RE: Reading - Next Wednesday - CA Baggie - 08-16-2019
(08-16-2019, 06:56 PM)I Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-16-2019, 04:59 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: (08-16-2019, 02:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-16-2019, 02:14 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: (08-16-2019, 01:23 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: People simply don't realise or won't admit what a well run club we have been and still are. With our resources and practices patience is key. We can look over the fence at neighbours being bank rolled with envy but just realise if that money was cut off they would be in all kinds of shite. We haven't got that backing, end of story. It's about time people started supporting what WE do well and stop wanting what we don't do. A well run club isn't full of fools and idiots as claimed on places like this. On the other hand plenty of idiots to be found on here though.
So we can't be a well run club, financially speaking by JRP, and do more to attract new fans?
Our crowds have bucked the trend of many clubs, so what is unique about us?
People point to Leicester and Brighton etc but they are growing cities with no competition around them. As much as we have places like Worcester and Shropshire etc around us so do all our competitors.
All the pathetic moaning, wailing and gnashing of teeth that I heard during our last successful Prem season when we finished top half under the anti- Christ I guarantee our rivals would have sold more than 25k on average seats. That’s where and who we are as a club.
Excuses include:
Too expensive - compared to what a packet of fags and a couple of beers?
Can’t sit with x amount of my friends - there are several areas with seats available almost every match
Football isn’t pretty - they might want to rethink what the word supporter means
I’m sure I’ve missed out a fair few but the argument for a second tier looks weaker every season.
We have a bigger population to attract fans from than either of those clubs. We haven't attracted them but those 2 you named have done so, what did they do differently in their approach to us? Leicester added 10K when they opened a new ground despite not selling out at Filbert Street (which had a 22k capacity). Off the back of that they averaged more in Champo and League1, when struggling, than they did whilst doing reasonably well in the Prem at Filbert Street.
If this is our lot- championship, with an absent owner - then you're right we don't now need a second tier. That opportunity was missed and we'll pay for it over the coming years.
The short-sightedness of the JRP tenure was that any expenditure had to repay itself in a relatively short period of time as he wanted to keep us at an optimum point for sale. We could have added seats and if needs be given thousands away. Get them in and some will be hooked, Villa (the biggest supported club in the area) have been doing this for years.
We have an ageing support base.
We were the only place for 50 miles to watch Premier League football and we fucked it up on and off the pitch.
Leicestershire has a population of nearly 700k
East Sussex has a population of 500k approx and West Sussex nearly 800k
Who are Leicester and Brighton sharing their support with? They have a captive audience and in answer to your question football became fashionable and gentrified just at the right time for those clubs to capitalise. Look at the mcw’s who now follow Brighton it’s Tapas all the way for them.
Only once have we got close to a sell out at the ground in the last twenty years and that’s our first season in the Prem. We have a loyal but not spectacular support base. Lots of hangers on for the big games but going to bog standard games? Nope.
It’s a bit daft trying to suggest that that tiny window relatively speaking of three years (???) where we were the only Prem team was enough to persuade kids in Sutton or Worcester etc to follow us over Villa or in Brewood or Telford to switch interest from Wolves? I’d love us to be the sleeping giant my Nan and the local press said we were but no amount of clever marketing will see our gates swell to 30k plus if the last decade is anything to go by.
We have one of the best community programs in the country and it’s slowly paying dividends with younger supporters from diverse backgrounds but it’s going to take decades to encourage many to support us whilst the allure of Liverpool and Man U is still prevalent and culturally ingrained for whatever reason.
5.8m in the West Midlands for us to share, plus parts of Staffordshire, Shropshire, Warwickshire and Worcestershire. I’m not having the idea that those clubs have a better catchment area than we do.
Only one sell out in 20 years? How many times did Leicester or Brighton sell out before expanding?
So when did it become fashionable and gentrified? Why didn’t we capitalise when those clubs did?
Kids won’t switch allegiance, but we may have tempted both the casual fan and unattached kids, some will invariably stick with the club and thus grow the fan base. The reality is that we didn’t try despite having the upper hand in the area for the best part of a decade. And that was down to JRP ensuring his golden egg remained intact for the possible price for himself.
We’re not sleeping giants, but neither are we minnows, smaller than all those clubs I previously mentioned and yet in a relatively good time for us we’ve gone backwards and those clubs have overtaken us.
