RE: Mowbray - Peachy - 02-14-2025
(02-14-2025, 02:11 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-14-2025, 11:28 AM)B68baggy2 Wrote: (02-14-2025, 10:47 AM)richbaggie Wrote: (02-14-2025, 10:33 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (02-14-2025, 10:19 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Yes but of that group of teams we have the strongest squad!
Norwich will be a threat now Sargeant has returned, the best striker in the league . But were no better off under CC who is lauded as a mastermind.
My view was, and is, that CC will become an excellent coach, and we were lucky to have him, but, if the squad was so good, why wasn't he doing better? Could it be that our squad isn't as good as we think? After all, ours is the only one we see week in week out so how are we judging the others objectively.
The league never lies, as they say, so, even under CC we had a squad that was somewhere between 5th and 8th. We are currently 6th. If we drop below that then there will be evidence of obvious decline, until then we are punching our weight.
We have a stronger squad now than when CC was here.
I'd agree but add a few caveats.
The addition of Armstrong and Lanky makes the squad stronger but CC had Maja for long periods who was key to the system, as well as scoring goals, and I can't wait to see him and Armstrong play together.
Price looks a class act in the making but he's no ten, neither is Grady and TM for all his initial talk has realised Swift's deficiencies. In the clips I've seen TB looks similar in statue and style to B'burns 10 the other night, here's hoping, which allows Price to drop back.
And finally we've added the above, but also lost possibly the best keeper in the league. We certainly don't concede the first with him in there, and I'm doubtful on the second.
I also agree this is no free hit for Mowbray, and I'm sure the agreed goal with the owners is play offs. However, I don't see failure leading to uncertainty about his future, as he has been bought in to help nurture these new signings.
Finally and finally the idea the TM could just keep what CC did and tweak it is completely underestimating the intensity and detail that Carlos bought to his management. The caretaker team were just a continuation of that for a few games where plans were most likely already in place.
I'm ambitious as a fan but also a pragmatist. All the advantages we built up through our years in the Prem over the rest of the division are now GONE....spunked up the wall by a succession of terrible decisions starting with Rolands appointment of TTITC to protect his investment and then cashing in from the Chinese and fucking off. None of this is on the new owners or current manager, in fact without CC's arrival we could have been in the absolute mucky stuff down in division one and potential receivership. The new owners are planning for the reality of our situation whilst still throwing the odd bone at an immediate chance of promotion.
Take away TMs history and they appointed an experienced and available manager with a track record of success in lower leagues through the development of younger players. Fucking tick. I can't see a situation this season, other than his health, that leads to him not being here at the start of next season However I'm sure Nestor will have learned from the recent recruitment process and have alternatives still in mind.
So backing TM but Blackburn was still fucking desperate and we need to see improvement, and pretty quickly. It's what has happened in his last three jobs, so no reason to think it can't happen here.
One point… we had lost our way before TP arrived not after that’s why he was brought in because our fabled system had malfunctioned because we couldn’t or wouldn’t replace Ashworth with a quality replacement(s). Garlick, Burton, Irvine, Mel and that’s before you get to the players.
Is that the same Richard Garlick that is currently MD of Arsenal? 
But I'm jesting......Garlick, Burton, Irvine and Mel was a desperate mess of a period I agree.
RE: Mowbray - Tom of the Brom - 02-14-2025
(02-14-2025, 10:03 AM)Sliced Wrote: A free hit?! We've got the top assister in the league, we had the top scorer in the league until he got injured so we've now brought in last years second highest scorer as a replacement and that's the one position that everyones been saying is where we're worst off!
Absolutely ZERO excuses for not getting in the playoffs now.
Completely agree , but imo TM problem is that although this squad is good enough to get a playoff place ,he also as,to many players who are inconsistent and that could cost us at the end .If we fail this season then I would give TM till Xmas and if we look like we ain't going to get into the top2 or playoffs then I say we go our separate ways
RE: Mowbray - sickParrot - 02-14-2025
Now that the dust has settled from Blackburn, I am starting to think that despite the way it played out, I do think that we shouldn't be too worried.
