WBAUnofficial
More rail strikes - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: More rail strikes (/showthread.php?tid=27740)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24


RE: More rail strikes - Borin' Baggie - 12-01-2022

(12-01-2022, 07:33 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
Everything Zin Wrote:End all taxpayer subsidies of the railways. Make ticket prices reflect the true cost of running the business and if they can’t make a profit then let the businesses go into liquidation, not get rescued by the taxpayer. If they fail all the employees lose their jobs but maybe a new business can come in with a reasonable cost base.

Like what happens in the normal, non taxpayer funded, world.

But the tickets are ridiculously expensive anyway!

Either the rail infrastructure is not commercially viable, or efficiencies have to be made to make it cover it's costs. I'm not sure which one it is, but railways exist all over the world, so presumably some areas are running them at break-even?
Pretty much all railways are subsidised, one way or another. Switzerland, possibly the most capitalist country in Europe, has nationalised railways. The UK network receives more state support now than the nationalised British Rail ever did, and has done so every year since the railways were taken from public ownership. Of course, they have to find extra money for things like shareholders. We were told they would be more efficient, amongst many other things, I read of a commuter today that travels from Sussex to Liverpool twice a week. His fare is over £400. He has found by buying tickets to split the journey he can travel for £80.  That isn't the fault of the workers, that is the action of a company that simply doesn't care.

Japan has the only successful modern implementation of privatised railways and even there 3 of the 7 JR groups are publicly owned and regional governments own and subsidise regional rail. And the remaining 4 JR groups are regulated to the point of being state operated.


RE: More rail strikes - Protheroe - 12-01-2022

(12-01-2022, 06:13 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(12-01-2022, 06:06 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-01-2022, 04:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm just looking forward to how the nurses are going to go on strike without "harming patient care". It's a little like the rail workers going on strike but the trains still running.

I mean it’s impossible. There’s no way they can go on strike without harming patient care. 

But it’s bigoted to point that out, so the choice is between being a bigot or a liar.

The easy way to stop the nurses strike, pay them what they’re worth for looking after our sick and critically ill family’s. Everyone says what a brilliant job they do well now is the time to show them. Pay them what they deserve.
It’s ok for the rich they just pop along to the local private hospital majority can’t afford this.

What are they worth? The independent pay review body has made a recommendation which the government said it will pay in full. Nurses have decided themselves that they are worth more. On what grounds? Many people do a brilliant job, why not pay everyone what they think their worth?

TBH - I think they think they're worth more because the cost of withdrawing their labour is measured in suffering. That's not a moral position I'd be comfortable with if I was a nurse.


RE: More rail strikes - Ossian - 12-01-2022

(12-01-2022, 04:00 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Either the rail infrastructure is not commercially viable, or efficiencies have to be made to make it cover it's costs. I'm not sure which one it is, but railways exist all over the world, so presumably some areas are running them at break-even?

Some of it is (commercially viable) as long as fares are properly collected; other parts undoubtedly not, at least not throughout the entire year. So, as a society, we have a choice to make - do we retain only those routes/services which show a return? Or do we accept that some parts of the network will have to be treated as a publicly subsidised amenity?

It's a philosophical conundrum which requires a decision, followed by a defence in the face of inevitable criticism (whatever is decided). In other words, exactly the kind of issue our politicians either fudge or avoid like the plague.


RE: More rail strikes - wba13 - 12-01-2022

(12-01-2022, 09:00 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(12-01-2022, 06:13 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(12-01-2022, 06:06 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-01-2022, 04:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm just looking forward to how the nurses are going to go on strike without "harming patient care". It's a little like the rail workers going on strike but the trains still running.

I mean it’s impossible. There’s no way they can go on strike without harming patient care. 

But it’s bigoted to point that out, so the choice is between being a bigot or a liar.

The easy way to stop the nurses strike, pay them what they’re worth for looking after our sick and critically ill family’s. Everyone says what a brilliant job they do well now is the time to show them. Pay them what they deserve.
It’s ok for the rich they just pop along to the local private hospital majority can’t afford this.

What are they worth? The independent pay review body has made a recommendation which the government said it will pay in full. Nurses have decided themselves that they are worth more. On what grounds? Many people do a brilliant job, why not pay everyone what they think their worth?

TBH - I think they think they're worth more because the cost of withdrawing their labour is measured in suffering. That's not a moral position I'd be comfortable with if I was a nurse.

I think most people think that nurses deserve more,which they do.Not the nurses themselves I hope some of you never need the care and love that the nurses do. A lot of the time they work unpaid overtime so that patients get the care they deserve yet some seem to think they  decided themselves they deserve more. Give them what they need without taking car parking charges of them. Let the fat cats who do fuck all pay for them along with politicians who turn up at the House of Commons to collect their fees for doing fuck all.


RE: More rail strikes - Tom Joad - 12-01-2022

Ossian Wrote:
Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:Either the rail infrastructure is not commercially viable, or efficiencies have to be made to make it cover it's costs. I'm not sure which one it is, but railways exist all over the world, so presumably some areas are running them at break-even?

Some of it is (commercially viable) as long as fares are properly collected; other parts undoubtedly not, at least not throughout the entire year. So, as a society, we have a choice to make - do we retain only those routes/services which show a return? Or do we accept that some parts of the network will have to be treated as a publicly subsidised amenity?

It's a philosophical conundrum which requires a decision, followed by a defence in the face of inevitable criticism (whatever is decided). In other words, exactly the kind of issue our politicians either fudge or avoid like the plague.
This is a moot point. Either we accept an efficient, equitable system of transport. Or, we accept a system whereby a thousand buses/trains a day compete for the same profitable routes (i.e. into and out of major cities), and no one runs the unprofitable rural or even late night routes. Sometimes quality of life must come before a quick profit.


RE: More rail strikes - Ossian - 12-01-2022

Probably no surprise that we find ourselves on the same side of the argument, Tom.


RE: More rail strikes - Protheroe - 12-02-2022

(12-01-2022, 09:12 PM)wba13 Wrote: I think most people think that nurses deserve more,which they do.Not the nurses themselves I hope some of you never need the care and love that the nurses do. A lot of the time they work unpaid overtime so that patients get the care they deserve yet some seem to think they  decided themselves they deserve more. Give them what they need without taking car parking charges of them. Let the fat cats who do fuck all pay for them along with politicians who turn up at the House of Commons to collect their fees for doing fuck all.

It doesn't matter "what most people think". Most people are not as acquainted with the financial pressures facing the NHS as the Independent Pay Review body which made recommendations to the government which they intend to fund in full.

My family (late parents) did need and didn't get the care they deserved with Stage 4 cancer until we moved them into the hospice movement where they both died cared for, in no pain and with the dignity sorely lacking on the hospital wards they'd inhabited. In fact we had to virtually kidnap my father from Solihull Hospital to get him into the Marie Curie down the road.

The lack of care my family experienced is nothing to do with pay. It's to do with the culture and priorities of a dysfunctional organisation and the people within it who too often forget who their clients actually are. It's no coincidence that I feel this way about the QE - where my dad was unfortunate enough to spend too much time.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-63827648


RE: More rail strikes - Woodman scoreboard - 12-05-2022

I see the wankers are on strike on Xmas Eve until the 27th I hope they get food poisoning off a rotten turkey


RE: More rail strikes - Ted Maul - 12-05-2022

Just announced strikes over Christmas from 6pm on Christmas Eve to 6am on the 27th.


RE: More rail strikes - Sliced - 12-05-2022

(12-05-2022, 07:01 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Just announced strikes over Christmas from 6pm on Christmas Eve to 6am on the 27th.

Conveniently timed eh