WBAUnofficial
Cricket World Cup Thread - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Cricket World Cup Thread (/showthread.php?tid=31401)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35


RE: Cricket World Cup Thread - pindgill - 11-05-2023

(11-05-2023, 03:23 PM)spudgun Wrote: This has been an absolutely woeful tournament so far, has there been a single close and exciting game?

I'm sure that the ICC will be delighted by India's performances on home turf, but the location and timing of this tournament has not delivered the exciting and competitive cricket that a world cup deserves

Absolute nonsense “woeful tournament” only because England have been so uncompetitive & just so crap.
This WC has been great if your team is in the semi's or has a real chance to be there.
Financially this WC has been the most profitable every ground have been full for the India matches and good for the other games too tv audiences have been record breaking for the India matches and very good for others.
The format should get the best 4 teams into the semi's with every team playing each other however ODI WCs are to long should be reduced to 5 weeks max can be done by increasing squads to 23 players & teams playing 2/3 times a week.
Be happy by watching a great India team if they win they will be comparable to the great Aussie WC winners of the early 2000s.


RE: Cricket World Cup Thread - Borin' Baggie - 11-05-2023

(11-05-2023, 05:44 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Well at least one of the major favourites are out and Afghanistan... a relative minnow ... has a chance of getting to the semi finals. But why facts get in the way of another dig at the tournament and the organisers. The World Cup should be about the best teams contesting the final stages. In this case it seems that's how it will end up. Just because England have failed shouldn't be used as an excuse to bash the rest of the tournament.

If they had used the same format as 2015 then Afghanistan would have been through to the quarter finals. The format was shit four years ago and it's shit now. It is purely designed to ensure that there's an England v Australia game and an India v Pakistan game, nothing to do with sporting integrity. The World Cup is the ICC's premier tournament and is a central part in growing the game and enabling opportunities for growth in the sport, the Champions Trophy already exists for a competition with a small number of teams.

And I'm sorry but the organisation of the tournament has been shambolic. That has nothing to do with England. Issues with air quality in Delhi have been known for a long time and there's a game in doubt because of that. Need I mention the ticketing timetabling and the fallout from that? Or the "opening ceremony" not happening until several games in? Or the complete lack of advertising (not just in England but also IN INDIA).

And, I repeat, this has nothing to do with England's performances. I have zero idea why you would need to link the tournament organisation with how England have performed.


RE: Cricket World Cup Thread - rsbaggy2 - 11-05-2023

(11-05-2023, 06:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 05:44 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Well at least one of the major favourites are out and Afghanistan... a relative minnow ... has a chance of getting to the semi finals. But why facts get in the way of another dig at the tournament and the organisers. The World Cup should be about the best teams contesting the final stages. In this case it seems that's how it will end up. Just because England have failed shouldn't be used as an excuse to bash the rest of the tournament.

If they had used the same format as 2015 then Afghanistan would have been through to the quarter finals. The format was shit four years ago and it's shit now. It is purely designed to ensure that there's an England v Australia game and an India v Pakistan game, nothing to do with sporting integrity. The World Cup is the ICC's premier tournament and is a central part in growing the game and enabling opportunities for growth in the sport, the Champions Trophy already exists for a competition with a small number of teams.

And I'm sorry but the organisation of the tournament has been shambolic. That has nothing to do with England. Issues with air quality in Delhi have been known for a long time and there's a game in doubt because of that. Need I mention the ticketing timetabling and the fallout from that? Or the "opening ceremony" not happening until several games in? Or the complete lack of advertising (not just in England but also IN INDIA).

And, I repeat, this has nothing to do with England's performances. I have zero idea why you would need to link the tournament organisation with how England have performed.
I haven't linked it. I'm saying don't let the abject failure of the holders to start picking holes in the rest of the tournament.

(11-05-2023, 06:43 PM)spudgun Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 05:44 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Well at least one of the major favourites are out and Afghanistan... a relative minnow ... has a chance of getting to the semi finals. But why facts get in the way of another dig at the tournament and the organisers. The World Cup should be about the best teams contesting the final stages. In this case it seems that's how it will end up. Just because England have failed shouldn't be used as an excuse to bash the rest of the tournament.

My critique of the tournament has nothing to do with England's lacklustre performance, it is, however, a critique of how many of the games have been one sided and provide little entertainment for a cricket or sport lover. 

The best way to grow interest in the game is to offer a competitive and exciting spectacle and that is something that this tournament has absolutely failed to deliver. The world cup should be offering the best of the sport and acting as a showcase, but almost without exception, it has only produced one sided games that offer nothing of interest.