For a start, the ref played a big part in that game, 3 big decision look to be incorrect and have gone against us. On top of the the clown allowed the game to defend into a farce. Let's not underestimate how much it fucked us over and helped them.
On top of that, it was 6th vs 5th and we all said before the game that the manager situation could go either way, they also have a centre forward who cant hit a barn door, the script is all too familiar.
The number 9 did one of our players in the first minute, if not was one of ours Sky would be replaying it 100 times with dingle don crying and asking for a ban. He scored, two, should have been 3 really and spent half the game on the floor. Yet not one of our lot had the balls to leave one on him and take a yellow for the team.
RE: Mowbray - Sliced - 02-14-2025
(02-14-2025, 03:40 PM)Tom of the Brom Wrote: (02-14-2025, 10:03 AM)Sliced Wrote: A free hit?! We've got the top assister in the league, we had the top scorer in the league until he got injured so we've now brought in last years second highest scorer as a replacement and that's the one position that everyones been saying is where we're worst off!
Absolutely ZERO excuses for not getting in the playoffs now.
Completely agree , but imo TM problem is that although this squad is good enough to get a playoff place ,he also as,to many players who are inconsistent and that could cost us at the end .If we fail this season then I would give TM till Xmas and if we look like we ain't going to get into the top2 or playoffs then I say we go our separate ways
I don't disagree but he's also got a decent amount of options when players are fit. Don't fancy playing Holgate next game he can put in Ajayi, or he can move Heggem to left back or Frabotta can come in. In the middle of the park Mowatt's been out of form the past couple of games so there's Diakite, or Price, or Swift, wingers we have as many options as any team in the division and now we have a couple of striking options too.
RE: Mowbray - Remi_Moses - 02-14-2025
(02-14-2025, 09:11 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (02-14-2025, 09:00 AM)richbaggie Wrote: (02-14-2025, 08:55 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Mowbray is being too nice, he needs to bin the slackers.
Swift, Wallace and Grady are coasting until they get free transfers is a few weeks time.
Do us all a favour and send them to play with the kids. Play the new lads at least they will run..
If he doesn't nothing changes.
Jed has 18 months left and never lacks effort. When have you ever looked at Jed and thought...there's a slacker. What he lacks is quality.
This.
Also, in fairness to Grady, he has improved since TM took over. The only one I'd agree with is Swift. He should be nowhere near the squad, let alone starting XI.
TBH maybe Jed does try, but his application has fell by the wayside why is that he was way better 12 months ago. Swift runs on occasions as does Grady but the end product is woeful.
Why is that? The all have the talent
RE: Mowbray - KRO - 02-14-2025
(02-14-2025, 09:17 AM)richbaggie Wrote: (02-14-2025, 09:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Ultimately a manager is judged by results within the parameters of resources. We aren’t a nursery for richer clubs to buy our best young players from, after we’ve carefully nutured them. We are a professional football club, with a decent squad that first and foremost should be looking to win promotion. Some seem to have forgotten this, with talk of developing young players and selling them on as a prime concern… that should be by-product of the clubs success on the field it certainly shouldn’t be the main ambition for the next few seasons.
We are the only club in the West Midlands who show this complete lack of ambition for ourselves and it’s distinctly small time.
We are the only club close to getting points docked for PSR, not sure a comparison is fair. Villa are in a different financial world to us, Wolves have been having to sell to survive, Blues are having a free shot outside the PSR constraints. We really aren’t.
It’s a myth
RE: Mowbray - TETLEY74 - 02-14-2025
(02-14-2025, 03:53 PM)sickParrot Wrote: Now that the dust has settled from Blackburn, I am starting to think that despite the way it played out, I do think that we shouldn't be too worried.
For a start, the ref played a big part in that game, 3 big decision look to be incorrect and have gone against us. On top of the the clown allowed the game to defend into a farce. Let's not underestimate how much it fucked us over and helped them.
On top of that, it was 6th vs 5th and we all said before the game that the manager situation could go either way, they also have a centre forward who cant hit a barn door, the script is all too familiar.
