RE: Imminent Sacking? - coxy134 - 01-30-2022
(01-30-2022, 06:16 PM)wbamitch Wrote: (01-30-2022, 05:59 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (01-30-2022, 05:45 PM)coxy134 Wrote: If we are a club which has not got much money to spend with an average squad and can only bring in one or two players at a time then we need a manager whose style of play does not require anything above average.
Thats Val's problem his high press needs players who can win the ball, keep it and play it forward quickly. So we either give him time to bring in players who can play it that way (expensive and takes time) or lots of money, we have not got either because we have an owner and fans that wants to see us go up this year. His other problem is that he will not change his style or mix it to adapt to the players he has.
That is why Hodgson, Bruce, Big Sam and perhaps even Pulis do well they keep it simple and defend/ stop conceding. They tend to get teams doing well at set pieces both defending and attacking them, getting wingers helping out at the back etc. The problem is in its simplicity it often looks boring but does make average players look decent.
Their coaching is also regimented and disciplined and that is seen on the pitch where sadly this season we have seen far to many sending offs and silly free kicks given away.
So at the moment that is the sort of manager we need.
And the short term wheel continues to turn. Whilst we become more and more boring and uninspiring.
But hey ho we may get closer to another season of abject humiliation and desperation clawing pathetically at the premier league piggy Bank.
Can't buy into your vision, sorry Coxy. If he goes he needs replacing with another "Philosophy Manager".
We must look to the future. Even if this appointment hasn't worked.
Which ever manager gives us the best chance of going up this season is what we need. Otherwise any longterm philosophy manager isn't going to have a pot to piss in to build what he wants. We have a bunch of players on long term deals who have rapidly declined in value, we need someone who can work with them as if we stay in this division we are stuck with them. And a manager who can then bring in better players. That was Pulis downfall could only work short term. Only Hodgson and Allerdyce have the ability to build a team out of that bunch.
RE: Imminent Sacking? - mickeypearce - 01-30-2022
(01-30-2022, 05:55 PM)MassDebater Wrote: So... none of the reliable and ITK sources were right... anyone surprised?
Apart from Manc, he said his ITK source said nothing was happening and Val was at the training ground.
RE: Imminent Sacking? - wba13 - 01-30-2022
Twitter supposed to be in full mode that Ismael going no idea if true.
tweeted
"Ekrem KONUR
@Ekremkonur
West Bromwich do not intend to continue with manager Valerien Ismael. #WBA"
RE: Imminent Sacking? - Peachy - 01-30-2022
(01-30-2022, 06:33 PM)mickeypearce Wrote: (01-30-2022, 05:55 PM)MassDebater Wrote: So... none of the reliable and ITK sources were right... anyone surprised?
Apart from Manc, he said his ITK source said nothing was happening and Val was at the training ground.
Tbf Mancs sauce is rock solid.....
RE: Imminent Sacking? - Derek Hardballs - 01-30-2022
(01-30-2022, 06:13 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (01-30-2022, 06:07 PM)MassDebater Wrote: You seriously don't see this as a season of abject humiliation? I do and have done for months. That's what makes it such a rich and often interesting place to be (on 'ere) the different views combined into a melting pot, where none of us really know anything, but all will make out we have some clue.
The future is not Six...Imagine what he'd do next year, the sort of players he'll bring in, to get us firing again. Sorry, but your long term plan fails with the wrong man in charge, Dave may have achieved it, with Shan, and more time...
Any plan goes to pot when contact with the enemy is made. Contact has been made, Six has been found massively wanting.
Thats because you focus more on the short term than I do MD.
Am I dissapointed in our performances and results? Yes... But I have been for about 6 or 7 years bar perhaps 2, 6 month spells. But as I have stated, I frankly don't know what to thjnk of Vals future. If the option is Val or one of the short term, old boys club, managers, I will stick with Val, thanks. If the club we going to look for a Graham Potter-esque manager, I would be open to it.
I have said Rob Edwards in other posts as I think he has a bright future.
We will not go forward without the money that promotion brings.
Let’s look at the facts…
We have an owner who wants to sell if they could get their money back
We have no one with any football knowledge at boardroom level
We have a DoF that has very limited experience in building a football department / infrastructure
We have a manager who has an average and limited CV with the pinnacle of it, finishing 5th with Barnsley
We have a manager with no experience of building any long term success at one club
We have a manager entrusted with according to some building a new squad over a four year period
We have no idea who is scouting our players, is it the manager, his coaches, club scouts? What happens when he leaves?
We have employed a manager with one way of playing, which then determines what players we sign and how we play. It’s very niche, inflexible in a world where football moves on and we’ve already seen it’s easily combated / negated by any half decent manager.
