WBAUnofficial
QPR Match thread - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: QPR Match thread (/showthread.php?tid=23530)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14


RE: QPR Match thread - EastMidsBaggie - 01-15-2022

(01-15-2022, 05:59 PM)strawman Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 05:51 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 05:46 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 05:40 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Not saying the manager is doing things right by the way.

But name the players that are promotion chasing Champ players in this squad, and look at the careers of these players prior to us, mid table champ is generally their level for a reason.

As said, awful recruitment for years, reliance on loans to add stuff clearly missing from players we own, poor value when buying players, all combined to create this mess.

Who are these better squads? I’ve asked the question so many times now but apart from Fulham I don’t see any. I see a manager making decent Champ players look / play below what they are capable of. 

There is no way that the results we are getting currently are representative of the quality of our squad.

To be fair, I think we're in a group of squads under Fulham, all much of a muchness with a couple of standout players. Problem is, there are pretty much no goals in our squad.

Add in a philosophy driven manager whose philosophy doesn't suit the squad. It's only going to go wrong.

As said, back to you, which of our players stand out as better than others? As I said, much of a muchness past Fulham. 

Without goals, you don't win games, there are so few goals in this squad it's painful.
In the first 10 games we achieved 22 points averaging 2.2points pre game and scoring 20 goals.
In the last 16 games we have achieved 20 points at 1.25 points per game and scored only 11 goals (and 3 of those in 1 game)

So what happened? - did the players suddenly decide that they couldn’t be arsed to score or win anymore  or did the tactics get sussed out and the manager has little clue what to do in response ?

Will a new striker make a difference. I’m not so sure, if they aren’t getting the support from midfield then it may be easy to mark them out of the game. Most of the crosses are garbage.

I don’t think I have seen one instance of a change being made which has changed a game positively, if anyone can point to one then feel free to point it out.

Sorry but I think he is a one tactic wonder and has no clue how to respond when other teams negates that tactic. We are back to having a ‘project’ without any response when the project goes off track.
 A lot of fans seem to love a project but what’s the point of the projects failing abysmally?
Rather have competence than a project for my club.


RE: QPR Match thread - Birdman1811 - 01-15-2022

(01-15-2022, 05:57 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 05:51 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 05:46 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 05:40 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Not saying the manager is doing things right by the way.

But name the players that are promotion chasing Champ players in this squad, and look at the careers of these players prior to us, mid table champ is generally their level for a reason.

As said, awful recruitment for years, reliance on loans to add stuff clearly missing from players we own, poor value when buying players, all combined to create this mess.

Who are these better squads? I’ve asked the question so many times now but apart from Fulham I don’t see any. I see a manager making decent Champ players look / play below what they are capable of. 

There is no way that the results we are getting currently are representative of the quality of our squad.

To be fair, I think we're in a group of squads under Fulham, all much of a muchness with a couple of standout players. Problem is, there are pretty much no goals in our squad.

Add in a philosophy driven manager whose philosophy doesn't suit the squad. It's only going to go wrong.

As said, back to you, which of our players stand out as better than others? As I said, much of a muchness past Fulham. 

Without goals, you don't win games, there are so few goals in this squad it's painful.

Grant, Robinson, Dike Phillips, Diagana would all more score goals with a better manager. Ours is doing his very best to make us the least creative / dangerous team in the division. Come on Birdie you’re a results man and the results we are getting aren’t good enough for this squad. 

He has time to turn it around and shove the negative down mine and others throats but it has to happen soon.

Grant has one way of scoring goals, and that's it.

Robinson is a vastly over rated, over paid Champ player.

Dike, yes hopefully.

Phillips, never been consistent his entire career.

Grady. Sorry, bar a purple patch early on loan, he's just a show pony with little actual use and too easily bullied.

This is the issue, none, bar potentially Dike are consistent, reliable goal scorers. All out of form, and yes, misused by current manager, but I don't see that forward line firing a team to automatic promotion over a season, too often they'll all be out of form and struggle for goals for long periods.

