genocide in Gaza and is basically defending itself on the premise that we are not putting up with this shit again. I find that perfectly understandable and such I would defend their right to do what they think fit within the rules of combat. I think perhap the majority of Israelis support the war in Gaza
But it's not within the rules of combat because they're blowing up kids again. Isn't that the whole point of this debate?
|