WBAUnofficial
Daryl Burgess - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Daryl Burgess (/showthread.php?tid=34875)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14


RE: Daryl Burgess - Derek Hardballs - 08-29-2024

We have been appeasing and platforming right wing commentators and politicians for the past decade. The idea they have been marginalised or silenced flies in the face of reality. Yes there are concerns around immigration and imo more importantly integration and checks on the character of those arriving, rather than numbers, but this flawed argument that you must listen to the concerns of those who won’t listen to facts but steadfastly stand behind their ‘beliefs’ has got us to where we are now.

Take Brexit, those that got what they voted for, aren’t satisfied. It’s either the wrong kind of Brexit, the WEF, the EU etc etc that’s the problem and if they had only done Brexit their way it would be a great success. The truth is there is no satisfying those on the far right or left. Nothing will be ‘pure’ enough for them be it immigration or Brexit. Until we start ignoring rather than appeasing these extreme positions nothing will change. Belief will always win out with these types of people but they are very much the tail that is wagging the dog in the U.K. currently.


RE: Daryl Burgess - fuzzbox - 08-29-2024

Despite being a committed remainer, I'm not sure that conflating brexiteers and the far right is correct or helpful. 

I get that you don't want to reason with people that you don't think will change their beliefs. However, by your inaccurate and derogatory labelling, I  can't  help feeling that you may be similar!

 If that's the case, how can you be expected to understand their motivations? Following on from that, isn't it inevitable they will never be influenced by your arguments and so, as you say, will never change their minds?

If i got labelled racist for advocating tighter immigration or brexit, I doubt l'd listen to their arguments. My over-riding emotion would be anger. If enough people closed me down and insulted me, I may seek solace somewhere else that i felt i was respected and listened to...


RE: Daryl Burgess - ColliersWoodBaggie - 08-29-2024

(08-29-2024, 09:49 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: Despite being a committed remainer, I'm not sure that conflating brexiteers and the far right is correct or helpful. 

I get that you don't want to reason with people that you don't think will change their beliefs. However, by your inaccurate and derogatory labelling, I  can't  help feeling that you may be similar!

 If that's the case, how can you be expected to understand their motivations? Following on from that, isn't it inevitable they will never be influenced by your arguments and so, as you say, will never change their minds?

As Will Self said (He was right of course) every racist voted for Brexit. 

It does not mean every Brexit voter is a racist, a fact that Marc Francois couldn't get his fat little head around.


RE: Daryl Burgess - Mr Nimbus - 08-29-2024

Only one word needed sorts it all out. Why?

A good friend of mine, who is a one nation Tory, right of centre, voted Leave because he objected to the lack of accountability and undemocratic organisation within the EU. It was a vote against the EU as an organisation.

In all our conversations back and forth he didnt focus on immigration, asylum seekers and certainly had no baseless conviction that Brexit would lead us back to the time of empire. He is intelligent and engaged in the political and fiscal situation. When I asked why, he was able to give me a reasonable and well constructed response, which I of course disagreed with but respected. He is NOT a racist.

It's safe to say he is not an atypical Brexit voter, and I'm guessing this wouldn't be the argument Daryl would present if pushed.

I've mentioned it before on the thread but I've finally gotten round to reading Who Broke Britain and the chapters on Murdoch and Dacre answer a lot of questions around the platforming of right wing commentators.


RE: Daryl Burgess - fuzzbox - 08-29-2024

'Why?' That was my point, but more succinct! Of course, that means you have to listen to the response constructively - which I think is the opposite of dh's opinion.


A real eye opener for me was some of the people who are/ were going to vote for Trump. You listen to their reasoning and it actually makes their decision logical even if, in my opinion, utterly wrong.

Thankfully, the democrat hierarchy have actually started to listen to the sane Trump voters and their new message seems to be working.


RE: Daryl Burgess - Baggiejacko - 08-29-2024

(08-29-2024, 09:49 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: Despite being a committed remainer, I'm not sure that conflating brexiteers and the far right is correct or helpful. 

I get that you don't want to reason with people that you don't think will change their beliefs. However, by your inaccurate and derogatory labelling, I  can't  help feeling that you may be similar!

 If that's the case, how can you be expected to understand their motivations? Following on from that, isn't it inevitable they will never be influenced by your arguments and so, as you say, will never change their minds?

If i got labelled racist for advocating tighter immigration or brexit, I doubt l'd listen to their arguments. My over-riding emotion would be anger. If enough people closed me down and insulted me, I may seek solace somewhere  else that i felt i was respected and listened to...

