WBAUnofficial
Derby match Fred - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Derby match Fred (/showthread.php?tid=38696)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18


RE: Derby match Fred - Duffers - 09-14-2025

Derby were under no obligation to attack and were perfectly to stick everyone behind the ball and let us play in front of them for 90 minutes. They one one lucky break from a ball slung into the box and that was that.

They did a job on us. We need to be more proactive in home games where teams are going to do that to us, we need to find ways of getting behind the defences and that requires midfielders getting forward and full backs overlapping. Neither of which happened yesterday.


RE: Derby match Fred - Borin' Baggie - 09-14-2025

(09-14-2025, 08:07 AM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote:
(09-14-2025, 07:41 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm not sure surrendering possession and showing no intent to win the game, or at least showing very little attacking intent, is tactically out thinking your adversary.

Tactically yesterday was fine. As was the performance. Derby got lucky, didn't deserve the win, but took their single chance and took all 3 points. Fair play to them for that, that happens. 

But to say it was some sort of tactical masterclass and to somehow say Mason was outclassed is incorrect.

In terms of gameplay I'm not sure what more we could have done. We just lacked the on-pitch quality in the final third to unlock Derby on a regular basis. Even then we created enough chances to win the match comfortably.

I think people are overlooking the fact we had one cleared off the line, hit the bar, had at least 3 other efforts on goal which should have been taken. That's a combination of bad luck and not being clinical enough. There's not a lot Mason can do about that.

People are trying to find fault and negativity where none exist. Let's not go overboard after one bad result.

No one’s going overboard and don’t think it was a tactical master class against us but they repeated the Cup match where, yet again, we struggled to score.
It’s up to the coach to deal with the opponents tactics and we failed.
We lined up very predictably and didn’t really try much different throughout.
I don’t get the unlucky bit when we have so much possession and are so wasteful with final balls, crosses and set pieces. Not using the bench well enough and having Jed as a starter was poor.
We now have some really difficult games coming up against much better teams than Derby so let’s see how we get on.

The cup game was different, we carved them apart and had multiple good chances. Their keeper was man of the match that day. Yesterday their keeper made 3 saves and we only had two good chances with Molumby at the end and the header that Mowatt cleared off the line (maybe the Price volley in the first half but that's difficult to pull off).


RE: Derby match Fred - DemonicBaggie - 09-14-2025

Like the brass band pre-game we blew hard but didn’t produce much sound.

A travesty of a result but if you don’t score you don’t win. We were the thickness of the woodwork away from a tremendous and deserved equaliser.

Derby won’t get away with that every week - they were abysmal and rode their luck- and our prospects going forward are far better than theirs.

Onwards and upwards.


RE: Derby match Fred - Josh1873 - 09-14-2025

I'm just wondering, a few questions for the tactical geniuses on here, what would you have done differently with the starting XI, and how would you have approached the game differently? What subs would you have made? How would you have broken Derby down, when it became clear they had no intention of attacking us?

I don't think I'd have done much different to Mason. Perhaps bring Maja on earlier alongside Heggebø, but other than that, I'm not sure what else he could have done given his resources.


RE: Derby match Fred - Tiptonmon - 09-14-2025

(09-14-2025, 09:00 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm just wondering, a few questions for the tactical geniuses on here, what would you have done differently with the starting XI, and how would you have approached the game differently? What subs would you have made? How would you have broken Derby down, when it became clear they had no intention of attacking us?

I don't think I'd have done much different to Mason. Perhaps bring Maja on earlier alongside Heggebø, but other than that, I'm not sure what else he could have done given his resources.

Not bringing Maja on much earlier, either alongside Heggebo or replacing him was a glaring error. Maja is a proven goalscorer at this level and if he can't last for at least 30 minutes, he shouldn't be on the bench.


RE: Derby match Fred - Duffers - 09-14-2025

(09-14-2025, 09:00 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm just wondering, a few questions for the tactical geniuses on here, what would you have done differently with the starting XI, and how would you have approached the game differently? What subs would you have made? How would you have broken Derby down, when it became clear they had no intention of attacking us?

I don't think I'd have done much different to Mason. Perhaps bring Maja on earlier alongside Heggebø, but other than that, I'm not sure what else he could have done given his resources.

You seem determined to paint yourself as the sole voice of reason Josh, labelling any legitimate criticism of yesterday’s performance as a meltdown.

