WBAUnofficial
Toby Collyer - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Toby Collyer (/showthread.php?tid=42427)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21


RE: Toby Collyer - SW4Baggie - 08-28-2026

(08-28-2026, 09:02 AM)AlsoKeithCurlesToePoke Wrote: Wherever he ends up, I'm not keen. Overpriced for what he is owing to his origins. Is he the next Ronnie Wallwork, minus the scrap car spares?

Thing is, we don't really now what the likely fee is - so it's hard to say whether he's overpriced or not... The only price mooted was a relatively dubious source saying 3M which is probably about right when you consider we got 2.5M for Bielik!

The fact both us and Hull have tried to sign him suggests his body must be better than we as fans think. If he was such a crock, 2 clubs where he's spent several months training daily wouldn't be keen to pay a fee for him IMO.


RE: Toby Collyer - Wednesburybaggie - 08-28-2026

(08-28-2026, 08:32 AM)MGalea Wrote: Collyer loves the Baggies.

I get a whiff of Darren Fletcher having a word here.

My thoughts exactly.


RE: Toby Collyer - Cheshire East Baggie - 08-28-2026

Could be a commuting thing. South Manchester footballer-belt to Walsall is a doable daily commute. Hull is twice as far and an absolute bastard of a journey. He's a Southern softie, not a Manc from the mean streets. I reckon we'd suit him far better than Hull City.

Rabby Nzingoula has shaped up OK in what we've seen so far. I still think if we sign Collyer, we're at risk of a decent bid for Molumby on deadline day which Shilen Patel can't refuse. Whether that achieves the result of "moving us on" from limited players like Jayse, or leaves us short remains to be seen. Could a big money bid for Diakite upset Mozza's plans? It's the not knowing that makes it so exciting.


RE: Toby Collyer - Lurker#3 - 08-28-2026

Midfield will be sorted if we get Collyer apart from perhaps another loan winger to cover.

Lots of flexibility in there too.

Players who can play centrally in the championship as a 2:
Diakite
Collyer
Molumby
Rabby
Horny

Defensive options out wide:
Molumby
Rabby
Styles
Galvez

Possession based wide midfielders:
Horny
Price
Whitwell

Width and pace:
Tunde
MJ
Bany?

Gives us flexibility for sure, but unless Bany keeps fit and can offer another attacking wide option, I still feel we're short.


RE: Toby Collyer - PatelsPlatoon - 08-28-2026

A southern boy called Toby going to Hull! I don't think so.

Jokes apart- it's 1hr 37 from the Man U training ground to us. Most of their players live south of there, in Cheshire, so probably 1hr 10-1hr 20 currently from us.
Hull will almost certainly be relegated, despite their great start. If it was Sunderland or Newcastle I think he'd be mad, but I guess he has to weigh up what he feels suits him best.


RE: Toby Collyer - Dumbo - 08-28-2026

My view is this.

If Collyer signs for Hull. He’s not that good and I never wanted him.

If Collyer sings for us. He’s got massive potential and Baggies are winning the World Cup.


RE: Toby Collyer - Duffers - 08-28-2026

(08-28-2026, 09:07 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-28-2026, 09:02 AM)AlsoKeithCurlesToePoke Wrote: Wherever he ends up, I'm not keen. Overpriced for what he is owing to his origins. Is he the next Ronnie Wallwork, minus the scrap car spares?

Thing is, we don't really now what the likely fee is - so it's hard to say whether he's overpriced or not... The only price mooted was a relatively dubious source saying 3M which is probably about right when you consider we got 2.5M for Bielik!

The fact both us and Hull have tried to sign him suggests his body must be better than we as fans think. If he was such a crock, 2 clubs where he's spent several months training daily wouldn't be keen to pay a fee for him IMO.

In terms of fees it sounds like it would be close to a straight swap for Bielek.

Feels like a punt worth taking to me.


RE: Toby Collyer - Johnnykayeengland - 08-28-2026

(08-28-2026, 09:40 AM)Dumbo Wrote: My view is this.

If Collyer signs for Hull. He’s not that good and I never wanted him.

If Collyer sings for us. He’s got massive potential and Baggies are winning the World Cup.

At last! The voice of Reason   Heart


RE: Toby Collyer - SW4Baggie - 08-28-2026

(08-28-2026, 09:40 AM)Dumbo Wrote: My view is this.

If Collyer signs for Hull. He’s not that good and I never wanted him.

If Collyer sings for us. He’s got massive potential and Baggies are winning the World Cup.

Sign of the optimism around the place - usually it's the opposite on ere Big Grin


RE: Toby Collyer - Bartley_baggie - 08-28-2026

(08-28-2026, 09:11 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Could be a commuting thing. South Manchester footballer-belt to Walsall is a doable daily commute. Hull is twice as far and an absolute bastard of a journey. He's a Southern softie, not a Manc from the mean streets. I reckon we'd suit him far better than Hull City.

Rabby Nzingoula has shaped up OK in what we've seen so far. I still think if we sign Collyer, we're at risk of a decent bid for Molumby on deadline day which Shilen Patel can't refuse. Whether that achieves the result of "moving us on" from limited players like Jayse, or leaves us short remains to be seen. Could a big money bid for Diakite upset Mozza's plans? It's the not knowing that makes it so exciting.
If it was a choice I would honestly rather keep Molumby, we always look a better team when he’s on the pitch even with his so called “limitations “