WBAUnofficial
Imminent Sacking? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Imminent Sacking? (/showthread.php?tid=23774)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18


RE: Imminent Sacking? - WorcsWBA - 01-30-2022

To be fair to Val (although few are willing to now it would seem), he hasn't only had one season of modest success and the pinnacle of his achievement to date isn't Barnsley. Look back to his tenure at LASK for that. Here's his record there to save you the trouble:

P50 W31 D6 L13 F102 A57 Win% 62%

He led LASK to their first appearance in the Champions League play-offs, where they beat Basel, but then lost to Club Brugge. They then won their group in the Europa League which contained Sporting Lisbon, PSV Eindhoven and Rosenborg. Next they beat AZ Alkmaar in the Round of 32, only to lose to Man Utd in the next round. I think all of that trumps 5th in the Championship with Barnsley.

Even taking into account his record with us, his career win percentage as a manager is still 53.45%.


RE: Imminent Sacking? - HawkingsHalfpint - 01-30-2022

Fuck all that, what’s his xG like? We need to know!!


RE: Imminent Sacking? - WorcsWBA - 01-30-2022

(01-30-2022, 10:32 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Fuck all that, what’s his xG like? We need to know!!

I can tell you that his sides averaged scoring 1.82 goals per game before he came here!


RE: Imminent Sacking? - Cuzer - 01-30-2022

Which is why I find myself having some sympathy (still) for Val, he's been told by Ken to bring a structure and system to the club which has jumped from one manager to another all to frequenty

We've gaping holes in the squad, invested very little in the summer and brought in pretty average players in all honesty, prior to January we've for me been quite unlucky at times, battered sides and not scored, gone out and signed a real exciting prospect in Dike who gets injured on his first bloody start

I can't help thinking the players are throwing him under the bus somewhat, clearly his fall out with Snodgrass and more recently Sam Johnson has upset some of the players who at times this season have downed tools quite visibily. The Preston game was as bad as I can remember for a long time and I found myself Saturday, after the first 20 minutes just thinking to myself how crap this football is and we're just lumping balls into Andy Carrol and playing off second balls, we're a better side than that
However, we have been playing better, even QPR, Barnsley, Derby shite games but we've created, certainly didn't deserve to get one point from those three away games, Hugill sitter at Barnsley, Kipre hitting the post, Bartley at Derby, Phillips sliding in at QPR, list goes on yet against Milwall bar the lively start we were pretty woeful

Players downed tools and the attitude once we went behind was woeful, the last two performances have smacked of a team getting rid of a manager, the big critcism of Val is the insistance on one system, even yesterday if he goes to a back four the fans can see he's trying something else, he didn't and this inability to adapt coupled with some charlatan players at the club who are openly taking the piss it seems will be his downfall

Cuzer


RE: Imminent Sacking? - Squid - 01-30-2022

(01-30-2022, 10:50 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Which is why I find myself having some sympathy (still) for Val, he's been told by Ken to bring a structure and system to the club which has jumped from one manager to another all to frequenty

We've gaping holes in the squad, invested very little in the summer and brought in pretty average players in all honesty, prior to January we've for me been quite unlucky at times, battered sides and not scored, gone out and signed a real exciting prospect in Dike who gets injured on his first bloody start

I can't help thinking the players are throwing him under the bus somewhat, clearly his fall out with Snodgrass and more recently Sam Johnson has upset some of the players who at times this season have downed tools quite visibily. The Preston game was as bad as I can remember for a long time and I found myself Saturday, after the first 20 minutes just thinking to myself how crap this football is and we're just lumping balls into Andy Carrol and playing off second balls, we're a better side than that
However, we have been playing better, even QPR, Barnsley, Derby shite games but we've created, certainly didn't deserve to get one point from those three away games, Hugill sitter at Barnsley, Kipre hitting the post, Bartley at Derby, Phillips sliding in at QPR, list goes on yet against Milwall bar the lively start we were pretty woeful

Players downed tools and the attitude once we went behind was woeful, the last two performances have smacked of a team getting rid of a manager, the big critcism of Val is the insistance on one system, even yesterday if he goes to a back four the fans can see he's trying something else, he didn't and this inability to adapt coupled with some charlatan players at the club who are openly taking the piss it seems will be his downfall

Cuzer

Considering some of the characters we've had as managers, the nature of the vitriol, particularly on twitter, aimed the manager has really not sat well with me at all.