India have been head and shoulders above everyone else so far, but the ICC need to take a serious look at themselves as other than delivering a win for the numerous and thoroughly engaged Indian fans, this tournament has done nothing to boost interest in the game and it should never have been held in this location at this time of the year. Perhaps the next tournament should be in Durham in March?

Given the way the way the MCC arranged the cricket this year I wouldn't put that past them!


RE: Cricket World Cup Thread - Borin' Baggie - 11-05-2023

(11-05-2023, 07:12 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 06:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 05:44 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Well at least one of the major favourites are out and Afghanistan... a relative minnow ... has a chance of getting to the semi finals. But why facts get in the way of another dig at the tournament and the organisers. The World Cup should be about the best teams contesting the final stages. In this case it seems that's how it will end up. Just because England have failed shouldn't be used as an excuse to bash the rest of the tournament.

If they had used the same format as 2015 then Afghanistan would have been through to the quarter finals. The format was shit four years ago and it's shit now. It is purely designed to ensure that there's an England v Australia game and an India v Pakistan game, nothing to do with sporting integrity. The World Cup is the ICC's premier tournament and is a central part in growing the game and enabling opportunities for growth in the sport, the Champions Trophy already exists for a competition with a small number of teams.

And I'm sorry but the organisation of the tournament has been shambolic. That has nothing to do with England. Issues with air quality in Delhi have been known for a long time and there's a game in doubt because of that. Need I mention the ticketing timetabling and the fallout from that? Or the "opening ceremony" not happening until several games in? Or the complete lack of advertising (not just in England but also IN INDIA).

And, I repeat, this has nothing to do with England's performances. I have zero idea why you would need to link the tournament organisation with how England have performed.
I haven't linked it. I'm saying don't let the abject failure of the holders to start picking holes in the rest of the tournament.

The organisation of the tournament has nothing to do with how shit England have been. And these issues have been present since the start (who schedules ticket sales to start the month before a tournament?)


RE: Cricket World Cup Thread - rsbaggy2 - 11-05-2023

(11-05-2023, 07:25 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 07:12 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 06:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 05:44 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Well at least one of the major favourites are out and Afghanistan... a relative minnow ... has a chance of getting to the semi finals. But why facts get in the way of another dig at the tournament and the organisers. The World Cup should be about the best teams contesting the final stages. In this case it seems that's how it will end up. Just because England have failed shouldn't be used as an excuse to bash the rest of the tournament.

If they had used the same format as 2015 then Afghanistan would have been through to the quarter finals. The format was shit four years ago and it's shit now. It is purely designed to ensure that there's an England v Australia game and an India v Pakistan game, nothing to do with sporting integrity. The World Cup is the ICC's premier tournament and is a central part in growing the game and enabling opportunities for growth in the sport, the Champions Trophy already exists for a competition with a small number of teams.

And I'm sorry but the organisation of the tournament has been shambolic. That has nothing to do with England. Issues with air quality in Delhi have been known for a long time and there's a game in doubt because of that. Need I mention the ticketing timetabling and the fallout from that? Or the "opening ceremony" not happening until several games in? Or the complete lack of advertising (not just in England but also IN INDIA).

And, I repeat, this has nothing to do with England's performances. I have zero idea why you would need to link the tournament organisation with how England have performed.
I haven't linked it. I'm saying don't let the abject failure of the holders to start picking holes in the rest of the tournament.

The organisation of the tournament has nothing to do with how shit England have been. And these issues have been present since the start (who schedules ticket sales to start the month before a tournament?)
England fail. Let's look for shit to demean the tournament. The 4 best teams will qualify for the semis. That's what a world cup is about.


RE: Cricket World Cup Thread - Borin' Baggie - 11-05-2023

(11-05-2023, 07:30 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 07:25 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 07:12 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 06:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 05:44 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Well at least one of the major favourites are out and Afghanistan... a relative minnow ... has a chance of getting to the semi finals. But why facts get in the way of another dig at the tournament and the organisers. The World Cup should be about the best teams contesting the final stages. In this case it seems that's how it will end up. Just because England have failed shouldn't be used as an excuse to bash the rest of the tournament.

If they had used the same format as 2015 then Afghanistan would have been through to the quarter finals. The format was shit four years ago and it's shit now. It is purely designed to ensure that there's an England v Australia game and an India v Pakistan game, nothing to do with sporting integrity. The World Cup is the ICC's premier tournament and is a central part in growing the game and enabling opportunities for growth in the sport, the Champions Trophy already exists for a competition with a small number of teams.