No issues with the starting XI as they’d done well at Stoke. However it was painfully obvious by HT that Derby were happy to sit back and we didn’t have the pace or guile to break them down. The midfield was static and nothing was being offered down the wings. There was a spell in the opening 10 minutes of the second half where we came out with a little more purpose, but rather than seizing the initiative and making some proactive changes Mason did nothing and the momentum was lost. Waiting until 70 minutes to make any changes was too late.

We were poor yesterday, players were poor and Mason got it wrong with his game management. It happens but it’s ok to acknowledge that. It’s not a meltdown nor is it saying we’re doomed. Just acknowledging how poor we were.


RE: Derby match Fred - Ted Maul - 09-14-2025

The big things for me I spot when I watch us play, especially in games like yesterday.

We're far too narrow. Can we stretch the pitch and play with higher 8s or two 10s off Heggebo

Our midfield two does the job of one player. Molumby runs around so people like him but is not good enough on the ball to help us unpick a deep defence.

I don't mind the narrow back four but it means that we need the wingers wide. Perhaps trying them on the opposite flanks, can Johnston play off the right as effectively?

Our striker, whilst he fights defenders and holds the ball up well isn't a goalscorer in a million years so when the chance comes in games like that, do we trust him to put it away?

Griffiths; Campbell, Phillips, Mepham, SIJ; Price, Mowatt, Styles, Johnston, Heggebo, Maja in a 4-3-3 in games like yesterday. SIJ giving the width on the left to tuck Maja inside to play as a second 10 with Price and Styles supporting from deeper.


RE: Derby match Fred - Josh1873 - 09-14-2025

I don't see my self as anything, let alone the voice of reason. I'm just calling the game how I saw it, like other posters are. We were not poor yesterday, FFS. I must have been watching a different game. If people watched us yesterday and thought we were poor, then that's their perogative, I think they're wrong, and I'm putting across why I think they're wrong. That's kind of how a discussion forum works!

The only valid critisicms I've seen so far have been our inability to be clinical in front of goal, our lack of creativity (however, it also has to be acknowledged we ARE creating some chances), and, having seen the goal back, critisicm for Campbell's role in the winner. He should be standing Wieman up there, not diving in like that.

Other than that I genuinely thought we played well enough, and did enough to win. Yes, we were short on creativity, but there's also a stubborn team trying to stop us scoring, that has to be acknowledged, too. Derby did a good job on us. That being said the chances to score were there, and should have been taken. I thought Mason set us up well enough, and his changes were fine. We were on top all game but couldn't break down a stubborn defence. It happens. I'm certainly not going to have a meltdown and go all negative off the back of one bad result.

How Mason has set us up and how we play has yielded positive results so far. I don't see, and didn't see anything yesterday, as to why he should fundamentally change his tactics and selections. We were unlucky yesterday, and Derby got away with one. There's nothing more to analyse, really.


RE: Derby match Fred - Duffers - 09-14-2025

(09-14-2025, 09:59 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I don't see my self as anything, let alone the voice of reason. I'm just calling the game how I see it, like other posters are. We were not poor yesterday, FFS. I must have been watching a different game. If people watched us yesterday and thought we were poor, then that's their perogative, I think they're wrong, and I'm putting across why I think they're wrong. That's kind of how a discussion forum works!

The only valid critisicms I've seen so far have been our inability to be clinical in front of goal, our lack of creativity (however, it also has to be acknowledged we ARE creating chances), and, having seen the goal back, critisicm for Campbell's role in the winner. He should be standing Wieman up there, not diving in like that.

Other than those I genuinely thought we played well enough, and did enough to win. I thought Mason set us up well enough, and his changes were fine. We were on top all game but couldn't break down a stubborn defence. It happens.

How Mason has set us up and how we play has yielded positive results so far. I don't see, and didn't see anything yesterday, as to why he should fundamentally change his tactics and selections. We were unlucky yesterday, and Derby got away with one. There's nothing more to analyse, really.

Are we? Other than hitting the bar yesterday how many times did the keeper have a save to make?


RE: Derby match Fred - Josh1873 - 09-14-2025

He made a good save off Molumby. Wallace had a good chance on his left foot, Mowatt managed to clear one off the line, Price nearly scored a great goal, the Molumby effort off the bar, you mentioned, and numerous blocked shots and missed headers, from corners and crosses.

Look, I'm not saying we had chance after chance, and it was free flowing, but conversely to say we created nothing is incorrect. There were enough chances for us to score a goal, the players those chances fell to need to be more clinical.

Our defenders also needs to make better decisions in individual situations. As well organised and generally defensively sound as we are, we are still conceding sloppy goals, that are costing us. That's as much, maybe even a bigger, frustration than our goalscoring, or lack thereof.