WBAUnofficial
European super League - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: European super League (/showthread.php?tid=16811)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32


RE: European super League - TETLEY74 - 04-20-2021

(04-20-2021, 06:32 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-19-2021, 11:04 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(04-19-2021, 11:02 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Good to see they are keeping it real on H & V with one poster saying Villa was the biggest club in the World until the 1950s and another saying they were the biggest club in English football until the 1980s, because of something a Rothman's book said in 1973. Seriously.

One very small positive in all this is that it might make them finally realise they are not a big club to anyone outside their own support, but I wouldn't bet on that happening.

If they are excluded from the European dream, their American owners won't keep spunking the cash.

No owners anywhere will.
No change for us then  Rolleyes


RE: European super League - Remi_Moses - 04-20-2021

(04-19-2021, 04:30 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: We have the Prem league and European cup? by leaving it's just a selfish money grab. No consideration for where they came from, the clubs humble beginnings ands it's fans. The timing of the announcement during a pandemic clearly shows the participants don't give a fk for anyone. Sad day for football. It's all driven by Sky - give them no money and ban broadcasts of the games, let them fund themselves. Then we would see who wants a super League ?

(04-20-2021, 05:10 AM)TETLEY74 Wrote:
(04-19-2021, 11:04 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(04-19-2021, 11:02 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote: Good to see they are keeping it real on H & V with one poster saying Villa was the biggest club in the World until the 1950s and another saying they were the biggest club in English football until the 1980s, because of something a Rothman's book said in 1973. Seriously.

One very small positive in all this is that it might make them finally realise they are not a big club to anyone outside their own support, but I wouldn't bet on that happening.

If they are excluded from the European dream, their American owners won't keep spunking the cash.
And money is the very reason why we all know the remaining 14 prem teams will not be able to agree what to do ,the Prem and FA will cave in for fear of loosing its cash cows and the big 6 will get more or less what they want and everyone else will have to make do with the crumbs left. And if that happens im done with it and hope Albion never set foot in the prem again, personally id rather watch us in L1 or L2 infront of 9k or so fans playing honest football against honest teams and not be associated with that corrupt ,greed driven sleaze that is the prem ,no doubt plenty on here will disagree but at the moment thats me onions.

A charity game with whole family involvement is far more entertaining. 
The beautiful game lost its way when Sky corrupted the game and clubs owners sold out to the highest bidders. Probably Chelsea led the way ATT.


RE: European super League - Shabby Russian - 04-20-2021

The more i think about this, the less sure i am about this will play out.

The breakaway clubs seem very determined to form this league, but this determination has yet to be tested. It seems to me that they want to remain in their domestic leagues, are they prepared to risk this for the league. I am not aware of this question being asked of them and what their response would be. I find it hard to believe that these clubs are prepared to give up domestic competition for this'super' league, but the plans for it appear to be a long way down the road, perhaps too far to turn round?

On the other hand, the rest of football seems determined they won't be allowed to enter domestic competitions, but push comes to shove what will they compromise on to make them stay ?

Looks like a question of who will blink first.

I have been an advocate of a super league for some time, to allow greater competition. The top european clubs are so dominant that there is very little domestic competition (with the exception of the UK), making domestic competitions increasingly boring. Juventus, Munich and PSG most seasons have a stroll to their domestic league title.

I said yesterday that the championship is a template for what a league should be like, but even here there is a danger that there is a small elite number of clubs who have a massive financial advantage which increasingly is providing an advantage on the pitch. Surely as fans we want a league where as far as possible, the key determinants to success is good coaching, scouting and player development, not financial muscle.


RE: European super League - Fulham Fallout - 04-20-2021

(04-20-2021, 07:49 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: The more i think about this, the less sure i am about this will play out.

The breakaway clubs seem very determined to form this league, but this determination has yet to be tested. It seems to me that they want to remain in their domestic leagues, are they prepared to risk this for the league. I am not aware of this question being asked of them and what their response would be. I find it hard to believe that these clubs are prepared to give up domestic competition for this'super' league, but the plans for it appear to be a long way down the road, perhaps too far to turn round?

On the other hand, the rest of football seems determined they won't be allowed to enter domestic competitions, but push comes to shove what will they compromise on to make them stay ?

Looks like a question of who will blink first.

I have been an advocate of a super league for some time, to allow greater competition. The top european clubs are so dominant that there is very little domestic competition (with the exception of the UK), making domestic competitions increasingly boring. Juventus, Munich and PSG most seasons have a stroll to their domestic league title.

I said yesterday that the championship is a template for what a league should be like, but even here there is a danger that there is a small elite number of clubs who have a massive financial advantage which increasingly is providing an advantage on the pitch. Surely as fans we want a league where as far as possible, the key determinants to success is good coaching, scouting and player development, not financial muscle.

Safety net. If the super league isn’t a financial success they will scrap it and they are still in their respective domestic leagues.  If it is a financial success, then no doubt they would withdraw from domestic leagues and competitions.


RE: European super League - Derek Hardballs - 04-20-2021

(04-20-2021, 07:49 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: The more i think about this, the less sure i am about this will play out.

The breakaway clubs seem very determined to form this league, but this determination has yet to be tested. It seems to me that they want to remain in their domestic leagues, are they prepared to risk this for the league. I am not aware of this question being asked of them and what their response would be. I find it hard to believe that these clubs are prepared to give up domestic competition for this'super' league, but the plans for it appear to be a long way down the road, perhaps too far to turn round?

