![]() |
|
Cricket Clique - England vz NZ Tests - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Cricket Clique - England vz NZ Tests (/showthread.php?tid=41708) |
RE: Cricket Clique - England vz NZ Tests - pindgill - 06-29-2026 (06-29-2026, 12:01 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: However bad England might be at the moment, Pakistan are absolute gash right now. What would thrashing a very very poor Pakistan team 3-0 mean!!!???… NOTHING. RE: Cricket Clique - England vz NZ Tests - backsidebaggie - 06-29-2026 (06-29-2026, 02:18 PM)pindgill Wrote:(06-29-2026, 12:01 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: However bad England might be at the moment, Pakistan are absolute gash right now. At home, I agree. That’s exactly why I was pointing it out, it’s an easy start. RE: Cricket Clique - England vz NZ Tests - Cheshire East Baggie - 06-29-2026 (06-29-2026, 11:00 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Real issues for England moving forwards, struggling to pick an XI I'd have confidence in going into the Pakistan series. It's the least attached I've been to an England side and that's mostly down to the fact that 75% of them (and the management at the ECB) don't give a shit about playing test cricket it seems. Once Root goes, I dread to think what we'll be like. There's a lot of misty-eyed nostalgia for the golden days of Bazball and a bit of "be careful what you wish for without Stokes" going on in the media and on here. Let's not forget that Ben has been a key component in the management team, not just the on-field captain. Our inability to pick an XI that looks any good is the direct (and inevitable) result of the selection policy for the last 4 years. So many bad decisions - in no particular order: Persisting with Crawley far past the point where it was clear he's not up to the job - leaving us with an inexperienced opener at a difficult time. By-passing a generation of solid county players with potential and promoting the 12 year old Bethell who hasn't actually played red ball cricket much at all. Deciding that wicket-keeping doesn't matter - therefore trashing Smith's confidence and batting form due to the stresses and strains of being the glove-man. Choosing Bashir as the spinner for the future on the basis of a YouTube video (then not using him in the series he was picked for) - therefore losing the benefit of at least one truly experienced, match-winning spin bowler in Jack Leach. Concentrating on pace - assuming that Jofra and Woody could ever be fit enough to blast the Aussies Down Under - leaving us with a bunch of injury-prone quicks and no-one with any subtlety or variation. Not sure if they're even my top five Bazball fuckups, but it's enough to be going on with. Stokes was the glue that held it together, made it work. Now he's gone, we're fucked over by Baz'n'Ben. Thanks guys. If only someone could have seen this coming. I mean someone with influence in the game, not just fans and the media. RE: Cricket Clique - England vz NZ Tests - Tom Joad 25 - 06-29-2026 The very absence of Stokes is a problem. Even when he is not bowling well he can make things happen. Even when out of form with a bat you wouldn't bet against him winning us a game. Where is the next all-rounder coming from? Then there's the captaincy. He is certainly positive, pro active, not always the right choices but always looking to keep everyone on their toes. Brook is simply not fit to step up. I sincerely hope Root doesn't take over and outside these who else is guaranteed a place in the side? Could Duckett do it? Maybe bring Pope back but that is surely a backward move? I'm not familiar enough with county cricket to see another Mike Brearley out there. This sudden resignation has left us high and dry. All I can look back on is the ECB should have taken action straight after the Ashes debacle. McCullum and Key needed sacking, Stokes kept on, he isn't going to last that much longer whatever and we didn't need to chuck out the baby with the bathwater. The whole Bazball saga wasn't necessarily all bad. It was great to watch England trying to win a game, no more trying and failing to bat for a draw. I don't think any of us can comprehend why the style couldn't be tweaked to be more ruthless and less chancy. We have thrown games away regularly. A one nil lead in India where we got thumped despite having chances over the following games to occupy the crease. The declaration on day 1 at Edgbaston v Australia. The last Ashes series when we effectively lost a test in one session. Even this test where after the bizarre timing of the resignation