WBAUnofficial
MP to Al-Hilal - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: MP to Al-Hilal (/showthread.php?tid=20129)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29


RE: MP to Al-Hilal - DJPunkRoc - 08-05-2021

Interesting negotiation but there's a simple way of improving our position:

Declare very publicly that, because of Al Hilal's actions we, resolutely, will not sell to them. MP remains 'for sale' but not to anybody who, in our opinion rather that FIFA's, engages in actions which usettle players. We want a deal done in two weeks otherewise the market is closed until January for MP. MP knows that he's not getting £150k any more. Everyone else knows he's available. We're clear that 'tapping up' has negative consequences - for players and clubs.

Yes, there's a risk it goes wrong and we're stuck with a bad egg for a few months. Thankfully it's not my money as I'd be losing sleep over it. But I'd do the above.


RE: MP to Al-Hilal - Birdman1811 - 08-05-2021

(08-05-2021, 10:59 AM)DJPunkRoc Wrote: Interesting negotiation but there's a simple way of improving our position:

Declare very publicly that, because of Al Hilal's actions we, resolutely, will not sell to them.  MP remains 'for sale' but not to anybody who, in our opinion rather that FIFA's, engages in actions which usettle players.  We want a deal done in two weeks otherewise the market is closed until January for MP.  MP knows that he's not getting £150k any more.  Everyone else knows he's available.  We're clear that 'tapping up' has negative consequences - for players and clubs.

Yes, there's a risk it goes wrong and we're stuck with a bad egg for a few months.  Thankfully it's not my money as I'd be losing sleep over it.  But I'd do the above.

Tbf.

I would too, but as said, not my money or business.

Plus of course, means Val doesn't get the striker he wants.


RE: MP to Al-Hilal - MrFizz - 08-05-2021

(08-05-2021, 10:53 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 10:50 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 10:47 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: By the way.

If you want to know why I'm so peaceful about it. I had a good inkling this was going to happen back in January, then it was clubs in China, its now changed to Saudi Arabia. Hence the low valuation mentioned before. We then tried to conjure up some prem interest but there wasn't anything concrete, and he wants the money.

So I've had time to get less angry about it.

How he can come out with all that shit about us getting a fair value for him, though, is beyond me.

When we signed him, we knew he was a talent, but had a problematic background. We took the gamble, we've reaped the benefits, and now we pay the price.

He doesn't give a flying fuck for West Brom. Compared to Johnstone who by many accounts will sign a new contract after the window to protect the club, has given everything in training, came back early to meet the new boss, yet hasn't always had a good time with our fans. 

I know it's just a job fir them, but his career was stalling when we took a chance on him, and there is no regard from him for us at all.

Fuck him.

This.

On SJ i wasn't his biggest fan prior to last season. But his performances last year and his attitude since the Euro's have been exemplary. He's gone up massively in my estimation. I hope he signs a new contract with a sensible release clause (say £15m) and if he gets his move to a top Prem club next year then fair play to him and i shall wish him every success.


RE: MP to Al-Hilal - DJPunkRoc - 08-05-2021

(08-05-2021, 11:01 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 10:59 AM)DJPunkRoc Wrote: Interesting negotiation but there's a simple way of improving our position:

Declare very publicly that, because of Al Hilal's actions we, resolutely, will not sell to them.  MP remains 'for sale' but not to anybody who, in our opinion rather that FIFA's, engages in actions which usettle players.  We want a deal done in two weeks otherewise the market is closed until January for MP.  MP knows that he's not getting £150k any more.  Everyone else knows he's available.  We're clear that 'tapping up' has negative consequences - for players and clubs.

Yes, there's a risk it goes wrong and we're stuck with a bad egg for a few months.  Thankfully it's not my money as I'd be losing sleep over it.  But I'd do the above.

Tbf.

I would too, but as said, not my money or business.

Plus of course, means Val doesn't get the striker he wants.
Does it though?  If the plan is loaning Delap (or similar) for the season then capital spend is low and revenue savings from Pereira (and other dross signed by Bilic) should get us close to being affordable, I speculate.


RE: MP to Al-Hilal - Ted Maul - 08-05-2021

(08-05-2021, 11:01 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 10:59 AM)DJPunkRoc Wrote: Interesting negotiation but there's a simple way of improving our position:

Declare very publicly that, because of Al Hilal's actions we, resolutely, will not sell to them.  MP remains 'for sale' but not to anybody who, in our opinion rather that FIFA's, engages in actions which usettle players.  We want a deal done in two weeks otherewise the market is closed until January for MP.  MP knows that he's not getting £150k any more.  Everyone else knows he's available.  We're clear that 'tapping up' has negative consequences - for players and clubs.

Yes, there's a risk it goes wrong and we're stuck with a bad egg for a few months.  Thankfully it's not my money as I'd be losing sleep over it.  But I'd do the above.

