WBAUnofficial
The Perce has spoken - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The Perce has spoken (/showthread.php?tid=37749)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18


RE: The Perce has spoken - Jacko - 05-28-2025

(05-28-2025, 11:01 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(05-28-2025, 10:30 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Mullers, no hindsight required to know it was a shit appointment at the time. And that is solely on Nestor.

I've listened to Nestor and read what he has to say. And as I say, it's a very seductive narrative. And I so want to believe in his plan. Who wouldn't?

Yet the Mowbray appointment, his skewed rationale for doing it, and the very variable player recruitment - especially the loans - makes me think he just talks a good game.

I'm sorry you think this is bizarre but it seems reasonable to me. I honestly don't think he's got long. Only a managerial appointment that exceeds expectations will save him.

As much as I think Mowbray is inept, the blame lies with Nestor.
Some of the blame lies with Nester but if Mowbray had a remit and tried to implement it to quickly how can Nester have known that.Also Mowbray talking out of turn about players wasn’t Nesters fault. Yes I don’t think Mowbray was the right fit and that is on Nester. I’m all in if it is Mason or whoever comes in hopefully Nester and co get this one right.

You're all in? Surely not? I'm absolutely shocked. Big Grin


RE: The Perce has spoken - Lurker#3 - 05-28-2025

(05-28-2025, 09:39 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-28-2025, 09:26 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-28-2025, 09:23 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-28-2025, 09:20 PM)Squid Wrote: Right.

I've said there will be scrutiny on Nestor if this doesn't work out. What "doesn't work out" looks like at this juncture is up for debate. I stand by that.

However, as badly as Mowbray did, I actually can't criticise bringing him in. He had done well enough at Sunderland and Blackburn to think that he would be able to work pragmatically to keep us in the playoffs. Those aren't head pixies talking to me, his Blackburn and Sunderland sides were tough to beat at the Hawthorns.

I am never usually ITK, but I got a snippet yesterday. To the surprise of nobody here with eyes, Mowbray decided he wanted to change everything all at once, the players got confused and nobody knew what they were doing.

Is that on Nestor and his data? Not really. Can't complain they didn't act when the wheels fell off either.

… and yet two managers I really didn’t want were TM and Williams both of which got sacked before the end of the season! If the data led search is throwing up those two, it’s a flawed process.

I'd hope they've changed what they want the data to say, since it didn't work last time that would be sensible.

Data should be just a tool, it should not determine any decisions, I’m not saying that’s what the club are doing btw, however recruitment of managers and players is not a science that you crunch the numbers and it churns out a list of ideal candidates. If it did Man U and others struggling with all the resources in the world would not be getting things so wrong for so long.

Of course it should only be a tool. But as with pretty much everything, the real discussion lies in terms of how much the tool should impact the decision. 

I believe the 'data', what ever the perimeter is, is more useful fir the playing staff, as their individual outputs and ability can influence a team much more directly than the HC.  The head coach, especially in our position needs to demonstrate an ability to improve players over a number of seasons, from scholar ages through the pathway to first team. Because frankly, that will, and should be our core model going forwards and any success needs be borne from that not on spite of it.


RE: The Perce has spoken - wba13 - 05-28-2025

(05-28-2025, 11:12 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(05-28-2025, 11:01 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(05-28-2025, 10:30 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Mullers, no hindsight required to know it was a shit appointment at the time. And that is solely on Nestor.

I've listened to Nestor and read what he has to say. And as I say, it's a very seductive narrative. And I so want to believe in his plan. Who wouldn't?

Yet the Mowbray appointment, his skewed rationale for doing it, and the very variable player recruitment - especially the loans - makes me think he just talks a good game.

I'm sorry you think this is bizarre but it seems reasonable to me. I honestly don't think he's got long. Only a managerial appointment that exceeds expectations will save him.