NZ went from a get-able 300, 8 down, to us needing 370+. But with 110 overs to bat, England could still get a result by being canny. But no, the crazy batting order, not just Stokes opening, the whole unnecessary shuffle was ridiculous. This doesnt even go near the odd squad selection and accusations of favouritism. Ive genuinely heard these myself first hand and from within the game. McCullum and Key must go, this side is only going one way. I'd get Alec Stewart in as top man and let him pick the coach and captain. RE: Cricket Clique - England vz NZ Tests - Hughie Reed 31 - 06-29-2026 I’d give the captaincy to Haseeb Hameed he’s 29 now been captain of Nottinghamshire for around 2 Seasons far better equipped this time round for Test Cricket and also doing well leading his team And get Sam Curran in as the all rounder & Jordan Cox as the wicket Keeper Fuck off McCullum & Key Make Flintoff the coach along with Anderson Put Vaughan in overall Charge RE: Cricket Clique - England vz NZ Tests - backsidebaggie - 06-29-2026 (06-29-2026, 08:36 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote: I’d give the captaincy to Haseeb Hameed he’s 29 now been captain of Nottinghamshire for around 2 Hameed is nowhere near good enough. Had a good season last season granted, but he’s got serious technical flaws. RE: Cricket Clique - England vz NZ Tests - AnelkasBeard - 06-30-2026 (06-29-2026, 08:36 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote: I’d give the captaincy to Haseeb Hameed he’s 29 now been captain of Nottinghamshire for around 2 Wowzers. Sam Curran? Averages 24 and 35, and not the right way around. Michael Vaughan should be nowhere near the ECB, will be just as bad as Key. Hameed whilst playing well is a flawed batter, and there is no reason to drop either Duckett or Gay (who has looked like he has potential in this series) However, this does need to be the time to completely reset everything. Bazball wasn't a reset, it was the same core of blokes given a mentality shift. And it worked for the first year or so, until they started believing their own hype. Compare the batting from the NZ and Pakistan series, and the postponed India Test, to the more recent fare. Aggressive and attacking, but not reckless. It soon became very reckless, and became mired in selection headaches (Bashir? really?!) Get proper cricket blokes with their heads screwed on in charge. Alec Stewart as the Key replacement, go all out to get someone like Ponting as coach and put together a 5-10 year plan of how we can actually use County cricket as a proper pipeline of talent and players. In terms of the team moving forward in the short term... it doesnt look great. Need to focus on getting younger players the experience. Bring Rehan in and cobble together him and Atkinson as the "all-rounder". Jamie Smith is still averaging 40 in Tests, but he needs to drastically improve his keeping. Longer term, Thomas Rew needs to replace him. Bethell has potential, but they've got to get him playing more red ball to gain that experience. Bowlers? Honestly, fuck knows. We'll have to stick with Atkinson, Robinson, Tongue and Archer in the short term but that's a very injury prone stable of quicks. Duckett Gay Bethell Root Brook Smith Rehan Atkinson Archer Tongue Robinson RE: Cricket Clique - England vz NZ Tests - man in the corner shop - 06-30-2026 Vaughan has called for McCullum and Key to go. With Stokes going, now is a good time. RE: Cricket Clique - England vz NZ Tests - Josh1873 - 06-30-2026 What have Jimmy and Freddie done coaching wise? Are they in current roles, or is this just an idea because they were superb cricketers? I'm not clued up on cricket coaches, so I can't really offer serious suggestions, other than Jason Gillespie, who seems to be a successful coach wherever he ends up. Mark Robinson, former Bears coach, would be another ridiculous shout from me. He was successful with the women's side, and I believe he did a good job at Bears - winning us the CC. A lot of Warwickshire fans weren't keen on him, and wanted him gone, but I liked him, which probably means he was shit. I can't offer suggestions, but go on to give two names. I really am a whoppering bell end. RE: Cricket Clique - England vz NZ Tests - AnelkasBeard - 06-30-2026 (06-30-2026, 09:25 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: What have Jimmy and Freddie done coaching wise? Flintoff is the current Lions Head Coach I believe, and has done some T20/100 coaching roles too. So he has some pedigree. I think the Anderson shout is more for bowling coach (I assume), but not sure if he's done any formal coaching. |