Tbf.

I would too, but as said, not my money or business.

Plus of course, means Val doesn't get the striker he wants.

This is the key people seem to miss. If we had funds to spare then we can play hardball with Pereira, we don't, so we can't. We have to sell for whatever price we feel we'll be able to use to get at least one in. £17m in the Championship should cover it easily*


*we won't see a penny.


RE: MP to Al-Hilal - Birdman1811 - 08-05-2021

(08-05-2021, 11:04 AM)DJPunkRoc Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 11:01 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 10:59 AM)DJPunkRoc Wrote: Interesting negotiation but there's a simple way of improving our position:

Declare very publicly that, because of Al Hilal's actions we, resolutely, will not sell to them.  MP remains 'for sale' but not to anybody who, in our opinion rather that FIFA's, engages in actions which usettle players.  We want a deal done in two weeks otherewise the market is closed until January for MP.  MP knows that he's not getting £150k any more.  Everyone else knows he's available.  We're clear that 'tapping up' has negative consequences - for players and clubs.

Yes, there's a risk it goes wrong and we're stuck with a bad egg for a few months.  Thankfully it's not my money as I'd be losing sleep over it.  But I'd do the above.

Tbf.

I would too, but as said, not my money or business.

Plus of course, means Val doesn't get the striker he wants.
Does it though?  If the plan is loaning Delap (or similar) for the season then capital spend is low and revenue savings from Pereira (and other dross signed by Bilic) should get us close to being affordable, I speculate.

I don't think Delap is the main plan.


RE: MP to Al-Hilal - MassDebater - 08-05-2021

(08-05-2021, 10:59 AM)DJPunkRoc Wrote: Interesting negotiation but there's a simple way of improving our position:

Declare very publicly that, because of Al Hilal's actions we, resolutely, will not sell to them. MP remains 'for sale' but not to anybody who, in our opinion rather that FIFA's, engages in actions which usettle players. We want a deal done in two weeks otherewise the market is closed until January for MP. MP knows that he's not getting £150k any more. Everyone else knows he's available. We're clear that 'tapping up' has negative consequences - for players and clubs.

Yes, there's a risk it goes wrong and we're stuck with a bad egg for a few months. Thankfully it's not my money as I'd be losing sleep over it. But I'd do the above.

Play hardball, say no Al Hilal unless they up the fee, OR
We could in effect get MP to pay £50k per week of his new salary for a year to sweeten the pot as well... that'd top the £17m to the £20m mark... And MP would still have £100k per week instead of £6k...


RE: MP to Al-Hilal - Kit Kat Chunky - 08-05-2021

(08-05-2021, 11:04 AM)MrFizz Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 10:53 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 10:50 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(08-05-2021, 10:47 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: By the way.

If you want to know why I'm so peaceful about it. I had a good inkling this was going to happen back in January, then it was clubs in China, its now changed to Saudi Arabia. Hence the low valuation mentioned before. We then tried to conjure up some prem interest but there wasn't anything concrete, and he wants the money.

So I've had time to get less angry about it.

How he can come out with all that shit about us getting a fair value for him, though, is beyond me.

When we signed him, we knew he was a talent, but had a problematic background. We took the gamble, we've reaped the benefits, and now we pay the price.

He doesn't give a flying fuck for West Brom. Compared to Johnstone who by many accounts will sign a new contract after the window to protect the club, has given everything in training, came back early to meet the new boss, yet hasn't always had a good time with our fans. 

I know it's just a job fir them, but his career was stalling when we took a chance on him, and there is no regard from him for us at all.

Fuck him.

This.

On SJ i wasn't his biggest fan prior to last season. But his performances last year and his attitude since the Euro's have been exemplary. He's gone up massively in my estimation. I hope he signs a new contract with a sensible release clause (say £15m) and if he gets his move to a top Prem club next year then fair play to him and i shall wish him every success.

I agree.


RE: MP to Al-Hilal - Derek Hardballs - 08-05-2021

Why would we try and play hard ball when we hold none of the cards? That’s the job of Johnson and Lord Frost!

The player wants to leave, no other club will pay the silly wages they are offering so we are either stuck with an unhappy player whilst the manager is trying to galvanise a sense of togetherness and team spirit or we sell and try and plug the gaps in our squad notably up front, full back and central defence. We may only be able to afford two places from the Pereira money but this was always going to happen.

I can’t say I really care or really bought into the love-in with the player.


RE: MP to Al-Hilal - Lightnin - 08-05-2021

On the contrary, I’d let him go because they’ve unsettled him. Provide the information to FIFA and let them step in against Al Hilal, it’s then not our problem and they could be forced to cough up more with a fair valuation.

If if don’t work then so be it but we move on and not make it our problem.