We can’t keep our best young players as they get poached by clubs above us, with bigger budgets
Our owners don’t need success like Peace did, their future is not linked to the success of the club relatively speaking
What’s the plan? Genuinely, without the money that short term success brings, with a self sufficient club, and no investment. With the list of things I’ve mentioned above you expect us to find a long term successful solution to these problems with a dwindling and potentially tiny income stream if we fail to go up this or next season?
Most fans want a long term plan, I certainly do but they aren’t naive enough to believe that success will come without the huge benefits that promotion brings to our club most of them financial. Entrusting that to a manager such as Val with one seasons of modest success isn’t a robust enough plan for me, it’s a huge gamble on our future erm long term success. I know it’s fashionable to believe you get a young dynamic manager over three, four year period who builds success, integrating young players into the squad, selling them and replacing with better squad players from around the world, found by our world beating scouting system but all this will not happen without money.
Locally Villa and Wolves are doing better than us because they have owners that have invested hugely in their clubs, they have tv millions pouring in, they are hoovering up the best talent in the area and can offer mercenary parents financial incentives for their kids to go to their respective clubs. Ourselves? We have two years max slight advantage to get back up over some other clubs in this division. Our edge has always been our ability to bounce back into the Prem asap, it eventually saw us hold onto our Prem status for a number of years… that is success for a self sufficient club.
We are at a crossroads promotion one way or a two or three trip down Shit Creek to Mid table at best Championship also ran.
RE: Imminent Sacking? - Peachy - 01-30-2022
(01-30-2022, 08:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-30-2022, 06:13 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (01-30-2022, 06:07 PM)MassDebater Wrote: You seriously don't see this as a season of abject humiliation? I do and have done for months. That's what makes it such a rich and often interesting place to be (on 'ere) the different views combined into a melting pot, where none of us really know anything, but all will make out we have some clue.
The future is not Six...Imagine what he'd do next year, the sort of players he'll bring in, to get us firing again. Sorry, but your long term plan fails with the wrong man in charge, Dave may have achieved it, with Shan, and more time...
Any plan goes to pot when contact with the enemy is made. Contact has been made, Six has been found massively wanting.
Thats because you focus more on the short term than I do MD.
Am I dissapointed in our performances and results? Yes... But I have been for about 6 or 7 years bar perhaps 2, 6 month spells. But as I have stated, I frankly don't know what to thjnk of Vals future. If the option is Val or one of the short term, old boys club, managers, I will stick with Val, thanks. If the club we going to look for a Graham Potter-esque manager, I would be open to it.
I have said Rob Edwards in other posts as I think he has a bright future.
We will not go forward without the money that promotion brings.
Let’s look at the facts…
We have an owner who wants to sell if they could get their money back
We have no one with any football knowledge at boardroom level
We have a DoF that has very limited experience in building a football department / infrastructure
We have a manager who has an average and limited CV with the pinnacle of it, finishing 5th with Barnsley
We have a manager with no experience of building any long term success at one club
We have a manager entrusted with according to some building a new squad over a four year period
We have no idea who is scouting our players, is it the manager, his coaches, club scouts? What happens when he leaves?
We have employed a manager with one way of playing, which then determines what players we sign and how we play. It’s very niche, inflexible in a world where football moves on and we’ve already seen it’s easily combated / negated by any half decent manager.
We can’t keep our best young players as they get poached by clubs above us, with bigger budgets
Our owners don’t need success like Peace did, their future is not linked to the success of the club relatively speaking
What’s the plan? Genuinely, without the money that short term success brings, with a self sufficient club, and no investment. With the list of things I’ve mentioned above you expect us to find a long term successful solution to these problems with a dwindling and potentially tiny income stream if we fail to go up this or next season?
Most fans want a long term plan, I certainly do but they aren’t naive enough to believe that success will come without the huge benefits that promotion brings to our club most of them financial. Entrusting that to a manager such as Val with one seasons of modest success isn’t a robust enough plan for me, it’s a huge gamble on our future erm long term success. I know it’s fashionable to believe you get a young dynamic manager over three, four year period who builds success, integrating young players into the squad, selling them and replacing with better squad players from around the world, found by our world beating scouting system but all this will not happen without money.
Locally Villa and Wolves are doing better than us because they have owners that have invested hugely in their clubs, they have tv millions pouring in, they are hoovering up the best talent in the area and can offer mercenary parents financial incentives for their kids to go to their respective clubs. Ourselves? We have two years max slight advantage to get back up over some other clubs in this division. Our edge has always been our ability to bounce back into the Prem asap, it eventually saw us hold onto our Prem status for a number of years… that is success for a self sufficient club.
We are at a crossroads promotion one way or a two or three trip down Shit Creek to Mid table at best Championship also ran.
Agree with every single word. Depressingly accurate.
Although i didn't know we had a DoF at all! Who is it?
RE: Imminent Sacking? - EastMidsBaggie - 01-30-2022
He’s still here then ?