The number 9 did one of our players in the first minute, if not was one of ours Sky would be replaying it 100 times with dingle don crying and asking for a ban. He scored, two, should have been 3 really and spent half the game on the floor. Yet not one of our lot had the balls to leave one on him and take a yellow for the team.
If Ally Rob, Clement, Paul Robbo or Jonas had been on the pitch Wednesday that no9 would have been clattered continuously all night.
RE: Mowbray - Tom Joad - 02-14-2025
(02-14-2025, 07:23 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (02-14-2025, 03:53 PM)sickParrot Wrote: Now that the dust has settled from Blackburn, I am starting to think that despite the way it played out, I do think that we shouldn't be too worried.
For a start, the ref played a big part in that game, 3 big decision look to be incorrect and have gone against us. On top of the the clown allowed the game to defend into a farce. Let's not underestimate how much it fucked us over and helped them.
On top of that, it was 6th vs 5th and we all said before the game that the manager situation could go either way, they also have a centre forward who cant hit a barn door, the script is all too familiar.
The number 9 did one of our players in the first minute, if not was one of ours Sky would be replaying it 100 times with dingle don crying and asking for a ban. He scored, two, should have been 3 really and spent half the game on the floor. Yet not one of our lot had the balls to leave one on him and take a yellow for the team.
If Ally Rob, Clement, Paul Robbo or Jonas had been on the pitch Wednesday that no9 would have been clattered continuously all night. Nah, Tetley, just the once would have sufficed.
RE: Mowbray - TETLEY74 - 02-14-2025
(02-14-2025, 07:37 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (02-14-2025, 07:23 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (02-14-2025, 03:53 PM)sickParrot Wrote: Now that the dust has settled from Blackburn, I am starting to think that despite the way it played out, I do think that we shouldn't be too worried.
For a start, the ref played a big part in that game, 3 big decision look to be incorrect and have gone against us. On top of the the clown allowed the game to defend into a farce. Let's not underestimate how much it fucked us over and helped them.
On top of that, it was 6th vs 5th and we all said before the game that the manager situation could go either way, they also have a centre forward who cant hit a barn door, the script is all too familiar.
The number 9 did one of our players in the first minute, if not was one of ours Sky would be replaying it 100 times with dingle don crying and asking for a ban. He scored, two, should have been 3 really and spent half the game on the floor. Yet not one of our lot had the balls to leave one on him and take a yellow for the team.
If Ally Rob, Clement, Paul Robbo or Jonas had been on the pitch Wednesday that no9 would have been clattered continuously all night. Nah, Tetley, just the once would have sufficed.
To be fair Ally Rob would have taken him out within minutes.
RE: Mowbray - Peachy - 02-16-2025
(02-14-2025, 09:08 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (02-14-2025, 07:37 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (02-14-2025, 07:23 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (02-14-2025, 03:53 PM)sickParrot Wrote: Now that the dust has settled from Blackburn, I am starting to think that despite the way it played out, I do think that we shouldn't be too worried.
For a start, the ref played a big part in that game, 3 big decision look to be incorrect and have gone against us. On top of the the clown allowed the game to defend into a farce. Let's not underestimate how much it fucked us over and helped them.
On top of that, it was 6th vs 5th and we all said before the game that the manager situation could go either way, they also have a centre forward who cant hit a barn door, the script is all too familiar.
The number 9 did one of our players in the first minute, if not was one of ours Sky would be replaying it 100 times with dingle don crying and asking for a ban. He scored, two, should have been 3 really and spent half the game on the floor. Yet not one of our lot had the balls to leave one on him and take a yellow for the team.
If Ally Rob, Clement, Paul Robbo or Jonas had been on the pitch Wednesday that no9 would have been clattered continuously all night. Nah, Tetley, just the once would have sufficed.
To be fair Ally Rob would have taken him out within minutes.
So would Bart's. That's why I was so annoyed at that game. Bartley loves a big number 9 battle. He would have been in his element. The lad bullied Holgate imo.
|