WBAUnofficial
Growth - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Growth (/showthread.php?tid=37673)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39


RE: Growth - baggy1 - 06-17-2025

(06-17-2025, 11:48 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Your "A bit" is my marginal tax rate going up by 50%. Sorry pal, but no one in their right mind who had the choice would bother.

There's not a tax expert alive who'd disagree with me either. Creating disincentives like this whilst, apparently, being "laser focused on growth" is just laughable. Don't even get me on to the Non Dom story above - "let's put people off living and investing in the UK whilst being laser focused on growth". Our government is in thrall to Treasury orthodoxy which prioritises the numbers adding up next year over sense. In terms of the depressing effect on the economy it's up there with the idiotic timing of Truss.

Your use of % masks the reality - for a quarter of your earnings to that point your tax rate will go up by half of what is was for a limited amount (£25k). Beyond that point you will only be taxed on an extra 5% of what you were paying before that point. There are ways to avoid that, you could pay more into your pension tax free for you to use in later life at a much lower tax rate. Me personally I'd put the 40% rate up to 41% and scrap the removal of the PA and tax everything over the £100k at 45%, that would raise more revenue for the government but you'd have legions of Chunks exploding simultaneously which would reduce the income again.


RE: Growth - Protheroe - 06-17-2025

The reality isn't "masked" for me or any of the poor saps hit by a marginal rate in excess of 70% when they hit £50,000 (if you include child benefit for a couple of kids and student loans). The reality is a chunky disincentive to put in more hours, or indeed the same hours as I was.

You seem to be defending the kind of tax cliff edges that no one sane would introduce. You're too intelligent to do that, surely?


RE: Growth - baggy1 - 06-17-2025

You’ve seen what I would do above and also a mass simplification of the basic tax system is overdue. But it is what it is at the moment and saying I’m not going to earn more money because the nett hourly rate isn’t as good is basically saying I’ll stop improving my life because it benefits the country more as well.


RE: Growth - Protheroe - 06-17-2025

That’s exactly what it’s saying, and what purpose does that serve for either the individual or the Treasury? This is the essence of quiet quitting


RE: Growth - baggy1 - 06-17-2025

So basically if it wasn’t for these tax thresholds you’d be working as hard as ever generating growth for the nation and not just be on the glide path. I’m calling bullshit here. You’re not talking to some kid who isn’t in the same position as you. We’re both about the same age, have done enough to make our retirement comfortable and are winding down. You just want a last moan before you pack it in and can blame it on the taxation cliff edges.


RE: Growth - tHEgLASSdOORS - 06-17-2025

Trouble is, for that to resonate, it would need an ability to process information outside of the notion that the world revolves around the person.

You’re absolutely spot on, but pissing in the wind hoping it’ll hit home.


RE: Growth - CarlosCorbewrong - 06-18-2025

It’s not retirement, it’s an ideological two fingers up to The Man, dude.


RE: Growth - Protheroe - 06-18-2025

(06-17-2025, 08:38 PM)baggy1 Wrote: So basically if it wasn’t for these tax thresholds you’d be working as hard as ever generating growth for the nation and not just be on the glide path. I’m calling bullshit here. You’re not talking to some kid who isn’t in the same position as you. We’re both about the same age, have done enough to make our retirement comfortable and are winding down. You just want a last moan before you pack it in and can blame it on the taxation cliff edges.

No. I'd like a government apparently "lasered focused on growth" to adopt a fiscal policy that isn't counter productive to that. That's all.

It's a demonstration of how utterly fucking useless the political class is that they're unable to process what's happening at £50K where people are refusing promotions, extra hours or additional responsibility as it's not worth as little as 30p in the £, and at £100K where in some cases people at best will take home 40p in the £ and in some cases won't make any additional money at all until they hit £125K. 

Amongst non-VAT registered sole traders it's even worse, which is why some are only working 8-9 months of the year or raking it in through cash payments completely off the books.

Creating such disincentives is no way to grow an economy. Any fool can see that, can't you?

(06-18-2025, 05:55 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: It’s not retirement, it’s an ideological two fingers up to The Man, dude.

Big Grin It's that as well.


RE: Growth - baggy1 - 06-18-2025

2nd time you've tried the 'fool / too intelligent' comment and not worked either time. It simply is what it is and always has been and always will, I can't remember a government that didn't want growth but here we still are. It's a bit of a nonsense though isn't it, you complain about the child tax credit cliff edge but obviously you powered through it at the time. My approach was not to get it as a) we didn't need it and b) I couldn't be arsed with the self assessment element of it. It didn't stop me earning more at the time as the 100k doesn't now. If someone is daft enough to not see the future promotions to stave off a limited time state benefit then that says more about their long term plans and aspirations. There are these sort of benefit cliff edges everywhere but complaining about the state on one hand and taking the benefits of the state on the other does sound a bit hypocritical.

Non-VAT registered sole traders wouldn't be worried about the 100k element but again the net is closing with MTD requirement intro level dropping to 50k from next year so they will get you either way.


RE: Growth - Protheroe - 06-18-2025

I'm sorry, we just don't appear to be on the same wavelength. Simply put, a government focused on growth would not design a tax system that is disincentivising that for many people including me. Let's just leave it there. I'm sure you're not defending the current system, so I'm not exactly sure what we're arguing about.