WBAUnofficial
Rugby World Cup - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Rugby World Cup (/showthread.php?tid=31146)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17


RE: Rugby World Cup - Borin' Baggie - 10-16-2023

(10-16-2023, 01:21 PM)NewWanker Wrote: I don't really follow cricket, but I'd love it if we won it, just watch the en masse backtracking on here...

What's your opinion on rugby though?


RE: Rugby World Cup - hudds - 10-16-2023

(10-16-2023, 02:01 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 01:21 PM)NewWanker Wrote: I don't really follow cricket, but I'd love it if we won it, just watch the en masse backtracking on here...

What's your opinion on rugby though?
Is he qualified to comment?  Shoe size etc.


RE: Rugby World Cup - SausEggBaton - 10-16-2023

(10-16-2023, 09:55 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Counter point:  They're not very good at basketball.

You gonna tell that to a Rugby players face?


RE: Rugby World Cup - NewWanker - 10-16-2023

(10-16-2023, 02:13 PM)hudds Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 02:01 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 01:21 PM)NewWanker Wrote: I don't really follow cricket, but I'd love it if we won it, just watch the en masse backtracking on here...

What's your opinion on rugby though?
Is he qualified to comment?  Shoe size etc.

Big Grin 'arfy oops... Same game innit? Easily mixed up


RE: Rugby World Cup - Derek Hardballs - 10-16-2023

(10-16-2023, 01:14 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 11:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 09:28 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: On this weekends QFS, what a 4 matches of rugby. All 4 matches were competitive, enthralling and generally played at a very high standard. England did well to get past possibly the best Fijian team ever, but have little to no hope against SA. Have to feel for France and Ireland, so close but just couldn't get past that rugby pedigree of NZ/SA.

Yes England have massively benefitted from an easy draw to get to the semis, and for the next RWC, the IRB really need to do the draw closer to the tournament (it was done 3 years ago FFS sake). To have the top 5 teams in the world in 2 groups, that were then drawn to all meet in the QFS in a farce, really.

It's hard to look past a NZ v SA final, but it's sport, so I guess you never know.

(10-15-2023, 09:37 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(10-15-2023, 04:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Well we could but given the size of country’s and resources of the respective countries of the world competing in this World Cup  it would look distinctly small time.

We should never be out of the final given the disparities.

Bizarre take. 3 finals out of the last 5, winning 1 of them, isn’t exactly a bad return.

Was going to post this too whilst catching up on the thread. It's also an incredibly arrogant attitude, belittling the role of every other Rugby nation along the way. And only 5 nations have ever been in a RWC Final. NZ, Australia and England have been to 4, France and SA to 3. So, England the joint best "Getting to the final" record. Derek might need to check his history.

Also regarding population and "registered" rugby players - how many of those players are professional? England (inc GB) also has many many sports to fill with athletes (as we compete globally on many sports), so you can't assume the absolute best athletes end up playing international rugby. You can assume that the best Fijians as an example, play rugby. They're also physically built to play rugby in a way that the English just aren't (in general).

And on Fijians (and Samoans/Tongans), a lot of their best players historically went and played for the All Blacks, Australia or other nations. In recent years, they have stopped doing this. Fiji are a proper team, and at the next WC in 4 years, I reckon they'll be a legitimate contender.

I would expect us to get to most finals given the amount of players we have and the professional leagues we play in. If you’re arguing that all the best athletes from other countries play Rugby rather than football or other sports I would have to ask where the evidence is to support this particularly in the northern hemisphere. The fact we have only one World Cup win given the disparity historically and even now between the top 3-4 countries and the rest is a poor return. That might sound harsh but we do punch below our weight whilst other nations punch way above theirs such as Fiji.

 I obviously want England to win but ‘laughing’ at the home nations with a fraction of the playing personnel to choose from that we are in the semi-finals whilst in a very fortunate side of the draw seem very small time.

You're reading what you want to, rather than what I said. I didn't argue that "If you’re arguing that all the best athletes from other countries play Rugby rather than football or other sports" - I specfically mentioned Fiji, and meant countries of that level, mostly Pacific Islanders, and at a higher level, SA & NZ. You're also not bothering to reply to the physical build point I made, or the fact that Pacific Islanders have historically played for other countries.

Meanwhile in France for example, the level of investment in the Top 14 is far far higher than our domestic leagues (the whole UK, not just England), and they have a much stronger Rugby culture than us. They've been to fewer finals, and have never won it. So where's the commentary on France?