And I'm sorry but the organisation of the tournament has been shambolic. That has nothing to do with England. Issues with air quality in Delhi have been known for a long time and there's a game in doubt because of that. Need I mention the ticketing timetabling and the fallout from that? Or the "opening ceremony" not happening until several games in? Or the complete lack of advertising (not just in England but also IN INDIA).

And, I repeat, this has nothing to do with England's performances. I have zero idea why you would need to link the tournament organisation with how England have performed.
I haven't linked it. I'm saying don't let the abject failure of the holders to start picking holes in the rest of the tournament.

The organisation of the tournament has nothing to do with how shit England have been. And these issues have been present since the start (who schedules ticket sales to start the month before a tournament?)
England fail. Let's look for shit to demean the tournament. The 4 best teams will qualify for the semis. That's what a world cup is about.

I don't know about Spud but I've been talking about how shambolic the planning is with an Indian mate of mine from uni, from India, since before the tournament started.

Hell, one of the issues about tournament structure was brought up 4 years ago as well.

As for "what a World Cup is about", you need only look at the Netherlands beating South Africa, Afghanistan beating England or Portugal winning in the Rugby World Cup and Argentina getting to the semi finals to see it's not just about "the best". The best performers will always get through, meanwhile the Netherlands and Afghanistan play fuck all 50 over cricket and there's countless other countries that have so little opportunity in that regard and the World Cup is the ICC's opportunity to grow the game which they're passing up to ensure there's always an England v Australia match and an India v Pakistan match.


RE: Cricket World Cup Thread - Cuzer - 11-05-2023

(11-05-2023, 12:38 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 11:04 AM)Cuzer Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 07:02 AM)pindgill Wrote: When you’re so underprepared for a WC that’s arrogance!!..
Very easy to say draw a line under this tournament the abject performances & results mean England will have to beat the Netherlands very well to stand any chance of qualifying for the 2025 ICC championship.

Yes and the fact they didn’t realise that until 5 days ago tells you everything about the focus applied to this tournament

Cuzer

Mccullum had a very significant "new manager" bounce. Everything went his way. However his demeanour was always over relaxed and this extended into what appears to be arrogance. In turn this will always permeate a squad that was very tight knit. This cannot be sustained for any length of time and when you get found out or stumble the fall can be spectacular. Serious introspection is needed and there should be no sacred cows!

Hang on

This is a one day tournament, BM has nothing to do with it, even the team is significantly different

Doesn’t matter how much of an anti England agenda you carry it’s borderline impossible to criticize Mccullam and Key for what a shot in the arm they’ve given test cricket

Cuzer

It’s a shame Pindgill and RS have now shown their true colors and nobody dare have any criticism of anything Indian and cricket, dear me

Points are valid, look at the state of the outfields FFS, you’ll see better in the Birmingham league in May!

ICB have put a lot of effort into the tournament, it’s not for the want of trying but the points about uncompetitive games is seriously valid, dew and conditions are playing way too much of a part and the traveling seems to be taking its toll on all and sundry

Oh, and before you wet your knickers this is no slant on the Indian team on the pitch who have performed superbly and will need shooting if they don’t raise the trophy from here. Clearly the best side in the comp

Cuzer


RE: Cricket World Cup Thread - rsbaggy2 - 11-05-2023

(11-05-2023, 08:06 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 12:38 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 11:04 AM)Cuzer Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 07:02 AM)pindgill Wrote: When you’re so underprepared for a WC that’s arrogance!!..
Very easy to say draw a line under this tournament the abject performances & results mean England will have to beat the Netherlands very well to stand any chance of qualifying for the 2025 ICC championship.

Yes and the fact they didn’t realise that until 5 days ago tells you everything about the focus applied to this tournament

Cuzer

Mccullum had a very significant "new manager" bounce. Everything went his way. However his demeanour was always over relaxed and this extended into what appears to be arrogance. In turn this will always permeate a squad that was very tight knit. This cannot be sustained for any length of time and when you get found out or stumble the fall can be spectacular. Serious introspection is needed and there should be no sacred cows!

Hang on

This is a one day tournament, BM has nothing to do with it, even the team is significantly different

Doesn’t matter how much of an anti England agenda you carry it’s borderline impossible to criticize Mccullam and Key for what a shot in the arm they’ve given test cricket

Cuzer

It’s a shame Pindgill and RS have now shown their true colors and nobody dare have any criticism of anything Indian and cricket, dear me

Points are valid, look at the state of the outfields FFS, you’ll see better in the Birmingham league in May!