I’ll say the word - ambition. That awful word that brings so much scorn. We didn’t show any to the fans or potential fans and that’s just not an attractive look. I don’t mean spending money we haven’t got, just talking us up a bit more. Saying positive things rather than trying to avoid the negative. We kept telling the world how we couldn’t compete and we’re dining off the crumbs of others etc. That doesn’t bring the crowds flocking back. No vision and no dream for people to get behind.
“The club aren’t bothered so why should we”.
We have a healthy hardcore, probably bettered only by Villa (in numbers) in the local area but offer nothing to attract the lapsed fan or the unattached kid looking to support a local side. Our time has passed, Wolves and Villa will sweep them up for the next couple of years.
RE: Reading - Next Wednesday - Cunninghamismagic - 08-16-2019
13 pages. Should be some crowd next Wednesday
RE: Reading - Next Wednesday - johntoewba - 08-16-2019
(08-16-2019, 07:20 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: (08-16-2019, 06:56 PM)I Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-16-2019, 04:59 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: (08-16-2019, 02:22 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (08-16-2019, 02:14 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: So we can't be a well run club, financially speaking by JRP, and do more to attract new fans?
Our crowds have bucked the trend of many clubs, so what is unique about us?
People point to Leicester and Brighton etc but they are growing cities with no competition around them. As much as we have places like Worcester and Shropshire etc around us so do all our competitors.
All the pathetic moaning, wailing and gnashing of teeth that I heard during our last successful Prem season when we finished top half under the anti- Christ I guarantee our rivals would have sold more than 25k on average seats. That’s where and who we are as a club.
Excuses include:
Too expensive - compared to what a packet of fags and a couple of beers?
Can’t sit with x amount of my friends - there are several areas with seats available almost every match
Football isn’t pretty - they might want to rethink what the word supporter means
I’m sure I’ve missed out a fair few but the argument for a second tier looks weaker every season.
We have a bigger population to attract fans from than either of those clubs. We haven't attracted them but those 2 you named have done so, what did they do differently in their approach to us? Leicester added 10K when they opened a new ground despite not selling out at Filbert Street (which had a 22k capacity). Off the back of that they averaged more in Champo and League1, when struggling, than they did whilst doing reasonably well in the Prem at Filbert Street.
If this is our lot- championship, with an absent owner - then you're right we don't now need a second tier. That opportunity was missed and we'll pay for it over the coming years.
The short-sightedness of the JRP tenure was that any expenditure had to repay itself in a relatively short period of time as he wanted to keep us at an optimum point for sale. We could have added seats and if needs be given thousands away. Get them in and some will be hooked, Villa (the biggest supported club in the area) have been doing this for years.
We have an ageing support base.
We were the only place for 50 miles to watch Premier League football and we fucked it up on and off the pitch.
Leicestershire has a population of nearly 700k
East Sussex has a population of 500k approx and West Sussex nearly 800k
Who are Leicester and Brighton sharing their support with? They have a captive audience and in answer to your question football became fashionable and gentrified just at the right time for those clubs to capitalise. Look at the mcw’s who now follow Brighton it’s Tapas all the way for them.
Only once have we got close to a sell out at the ground in the last twenty years and that’s our first season in the Prem. We have a loyal but not spectacular support base. Lots of hangers on for the big games but going to bog standard games? Nope.
It’s a bit daft trying to suggest that that tiny window relatively speaking of three years (???) where we were the only Prem team was enough to persuade kids in Sutton or Worcester etc to follow us over Villa or in Brewood or Telford to switch interest from Wolves? I’d love us to be the sleeping giant my Nan and the local press said we were but no amount of clever marketing will see our gates swell to 30k plus if the last decade is anything to go by.
We have one of the best community programs in the country and it’s slowly paying dividends with younger supporters from diverse backgrounds but it’s going to take decades to encourage many to support us whilst the allure of Liverpool and Man U is still prevalent and culturally ingrained for whatever reason.
5.8m in the West Midlands for us to share, plus parts of Staffordshire, Shropshire, Warwickshire and Worcestershire. I’m not having the idea that those clubs have a better catchment area than we do.
Only one sell out in 20 years? How many times did Leicester or Brighton sell out before expanding?
So when did it become fashionable and gentrified? Why didn’t we capitalise when those clubs did?
Kids won’t switch allegiance, but we may have tempted both the casual fan and unattached kids, some will invariably stick with the club and thus grow the fan base. The reality is that we didn’t try despite having the upper hand in the area for the best part of a decade. And that was down to JRP ensuring his golden egg remained intact for the possible price for himself.
We’re not sleeping giants, but neither are we minnows, smaller than all those clubs I previously mentioned and yet in a relatively good time for us we’ve gone backwards and those clubs have overtaken us.