Madeley at the Athletic wrote a decent article on the situation (though somewhat overly soft on Sam Johnstone), that the real issue is the flawed decision making at the club.

And we have had some awful luck too, the polar opposite of the Bilic season, where so many flukey things, from Wigan goalkeeper taking a sip of his drink at the wrong time, to Stoke beating Brentford, all went our way.

Whoever comes in will have to sort that dressing room out by any means necessary. I don't care which of them ends up playing in the stiffs until their contract ends, I want them all to be trying their hardest, week in, week out.


RE: Imminent Sacking? - SW4Baggie - 01-30-2022

(01-30-2022, 11:01 PM)Squid Wrote:
(01-30-2022, 10:50 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Which is why I find myself having some sympathy (still) for Val, he's been told by Ken to bring a structure and system to the club which has jumped from one manager to another all to frequenty

We've gaping holes in the squad, invested very little in the summer and brought in pretty average players in all honesty, prior to January we've for me been quite unlucky at times, battered sides and not scored, gone out and signed a real exciting prospect in Dike who gets injured on his first bloody start

I can't help thinking the players are throwing him under the bus somewhat, clearly his fall out with Snodgrass and more recently Sam Johnson has upset some of the players who at times this season have downed tools quite visibily. The Preston game was as bad as I can remember for a long time and I found myself Saturday, after the first 20 minutes just thinking to myself how crap this football is and we're just lumping balls into Andy Carrol and playing off second balls, we're a better side than that
However, we have been playing better, even QPR, Barnsley, Derby shite games but we've created, certainly didn't deserve to get one point from those three away games, Hugill sitter at Barnsley, Kipre hitting the post, Bartley at Derby, Phillips sliding in at QPR, list goes on yet against Milwall bar the lively start we were pretty woeful

Players downed tools and the attitude once we went behind was woeful, the last two performances have smacked of a team getting rid of a manager, the big critcism of Val is the insistance on one system, even yesterday if he goes to a back four the fans can see he's trying something else, he didn't and this inability to adapt coupled with some charlatan players at the club who are openly taking the piss it seems will be his downfall

Cuzer

Considering some of the characters we've had as managers, the nature of the vitriol, particularly on twitter, aimed the manager has really not sat well with me at all.

Madeley at the Athletic wrote a decent article on the situation (though somewhat overly soft on Sam Johnstone), that the real issue is the flawed decision making at the club.

And we have had some awful luck too, the polar opposite of the Bilic season, where so many flukey things, from Wigan goalkeeper taking a sip of his drink at the wrong time, to Stoke beating Brentford, all went our way.

Whoever comes in will have to sort that dressing room out by any means necessary. I don't care which of them ends up playing in the stiffs until their contract ends, I want them all to be trying their hardest, week in, week out.

Agree with both of you.

Now the dust has settled, I do feel sorry for Val, but he’s making it bloody hard to show any support with his stubborn refusal to try anything a little different given the lack of success his rigidity has delivering.

If we’d lined up with a back 4 against Millwall, I think regardless of the result he’d have gotten much more support from the fans.  

I posted yesterday that this is the most disconnected I’ve felt from a group of players… even the wasters Robson brought in to go on the piss with was better than this shambles. I cannot wait to see the back of Captain Livermore. Pity I’m not an opposition midfielder as I’d see it every week.


