WBAUnofficial
Bacuna racist abuse - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Bacuna racist abuse (/showthread.php?tid=32579)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27


RE: Bacuna racist abuse - Spandaubaggie - 02-06-2024

(02-06-2024, 09:23 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 09:11 AM)KRO Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 08:11 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 07:32 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(02-05-2024, 10:31 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I’d added in my deleted post about a school kid I know of who was expelled for an alleged racist comment at an opponent whilst he was in a football match. Every one of his team mates backed him up that whilst he swore at his opponent he didn’t use racist language. 
The opposing school said unless he was removed from the school the police would be called in. 
The lad was moved, at a time when he was set to do exams as his school was so twitchy. 

That's got nothing to do with racism or any laws in the United Kingdom. If you expel children, there have to be reasons given, investigations have to be made and approval has to be given by not only the school, but also government administrators. There is also a very stringent appeals procedure that leans very heavily towards the child's rights, rather than his alleged victim. The child denying it is usually enough, unless someone else hears it.  A group of people backing up his version of his events should have been more than enough. I've never known when it wasn't.

In my experience, people complain about how kids can't get expelled no matter what they do, not the other way around. They usually say it's political correctness gone mad. Ironic, eh?

If none of those procedures were followed, his parents should have sued. If it was near his exams, he would have won a six-figure settlement. If the school excluded him despite the findings of the investigation, just for an easy life, they would have been sacked and most likely prevented from ever working in education again. If the parents felt coerced by threats of police and so removed him voluntarily, they could sue both schools and if either admitted it, or there was any evidence, the damages would be even greater and the repercussions for the teachers' careers substantial.

In addition, if the other school did hear the language, they should have reported it to the police regardless of any 'deal' as it's a criminal offence. If they didn't, they should also be investigated for not safeguarding the 'victim' who was in their charge.

It's an almost impossible conspiracy of seemingly unconnected people all working together to perpetrate a miscarriage of justice on a child. If it happened in the last ten years or so and he can prove his education suffered and therefore his life, he probably still could sue. You should get on to him and let him know.

If it happened like you say.



This, by the way, is me speaking as both a lawyer and a school governor.
I bow to your superior knowledge on this Fuzzbox. I know the lad’s mother and that’s her version of events directly to me. I don’t know the lad myself.
I do question though why police should be involved in something that I see as minor as a supposed throw away comment in the heat of the moment in a sporting event. It’s not right, but surely someone being pulled up by a ref etc should be enough.
That brings me onto Bacuna.
It seems a terrible waste of police resources. I’m not saying racism shouldn’t be investigated or happily allowed but treating what is clearly a very low end possibly bogus offence appears to me like investigating every time a crisp packet is dropped like it’s fly tipping.
Perhaps we can investigate if we even think we saw a crisp packet being dropped too.
There just appears no common sense and a ridiculous agenda now that I can’t see is helpful to social harmony and a terrible waste of police resources when stabbings, robberies and no police stations are all far more important to anyone with any form of normal mental capacity.

You pretty much are saying racism shouldn’t be investigated and players should put up with it
I think it's the level of, initial, investigation, and who conducts it that is important. If something happened at my place of work, it would be investigated internally and only based on those findings would the police be involved and I think that's sensible.
The club should have all the data available along with CCTV etc. to conduct the initial investigation and, if there's substance to it, i.e someone verifies Bacuna's account, then absolutely the book should be thrown at the culprit.  Because, however, it was on TV and all and sundry have now voiced their opinions, without any real facts, the outcome of this will always be up for question.

 
You pretty much are saying racism shouldn’t be investigated and players should put up with it

No. I'm saying use common sense, which is context and perhaps clubs and those in the vicinity, such as stewards, can help set standards and the club's should take action.
For context right now some coppers are investigating Bacuna's incident, whilst some one who has had their house burgled isn't even seeing a policeman and pissed up idiots are driving here there and everywhere threatening life and limb, whilst this Bacuna incident takes precedent with police time and makes headlines.

 


 

(02-06-2024, 09:23 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 09:11 AM)KRO Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 08:11 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 07:32 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(02-05-2024, 10:31 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I’d added in my deleted post about a school kid I know of who was expelled for an alleged racist comment at an opponent whilst he was in a football match. Every one of his team mates backed him up that whilst he swore at his opponent he didn’t use racist language. 
The opposing school said unless he was removed from the school the police would be called in. 
The lad was moved, at a time when he was set to do exams as his school was so twitchy. 