ICB have put a lot of effort into the tournament, it’s not for the want of trying but the points about uncompetitive games is seriously valid, dew and conditions are playing way too much of a part and the traveling seems to be taking its toll on all and sundry

Oh, and before you wet your knickers this is no slant on the Indian team on the pitch who have performed superbly and will need shooting if they don’t raise the trophy from here. Clearly the best side in the comp

Cuzer
Would we get so much bleating about the external factors if England had performed to their expected levels? I think not but it's a genuine question. The majority of chat would have been about on field matters.  Just my opinion. 
But anyway it's been a delight to see teams like Afghanistan and the Netherlands have overperformed. 
Your praise of India is accepted and well founded. 
Of course there has been no mention of the cricketing achievement of the most ODI centuries by that master batsmen .. one Virat Kohli. Should I be surprised? Not really I guess.


RE: Cricket World Cup Thread - Cuzer - 11-05-2023

Loffin'

I'd say you pair would defend Indian cricket more than you would defend your own kids! Blind loyalty or madness, you decide

I'm not getting drawn in, pretty well documented I've little interest in the ODI game, Test's all day for me. I see your man got a ton today didn't he? I genuinely haven't watched much, turned off most the games when you've quickly seen the result is a formality, including our capitulation

I'd like to think as Albion fans on an Albion board the comments would be the same whether England were top of the group or bottom, petty point scoring is all a bit pathetic if you think that's what it is? I think the bleating as you put it is purely based on people's observations

Cuzer


RE: Cricket World Cup Thread - Tom Joad - 11-06-2023

(11-05-2023, 08:33 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 08:06 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 12:38 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 11:04 AM)Cuzer Wrote:
(11-05-2023, 07:02 AM)pindgill Wrote: When you’re so underprepared for a WC that’s arrogance!!..
Very easy to say draw a line under this tournament the abject performances & results mean England will have to beat the Netherlands very well to stand any chance of qualifying for the 2025 ICC championship.

Yes and the fact they didn’t realise that until 5 days ago tells you everything about the focus applied to this tournament

Cuzer

Mccullum had a very significant "new manager" bounce. Everything went his way. However his demeanour was always over relaxed and this extended into what appears to be arrogance. In turn this will always permeate a squad that was very tight knit. This cannot be sustained for any length of time and when you get found out or stumble the fall can be spectacular. Serious introspection is needed and there should be no sacred cows!

Hang on

This is a one day tournament, BM has nothing to do with it, even the team is significantly different

Doesn’t matter how much of an anti England agenda you carry it’s borderline impossible to criticize Mccullam and Key for what a shot in the arm they’ve given test cricket

Cuzer

It’s a shame Pindgill and RS have now shown their true colors and nobody dare have any criticism of anything Indian and cricket, dear me

Points are valid, look at the state of the outfields FFS, you’ll see better in the Birmingham league in May!

ICB have put a lot of effort into the tournament, it’s not for the want of trying but the points about uncompetitive games is seriously valid, dew and conditions are playing way too much of a part and the traveling seems to be taking its toll on all and sundry

Oh, and before you wet your knickers this is no slant on the Indian team on the pitch who have performed superbly and will need shooting if they don’t raise the trophy from here. Clearly the best side in the comp

Cuzer
Would we get so much bleating about the external factors if England had performed to their expected levels? I think not but it's a genuine question. The majority of chat would have been about on field matters.  Just my opinion. 
But anyway it's been a delight to see teams like Afghanistan and the Netherlands have overperformed. 
Your praise of India is accepted and well founded. 
Of course there has been no mention of the cricketing achievement of the most ODI centuries by that master batsmen .. one Virat Kohli. Should I be surprised? Not really I guess.
Probably right. England have been dire. There are no excuses for such a no show. The home team are strong and the short form of the game is so loved there. They should win it, fair play.  I genuinely hope the disconnect between our test team and our 50 over team is as it looks and the test team manage to get a game or 2 before Hydrebad. Kohli winds me up, but luckily he hasn't hurt us much in 5 day cricket recently, we love a pantomime villain.  If anyone is out there next feb/ march, We'll be there at Ranchi and Dharamsala. Flights and hotels booked, just a little disappointed Eden Gardens isn't one, it was one of my main ambitions to visit as a kid,  after the MCG.