On the other hand, the rest of football seems determined they won't be allowed to enter domestic competitions, but push comes to shove what will they compromise on to make them stay ?

Looks like a question of who will blink first.

I have been an advocate of a super league for some time, to allow greater competition. The top european clubs are so dominant that there is very little domestic competition (with the exception of the UK), making domestic competitions increasingly boring. Juventus, Munich and PSG most seasons have a stroll to their domestic league title.

I said yesterday that the championship is a template for what a league should be like, but even here there is a danger that there is a small elite number of clubs who have a massive financial advantage which increasingly is providing an advantage on the pitch. Surely as fans we want a league where as far as possible, the key determinants to success is good coaching, scouting and player development, not financial muscle.

Unless you put a salary cap and transfer fee ceiling in place you’re never going to create a level playing field. Big city clubs are still going to generate more money, their potential to spend will outstrip other teams in smaller cities and towns. As a fan I want a level playing field but I cannot see any club within the current system voting for it at Prem or Championship level.


RE: European super League - Sliced - 04-20-2021

(04-20-2021, 07:58 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(04-20-2021, 07:49 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: The more i think about this, the less sure i am about this will play out.

The breakaway clubs seem very determined to form this league, but this determination has yet to be tested. It seems to me that they want to remain in their domestic leagues, are they prepared to risk this for the league. I am not aware of this question being asked of them and what their response would be. I find it hard to believe that these clubs are prepared to give up domestic competition for this'super' league, but the plans for it appear to be a long way down the road, perhaps too far to turn round?

On the other hand, the rest of football seems determined they won't be allowed to enter domestic competitions, but push comes to shove what will they compromise on to make them stay ?

Looks like a question of who will blink first.

I have been an advocate of a super league for some time, to allow greater competition. The top european clubs are so dominant that there is very little domestic competition (with the exception of the UK), making domestic competitions increasingly boring. Juventus, Munich and PSG most seasons have a stroll to their domestic league title.

I said yesterday that the championship is a template for what a league should be like, but even here there is a danger that there is a small elite number of clubs who have a massive financial advantage which increasingly is providing an advantage on the pitch. Surely as fans we want a league where as far as possible, the key determinants to success is good coaching, scouting and player development, not financial muscle.

Safety net. If the super league isn’t a financial success they will scrap it and they are still in their respective domestic leagues.  If it is a financial success, then no doubt they would withdraw from domestic leagues and competitions.

This is true. However if it was a choice of one or the other the feeling I get is that they would go for the Super League


RE: European super League - Rustynail - 04-20-2021

If the American influence which this clearly is filters down to the game how long do you think they will stretch out the actual length of a 90 minute game, when they can get a 60 minute game to take hours to complete.

I suppose everyone will get game time when they switch defensive and offensive "teams" on the fly from the 50 man match day squad.

Then they could lose the nets, extend the posts and introduce a child size rugby ball, painting lines every 10m down the pitch.

Then all they need to do is buy up some ladies rounders teams ...


RE: European super League - Shabby Russian - 04-20-2021

(04-20-2021, 07:58 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(04-20-2021, 07:49 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: The more i think about this, the less sure i am about this will play out.

The breakaway clubs seem very determined to form this league, but this determination has yet to be tested. It seems to me that they want to remain in their domestic leagues, are they prepared to risk this for the league. I am not aware of this question being asked of them and what their response would be. I find it hard to believe that these clubs are prepared to give up domestic competition for this'super' league, but the plans for it appear to be a long way down the road, perhaps too far to turn round?

On the other hand, the rest of football seems determined they won't be allowed to enter domestic competitions, but push comes to shove what will they compromise on to make them stay ?

Looks like a question of who will blink first.

I have been an advocate of a super league for some time, to allow greater competition. The top european clubs are so dominant that there is very little domestic competition (with the exception of the UK), making domestic competitions increasingly boring. Juventus, Munich and PSG most seasons have a stroll to their domestic league title.

I said yesterday that the championship is a template for what a league should be like, but even here there is a danger that there is a small elite number of clubs who have a massive financial advantage which increasingly is providing an advantage on the pitch. Surely as fans we want a league where as far as possible, the key determinants to success is good coaching, scouting and player development, not financial muscle.

Safety net. If the super league isn’t a financial success they will scrap it and they are still in their respective domestic leagues.  If it is a financial success, then no doubt they would withdraw from domestic leagues and competitions.

I was thinking more of what would happen if they were given an ultimatum by the rest of football, choose between domestic competition and the super league. That choice will have to be made before they can determine if the new league will be a success or not.


RE: European super League - ChamonixBaggie - 04-20-2021

I've not kept abreast of the ins and outs of this one. Is the intention to stay in the their domestic leagues, NOT play in the current Champions League and form the Super League instead? What would the ESL give these clubs that the current incarnation of the Champion's League isn't giving them already?


RE: European super League - Peachy - 04-20-2021

(04-20-2021, 08:15 AM)Rustynail Wrote: If the American influence which this clearly is filters down to the game how long do you think they will stretch out the actual length of a 90 minute game, when they can get a 60 minute game to take hours to complete.

I suppose everyone will get game time when they switch defensive and offensive "teams" on the fly from the 50 man match day squad.

Then they could lose the nets, extend the posts and introduce a child size rugby ball, painting lines every 10m down the pitch.

Then all they need to do is buy up some ladies rounders teams ...

It sounds far fetched but this is the way that it could go in the ESL. They will govern themselves and will be law makers. Nothing will be off limits imo. Very dangerous ground imo.

If I was a true supporter of one of those clubs I would be genuinely gutted.