We'd be doing better under Wilder, but not top 2, at least, not clearly.

And this is my point really, Val is failing, yes, I've not once said different, but I see this being an issue under any manager at the moment.


RE: QPR Match thread - Derek Hardballs - 01-15-2022

(01-15-2022, 06:16 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 05:57 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 05:51 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 05:46 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 05:40 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Not saying the manager is doing things right by the way.

But name the players that are promotion chasing Champ players in this squad, and look at the careers of these players prior to us, mid table champ is generally their level for a reason.

As said, awful recruitment for years, reliance on loans to add stuff clearly missing from players we own, poor value when buying players, all combined to create this mess.

Who are these better squads? I’ve asked the question so many times now but apart from Fulham I don’t see any. I see a manager making decent Champ players look / play below what they are capable of. 

There is no way that the results we are getting currently are representative of the quality of our squad.

To be fair, I think we're in a group of squads under Fulham, all much of a muchness with a couple of standout players. Problem is, there are pretty much no goals in our squad.

Add in a philosophy driven manager whose philosophy doesn't suit the squad. It's only going to go wrong.

As said, back to you, which of our players stand out as better than others? As I said, much of a muchness past Fulham. 

Without goals, you don't win games, there are so few goals in this squad it's painful.

Grant, Robinson, Dike Phillips, Diagana would all more score goals with a better manager. Ours is doing his very best to make us the least creative / dangerous team in the division. Come on Birdie you’re a results man and the results we are getting aren’t good enough for this squad. 

He has time to turn it around and shove the negative down mine and others throats but it has to happen soon.

Grant has one way of scoring goals, and that's it.

Robinson is a vastly over rated, over paid Champ player.

Dike, yes hopefully.

Phillips, never been consistent his entire career.

Grady. Sorry, bar a purple patch early on loan, he's just a show pony with little actual use and too easily bullied.

This is the issue, none, bar potentially Dike are consistent, reliable goal scorers. All out of form, and yes, misused by current manager, but I don't see that forward line firing a team to automatic promotion over a season, too often they'll all be out of form and struggle for goals for long periods.

We'd be doing better under Wilder, but not top 2, at least, not clearly.

And this is my point really, Val is failing, yes, I've not once said different, but I see this being an issue under any manager at the moment.

You can break down any player negatively at this level as they all have flaws. I just feel the biggest weakness in our set-up is the manager. Decent managers get the best out of their squads and play tactics that make that happen. Unless you have obscene amounts of money to buy success. Our tactics don’t get the best out of our players and results are backing that up.


RE: QPR Match thread - Big Daddy Cool - 01-15-2022

The problem is the manager and his tactics. It's been obvious for months now that it's not working. An awful appointment and one of the worst managers we've had in my lifetime. This season has been the most depressing since Brian Little was in charge. I don't care where we are in the league still and that there's clubs who are much worse off. I want to enjoy watching my team play and this football is abysmal. No creativity, no excitement. He's killing the fans enthusiasm. Time to fuck him off.


RE: QPR Match thread - Dial M for Mick - 01-15-2022

(01-15-2022, 06:30 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: The problem is the manager and his tactics. It's been obvious for months now that it's not working. An awful appointment and one of the worst managers we've had in my lifetime. This season has been the most depressing since Brian Little was in charge. I don't care where we are in the league still and that there's clubs who are much worse off. I want to enjoy watching my team play and this football is abysmal. No creativity, no excitement. He's killing the fans enthusiasm. Time to fuck him off.

People said this about Allardyce as well, who was 100% to blame for last season apparently, just as VI is this time when it’s the same players doing the same things since before lockdown. The only saving grace was Pereira who dragged this lot up.


RE: QPR Match thread - sickParrot - 01-15-2022

(01-15-2022, 05:18 PM)Crossbar11 Wrote: I could cut him some slack if he actually tried something different .When the day comes it will be self inflicted .

Can’t disagree with this when our plan b involves Bartley playing up front.