What's this historic disparity you're mentioning? The sport only went professional in 1995. Since then we've done better than all countries not named NZ/SA. Given they're most likely to meet in the final, it's quite easy to suggest they're easily the best rugby countries in the world. And shockingly, rugby is their main sport (you could argue cricket for both as well, but it's between the two sports). I'd say we're exactly punching our weight. Again, you're disregarding the fact that other teams are actively trying to stop us winning/are more talented/have better coaching etc etc etc.

" I obviously want England to win but ‘laughing’ at the home nations with a fraction of the playing personnel to choose from that we are in the semi-finals whilst in a very fortunate side of the draw seem very small time." - I didn't comment on this, because frankly, I have no opinion. If people wish to WUM the other Home Nations using the fact we're in the semis and they arent, I'm sure they'll get some bites. I would tend to agree with you on this point if I cared.

Answer to first paragraph I said IF you are arguing. We also live in multicultural country with people from from across the world in terms of their heritage that could play for England. The argument that somehow the Pacific Islanders are physically superior is questionable to the players we could potentially pick from. There might be an argument to suggest we don’t attract enough youngsters from diverse backgrounds though. 

Answer to second paragraph yes France are under achieving but I wasn’t talking about France. 

Answer to third paragraph you can’t compare Italy, Spain, Argentina, Japan, Samoa or even the smaller home nations amateur teams now or historically with the resources England have had since the inception of the World Cup. One World Cup is a poor return in a competition. 

The comment was just a reply to those scoffing at Ireland and Wales etc not your good self. 

I used to play Rugby at colt level and then broke into the b team at 16 and had a trial for Moseley, went to Twickeham for a junior sevens competition so I do have some knowledge of the game but not much love I have to admit. I decided to give it up as it was either a season ticket or playing hungover blokes who wanted a scrap every Saturday.


RE: Rugby World Cup - AnelkasBeard - 10-17-2023

(10-16-2023, 05:55 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 01:14 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 11:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 09:28 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: On this weekends QFS, what a 4 matches of rugby. All 4 matches were competitive, enthralling and generally played at a very high standard. England did well to get past possibly the best Fijian team ever, but have little to no hope against SA. Have to feel for France and Ireland, so close but just couldn't get past that rugby pedigree of NZ/SA.

Yes England have massively benefitted from an easy draw to get to the semis, and for the next RWC, the IRB really need to do the draw closer to the tournament (it was done 3 years ago FFS sake). To have the top 5 teams in the world in 2 groups, that were then drawn to all meet in the QFS in a farce, really.

It's hard to look past a NZ v SA final, but it's sport, so I guess you never know.

(10-15-2023, 09:37 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Bizarre take. 3 finals out of the last 5, winning 1 of them, isn’t exactly a bad return.

Was going to post this too whilst catching up on the thread. It's also an incredibly arrogant attitude, belittling the role of every other Rugby nation along the way. And only 5 nations have ever been in a RWC Final. NZ, Australia and England have been to 4, France and SA to 3. So, England the joint best "Getting to the final" record. Derek might need to check his history.

Also regarding population and "registered" rugby players - how many of those players are professional? England (inc GB) also has many many sports to fill with athletes (as we compete globally on many sports), so you can't assume the absolute best athletes end up playing international rugby. You can assume that the best Fijians as an example, play rugby. They're also physically built to play rugby in a way that the English just aren't (in general).

And on Fijians (and Samoans/Tongans), a lot of their best players historically went and played for the All Blacks, Australia or other nations. In recent years, they have stopped doing this. Fiji are a proper team, and at the next WC in 4 years, I reckon they'll be a legitimate contender.

I would expect us to get to most finals given the amount of players we have and the professional leagues we play in. If you’re arguing that all the best athletes from other countries play Rugby rather than football or other sports I would have to ask where the evidence is to support this particularly in the northern hemisphere. The fact we have only one World Cup win given the disparity historically and even now between the top 3-4 countries and the rest is a poor return. That might sound harsh but we do punch below our weight whilst other nations punch way above theirs such as Fiji.

 I obviously want England to win but ‘laughing’ at the home nations with a fraction of the playing personnel to choose from that we are in the semi-finals whilst in a very fortunate side of the draw seem very small time.

You're reading what you want to, rather than what I said. I didn't argue that "If you’re arguing that all the best athletes from other countries play Rugby rather than football or other sports" - I specfically mentioned Fiji, and meant countries of that level, mostly Pacific Islanders, and at a higher level, SA & NZ. You're also not bothering to reply to the physical build point I made, or the fact that Pacific Islanders have historically played for other countries.