As much as I think Mowbray is inept, the blame lies with Nestor.
Some of the blame lies with Nester but if Mowbray had a remit and tried to implement it to quickly how can Nester have known that.Also Mowbray talking out of turn about players wasn’t Nesters fault. Yes I don’t think Mowbray was the right fit and that is on Nester. I’m all in if it is Mason or whoever comes in hopefully Nester and co get this one right.

You're all in? Surely not? I'm absolutely shocked. Big Grin
Tongue Big Grin


RE: The Perce has spoken - Mullers - 05-29-2025

(05-28-2025, 10:30 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Mullers, no hindsight required to know it was a shit appointment at the time. And that is solely on Nestor.

I've listened to Nestor and read what he has to say. And as I say, it's a very seductive narrative. And I so want to believe in his plan. Who wouldn't?

Yet the Mowbray appointment, his skewed rationale for doing it, and the very variable player recruitment - especially the loans - makes me think he just talks a good game.

I'm sorry you think this is bizarre but it seems reasonable to me. I honestly don't think he's got long. Only a managerial appointment that exceeds expectations will save him.

As much as I think Mowbray is inept, the blame lies with Nestor.

As I said, some like yourself may have called it at the time Mowbray was appointed (fair play). I still maintain there were good reasons to appoint him though, his experience being a key one. I will agree with you that if Mason (assuming it is to be him) doesn’t go well, Nestor’s judgement will be called into question.

On player recruitment, I know this debate has been run elsewhere but Heggem, Diakite, Price, Bany and Styles are testament to the club’s scouting which Nestor & his team oversees (and presumably, has a big say in). We signed some dross in Cole and Frabotta, but overall I’d say signings have been positive. Loans-wise: Armstrong, a number 9, was played on the left wing by the manager. Lankshear genuinely looks like a decent striker but looks best with a partner which he rarely had (along with game time). Holgate was very average which should have been known, and Racic didn’t work out.

I guess from my POV, I’m optimistic about the squad cause we’ve brought in some strong talent which we can profit on when the time comes to sell. And much of that will be thanks to Nestor, so I still trust him. But I will concede that in his role, you are only as good as your next big call…


RE: The Perce has spoken - SW4Baggie - 05-29-2025

Well Jonny Heitinga is leaving Liverpool for the Ajax job so I guess that rules him out Big Grin


RE: The Perce has spoken - Ted Maul - 05-29-2025

(05-28-2025, 09:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-28-2025, 09:09 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: See Derek has decided to take his position to cause as many arguments as possible, the consistency and skill in doing so is actually impressive.

Now he hates data analysis.

I think it keeps lots of people who know fug all about football but have a l laptop in a job Wink 

How long did you need to ‘analyse games’ to realise teams had set-up for a draw by sitting deep (sorry low block) whilst playing us at home? There is a lot of buzz words and Apprentice management speak going around football currently and it pretentious tosh.

But not every team who sits deep is setting up for a draw. Every time you open your mouth on the subject of analytics and tactics you expose yourself as knowing the sum total of fuck all Dekka. Stick to politics.


RE: The Perce has spoken - man in the corner shop - 05-29-2025

(05-29-2025, 07:04 AM)Mullers Wrote:
(05-28-2025, 10:30 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Mullers, no hindsight required to know it was a shit appointment at the time. And that is solely on Nestor.

I've listened to Nestor and read what he has to say. And as I say, it's a very seductive narrative. And I so want to believe in his plan. Who wouldn't?

Yet the Mowbray appointment, his skewed rationale for doing it, and the very variable player recruitment - especially the loans - makes me think he just talks a good game.

I'm sorry you think this is bizarre but it seems reasonable to me. I honestly don't think he's got long. Only a managerial appointment that exceeds expectations will save him.

As much as I think Mowbray is inept, the blame lies with Nestor.

As I said, some like yourself may have called it at the time Mowbray was appointed (fair play). I still maintain there were good reasons to appoint him though, his experience being a key one. I will agree with you that if Mason (assuming it is to be him) doesn’t go well, Nestor’s judgement will be called into question.