RE: QPR Match thread - Sliced - 01-15-2022

(01-15-2022, 06:42 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 06:30 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: The problem is the manager and his tactics. It's been obvious for months now that it's not working. An awful appointment and one of the worst managers we've had in my lifetime. This season has been the most depressing since Brian Little was in charge. I don't care where we are in the league still and that there's clubs who are much worse off. I want to enjoy watching my team play and this football is abysmal. No creativity, no excitement. He's killing the fans enthusiasm. Time to fuck him off.

People said this about Allardyce as well, who was 100% to blame for last season apparently, just as VI is this time when it’s the same players doing the same things since before lockdown. The only saving grace was Pereira who dragged this lot up.

Allardyce was shite for about 5 games and then did the almost impossible by making us competitive. Everyone seems to be either in the “Vals not good enough” or “the players aren’t good enough” camp. When the truth is somewhere in between. How anyone can look at that 18 today and tell me it’s top 3 in terms of quality is beyond me, but scoring so few goals is not good enough


RE: QPR Match thread - Birdman1811 - 01-15-2022

(01-15-2022, 06:28 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 06:16 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 05:57 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 05:51 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 05:46 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Who are these better squads? I’ve asked the question so many times now but apart from Fulham I don’t see any. I see a manager making decent Champ players look / play below what they are capable of. 

There is no way that the results we are getting currently are representative of the quality of our squad.

To be fair, I think we're in a group of squads under Fulham, all much of a muchness with a couple of standout players. Problem is, there are pretty much no goals in our squad.

Add in a philosophy driven manager whose philosophy doesn't suit the squad. It's only going to go wrong.

As said, back to you, which of our players stand out as better than others? As I said, much of a muchness past Fulham. 

Without goals, you don't win games, there are so few goals in this squad it's painful.

Grant, Robinson, Dike Phillips, Diagana would all more score goals with a better manager. Ours is doing his very best to make us the least creative / dangerous team in the division. Come on Birdie you’re a results man and the results we are getting aren’t good enough for this squad. 

He has time to turn it around and shove the negative down mine and others throats but it has to happen soon.

Grant has one way of scoring goals, and that's it.

Robinson is a vastly over rated, over paid Champ player.

Dike, yes hopefully.

Phillips, never been consistent his entire career.

Grady. Sorry, bar a purple patch early on loan, he's just a show pony with little actual use and too easily bullied.

This is the issue, none, bar potentially Dike are consistent, reliable goal scorers. All out of form, and yes, misused by current manager, but I don't see that forward line firing a team to automatic promotion over a season, too often they'll all be out of form and struggle for goals for long periods.

We'd be doing better under Wilder, but not top 2, at least, not clearly.

And this is my point really, Val is failing, yes, I've not once said different, but I see this being an issue under any manager at the moment.

You can break down any player negatively at this level as they all have flaws. I just feel the biggest weakness in our set-up is the manager. Decent managers get the best out of their squads and play tactics that make that happen. Unless you have obscene amounts of money to buy success. Our tactics don’t get the best out of our players and results are backing that up.

You're doing your amazing habit of reading something totally different to what said for a debate Derek.

I've said they're misused, repeatedly in fact, but they'll never be consistent enough to fire a team to promotion without a lot of goals from elsewhere.


RE: QPR Match thread - Derek Hardballs - 01-15-2022

(01-15-2022, 06:47 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 06:42 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 06:30 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: The problem is the manager and his tactics. It's been obvious for months now that it's not working. An awful appointment and one of the worst managers we've had in my lifetime. This season has been the most depressing since Brian Little was in charge. I don't care where we are in the league still and that there's clubs who are much worse off. I want to enjoy watching my team play and this football is abysmal. No creativity, no excitement. He's killing the fans enthusiasm. Time to fuck him off.

People said this about Allardyce as well, who was 100% to blame for last season apparently, just as VI is this time when it’s the same players doing the same things since before lockdown. The only saving grace was Pereira who dragged this lot up.