Meanwhile in France for example, the level of investment in the Top 14 is far far higher than our domestic leagues (the whole UK, not just England), and they have a much stronger Rugby culture than us. They've been to fewer finals, and have never won it. So where's the commentary on France?

What's this historic disparity you're mentioning? The sport only went professional in 1995. Since then we've done better than all countries not named NZ/SA. Given they're most likely to meet in the final, it's quite easy to suggest they're easily the best rugby countries in the world. And shockingly, rugby is their main sport (you could argue cricket for both as well, but it's between the two sports). I'd say we're exactly punching our weight. Again, you're disregarding the fact that other teams are actively trying to stop us winning/are more talented/have better coaching etc etc etc.

" I obviously want England to win but ‘laughing’ at the home nations with a fraction of the playing personnel to choose from that we are in the semi-finals whilst in a very fortunate side of the draw seem very small time." - I didn't comment on this, because frankly, I have no opinion. If people wish to WUM the other Home Nations using the fact we're in the semis and they arent, I'm sure they'll get some bites. I would tend to agree with you on this point if I cared.

Answer to first paragraph I said IF you are arguing. We also live in multicultural country with people from from across the world in terms of their heritage that could play for England. The argument that somehow the Pacific Islanders are physically superior is questionable to the players we could potentially pick from. There might be an argument to suggest we don’t attract enough youngsters from diverse backgrounds though. 

Answer to second paragraph yes France are under achieving but I wasn’t talking about France. 

Answer to third paragraph you can’t compare Italy, Spain, Argentina, Japan, Samoa or even the smaller home nations amateur teams now or historically with the resources England have had since the inception of the World Cup. One World Cup is a poor return in a competition. 

The comment was just a reply to those scoffing at Ireland and Wales etc not your good self. 

I used to play Rugby at colt level and then broke into the b team at 16 and had a trial for Moseley, went to Twickeham for a junior sevens competition so I do have some knowledge of the game but not much love I have to admit. I decided to give it up as it was either a season ticket or playing hungover blokes who wanted a scrap every Saturday.

Just compare the size of Fiji's backs to Englands. Also, it's a pretty well known thing that the Pacific Islanders have a more bulky, strong physique than Europeans. You're probably right in regards the diverse background point though.

You weren't talking about France, but you can't talk about England "under achieving" and not compare them to other similar countries performance. We've performed about where you'd expect us to taking everything in to account. We were very close to somehow winning that 2007 final.


RE: Rugby World Cup - Derek Hardballs - 10-17-2023

(10-17-2023, 10:15 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 05:55 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 01:14 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 11:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 09:28 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: On this weekends QFS, what a 4 matches of rugby. All 4 matches were competitive, enthralling and generally played at a very high standard. England did well to get past possibly the best Fijian team ever, but have little to no hope against SA. Have to feel for France and Ireland, so close but just couldn't get past that rugby pedigree of NZ/SA.

Yes England have massively benefitted from an easy draw to get to the semis, and for the next RWC, the IRB really need to do the draw closer to the tournament (it was done 3 years ago FFS sake). To have the top 5 teams in the world in 2 groups, that were then drawn to all meet in the QFS in a farce, really.

It's hard to look past a NZ v SA final, but it's sport, so I guess you never know.


Was going to post this too whilst catching up on the thread. It's also an incredibly arrogant attitude, belittling the role of every other Rugby nation along the way. And only 5 nations have ever been in a RWC Final. NZ, Australia and England have been to 4, France and SA to 3. So, England the joint best "Getting to the final" record. Derek might need to check his history.

Also regarding population and "registered" rugby players - how many of those players are professional? England (inc GB) also has many many sports to fill with athletes (as we compete globally on many sports), so you can't assume the absolute best athletes end up playing international rugby. You can assume that the best Fijians as an example, play rugby. They're also physically built to play rugby in a way that the English just aren't (in general).

And on Fijians (and Samoans/Tongans), a lot of their best players historically went and played for the All Blacks, Australia or other nations. In recent years, they have stopped doing this. Fiji are a proper team, and at the next WC in 4 years, I reckon they'll be a legitimate contender.