I’ll say the word - ambition. That awful word that brings so much scorn. We didn’t show any to the fans or potential fans and that’s just not an attractive look. I don’t mean spending money we haven’t got, just talking us up a bit more. Saying positive things rather than trying to avoid the negative. We kept telling the world how we couldn’t compete and we’re dining off the crumbs of others etc. That doesn’t bring the crowds flocking back. No vision and no dream for people to get behind.
“The club aren’t bothered so why should we”.
We have a healthy hardcore, probably bettered only by Villa (in numbers) in the local area but offer nothing to attract the lapsed fan or the unattached kid looking to support a local side. Our time has passed, Wolves and Villa will sweep them up for the next couple of years.
this in spades no ambition hasn’t been since I started in 1979 we nearly get there but just fail to push that boat out
RE: Reading - Next Wednesday - Statto - 08-16-2019
Villa have been giving away tickets in their thousands to local schools for years. Now they’re back with some momentum, they’re paying for season tickets.
It’s not just a case of build it and they will come, it’s build it and hook them. Brighton do free travel. The fact is that unless any individual initiative or development shows an immediate plus on the balance sheet it will not happen. We will not speculate to accumulate.
RE: Reading - Next Wednesday - EastMidsBaggie - 08-16-2019
(08-16-2019, 08:30 PM)Statto Wrote: Villa have been giving away tickets in their thousands to local schools for years. Now they’re back with some momentum, they’re paying for season tickets.
It’s not just a case of build it and they will come, it’s build it and hook them. Brighton do free travel. The fact is that unless any individual initiative or development shows an immediate plus on the balance sheet it will not happen. We will not speculate to accumulate.
And, in your last paragraph, that is it in a nutshell; the WBA way and mantra allied to never trying to sell us any ambition or dreams !
RE: Reading - Next Wednesday - Atomic - 08-17-2019
Wow. Didn't expect to be starting a 13 page stadium expansion topic lol.
Saturday morning update:
Smethwick: 5
West Stand: 521
Brummie: 1,705
East Stand: 1,894
Remaining: 4,125
Sold: 19,375 approx.
RE: Reading - Next Wednesday - baggiebloke - 08-17-2019
(08-17-2019, 08:53 AM)Atomic Wrote: Wow. Didn't expect to be starting a 13 page stadium expansion topic lol.
Saturday morning update:
Smethwick: 5
West Stand: 521
Brummie: 1,705
East Stand: 1,894
Remaining: 4,125
Sold: 19,375 approx.
It's a gripping debate.
RE: Reading - Next Wednesday - Atomic - 08-17-2019
(08-17-2019, 09:06 AM)baggiebloke Wrote: (08-17-2019, 08:53 AM)Atomic Wrote: Wow. Didn't expect to be starting a 13 page stadium expansion topic lol.
Saturday morning update:
Smethwick: 5
West Stand: 521
Brummie: 1,705
East Stand: 1,894
Remaining: 4,125
Sold: 19,375 approx.
It's a gripping debate.
It's certainly one that will not go away until they re-build the Halfords.
Should they? Of course. 30,000 stadium capacity will do.
RE: Reading - Next Wednesday - MassDebater - 08-17-2019
Regarding the expansion idea, didn't the club get a shed load of grief for selling one of our best players and then spending the cash on the Halfords?
Building work costs a heck of a lot, would you rather we expanded and missed out on a couple of players?
Regarding the catchment area, outside of London we probably have the most teams vying for fans. Seals, Dingles probably have the best public profiles now, by virtue of being in the Prem, we're sandwiched right between them.
Then you have Blues, and we're currently achieving larger crowds than they are, even though they have around 3.5k extra capacity than us, they're struggling to fill it (their best last year was around 26.5k (Seals and Stoke) out of a 29k capacity, they've had one 29k attendance in 4 seasons (vs Seals)), but typically in the last 5 seasons they've struggled to get over 20k for most games, so they are currently running below us, sure they've had a lot of off field problems, but their case would suggest not expanding makes sense.
RE: Reading - Next Wednesday - Baggiejacko - 08-17-2019
Having vision has fucked up a lot of clubs financially. Having vision is great if you can afford for it to go wrong. Imo we've had a good balance between vision and caution. Name another club that has reached our recent achievements without being invested in. For all the Dings have now look at all the shit players, managers and stadium mods they've had to endure despite being heavily invested in. Then look at the spunkings of the Vile for fuck knows how long.
|