That's got nothing to do with racism or any laws in the United Kingdom. If you expel children, there have to be reasons given, investigations have to be made and approval has to be given by not only the school, but also government administrators. There is also a very stringent appeals procedure that leans very heavily towards the child's rights, rather than his alleged victim. The child denying it is usually enough, unless someone else hears it.  A group of people backing up his version of his events should have been more than enough. I've never known when it wasn't.

In my experience, people complain about how kids can't get expelled no matter what they do, not the other way around. They usually say it's political correctness gone mad. Ironic, eh?

If none of those procedures were followed, his parents should have sued. If it was near his exams, he would have won a six-figure settlement. If the school excluded him despite the findings of the investigation, just for an easy life, they would have been sacked and most likely prevented from ever working in education again. If the parents felt coerced by threats of police and so removed him voluntarily, they could sue both schools and if either admitted it, or there was any evidence, the damages would be even greater and the repercussions for the teachers' careers substantial.

In addition, if the other school did hear the language, they should have reported it to the police regardless of any 'deal' as it's a criminal offence. If they didn't, they should also be investigated for not safeguarding the 'victim' who was in their charge.

It's an almost impossible conspiracy of seemingly unconnected people all working together to perpetrate a miscarriage of justice on a child. If it happened in the last ten years or so and he can prove his education suffered and therefore his life, he probably still could sue. You should get on to him and let him know.

If it happened like you say.



This, by the way, is me speaking as both a lawyer and a school governor.
I bow to your superior knowledge on this Fuzzbox. I know the lad’s mother and that’s her version of events directly to me. I don’t know the lad myself.
I do question though why police should be involved in something that I see as minor as a supposed throw away comment in the heat of the moment in a sporting event. It’s not right, but surely someone being pulled up by a ref etc should be enough.
That brings me onto Bacuna.
It seems a terrible waste of police resources. I’m not saying racism shouldn’t be investigated or happily allowed but treating what is clearly a very low end possibly bogus offence appears to me like investigating every time a crisp packet is dropped like it’s fly tipping.
Perhaps we can investigate if we even think we saw a crisp packet being dropped too.
There just appears no common sense and a ridiculous agenda now that I can’t see is helpful to social harmony and a terrible waste of police resources when stabbings, robberies and no police stations are all far more important to anyone with any form of normal mental capacity.

You pretty much are saying racism shouldn’t be investigated and players should put up with it
I think it's the level of, initial, investigation, and who conducts it that is important. If something happened at my place of work, it would be investigated internally and only based on those findings would the police be involved and I think that's sensible.
The club should have all the data available along with CCTV etc. to conduct the initial investigation and, if there's substance to it, i.e someone verifies Bacuna's account, then absolutely the book should be thrown at the culprit.  Because, however, it was on TV and all and sundry have now voiced their opinions, without any real facts, the outcome of this will always be up for question.

 
You pretty much are saying racism shouldn’t be investigated and players should put up with it

No. I'm saying use common sense, which is context and perhaps clubs and those in the vicinity, such as stewards, can help set standards and the club's should take action.
For context right now some coppers are investigating Bacuna's incident, whilst some one who has had their house burgled isn't even seeing a policeman and pissed up idiots are driving here there and everywhere threatening life and limb, whilst this Bacuna incident takes precedent with police time and makes headlines.
As I said, it's almost impossible to have a sensible and calm debate about this and that is why I initially deleted my initial post. I think it speaks more about the climate and environment of now than anything else, where it is so hard to have honest and open debate.

 


 


RE: Bacuna racist abuse - CaptainFantastico - 02-06-2024

The Bacuna case isn’t taking up coppers time that could be used more wisely elsewhere because of bad prioritising. It’s taking up time that acts in opposition to what else it could be used for because of a pitifully underfunded and overstretched public resource.

Leaving us with an argument about it that doesn’t even need to exist and misses the point


RE: Bacuna racist abuse - baggiebloke - 02-06-2024

(02-06-2024, 09:45 AM)Squid Wrote: I'm surprised nobody's mentioned the J-Rod case yet. That was eventually found to be a case where as Allan Nyom put it, the player definitely believed a racist remark had been said, but there was no evidence that such a comment had been made.

Squid, 

sickParrot did, on page 5...


RE: Bacuna racist abuse - CarlosCorbewrong - 02-06-2024

(02-06-2024, 10:01 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: The Bacuna case isn’t taking up coppers time that could be used more wisely elsewhere because of bad prioritising. It’s taking up time that acts in opposition to what else it could be used for because of a pitifully underfunded and overstretched public resource.

Leaving us with an argument about it that doesn’t even need to exist and misses the point

Let's be honest, Spandex saying racism isn't important (or overstated in importance) is the equivalent of the cuddly toy on the Generation Game.  He just doesn't find it as important as the plight of the working class/burglary/bollocks being grabbed/trans issues and you're just trying to cancel him because of his views.