I would expect us to get to most finals given the amount of players we have and the professional leagues we play in. If you’re arguing that all the best athletes from other countries play Rugby rather than football or other sports I would have to ask where the evidence is to support this particularly in the northern hemisphere. The fact we have only one World Cup win given the disparity historically and even now between the top 3-4 countries and the rest is a poor return. That might sound harsh but we do punch below our weight whilst other nations punch way above theirs such as Fiji.

 I obviously want England to win but ‘laughing’ at the home nations with a fraction of the playing personnel to choose from that we are in the semi-finals whilst in a very fortunate side of the draw seem very small time.

You're reading what you want to, rather than what I said. I didn't argue that "If you’re arguing that all the best athletes from other countries play Rugby rather than football or other sports" - I specfically mentioned Fiji, and meant countries of that level, mostly Pacific Islanders, and at a higher level, SA & NZ. You're also not bothering to reply to the physical build point I made, or the fact that Pacific Islanders have historically played for other countries.

Meanwhile in France for example, the level of investment in the Top 14 is far far higher than our domestic leagues (the whole UK, not just England), and they have a much stronger Rugby culture than us. They've been to fewer finals, and have never won it. So where's the commentary on France?

What's this historic disparity you're mentioning? The sport only went professional in 1995. Since then we've done better than all countries not named NZ/SA. Given they're most likely to meet in the final, it's quite easy to suggest they're easily the best rugby countries in the world. And shockingly, rugby is their main sport (you could argue cricket for both as well, but it's between the two sports). I'd say we're exactly punching our weight. Again, you're disregarding the fact that other teams are actively trying to stop us winning/are more talented/have better coaching etc etc etc.

" I obviously want England to win but ‘laughing’ at the home nations with a fraction of the playing personnel to choose from that we are in the semi-finals whilst in a very fortunate side of the draw seem very small time." - I didn't comment on this, because frankly, I have no opinion. If people wish to WUM the other Home Nations using the fact we're in the semis and they arent, I'm sure they'll get some bites. I would tend to agree with you on this point if I cared.

Answer to first paragraph I said IF you are arguing. We also live in multicultural country with people from from across the world in terms of their heritage that could play for England. The argument that somehow the Pacific Islanders are physically superior is questionable to the players we could potentially pick from. There might be an argument to suggest we don’t attract enough youngsters from diverse backgrounds though. 

Answer to second paragraph yes France are under achieving but I wasn’t talking about France. 

Answer to third paragraph you can’t compare Italy, Spain, Argentina, Japan, Samoa or even the smaller home nations amateur teams now or historically with the resources England have had since the inception of the World Cup. One World Cup is a poor return in a competition. 

The comment was just a reply to those scoffing at Ireland and Wales etc not your good self. 

I used to play Rugby at colt level and then broke into the b team at 16 and had a trial for Moseley, went to Twickeham for a junior sevens competition so I do have some knowledge of the game but not much love I have to admit. I decided to give it up as it was either a season ticket or playing hungover blokes who wanted a scrap every Saturday.

Just compare the size of Fiji's backs to Englands. Also, it's a pretty well known thing that the Pacific Islanders have a more bulky, strong physique than Europeans. You're probably right in regards the diverse background point though.

You weren't talking about France, but you can't talk about England "under achieving" and not compare them to other similar countries performance. We've performed about where you'd expect us to taking everything in to account. We were very close to somehow winning that 2007 final.

Tbh I don’t think we are too far apart with this AB, the achievement of England and France in terms of them both not doing as well as they should is subjective I agree and we shall probably have to agree to disagree. I do think Rugby in the U.K. needs to be more reflective of the diversity of the country as Union is still a mcw sport in the main, and inevitably due to this misses out on a lot of talented kids that don’t go to Rugby schools etc. I only started playing because there was a scheme to get kids from local Comps playing the game at the time and I doubt if anything has really changed.


RE: Rugby World Cup - Fido - 10-17-2023

We played a fair bit of rugby at my comp as did most others around us. It was always rugby before Xmas and football after. My nipper’s school is decent but rugby seems to have almost disappeared. That then discludes anyone who doesn’t play for a club.


RE: Rugby World Cup - AnelkasBeard - 10-17-2023

(10-17-2023, 10:53 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-17-2023, 10:15 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 05:55 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 01:14 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(10-16-2023, 11:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I would expect us to get to most finals given the amount of players we have and the professional leagues we play in. If you’re arguing that all the best athletes from other countries play Rugby rather than football or other sports I would have to ask where the evidence is to support this particularly in the northern hemisphere. The fact we have only one World Cup win given the disparity historically and even now between the top 3-4 countries and the rest is a poor return. That might sound harsh but we do punch below our weight whilst other nations punch way above theirs such as Fiji.

