WBAUnofficial
Digital ID - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Digital ID (/showthread.php?tid=38836)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16


RE: Digital ID - Pontificator - 09-30-2025

https://www.theguardian.com/money/2025/sep/22/turned-my-life-into-hell-teacher-fights-to-clear-his-name-after-identity?ref=birminghamdispatch.co.uk


RE: Digital ID - Borin' Baggie - 09-30-2025

(09-30-2025, 08:25 AM)Pontificator Wrote: https://www.theguardian.com/money/2025/sep/22/turned-my-life-into-hell-teacher-fights-to-clear-his-name-after-identity?ref=birminghamdispatch.co.uk

And why would a voluntary digital services ID like MitID in Denmark not suffice, exactly?


RE: Digital ID - Birdman1811 - 09-30-2025

(09-30-2025, 08:25 AM)Pontificator Wrote: https://www.theguardian.com/money/2025/sep/22/turned-my-life-into-hell-teacher-fights-to-clear-his-name-after-identity?ref=birminghamdispatch.co.uk

Helps prove my point.

Their processes are not robust enough to deal with fraud, which this simply won't stop, every system is prone to fraud, and all data in one place is in some ways easier to defraud if it's not protected well enough.

They take far, far, far too long to correct data that's wrong, and deal with any problems, which, as I pointed out to them is against the various laws pertaining to data collection and storage, but as I was also told, since it's impossible to get compensation from them, they just ignore those laws.

When they're competent, they can introduce this.


RE: Digital ID - SW4Baggie - 09-30-2025

I’ve read 13 pages of this thread and I really don’t understand the animosity towards a Digital ID… I have to have one in Spain and I also have a physical ID card, and so far as I can see I’ve not fallen under the control of an authoritarian state as a result.

The digital ID here allows me to access things more quickly and easily - if I need a doctor’s appointment, or I go to an emergency room, I can be scanned in to ensure I receive treatment I am entitled to. I can use it to open a bank account without having to mess around with all that face scanning nonsense and km sure if I was in the UK it would work to let me watch porn.

So far it’s been mostly convenient and enables me to access public services and prevent those who aren’t entitled to use gaining access to them. They hold no more information on me than my gym or the state water company do, in fact I was able to use the card to register for both in minutes.

Then again, maybe I’m just one of the sheeple.


RE: Digital ID - baggy1 - 09-30-2025

You clearly are SW4 - you need to sell it to the mob, not tell them it makes life easier.


RE: Digital ID - Protheroe - 09-30-2025

(09-30-2025, 12:28 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I’ve read 13 pages of this thread and I really don’t understand the animosity towards a Digital ID… I have to have one in Spain and I also have a physical ID card, and so far as I can see I’ve not fallen under the control of an authoritarian state as a result.

The digital ID here allows me to access things more quickly and easily - if I need a doctor’s appointment, or I go to an emergency room, I can be scanned in to ensure I receive treatment I am entitled to. I can use it to open a bank account without having to mess around with all that face scanning nonsense and km sure if I was in the UK it would work to let me watch porn.

So far it’s been mostly convenient and enables me to access public services and prevent those who aren’t entitled to use gaining access to them. They hold no more information on me than my gym or the state water company do, in fact I was able to use the card to register for both in minutes.

Then again, maybe I’m just one of the sheeple.

To be fair Spain was also totalitarian fascist state within living memory.


RE: Digital ID - SW4Baggie - 09-30-2025

(09-30-2025, 01:25 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-30-2025, 12:28 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I’ve read 13 pages of this thread and I really don’t understand the animosity towards a Digital ID… I have to have one in Spain and I also have a physical ID card, and so far as I can see I’ve not fallen under the control of an authoritarian state as a result.

The digital ID here allows me to access things more quickly and easily - if I need a doctor’s appointment, or I go to an emergency room, I can be scanned in to ensure I receive treatment I am entitled to. I can use it to open a bank account without having to mess around with all that face scanning nonsense and km sure if I was in the UK it would work to let me watch porn.

So far it’s been mostly convenient and enables me to access public services and prevent those who aren’t entitled to use gaining access to them. They hold no more information on me than my gym or the state water company do, in fact I was able to use the card to register for both in minutes.

Then again, maybe I’m just one of the sheeple.

To be fair Spain was also totalitarian fascist state within living memory

You’d think that would make them less likely to want to do it again, then again in the last 10 years the UK have believed the lies of a charlatan and voted to apply economic sanctions to themselves and have elected a populist government that did its best to tank the economy and make us all poorer twice over, and yet we seem determined to vote for more of the same so!


RE: Digital ID - Tom Joad 25 - 09-30-2025

20 odd years ago I was dead against I.D. cards, mainly as an infringement of personal liberty.  Now I've changed, mainly because the world has changed. I now think I.D.cards would be a good thing to carry, along with my bank card, driving licence, train pass and all the other paraphernalia. That said, I'm unfortunately not so keen on the compulsory digital version. It will no doubt be a hideously expensive bunfight for I.T. companies and I have little faith in any enforcement methods that will supposedly be used on the black economy.


RE: Digital ID - Middlemore rd - 09-30-2025

Why would anyone trust this incompetent liebour government is beyond me ....i think we have had more breaches of data under liebour than i can remember.


RE: Digital ID - Borin' Baggie - 09-30-2025

(09-30-2025, 04:18 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-30-2025, 01:25 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(09-30-2025, 12:28 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I’ve read 13 pages of this thread and I really don’t understand the animosity towards a Digital ID… I have to have one in Spain and I also have a physical ID card, and so far as I can see I’ve not fallen under the control of an authoritarian state as a result.

The digital ID here allows me to access things more quickly and easily - if I need a doctor’s appointment, or I go to an emergency room, I can be scanned in to ensure I receive treatment I am entitled to. I can use it to open a bank account without having to mess around with all that face scanning nonsense and km sure if I was in the UK it would work to let me watch porn.

So far it’s been mostly convenient and enables me to access public services and prevent those who aren’t entitled to use gaining access to them. They hold no more information on me than my gym or the state water company do, in fact I was able to use the card to register for both in minutes.

Then again, maybe I’m just one of the sheeple.

To be fair Spain was also totalitarian fascist state within living memory

You’d think that would make them less likely to want to do it again, then again in the last 10 years the UK have believed the lies of a charlatan and voted to apply economic sanctions to themselves and have elected a populist government that did its best to tank the economy and make us all poorer twice over, and yet we seem determined to vote for more of the same so!

I've yet to see any reason for what Labour are proposing. The efficacy has been questioned by the foremost expert on this in the UK in David Rennie, it's not done what Labour say it will do in Italy, Greece and Germany and the best implemented systems are in the Nordics with Norway and Denmark having voluntary systems. That's not even going into data privacy and firewalls from external organisations or potential for abuse like our former national ID system from the 40s and early 50s.