Allardyce was shite for about 5 games and then did the almost impossible by making us competitive. Everyone seems to be either in the “Vals not good enough” or “the players aren’t good enough” camp. When the truth is somewhere in between. How anyone can look at that 18 today and tell me it’s top 3 in terms of quality is beyond me, but scoring so few goals is not good enough

The squad is comparable to anyone’s in the league bar Fulham. Yes today it was weakened mainly due to player suspensions but our form, discipline and goals scored is woeful. That is not down to the squads quality.

(01-15-2022, 06:58 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 06:28 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 06:16 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 05:57 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 05:51 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: To be fair, I think we're in a group of squads under Fulham, all much of a muchness with a couple of standout players. Problem is, there are pretty much no goals in our squad.

Add in a philosophy driven manager whose philosophy doesn't suit the squad. It's only going to go wrong.

As said, back to you, which of our players stand out as better than others? As I said, much of a muchness past Fulham. 

Without goals, you don't win games, there are so few goals in this squad it's painful.

Grant, Robinson, Dike Phillips, Diagana would all more score goals with a better manager. Ours is doing his very best to make us the least creative / dangerous team in the division. Come on Birdie you’re a results man and the results we are getting aren’t good enough for this squad. 

He has time to turn it around and shove the negative down mine and others throats but it has to happen soon.

Grant has one way of scoring goals, and that's it.

Robinson is a vastly over rated, over paid Champ player.

Dike, yes hopefully.

Phillips, never been consistent his entire career.

Grady. Sorry, bar a purple patch early on loan, he's just a show pony with little actual use and too easily bullied.

This is the issue, none, bar potentially Dike are consistent, reliable goal scorers. All out of form, and yes, misused by current manager, but I don't see that forward line firing a team to automatic promotion over a season, too often they'll all be out of form and struggle for goals for long periods.

We'd be doing better under Wilder, but not top 2, at least, not clearly.

And this is my point really, Val is failing, yes, I've not once said different, but I see this being an issue under any manager at the moment.

You can break down any player negatively at this level as they all have flaws. I just feel the biggest weakness in our set-up is the manager. Decent managers get the best out of their squads and play tactics that make that happen. Unless you have obscene amounts of money to buy success. Our tactics don’t get the best out of our players and results are backing that up.

You're doing your amazing habit of reading something totally different to what said for a debate Derek.

I've said they're misused, repeatedly in fact, but they'll never be consistent enough to fire a team to promotion without a lot of goals from elsewhere.

I think we agree he’s not getting the best out of the resources he has whether that is due to tactics /  use of personnel, the only difference is how much we blame that on the quality of players at his disposal. The argument / degree to which is impossible to prove in either way.


RE: QPR Match thread - Hopalong - 01-15-2022

(01-15-2022, 06:47 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 06:42 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote:
(01-15-2022, 06:30 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: The problem is the manager and his tactics. It's been obvious for months now that it's not working. An awful appointment and one of the worst managers we've had in my lifetime. This season has been the most depressing since Brian Little was in charge. I don't care where we are in the league still and that there's clubs who are much worse off. I want to enjoy watching my team play and this football is abysmal. No creativity, no excitement. He's killing the fans enthusiasm. Time to fuck him off.

People said this about Allardyce as well, who was 100% to blame for last season apparently, just as VI is this time when it’s the same players doing the same things since before lockdown. The only saving grace was Pereira who dragged this lot up.

Allardyce was shite for about 5 games and then did the almost impossible by making us competitive. Everyone seems to be either in the “Vals not good enough” or “the players aren’t good enough” camp. When the truth is somewhere in between. How anyone can look at that 18 today and tell me it’s top 3 in terms of quality is beyond me, but scoring so few goals is not good enough

Half the first 11 didn't start today and you also have Diangana who is lost and wasting his career away.  

I still think we need to see where we are when he has his first 11 on the pitch in ten days and then any further additions.  Automatic is still possible if we can get our act together by the close of the window.  After a very strange blip Fulham have clearly got their mojo back and look certain for promotion unless Mitrovic leaves or gets injured.  It's then wide open.