 I obviously want England to win but ‘laughing’ at the home nations with a fraction of the playing personnel to choose from that we are in the semi-finals whilst in a very fortunate side of the draw seem very small time.

You're reading what you want to, rather than what I said. I didn't argue that "If you’re arguing that all the best athletes from other countries play Rugby rather than football or other sports" - I specfically mentioned Fiji, and meant countries of that level, mostly Pacific Islanders, and at a higher level, SA & NZ. You're also not bothering to reply to the physical build point I made, or the fact that Pacific Islanders have historically played for other countries.

Meanwhile in France for example, the level of investment in the Top 14 is far far higher than our domestic leagues (the whole UK, not just England), and they have a much stronger Rugby culture than us. They've been to fewer finals, and have never won it. So where's the commentary on France?

What's this historic disparity you're mentioning? The sport only went professional in 1995. Since then we've done better than all countries not named NZ/SA. Given they're most likely to meet in the final, it's quite easy to suggest they're easily the best rugby countries in the world. And shockingly, rugby is their main sport (you could argue cricket for both as well, but it's between the two sports). I'd say we're exactly punching our weight. Again, you're disregarding the fact that other teams are actively trying to stop us winning/are more talented/have better coaching etc etc etc.

" I obviously want England to win but ‘laughing’ at the home nations with a fraction of the playing personnel to choose from that we are in the semi-finals whilst in a very fortunate side of the draw seem very small time." - I didn't comment on this, because frankly, I have no opinion. If people wish to WUM the other Home Nations using the fact we're in the semis and they arent, I'm sure they'll get some bites. I would tend to agree with you on this point if I cared.

Answer to first paragraph I said IF you are arguing. We also live in multicultural country with people from from across the world in terms of their heritage that could play for England. The argument that somehow the Pacific Islanders are physically superior is questionable to the players we could potentially pick from. There might be an argument to suggest we don’t attract enough youngsters from diverse backgrounds though. 

Answer to second paragraph yes France are under achieving but I wasn’t talking about France. 

Answer to third paragraph you can’t compare Italy, Spain, Argentina, Japan, Samoa or even the smaller home nations amateur teams now or historically with the resources England have had since the inception of the World Cup. One World Cup is a poor return in a competition. 

The comment was just a reply to those scoffing at Ireland and Wales etc not your good self. 

I used to play Rugby at colt level and then broke into the b team at 16 and had a trial for Moseley, went to Twickeham for a junior sevens competition so I do have some knowledge of the game but not much love I have to admit. I decided to give it up as it was either a season ticket or playing hungover blokes who wanted a scrap every Saturday.

Just compare the size of Fiji's backs to Englands. Also, it's a pretty well known thing that the Pacific Islanders have a more bulky, strong physique than Europeans. You're probably right in regards the diverse background point though.

You weren't talking about France, but you can't talk about England "under achieving" and not compare them to other similar countries performance. We've performed about where you'd expect us to taking everything in to account. We were very close to somehow winning that 2007 final.

Tbh I don’t think we are too far apart with this AB, the achievement of England and France in terms of them both not doing as well as they should is subjective I agree and we shall probably have to agree to disagree. I do think Rugby in the U.K. needs to be more reflective of the diversity of the country as Union is still a mcw sport in the main, and inevitably due to this misses out on a lot of talented kids that don’t go to Rugby schools etc. I only started playing because there was a scheme to get kids from local Comps playing the game at the time and I doubt if anything has really changed.

It is very much still an MCW sport. I went to a private school, but with a pretty good diverse background in general (certainly better than you'd expect). And we had to play the Bromsgrove school, Warwick school and Shrewsbury schools teams, RGS Worcester etc, and in general it was mostly MCW's and even UCW's toffing about.


RE: Rugby World Cup - Derek Hardballs - 10-17-2023

(10-17-2023, 11:10 AM)Fido Wrote: We played a fair bit of rugby at my comp as did most others around us. It was always rugby before Xmas and football after. My nipper’s school is decent but rugby seems to have almost disappeared. That then discludes anyone who doesn’t play for a club.

I think Grammar schools still play but most comps sorry academy’s don’t that I know and I’m not sure there are any leagues or cups like in football that you can play now in normal schools? We used to do similar with splitting the year into Rigby and Football but we played Rugby in reality twice in five years at School.