RE: Imminent Sacking? - Cuzer - 01-30-2022

Yep, totally agree Squid, the anger at times has often been at the lack of direction at the club and it's now become hostile and toxic towards Val, he's come in with a plan, a strategy which at times has worked, others has not but one thing I do know is how hard he works, the hours, the study, the research, he lives away from his family and he's had zero patience from the fan base IMO, we were booiing when we battered Derby and drew 0-0, 1-1 at home to Milwall, 5th game of the season was it, sure they were booed then, it's the fall out from a shit Premiership season and stumbling over the line under Slav and Val has took a lot of the wrap

Where he has failed is his complete one dimensional approach tactically, you would almost love a pint with him just to ask "Why?" From Sunday league to Klop managers have more than one approach, why can't he?

Cuzer


RE: Imminent Sacking? - WorcsWBA - 01-30-2022

(01-30-2022, 11:01 PM)Squid Wrote: Considering some of the characters we've had as managers, the nature of the vitriol, particularly on twitter, aimed the manager has really not sat well with me at all.

Madeley at the Athletic wrote a decent article on the situation (though somewhat overly soft on Sam Johnstone), that the real issue is the flawed decision making at the club.

And we have had some awful luck too, the polar opposite of the Bilic season, where so many flukey things, from Wigan goalkeeper taking a sip of his drink at the wrong time, to Stoke beating Brentford, all went our way.

Whoever comes in will have to sort that dressing room out by any means necessary. I don't care which of them ends up playing in the stiffs until their contract ends, I want them all to be trying their hardest, week in, week out.

Absoutely. The Board brought Val in to implement a major culture change, but then gave him pathetically little assistance in doing so during the summer. Although things have completely fallen apart in the last 2 games, if we'd scored just a few more goals here and there, things would be looking completely different.


RE: Imminent Sacking? - Squid - 01-30-2022

(01-30-2022, 11:20 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Yep, totally agree Squid, the anger at times has often been at the lack of direction at the club and it's now become hostile and toxic towards Val, he's come in with a plan, a strategy which at times has worked, others has not but one thing I do know is how hard he works, the hours, the study, the research, he lives away from his family and he's had zero patience from the fan base IMO, we were booiing when we battered Derby and drew 0-0, 1-1 at home to Milwall, 5th game of the season was it, sure they were booed then, it's the fall out from a shit Premiership season and stumbling over the line under Slav and Val has took a lot of the wrap

Where he has failed is his complete one dimensional approach tactically, you would almost love a pint with him just to ask "Why?" From Sunday league to Klop managers have more than one approach, why can't he?

Cuzer

If he'd just made us decent at set pieces it would have helped. If your strikers aren't working, you should at least be trying to get something from corners. It's been something we've lacked since Dawson left.


RE: Imminent Sacking? - WorcsWBA - 01-30-2022

(01-30-2022, 11:20 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Yep, totally agree Squid, the anger at times has often been at the lack of direction at the club and it's now become hostile and toxic towards Val, he's come in with a plan, a strategy which at times has worked, others has not but one thing I do know is how hard he works, the hours, the study, the research, he lives away from his family and he's had zero patience from the fan base IMO, we were booiing when we battered Derby and drew 0-0, 1-1 at home to Milwall, 5th game of the season was it, sure they were booed then, it's the fall out from a shit Premiership season and stumbling over the line under Slav and Val has took a lot of the wrap

Where he has failed is his complete one dimensional approach tactically, you would almost love a pint with him just to ask "Why?" From Sunday league to Klop managers have more than one approach, why can't he?

Cuzer

I agree with that, particularly what I've highlighted in bold. He deserves more respect in what is increasingly becoming a cynical and offensive world.

His system has served him so successfully in the past and, if things had just gone a little differently, would have here too, so I can understand him feeling that it would come good if only a few things went his way.

(01-30-2022, 11:41 PM)Squid Wrote: If he'd just made us decent at set pieces it would have helped. If your strikers aren't working, you should at least be trying to get something from corners. It's been something we've lacked since Dawson left.

We looked so dangerous at set pieces early in the season and, for a short while, had scored more goals (10 I think it was) from set pieces than any other club in the division. I don't know why they've gone so badly wrong, but I think it's a shame that he hasn't said anything about it to indicate that he knows they've gone to pot and has been trying to address it.