That is exactly 100% correct. Back o' the net mate


RE: Daryl Burgess - Duffers - 08-29-2024

Logs in… “Wow! A thread about Darryl Burgess is up to 13 pages?!?”

Reads thread.

“Ah.”


RE: Daryl Burgess - man in the corner shop - 08-29-2024

(08-29-2024, 10:37 AM)Duffers Wrote: Logs in… “Wow! A thread about Darryl Burgess is up to 13 pages?!?”

Reads thread.

“Ah.”

Not about his footballing abilities far shaw


RE: Daryl Burgess - Derek Hardballs - 08-29-2024

(08-29-2024, 09:49 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: Despite being a committed remainer, I'm not sure that conflating brexiteers and the far right is correct or helpful. 

I get that you don't want to reason with people that you don't think will change their beliefs. However, by your inaccurate and derogatory labelling, I  can't  help feeling that you may be similar!

 If that's the case, how can you be expected to understand their motivations? Following on from that, isn't it inevitable they will never be influenced by your arguments and so, as you say, will never change their minds?

If i got labelled racist for advocating tighter immigration or brexit, I doubt l'd listen to their arguments. My over-riding emotion would be anger. If enough people closed me down and insulted me, I may seek solace somewhere  else that i felt i was respected and listened to...

I didn’t confuse the two things I gave Brexit as an example of when people choose to believe in something no matter what information or facts given to the contrary. The purity of the cause is more important than reality of the situation, and no solution will be good enough to live up to the cause they have taken up.

With regards to right wing opinions that Robinson advocates, again you can put the facts to those who agree with him that disprove what he argues but belief will inevitably trump this with those who choose to believe. 

If you want to get personal that’s up to you but at the very beginning of my post I said there is a discussion to be had about immigration and integration. “Yes there are concerns around immigration and imo more importantly integration and checks on the character of those arriving”, these are hardly the words to suggest I’m against having the conversation. 

The point was two fold, one we have been listening and reacting as a country to people’s concerns on immigration for at least a decade. Farage, Robinson, Tice, The Mail, Telegraph, GB News and an entire think tank industry bankrolled by dubious backers have been shouting long and hard their position on the subject. They and those that support their views are not marginalised, we have had a Conservative Party pandering and appeasing those voices for years. 
 
The second point is, problems with immigration won’t be solved from the hard left or hard right politically, they can only ever be solved by moderates, through compromise, pragmatism, education and conversation between people willing to listen. Sadly those are the voices currently been marginalised on SM but as we’ve seen since the riots not by most people who were against the rhetoric Robinson and co expouse.


RE: Daryl Burgess - fuzzbox - 08-29-2024

(08-29-2024, 03:14 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-29-2024, 09:49 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: Despite being a committed remainer, I'm not sure that conflating brexiteers and the far right is correct or helpful. 

I get that you don't want to reason with people that you don't think will change their beliefs. However, by your inaccurate and derogatory labelling, I  can't  help feeling that you may be similar!

 If that's the case, how can you be expected to understand their motivations? Following on from that, isn't it inevitable they will never be influenced by your arguments and so, as you say, will never change their minds?

If i got labelled racist for advocating tighter immigration or brexit, I doubt l'd listen to their arguments. My over-riding emotion would be anger. If enough people closed me down and insulted me, I may seek solace somewhere  else that i felt i was respected and listened to...
I didn’t confuse the two things I gave Brexit as an example of when people choose to believe in something no matter what information or facts given to the contrary. The purity of the cause is more important than reality of the situation, and no solution will be good enough to live up to the cause they have taken up.

With regards to right wing opinions that Robinson advocates, again you can put the facts to those who agree with him that disprove what he argues but belief will inevitably trump this with those who choose to believe. 

If you want to get personal that’s up to you but at the very beginning of my post I said there is a discussion to be had about immigration and integration. “Yes there are concerns around immigration and imo more importantly integration and checks on the character of those arriving”, these are hardly the words to suggest I’m against having the conversation. 

The point was two fold, one we have been listening and reacting as a country to people’s concerns on immigration for at least a decade. Farage, Robinson, Tice, The Mail, Telegraph, GB News and an entire think tank industry bankrolled by dubious backers have been shouting long and hard their position on the subject. They and those that support their views are not marginalised, we have had a Conservative Party pandering and appeasing those voices for years. 
 
The second point is, problems with immigration won’t be solved from the hard left or hard right politically, they can only ever be solved by moderates, through compromise, pragmatism, education and conversation between people willing to listen. Sadly those are the voices currently been marginalised on SM but as we’ve seen since the riots not by most people who were against the rhetoric Robinson and co expouse.

On second thoughts, you might be right!  Smile