RE: Imminent Sacking? - MassDebater - 01-30-2022
(01-30-2022, 06:13 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (01-30-2022, 06:07 PM)MassDebater Wrote: You seriously don't see this as a season of abject humiliation? I do and have done for months. That's what makes it such a rich and often interesting place to be (on 'ere) the different views combined into a melting pot, where none of us really know anything, but all will make out we have some clue.
The future is not Six...Imagine what he'd do next year, the sort of players he'll bring in, to get us firing again. Sorry, but your long term plan fails with the wrong man in charge, Dave may have achieved it, with Shan, and more time...
Any plan goes to pot when contact with the enemy is made. Contact has been made, Six has been found massively wanting.
Thats because you focus more on the short term than I do MD.
Am I dissapointed in our performances and results? Yes... But I have been for about 6 or 7 years bar perhaps 2, 6 month spells. But as I have stated, I frankly don't know what to thjnk of Vals future. If the option is Val or one of the short term, old boys club, managers, I will stick with Val, thanks. If the club we going to look for a Graham Potter-esque manager, I would be open to it.
I have said Rob Edwards in other posts as I think he has a bright future.
I didn't want Dave sacked, i thought he could make more of us....
I didn't want Slav sacked, because i thought he could do a decent job of getting us back up and deserved a free hit, because as it turns out, limping over the line is better than this abject shyte we've been given this time around, and you know, he had the full brunt of a Global Pandemic to deal with that affected a hell of a lot more than it has affected for Six.
Yep i'm a short termer... Knock yourself out kiddo.
Six has done absolutely the sum of fuck all to deserve even half the credit he is being given, yet some keep saying it's short termist to ditch him. Well it looks like you and your elk have your wish, if they didn't sack him by now, he's going nowhere, so you get at least one more wasted game with his utterly mind numbing and backwards thinking football. Knock yourself out on it.
(01-30-2022, 08:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We will not go forward without the money that promotion brings.
Let’s look at the facts…
We have an owner who wants to sell if they could get their money back
We have no one with any football knowledge at boardroom level
We have a DoF that has very limited experience in building a football department / infrastructure
We have a manager who has an average and limited CV with the pinnacle of it, finishing 5th with Barnsley
We have a manager with no experience of building any long term success at one club
We have a manager entrusted with according to some building a new squad over a four year period
We have no idea who is scouting our players, is it the manager, his coaches, club scouts? What happens when he leaves?
We have employed a manager with one way of playing, which then determines what players we sign and how we play. It’s very niche, inflexible in a world where football moves on and we’ve already seen it’s easily combated / negated by any half decent manager.
We can’t keep our best young players as they get poached by clubs above us, with bigger budgets
Our owners don’t need success like Peace did, their future is not linked to the success of the club relatively speaking
What’s the plan? Genuinely, without the money that short term success brings, with a self sufficient club, and no investment. With the list of things I’ve mentioned above you expect us to find a long term successful solution to these problems with a dwindling and potentially tiny income stream if we fail to go up this or next season?
Most fans want a long term plan, I certainly do but they aren’t naive enough to believe that success will come without the huge benefits that promotion brings to our club most of them financial. Entrusting that to a manager such as Val with one seasons of modest success isn’t a robust enough plan for me, it’s a huge gamble on our future erm long term success. I know it’s fashionable to believe you get a young dynamic manager over three, four year period who builds success, integrating young players into the squad, selling them and replacing with better squad players from around the world, found by our world beating scouting system but all this will not happen without money.
Locally Villa and Wolves are doing better than us because they have owners that have invested hugely in their clubs, they have tv millions pouring in, they are hoovering up the best talent in the area and can offer mercenary parents financial incentives for their kids to go to their respective clubs. Ourselves? We have two years max slight advantage to get back up over some other clubs in this division. Our edge has always been our ability to bounce back into the Prem asap, it eventually saw us hold onto our Prem status for a number of years… that is success for a self sufficient club.
We are at a crossroads promotion one way or a two or three trip down Shit Creek to Mid table at best Championship also ran.
Once again Derek, i totally agree. This season was pretty much promotion or obscurity, but some see it as the perfect time to warrant second rates being given a chance to impart their 'philosophy' instead. I will never understand that thinking.
RE: Imminent Sacking? - Kit Kat Chunky - 01-30-2022
Fat Frank is at Everton, so strike him off the list
RE: Imminent Sacking? - MassDebater - 01-30-2022
(01-30-2022, 08:17 PM)Peachy Wrote: (01-30-2022, 06:33 PM)mickeypearce Wrote: (01-30-2022, 05:55 PM)MassDebater Wrote: So... none of the reliable and ITK sources were right... anyone surprised?
Apart from Manc, he said his ITK source said nothing was happening and Val was at the training ground.
Tbf Mancs sauce is rock solid.....
Apologies, I did not see Mancs post.
Has he had his sauce in the freezer if it is rock solid?? yes I know his sauces are probably the best, but fugg it, some waggling is the onyl way out of this mess!
|