On player recruitment, I know this debate has been run elsewhere but Heggem, Diakite, Price, Bany and Styles are testament to the club’s scouting which Nestor & his team oversees (and presumably, has a big say in). We signed some dross in Cole and Frabotta, but overall I’d say signings have been positive. Loans-wise: Armstrong, a number 9, was played on the left wing by the manager. Lankshear genuinely looks like a decent striker but looks best with a partner which he rarely had (along with game time). Holgate was very average which should have been known, and Racic didn’t work out.

I guess from my POV, I’m optimistic about the squad cause we’ve brought in some strong talent which we can profit on when the time comes to sell. And much of that will be thanks to Nestor, so I still trust him. But I will concede that in his role, you are only as good as your next big call…

Good post


RE: The Perce has spoken - tHEgLASSdOORS - 05-29-2025

(05-29-2025, 07:04 AM)Mullers Wrote:
(05-28-2025, 10:30 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Mullers, no hindsight required to know it was a shit appointment at the time. And that is solely on Nestor.

I've listened to Nestor and read what he has to say. And as I say, it's a very seductive narrative. And I so want to believe in his plan. Who wouldn't?

Yet the Mowbray appointment, his skewed rationale for doing it, and the very variable player recruitment - especially the loans - makes me think he just talks a good game.

I'm sorry you think this is bizarre but it seems reasonable to me. I honestly don't think he's got long. Only a managerial appointment that exceeds expectations will save him.

As much as I think Mowbray is inept, the blame lies with Nestor.

As I said, some like yourself may have called it at the time Mowbray was appointed (fair play). I still maintain there were good reasons to appoint him though, his experience being a key one. I will agree with you that if Mason (assuming it is to be him) doesn’t go well, Nestor’s judgement will be called into question.

On player recruitment, I know this debate has been run elsewhere but Heggem, Diakite, Price, Bany and Styles are testament to the club’s scouting which Nestor & his team oversees (and presumably, has a big say in). We signed some dross in Cole and Frabotta, but overall I’d say signings have been positive. Loans-wise: Armstrong, a number 9, was played on the left wing by the manager. Lankshear genuinely looks like a decent striker but looks best with a partner which he rarely had (along with game time). Holgate was very average which should have been known, and Racic didn’t work out.

I guess from my POV, I’m optimistic about the squad cause we’ve brought in some strong talent which we can profit on when the time comes to sell. And much of that will be thanks to Nestor, so I still trust him. But I will concede that in his role, you are only as good as your next big call…

That’s about where I’m at with it. If we continue to get key recruitment at the level we have, we’ll move forward over time.


RE: The Perce has spoken - KRO - 05-29-2025

Recruiting is vital but so is having a manager that suits the squad. Going from Corberan to Mowbray and presumably knowing that Mowbray wouldn’t play the same style, meant that giving him 3 or 4 months and half of a transfer window to presumably have some say in signings was daft. Otherwise you’d have given him a 6 months deal and not 18 months or 2 and a half years. The lack of wins over a 6 or 7 month period is staggering really, even before Mowbray got the gig. In hindsight especially it did seem a strange appointment to follow on from the pragmatism of Corberan


RE: The Perce has spoken - tHEgLASSdOORS - 05-29-2025

Absolutely agree KRO. I’m not sure we yet have a squad that has a clear leaning towards what style of play/coaching/set up it suits and that is part of the problem, but I would say the better end of the recent permanent signings we have done is leaning that way.

Nestor has done that well and got one managerial appointment “wrong”, so he’s plenty of time left in my book. I was very much in the camp that appointing Mowbray was circumstantially the best fit from a tricky circumstance, and it was clear the list of authentic candidates was poor, so I don’t hugely blame him for that. I’d have never appointed Mowbray given a summer and pre season to appoint and that’s where we are now. Hopefully this one aligns more with the squad trajectory.