RE: Bacuna racist abuse - Spandaubaggie - 02-06-2024

(02-06-2024, 10:01 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: The Bacuna case isn’t taking up coppers time that could be used more wisely elsewhere because of bad prioritising. It’s taking up time that acts in opposition to what else it could be used for because of a pitifully underfunded and overstretched public resource.

Leaving us with an argument about it that doesn’t even need to exist and misses the point

I grant you that as may be, but only when we find out what is supposed to have been said by this apparent phantom racist can we really see if it's been worthwhile.
My story about the kid being expelled kind of shows us though that racial allegations seem to wield a terrifying level of power, which has been proven to hamper investigation of high level crime due to ethnicity of the criminals. If society is comfortable with this then it's strange times.


RE: Bacuna racist abuse - Duffers - 02-06-2024

(02-06-2024, 09:45 AM)Squid Wrote: I'm surprised nobody's mentioned the J-Rod case yet. That was eventually found to be a case where as Allan Nyom put it, the player definitely believed a racist remark had been said, but there was no evidence that such a comment had been made.

I alluded to this a few pages ago.

I don't think Bacuna is lying or making it up, I think in the heat of the moment he genuinely believed he heard something. Whether anything actually was or not is the question, but being mistaken and believing your own truth is not the same as lying.


RE: Bacuna racist abuse - Ted Maul - 02-06-2024

What do A4A think, have we covered that yet?


RE: Bacuna racist abuse - Duffers - 02-06-2024

(02-06-2024, 10:12 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 10:01 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: The Bacuna case isn’t taking up coppers time that could be used more wisely elsewhere because of bad prioritising. It’s taking up time that acts in opposition to what else it could be used for because of a pitifully underfunded and overstretched public resource.

Leaving us with an argument about it that doesn’t even need to exist and misses the point

I grant you that as may be, but only when we find out what is supposed to have been said by this apparent phantom racist can we really see if it's been worthwhile.
My story about the kid being expelled kind of shows us though that racial allegations seem to wield a terrifying level of power, which has been proven to hamper investigation of high level crime like Asian drug gangs. If society is comfortable with this then it's strange times.

That story smacked of DHOTY to me, especially given Fuzzbox's response in terms of what would have actually happened.


RE: Bacuna racist abuse - CarlosCorbewrong - 02-06-2024

(02-06-2024, 10:14 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 09:45 AM)Squid Wrote: I'm surprised nobody's mentioned the J-Rod case yet. That was eventually found to be a case where as Allan Nyom put it, the player definitely believed a racist remark had been said, but there was no evidence that such a comment had been made.

I alluded to this a few pages ago.

I don't think Bacuna is lying or making it up, I think in the heat of the moment he genuinely believed he heard something. Whether anything actually was or not is the question, but being mistaken and believing your own truth is not the same as lying.

I hate the idea of an incident like this not attracting a thorough investigation and I don't think such an investigation is a waste of police time.

However, based upon what I have heard, I think the balance - for me - has shifted.  He was evidently wound up.  This happens to him a lot more than most, it seems yet I don't think a case has been proven to date.  There have been some sensible posters (not the type that like to whitewash racism) who have reported nothing witnessed.  Based upon what I've heard, and if I was on a jury, I'd acquit.  We need to hear his side first though.  

But to assume that a case doesn't even need to be investigated?  That doesn't sit ok with me.


RE: Bacuna racist abuse - CaptainFantastico - 02-06-2024

(02-06-2024, 10:15 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: What do A4A think, have we covered that yet?

There’s a Facebook pager where people aligned to a similar cause are now sworn enemies and nobody is any the wiser.

That’s only a guess because no one in their right mind still uses Facebook never mind gets into a public slanging match

(02-06-2024, 10:12 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-06-2024, 10:01 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: The Bacuna case isn’t taking up coppers time that could be used more wisely elsewhere because of bad prioritising. It’s taking up time that acts in opposition to what else it could be used for because of a pitifully underfunded and overstretched public resource.

Leaving us with an argument about it that doesn’t even need to exist and misses the point

I grant you that as may be, but only when we find out what is supposed to have been said by this apparent phantom racist can we really see if it's been worthwhile.
My story about the kid being expelled kind of shows us though that racial allegations seem to wield a terrifying level of power, which has been proven to hamper investigation of high level crime due to ethnicity of the criminals. If society is comfortable with this then it's strange times.

There is a woeful neglect of why we have ended up in the imperfect situation that you describe contained in that post. Shall we go back to what lead to it?